Republic of the Philippines DEPARTMENT OF BUDGET AND MANAGEMENT The Budget Operations Manual for Local Government Units, 2023 Edition, may be reproduced provided written permission is obtained from the Department of Budget and Management. BUDGET OPERATIONS MANUAL FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS 2023 EDITION This Manual was prepared with the Technical Assistance of the Asian Development Bank. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES DEPARTMENT OF BUDGET AND MANAGEMENT GENERAL SOLANO STREET, SAN MIGUEL, MANILA LOCAL BUDGET CIRCULAR No. _____________ 152 Date: _____________ August 2, 2023 To : Local Chief Executives, Members of the Local Sanggunian, Local Budget Officers, Local Treasurers, Local Planning and Development Coordinators, Local Accountants, and All Others Concerned Subject : BUDGET OPERATIONS MANUAL FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS (BOM for LGUs), 2023 EDITION 1.0 BACKGROUND 2.0 1.1 Pursuant to Section 354 of the Local Government Code of 1991 (Republic Act No. 7160) and Article 426 of its Implementing Rules and Regulations, the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) shall promulgate a BOM for LGUs to improve and systematize the methods, techniques, and procedures employed in budget preparation, authorization, execution, and accountability, as well as extend technical assistance in local government budgeting. 1.2 The previous version of the BOM for LGUs was promulgated under the auspices of the European Union Project, LGU PFM 2, and the same was officially prescribed by DBM through Local Budget Circular (LBC) No. 112 dated June 10, 2016.1 1.3 However, there have been significant developments in local government budgeting which call for the need to update the BOM for LGUs, 2016 Edition. PURPOSE This Circular is being issued to prescribe the institutionalization of the BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition as a guide for all provinces, cities, and municipalities in local government budgeting. 3.0 1 THE BOM for LGUs, 2023 EDITION 3.1 The BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition provides for the enhanced framework and approaches to local budgeting which shall enjoin the LGUs to be more responsible and accountable for the funds entrusted to them and direct their financial resources according to their thrust and mandates. 3.2 Specifically, the BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition contains the following enhancements and new features, to wit: Budget Operations Manual for Local Government Units (BOM for LGUs), 2016 Edition 4.0 5.0 6.0 3.2.1 Discussion on the fundamental principles governing local taxation and fiscal matters, limitations on the taxing powers of LGUs, and fundamental principles in local government budgeting; 3.2.2 Enhanced framework for strengthening policy-based budgeting by specifying how to harmonize the linkage among policy-making, planning, and budgeting; 3.2.3 Streamlining and updating of local budget forms; 3.2.4 Introduction of the Cash Budgeting System, a new approach to budgeting, which LGUs may adopt to instill fiscal discipline and ensure efficient and timely delivery of public service; and 3.2.5 Integration of other developments concerning local budget operations, in view of the enactment of new laws and issuance of updated/new policies and guidelines, including the implementation of the Supreme Court Ruling on the Mandanas-Garcia Case. ELECTRONIC BUDGET SYSTEM FOR LGUs 4.1 To assist the LGUs in the preparation of the different forms required in the budgeting processes and to facilitate the online submission of the Annual/Supplemental Budgets and other reports, the electronic Budget (eBudget) System for LGUs was enhanced under the Technical Assistance of Asian Development Bank. 4.2 The eBudget System also facilitates the online submission of report to the electronic Statement of Receipts and Expenditure (eSRE) System of the Department of Finance – Bureau of Local Government Finance by the Local Budget Officer. The eBudget System shall be made available free of charge to LGUs interested in automating their local budget processes. ROLL-OUT ACTIVITIES 5. 1 Training on the BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition shall be conducted by the Regional Offices in coordination with the Local Government and Regional Coordination Bureau. 5.2 The Regional Offices, with the support of the Information Communications and Technology Systems Service, shall provide technical assistance to LGUs who are interested to use the eBudget System for LGUs. ITEMS FOR RESOLUTION Interpretation of the provisions of this Circular and the BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition, including relevant items not covered therein, shall be referred to the DBM for resolution. 7.0 SEPARABILITY CLAUSE If any provision of this Circular and the BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition is declared invalid or unconstitutional, the other provisions not affected thereby shall remain valid and subsisting. 8.0 REPEALING CLAUSE This Circular and the BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition supersede LBC No. 112 dated June 10, 2016 and the BOM for LGUs, 2016 Edition, respectively. 9.0 EFFECTIVITY The BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition shall take effect in FY 2023. Secretary Message from the Secretary Unity amid diversity has been the resounding call of the administration of President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr., even before his assumption of duty. This message has fueled our whole-of-nation approach in the pursuit of economic transformation across all sectors and the growth of our localities. As we seek the empowerment of local government units (LGUs), we are reminded that the budget plays an important role in development planning at all levels of government. It is in this light that we bring you the 2023 Edition of the Budget Operations Manual for LGUs. Planning and budgeting must go hand-in-hand. At the same time, Public Financial Management (PFM) is crucial not only in identifying, but also in prioritizing high-impact programs, projects, and activities that truly respond to the needs of the people while maximizing our finite resources. We hope this Manual will aid our local governments in effectively performing their functions, implementing local plans, and providing quality public service, especially with the recent developments brought about by the Supreme Court Ruling on the Mandanas - Garcia Case. As the Department of Budget and Management continues to be at the forefront of institutionalizing budget reforms and promoting efficient PFM in the country, we hope that this Manual will aid and guide LGUs, who continue to be our ever-reliable bridge to the people. Let us work together towards enhancing bureaucratic efficiency and promoting sound fiscal management, in fulfillment of the Philippine Development Plan 2023 to 2028 and our Agenda for Prosperity. Wabillahi Tawfiq Wal Hidaya, Wasalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu. i Table of Contents List of Acronyms and Abbreviations…………………………………………………….. vii PART I. THE BUDGETING FRAMEWORK FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS……….. 1 Fundamental Principles Governing Local Taxation and Fiscal Matters………………… 2 Limitations on the Taxing Powers of the Local Government Units……………………… 2 Fundamental Principles in Local Government Budgeting………………………………… 6 CHAPTER 1. PARTICIPATORY BUDGETING…………………………………………… 8 1.1 Legal Bases of Participatory Budgeting…………………………………………….. 8 1.2 Guidelines on Participatory Budgeting……………………………………………… 8 1.3 Benefits of Participatory Budgeting…………………………………………………. 10 1.4 Membership of CSOs to the Local Development Council…………………………. 11 1.5 Roles of CSOs in the Local Budget Process……………………………………….. 11 CHAPTER 2. POLICY-BASED BUDGETING…………………………………………….. 15 2.1 Legal Bases of Policy-Based Budgeting……………………………………………. 15 2.2 Key Players in Policy-Based Budgeting…………………………………………….. 16 2.3 Harmonizing Plans and Policies…………………………………………………….. 17 2.4 Linking the Budget to Harmonized Plans and Policies…………………………….. 19 2.5 Synchronized Plan-Budget Process………………………………………………… 20 2.6 Preparation of the Annual Investment Program…………………………………… 23 2.7 Procurement Planning and Budgeting Linkage……………………………………. 29 CHAPTER 3. PERFORMANCE-INFORMED BUDGETING…………………………….. 31 3.1 Legal Bases of PIB……………………………………………………………………. 31 3.2 Key Players in PIB……………………………………………………………………. 31 3.3 Conceptual Framework of PIB………………………………………………………. 32 3.4 Key Features/Benefits of PIB………………………………………………………… 33 3.5 PIB Process…………………………………………………………………………… 34 CHAPTER 4. NEW APPROACH IN BUDGETING……………………………………….. 36 4.1 Cash Budgeting System……………………………………………………………… 36 4.2 Fundamental Principles of CBS……………………………………………………... 37 4.3 Benefits of Adopting CBS…………………………………………………………….. 38 PART II. THE LOCAL BUDGET PROCESS………………………………………………….. 39 CHAPTER 1. BUDGET PREPARATION PHASE………………………………………… 40 1.1 Legal Basis of Budget Preparation………………………………………………….. 40 1.2 Key Players in Budget Preparation………………………………………………….. 40 1.3 The Budget Preparation Flowchart…………………………………………………. 44 ii 1.4 Steps in the Budget Preparation Phase…………………………………………….. 44 1.5 Local Budget Preparation Forms……………………………………………………. 59 1.6 Illustrative Examples…………………………………………………………………. 72 CHAPTER 2. BUDGET AUTHORIZATION PHASE……………………………………… 90 2.1 Legal Basis of Budget Authorization………………………………………………… 90 2.2 Key Players in Budget Authorization………………………………………………... 90 2.3 The Budget Authorization Flowchart………………………………………………... 93 2.4 Steps in the Budget Authorization Phase…………………………………………… 93 2.5 Local Budget Authorization Forms………………………………………………….. 109 2.6 Illustrative Examples…………………………………………………………………. 112 CHAPTER 3. BUDGET REVIEW PHASE…………………………………………………. 127 3.1 Legal Bases of Budget Review……………………………………………………… 127 3.2 Key Players in Budget Review………………………………………………………. 127 3.3 Reglementary Period of Review……………………………………………..……… 128 3.4 The Budget Review Flowchart………………………………………………………. 128 3.5 Steps in the Budget Review Phase…………………………………………………. 129 3.6 Local Budget Review Forms…………………………………………………………. 136 3.7 Illustrative Examples…………………………………………………………………. 155 3.8 Stamp of Review……………………………………………………………………… 163 CHAPTER 4. THE BUDGET EXECUTION PHASE……………………………………… 164 4.1 Legal Bases of Budget Execution…………………………………………………… 164 4.2 Key Players in Budget Execution…………………………………………………… 165 4.3 The Budget Execution Flowchart……………………….…………………………… 169 4.4 Budgetary Accounts in Budget Execution……………….…………………………. 169 4.5 Steps in the Budget Execution Phase………………………………………………. 170 4.6 Changes in the Annual Budget………………………………………………………. 174 4.7 Reenacted Budget……………………………………………………………………. 176 4.8 Local Budget Execution Forms……………………………………………………… 178 CHAPTER 5. THE BUDGET ACCOUNTABILITY PHASE……………………………… 194 5.1 Legal Bases of Budget Accountability……………………………………….……… 194 5.2 Key Players in Budget Accountability……………………………………………….. 194 5.3 The Budget Monitoring and Evaluation Framework……………………………….. 199 5.4 Steps in the Budget Accountability Phase………………………………………….. 201 5.5 Local Budget Accountability Reports……………………………………………….. 205 iii PART III: ALLOCATIONS TO LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS…………………………….. 214 CHAPTER 1. NATIONAL TAX ALLOTMENT (FORMERLY INTERNAL REVENUE ALLOTMENT)………………………………………………………………………………… 215 1.1 Legal Bases…………………………………………………………………………… 215 1.2 Supreme Court Ruling on the Mandanas-Garcia Case…………………………… 215 1.3 Distribution of Shares………………………………………………………………… 217 1.4 Uses of the Fund……………………………………………………………………… 218 1.5 Fund Release Procedures…………………………………………………………… 219 CHAPTER 2. SHARE IN THE UTILIZATION AND DEVELOPMENT OF NATIONAL WEALTH……………………………………………………………………………………… 220 2.1 Legal Bases…………………………………………………………………………… 220 2.2 Distribution of Shares………………………………………………………………… 220 2.3 Uses of the Fund……………………………………………………………………… 221 2.4 Fund Release Procedures…………………………………………………………… 221 CHAPTER 3. SHARE IN THE GROSS INCOME TAXES PAID BY ALL BUSINESSES AND ENTERPRISES WITHIN THE SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONES….. 223 3.1 Legal Bases…………………………………………………………………………… 223 3.2 Computation of Shares………………………………………………………………. 223 3.3 Uses of the Fund……………………………………………………………………… 223 3.4 Fund Release Procedures…………………………………………………………… 223 CHAPTER 4. SHARE IN VALUE-ADDED TAX…………………………………………… 225 4.1 Legal Bases…………………………………………………………………………… 225 4.2 Computation of Shares………………………………………………………………. 225 4.3 Uses of the Fund……………………………………………………………………… 226 4.4 Fund Release Procedures…………………………………………………………… 227 CHAPTER 5. SHARE IN TOBACCO EXCISE TAXES…………………………………… 228 5.1 Legal Bases…………………………………………………………………………… 228 5.2 Computation of Shares of LGUs……………………………………………………. 228 5.3 Uses of the Fund……………………………………………………………………… 229 5.4 Fund Release Procedures…………………………………………………………… 230 5.5 Treatment of the Shares……………………………………………………………… 231 PART IV – SPECIAL FUNDS…………………………………………………………………… 232 CHAPTER 1. SPECIAL EDUCATION FUND……………………………………………... 232 1.1 Legal Bases…………………………………………………………………………… 232 1.2 Policy Guidelines……………………………………………………………………… 233 1.3 Allowable Expenses Chargeable against the SEF………………………………… 233 1.4 Planning and Budgeting for the SEF………………………………………………… 237 iv CHAPTER 2. SPECIAL HEALTH FUND…………………………………………………... 240 2.1 Legal Bases…………………………………………………………………………… 240 2.2 Policy Guidelines……………………………………………………………………… 240 2.3 Fund Sources of SHF………………………………………………………………… 240 2.4 Allowable Expenses Chargeable Against the SHF………………………………… 241 2.5 Steps in the Establishment of the SHF……………………………………………… 242 2.6 Planning and Budgeting for the SHF……………………………………………….. 243 2.7 SHF Budget Preparation Forms……………………………………………………... 247 PART V. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQs)……………………………………. 253 Budget Preparation…………………………………………………………………………... 253 Budget Authorization…………………………………………………………………………. 260 Budget Review………………………………………………………………………………... 271 Budget Execution…………………………………………………………………………….. 273 Allocations to Local Government Units…………………………………………………….. 277 Items of Appropriations Included, By Attribution, in the General Fund Annual Budget… 279 Confidential Expenses……………………………………………………………………….. 279 Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund…………………………………... 283 Aid to Barangays……………………………………………………………………………… 285 Gender and Development…………………………………………………………………… 285 Indigenous Cultural Communities/Indigenous Peoples…………………………………... 287 Creation of Positions…………………………………………………………………………. 287 ANNEXES Annex A. Synchronized Local Planning and Budgeting Calendar……………………….. 289 Annex B. Proposed Major Final Output (MFO) and Performance Indicators (PIs) of the Different Mandatory Offices in LGUs……………………………………………………….. 294 Annex C. The Service Falling Under Each of the Major Sectors Pursuant to the New Government Accounting System of the Commission on Audit…………………………… 300 Annex D. Coding Structure by Type of LGU and Office…………………………………… 302 Annex E. Process Guide for Climate Change Expenditure Tagging…………………….. 304 Annex F. Project Monitoring/Inspection Report……………………………………………. 305 GLOSSARY OF TERMS………………………………………………………………………… 306 v List of Figures Figure 1. Figure 2. Figure 3. Figure 4. Figure 5. Figure 6. Figure 7. Figure 8. Figure 9. Figure 10. Figure 11. Figure 12. Figure 13. Figure 14. Figure 15. Figure 16. Figure 17. Figure 18. Benefits of Participatory Budgeting……………………………………….. 10 Plan-Budget Link Model……………………………………………………. 20 AIP Preparation Flowchart………………………………………………… 24 AIP Reference Code Guide…………………………………………..…… 25 Procurement Planning and Budgeting Linkage…………………………. 30 PIB Conceptual Framework……………………………………………….. 33 Comparison Between Obligation-Based Budgeting and CBS…………. 37 The Local Budget Process………………………………………………… 39 Budget Preparation Flowchart…………………………………………….. 44 Budget Authorization Flowchart…………………………………………… 93 Budget Review Flowchart………………………………………………….. 129 Budget Execution Flowchart………………………………………………. 169 Budget Monitoring and Evaluation Framework………………………….. 200 Budget Accountability Flowchart………………………………………….. 201 NTA Share per LGU Level………………………………………………… 217 Distribution of Shares from National Wealth…………………………….. 221 Distribution of Shares from National Wealth…………………………….. 221 Formula for the Computation of LGUs' VAT Shares……………………. 226 List of Tables Table 1. Table 2. Table 3. Table 4. Table 5. Table 6. Table 7. Table 8. Table 9. Table 10. Table 11. Table 12. Table 13. Table 14. Table 15. Table 16. Table 17. Taxing Powers, by LGU Level………………………………………………. 4 Roles of CSOs in the Local Budget Process………………………………. 11 Sample Template for Medium Term Revenue Forecast………………….. 21 AIP Summary Form………………………………………………………….. 25 Roles of CSOs in the Budget Preparation Phase………………………… 42 Roles of CSOs in the Budget Authorization Phase………………………. 91 Roles of CSOs in the Budget Review Phase………………………………. 128 Review Actions and Corrective Measures…………………………………. 134 Roles of CSOs in the Budget Execution Phase…………………………… 166 Difference of the Use of Savings through Supplemental Budget and Augmentation…………………………………………………………………. 175 Roles of CSOs in the Budget Accountability Phase………………………. 198 Required Accountability Reports……………………………………………. 203 Variance Analysis of Output/Physical Performance………………………. 204 Variance Analysis of Financial Performance………………………………. 204 Distribution of NTA Shares Formula………………………………………... 217 Types of National Wealth with Corresponding Collecting Agency………. 220 Timelines for the Budget Process of SHF………………………………….. 245 vi LIST OF ABBREVIATONS AGSB AIP AO APP BAC BLGF BOM CapEx CBS CCET CDP CLUP CO COA COE CSC CSO DBM DENR DF DILG DOF ELA FE GAD HoPE IAM IRA IRP IRR JMC LBAc LBA LBE LBO LBP LBR LCE LDC LDIP LEE LEP LFC LGC LGU LPDC MFO MOOE MTEF Authorized Government Servicing Bank Annual Investment Program Appropriation Ordinance Annual Procurement Plan Bids and Awards Committee Bureau of Local Government Finance Budget Operations Manual Capital Expenditure Cash Budgeting System Climate Change Expenditure Tagging Comprehensive Development Plan Comprehensive Land Use Plan Capital Outlay Commission on Audit Current Operating Expenditures Civil Service Commission Civil Society Organization Department of Budget and Management Department of Environment and Natural Resources Development Fund Department of the Interior and Local Government Department of Finance Executive-Legislative Agenda Financial Expenses Gender and Development Head of the Procuring Entity Internal Audit Manual Internal Revenue Allotment Internal Rules of Procedure Implementing Rules and Regulations Joint Memorandum Circular Local Budget Accountability Local Budget Authorization Local Budget Execution Local Budget Officer Local Budget Preparation Local Budget Review Local Chief Executive Local Development Council Local Development Investment Program Local Economic Enterprise Local Expenditure Program Local Finance Committee Local Government Code of 1991 Local Government Unit Local Planning and Development Coordinator Major Final Output Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses Medium Term Expenditure Framework vii NDRRMC NEDA NGA NTA PEM PPA PDPFP PI PERA PFM PIB PPMP PS PU RA RATA RO RPT National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council National Economic and Development Authority National Government Agency National Tax Allotment Public Expenditure Management Program/Project/Activity Provincial Development and Physical Framework Plan Performance Indicator Personnel Economic Relief Allowance Public Financial Management Performance-Informed Budgeting Project Procurement Management Plan Personal Services Public Utility Republic Act Representation and Transportation Allowances Regional Office Real Property Tax viii Foreword Pursuant to its mandate under Section 354 of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 to promulgate a Budget Operations Manual for Local Government Units (BOM for LGUs) to improve and systematize methods, techniques, and procedures employed in the local budget process, the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) is issuing the BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition. The BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition reflects the earnest endeavor to sustain efforts to make Public Financial Management (PFM) more responsive, transparent, and accountable at the local level. It provides an enhanced framework for strengthening policy-based budgeting by specifying how to harmonize the linkage among policymaking, planning, and budgeting. It also reinforces the Performance-Informed Budgeting Framework. On top of this, the Manual features the Cash Budgeting System, a new approach to budgeting pursuant to Executive Order (EO) No. 91, series of 2019, which LGUs may adopt to instill fiscal discipline and ensure efficient and timely delivery of public service. The Manual also continues to espouse participatory budgeting, which reinforces the roles of Civil Society Organizations in the local budget process. This is in line with our commitment to promote open government in the country, and in accordance with EO No. 31, series of 2023, institutionalizing the Philippine Open Government Partnership. The foregoing new approaches to budgeting, as well as the latest issuances on local budgeting, including the recent developments brought by the implementation of the Supreme Court Ruling on the Mandanas-Garcia Case, are integrated and reflected in the entire budget process. This makes the BOM for LGUs, 2023 Edition a potent and effective tool for sound and efficient local PFM, which is key to a better local budgeting process toward the growth of our localities and the nation. ix PART I. THE BUDGETING FRAMEWORK FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS Local Fiscal Administration is governed by Book II - Local Taxation and Fiscal Matters of the Local Government Code (LGC) of 1991 (Republic Act [RA] No. 7160). The same law lays down the fundamental principles of taxation and budgeting from which the policies that form part of the budgeting framework for local government units (LGUs) are derived. The principle of participatory governance is advocated to be applied in the budget process. It attempts to persuade local thinking on the benefits of engaging civil society organizations (CSOs) in local governance. Complementary to participatory governance is strengthening the linkage among policy-making, planning and budgeting. It addresses the mismatch between policy objectives and resource realities, as documented in the LGU Public Financial Management Reform Roadmap. This gap, which is due to planning being largely separated from policy-making, leads to lack of fiscal discipline, and consequently, impairs service delivery. Both policy-making and planning are also weakly linked to budgeting which results to frequent year-in adjustments in budget items, thus, reducing the credibility of the budget. The inclusion of procurement planning in the preparation of the budget adds to the credibility of the budget inasmuch as the costing and programming of implementation are already initially determined as inputs to budget proposals. To deepen our understanding on Performance-Informed Budgeting, the discussion has been expanded in this Edition. Another budgeting approach presented in this Edition is the Cash Budgeting System which instills fiscal discipline by limiting contractual obligations for projects completed within the year. 1 Fundamental Principles Governing Local Taxation and Fiscal Matters Taxation and other revenue-raising powers of LGUs are governed by the following fundamental principles as embodied under Sections 130 and 132 of the LGC, to wit: “SECTION 130. Fundamental Principles. – The following fundamental principles shall govern the exercise of the taxing and other revenue-raising powers of local government units: a. Taxation shall be uniform in each local government unit; b. Taxes, fees, charges and other impositions shall: 1) be equitable and based as far as practicable on the taxpayer’s ability to pay; 2) be levied and collected only for public purposes; 3) not be unjust, excessive, oppressive, or confiscatory; 4) not be contrary to law, public policy, national economic policy, or in restraint of trade; c. The collection of local taxes, fees, charges and other impositions shall in no case be let to any private person; d. The revenue collected pursuant to the provisions of this Code shall inure solely to the benefit of, and be subject to disposition by, the local government unit levying the tax, fee, charge or other imposition unless otherwise specifically provided herein; and e. Each local government unit shall, as far as practicable, evolve a progressive system of taxation.” “SECTION 132. Local Taxing Authority. - The power to impose a tax, fee, or charge or to generate revenue under this Code shall be exercised by the sanggunian of the local government unit concerned through an appropriate ordinance.” Limitations on the Taxing Powers of the Local Government Units Section 133 of the LGC prescribes that, “[u]nless otherwise provided herein, the exercise of the taxing powers of provinces, cities, municipalities, and barangays shall not extend to the levy of the following: a. Income tax, except when levied on banks and other financial institutions; b. Documentary stamp tax; 2 c. Taxes on estates, inheritance, gifts, legacies and other acquisitions mortis causa, except as otherwise provided herein; d. Customs duties, registration fees of vessel and wharfage on wharves, tonnage dues, and all other kinds of customs fees, charges and dues except wharfage on wharves constructed and maintained by the local government unit concerned; e. Taxes, fees and charges and other impositions upon goods carried into or out of, or passing through, the territorial jurisdictions of local government units in the guise of charges for wharfage, tolls for bridges or otherwise, or other taxes, fees or charges in any form whatsoever upon such goods or merchandise; f. Taxes, fees or charges on agricultural and aquatic products when sold by marginal farmers or fishermen; g. Taxes on business enterprises certified to by the Board of Investments as pioneer or non-pioneer for a period of six (6) and four (4) years, respectively from the date of registration; h. Excise taxes on articles enumerated under the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended, and taxes, fees or charges on petroleum products; i. Percentage or value-added tax (VAT) on sales, barters or exchanges or similar transactions on goods or services except as otherwise provided herein; j. Taxes on the gross receipts of transportation contractors and persons engaged in the transportation of passengers or freight by hire and common carriers by air, land or water, except as provided in this Code; k. Taxes on premium paid by way of reinsurance or retrocession; l. Taxes, fees or charges for the registration of motor vehicle and for the issuance of all kinds of licenses or permits for the driving thereof, except tricycles; m. Taxes, fees, or charges on Philippine products actually exported, except as otherwise provided herein; n. Taxes, fees, or charges, on Countryside and Barangay Business Enterprises and cooperatives duly registered under R.A. No. 6810 and Republic Act Numbered Sixty-nine thirty-eight (R.A. No. 6938) otherwise known as the “Cooperatives Code of the Philippines” respectively; and o. Taxes, fees or charges, of any kind on the National Government, its agencies, instrumentalities, and local government units.” 3 Table 1 presents the taxing powers of each level of LGU based on the LGC. Table 1. Taxing Powers, by LGU Level Tax Base Province Cities Municipalities Municipalities within the Metropolitan Manila Area Transfer of Real Property Ownership (Section 135 of the LGC) Yes Yes No Yes Printing and Publication (Section 136 of the LGC) Yes Yes No Yes Franchise Tax (Section 137 of the LGC) Yes Yes No Yes Sand, Gravel and Other Quarry Resources (Section 138 of the LGC) Yes Yes No Yes Professional Tax (with required government examination) (Section 139 of the LGC) Yes Yes No Yes Amusement Tax (Section 140 of the LGC, as amended by RA No. 9640, 21 May 2009) Yes Yes No Yes Annual Fixed Tax for Every Delivery Truck or Van of Manufacturers or Producers, Wholesalers of, Dealers, or Retailers in, Certain Products (Section 141 of the LGC) Yes Yes No Yes Business Tax (Section 143 of the LGC) No Yes Yes Yes Community Tax (Section 156 of the LGC) No Yes Yes Yes Real Property Tax (RPT) (Section 232 of the LGC) Yes Yes No1 Yes Additional Levy on Real Property for the Special Education Fund (SEF) (Section 235 of the LGC) Yes Yes No Yes Additional Ad Valorem Tax on Idle Lands (Section 236 of the LGC) Yes Yes No Yes Special Levy on Lands Benefited by Public Works, Projects or Improvements Funded by LGU concerned (Section 240 of the LGC) Yes Yes Yes Yes Socialized Housing Tax (RA No. 7279 and Department of Finance [DOF] Local Finance Circular No. 1-97 dated April 10, 19972) No Yes No No 1 Section 271 of the LGC provides that the proceeds of the basic real property tax, including interest thereon, and proceeds from the use, lease or disposition, sale or redemption of property acquired at a public auction by the province shall be distributed as follows: 1) province – thirty-five (35%) shall accrue to the general funds; 2) municipality – forty percent (40%) to the general fund of the municipality where the property is located; and 3) barangay – twenty-five percent (25%) shall accrue to the barangay where the property is located. 2 Guidelines for the Implementation of Sections 7, 20, and 43 of R.A. 7279 otherwise known as the Urban Development and Housing Act of 1992; and to Supplement Local Finance Circular No. 3-92 dated September 11, 1992 4 Tax Base Province Cities Municipalities Municipalities within the Metropolitan Manila Area Fees and Charges on Business Occupation (Section 147 of the LGC) No Yes Yes Yes Fees for Sealing and Licensing of Weights and Measures (Section 148 of the LGC) No Yes Yes Yes Fishery Rentals, Fees (Section 149 of the LGC) Charges No Yes Yes Yes Service Fees and Charges (Section 153 of the LGC) Yes Yes Yes Yes Public Utility Charges (Section 154 of the LGC) Yes Yes Yes Yes Toll Fees or Charges (Section 155 of the LGC) Yes Yes Yes Yes Other Fees and Charges (Sections 147 and 151 of the LGC) No Yes Yes Yes and Taxing Powers of Municipalities Except as otherwise provided in the LGC, municipalities may levy taxes, fees and charges not otherwise levied by the provinces (Section 142 of the LGC). Taxing Powers of Cities Except as otherwise provided in the LGC, the city may levy the taxes, fees and charges which the province or municipality may impose: Provided, however, that the taxes, fees, and charges levied and collected by highly-urbanized and independent component cities shall accrue to them and distributed in accordance with the provisions of the same law (Section 151 of the LGC). The rates of taxes that the city may levy may exceed the maximum rates allowed for the province or municipality by not more than fifty percent (50%) except the rates of professional and amusement taxes (Section 151 of the LGC). The city may levy and collect a percentage tax on any business not otherwise specified under paragraphs (a) to (g), Article 233 of the Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) of the LGC, at rates not exceeding three percent (3%) of the gross sales or receipts of the preceding calendar year (Article 237 [b] of IRR of the LGC implementing Section 151 of the LGC). A city may levy local business tax in addition to local franchise tax at the same time (Angeles Electric Corporation v. City of Angeles and Juliet G. Quinsaat, General Registry [G.R.] No. 213136, September 5, 2018). 5 Taxing Powers of the Municipalities within the Metropolitan Manila Area The municipalities within the Metropolitan Manila Area (MMA) may levy the taxes on businesses enumerated in Article 233 of the IRR of the LGC, at rates not exceeding fifty percent (50%) of the maximum rates prescribed for said businesses (Article 236 [a] of the IRR of the LGC). The municipalities within the MMA, pursuant to Article 275 of the IRR of the LGC, may levy and collect the taxes which may be imposed by the province at the rates not exceeding those prescribed under Articles 225, 226, 227, 228, 229, 230, and 231 of the IRR of the LGC (Article 236 [b] of the IRR of the LGC). In the case of the basic RPT, the municipalities within the MMA shall fix a uniform rate not exceeding two percent (2%) of the assessed value of real property (Section 233 [b] of the LGC). Fundamental Principles in Local Government Budgeting Section 305 of the LGC provides the following fundamental principles which govern the financial affairs, transactions, and operations of LGUs, to wit: “SECTION 305. Fundamental Principles. - The financial affairs, transactions, and operations of local government units shall be governed by the following fundamental principles: a. No money shall be paid out of the local treasury except in pursuance of an appropriations ordinance or law; b. Local government funds and monies shall be spent solely for public purposes; c. Local revenue is generated only from sources expressly authorized by law or ordinance, and collection thereof shall at all times be acknowledged properly; d. All monies officially received by a local government officer in any capacity or on any occasion shall be accounted for as local funds unless otherwise provided by law; e. Trust funds in the local treasury shall not be paid out except in fulfillment of the purpose for which the trust was created or the funds received; f. Every officer of the local government unit whose duties permit or require the possession or custody of local funds shall be properly bonded, and such officer shall be accountable and responsible for said funds and for the safekeeping thereof in conformity with the provisions of law; g. Local governments shall formulate sound financial plans, and local budgets shall be based on functions, activities, and projects, in terms of expected results; 6 h. Local budget plans and goals shall, as far as practicable, be harmonized with national development plans, goals, and strategies in order to optimize the utilization of resources and to avoid duplication in use of fiscal and physical resources; i. Local budgets shall operationalize approved local development plans; j. Local government units shall ensure that their respective budgets incorporate the requirements of their component units and provide for equitable allocation of resources among these component units; k. National planning shall be based on local planning to ensure that the needs and aspirations of the people as articulated by the local government units in their respective local development plans, are considered in the formulation of budgets of national line agencies or offices; l. Fiscal responsibility shall be shared by all those exercising authority over the financial affairs, transactions, and operations of the local government units; and m. The local government unit shall endeavor to have a balanced budget in each fiscal year of operation.” 7 CHAPTER 1. PARTICIPATORY BUDGETING Participatory budgeting is an approach wherein citizens, through CSOs,3 are allowed to take part in the process of allocating public resources. It offers citizens the opportunity to contribute in the formulation of options and in making choices that will affect how their government acts. Since participatory budgeting helps promote transparency, it has the potential of reducing government inefficiencies and corruption.4 1.1 Legal Bases of Participatory Budgeting “The State shall encourage non-governmental, community-based, or sectoral organizations that promote the welfare of the nation.” (Section 23, Article II of the 1987 Philippine Constitution) “The participation of the private sector in local governance, particularly in the delivery of basic services, shall be encouraged to ensure the viability of local autonomy as an alternative strategy for sustainable development.” (Section 3 [l] of the LGC) “Local government units shall promote the establishment and operation of people’s and non-governmental organizations to become active partners in the pursuit of local autonomy.” (Section 34 of the LGC) 1.2 Guidelines on Participatory Budgeting To ensure the genuine and meaningful engagement of civil society, the following parameters shall guide both the LGUs and CSOs: a. LGUs shall allow and practice genuine participation of people in the planning and budgeting processes to promote and establish transparency and accountability in all transactions related to public financial management (PFM). b. LGUs shall encourage participation and involvement of the CSOs, as part of the Local Development Councils (LDCs) and as observers in the Local Finance Committees (LFCs), in the processes of setting directions and allocating available resources. The purpose is to draw concerned citizens together to participate and give inputs in decision-making related to local plans and budget. 3 CSOs refer to a non-state and non-profit association that works to improve society and the human condition. Basic types of CSOs include non-governmental organizations, people’s organizations, civic organizations, cooperatives, social movements, professional groups, business groups, and people’s councils. 4 Handbook on the Participation of Civil Society Organizations in the Local Budget Process (Local Budget Circular No. 106 dated June 9, 2015) 8 c. LGUs shall apply democratic principles in group decision-making techniques to arrive at choices and preferences that are genuinely responsive to people’s needs, particularly those of the marginalized and disadvantaged members of society. d. LGUs shall embody decisions arrived at in the plan and budget as products of broad–based consultation and participation that engender people’s collective consensus, commitment, and ownership. e. LGUs are encouraged to enhance participative planning in different venues, such as: In training workshops - more work than listening to lectures; In focused group discussions - discuss/resolve the issues at hand; In formal institutions - schools and formal classes are used; and Digital Governance - wide use of electronic system or computers to communicate with constituents via social media and other interactive platforms. f. LGUs shall establish priorities and allocate resources during investment programming of programs, projects, and activities (PPAs) as major links to budgeting. The ranked PPAs and their corresponding resource requirements become the bases for preparing the annual budget proposals. Both LGUs and CSOs shall also be guided by the following Principles of Engagement, as embodied under Item 4.1 of the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) National Budget Circular No. 536 dated January 31, 2012:5 Transparency – provide all parties, as well as the general public, timely access to relevant and verified information/data subject to the limits of the law; Accountability – abide by the policies, standards, and guidelines of engagement that may be agreed upon, and fulfill commitments; Integrity – adhere to moral and professional standards in fulfilling commitments; Partnership – cooperate and share responsibilities to ensure that the objectives of the engagement are achieved; Consultation and mutual empowerment – enhance knowledge sharing and continuing dialogue; Respect internal processes – understand and abide by the limitations of the stakeholders with respect to the nature of the information to be disclosed and the extent of involvement based on institutional/legally imposed limitations; 5 Guidelines on Partnership with Civil Society Organizations and Other Stakeholders in the Preparation of Agency Budget Proposals 9 1.3 Sustainability – ensure continuing engagement by instituting progressive policies and operational mechanisms that will promote an environment of mutual trust; and National interest – uphold the national welfare above the interest of organizations or individuals. Benefits of Participatory Budgeting Participatory budgeting increases opportunities for participation. While questions remain regarding whether the quality of participation is sufficient to ensure lasting interest in participating, and whether it is sufficiently broadbased, participatory budgeting can break down barriers between citizens and government, thereby, improving mutual understanding and communication. Participatory budgeting also strengthens local CSOs, which may improve local governance in the long term. It is noted, though, that the organizations that gain access to decision making and partnership with local government may themselves become arms of the local government. Participatory budgeting can also help make infrastructure and services more relevant to communities they serve and can result in additional revenue for local development.6 Figure 1 below further outlines the benefits of participatory budgeting. Figure 1. Benefits of Participatory Budgeting 6 Participatory Budgeting, edited by Anwar Shah, Public Sector Governance and Accountability Series, The World Bank, Washington D.C., undated 10 1.4 Membership of CSOs to the Local Development Council The CSO shall be represented in the LDCs pursuant to Section 107 (b) and (c) of the LGC, as follows: a. The city or municipal development council shall be headed by the mayor and shall be composed of the following members: 1. All punong barangays in the city or municipality; 2. The chairperson of the committee on appropriations of the sangguniang panlungsod or sangguniang bayan concerned; 3. The congressman/congresswoman or his/her representative; and 4. Representatives of non-governmental organizations operating in the city or municipality, as the case may be, who shall constitute not less than one-fourth (1/4) of the members of the fully organized council. b. The provincial development council shall be headed by the governor and shall be composed of the following members: 1. All mayors of component cities and municipalities; 2. The chairperson of the committee on appropriations of the sangguniang panlalawigan; 3. The congressman/congresswoman or his/her representative; and 4. Representatives of non-governmental organizations operating in the province, who shall constitute not less than one-fourth (1/4) of the members of the fully organized council. 1.5 Roles of CSOs in the Local Budget Process Decisions involving sources of financing, priorities in the use of funds, and allocation of scarce resources necessitate the involvement of stakeholders who can share ideas and information on sound PFM. The CSOs may be engaged in all phases of the budget process, as provided in the Handbook on the Participation of CSOs in the Local Budget Process, and as outlined in the subsequent Chapters of this Manual. Table 2. Roles of CSOs in the Local Budget Process7 ACTIVITY Budget Preparation Phase 1. ISSUE THE BUDGET CALL 7 CSO ROLES Check that Annual Investment Program (AIP) priorities are highlighted in the Budget Call. Source: Handbook on the Participation of Civil Society Organizations in the Local Budget Process 11 ACTIVITY 2. CONDUCT THE FORUM CSO ROLES BUDGET The accredited CSOs may participate in the Budget Forum to gain an overall appreciation of the thrusts and priorities of the LGU for the budget year as contained in the Budget Call. 3. PREPARE AND BUDGET PROPOSALS SUBMIT The accredited CSOs sectoral representative may partner with the Department Heads concerned in determining the target beneficiaries and funding requirements for the particular sector. The CSOs may also propose projects for consideration by the Department Heads concerned. In cases where CSOs’ proposed PPAs are not included in the budget, CSOs can request information from the LGU on the reasons for non-inclusion. 4. CONDUCT HEARINGS BUDGET The accredited CSOs may participate in the budget hearings to provide inputs on sectoral concerns. 5. EVALUATE PROPOSALS BUDGET The accredited CSOs may replicate the best practices of other CSOs in engaging LFC. 6. SUBMIT EXECUTIVE BUDGET The accredited CSOs may attend the TO SANGGUNIAN State of the Province/City/Municipality Address. Budget Authorization Phase 1. DELIBERATE ON THE BUDGET Observing the Internal Rules of Procedure (IRP) of the sanggunian, the accredited CSOs may: a. Provide inputs concerns; and on sectoral b. Raise questions on changes in the Executive Budget not found in the approved AIP. 2. AUTHORIZE BUDGET THE ANNUAL The accredited CSOs may observe the voting conducted by the sanggunian. 3. APPROVE THE The accredited CSOs may inform the APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE local chief executive (LCE) in writing of (AO) their observation in the deliberation and 12 ACTIVITY CSO ROLES enactment of AO, subject to the applicable reglementary period. 4. POST THE APPROPRIATION The accredited CSOs may monitor the ORDINANCE posting pursuant to the requirements under the LGC of the approved AO, and may assist in making this known to the public. Budget Review Phase 1. ISSUE THE REVIEW ACTION Budget Execution Phase 1. RELEASE THE ALLOTMENTS The accredited CSOs may request for a copy of the review action from the LGU. Monitor the LGU compliance on the release of allotments. Inform beneficiaries and communities concerned of the release of allotments through tri-media or conduct meetings with the beneficiaries and communities concerned. 2. POST THE STATEMENT OF Monitor the posting as required under RECEIPTS AND EXPENDITURES the LGC and the Full Disclosure Policy IN THE LGU WEBSITE of the Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG). Advocate for citizen’s awareness of posted information through tri-media. 3. PREPARE CASH PROGRAM Monitor the LGU compliance on the AND FINANCIAL AND PHYSICAL preparation of cash program and PERFORMANCE TARGETS financial and physical performance targets. Inform beneficiaries and communities concerned of the information through tri-media or conduct meetings with the beneficiaries and communities concerned. 4. PROCURE, AND OBLIGATE AND DISBURSE FUNDS FOR PPA IMPLEMENTATION 4.1 Procurement Process Attend as observer in the procurement process and carry out the responsibilities provided under Section 13.4 of the IRR of RA No. 9184. May use as reference the Government 13 ACTIVITY 4.2 PPA Execution CSO ROLES Procurement Policy Board (GPPB)issued 2014 Procurement Observers Guide. May participate in the monitoring of ongoing projects and prepare the Project Monitoring/Inspection Report (Annex F of this Manual) for submission to the LCE. The accredited CSOs may check the following, among others: ● standards of service; ● quality of work; ● timeliness of implementation; ● pricing of goods, contracts, and services; ● PPA fund release/utilization; and ● proper delivery to target beneficiaries. May assist the LGU in undertaking appropriate interventions on negative deviations on PPA execution, which may include providing possible support for service and/or resource gaps in the delivery of services. May check the LGU compliance with the review action. Budget Accountability Phase 1. EVALUATE OUTPUTS AND May participate RESULTS OF PPAs evaluation. in the project Enhance CSOs own technical capability in project evaluation. May provide recommendations based on evaluation results. May organize citizens’ fora with the LGU to provide feedback to the community. 14 CHAPTER 2. POLICY-BASED BUDGETING Policy-based budgeting means that the budget is prepared with due regard to local government policy, which, in turn, should be harmonized with the development plans and reflected in the investment programs that the LGUs are required to prepare pursuant to the LGC. A major indicator of policy-based budgeting is when an LGU is able to fund in its general fund budget/s the PPAs that were prioritized in the investment programs, which, in turn, were based on the approved long-term development plan. Another indicator of policy-based budgeting is orderliness in the planning and budgeting processes, as demonstrated in compliance with the Synchronized Local Planning and Budgeting Calendar (SLPBC) for LGUs. 2.1 Legal Bases of Policy-Based Budgeting “Each local government unit shall have a comprehensive multi-sectoral development plan to be initiated by its development council and approved by its sanggunian. For this purpose, the development council at the provincial, city, municipal, or barangay level, shall assist the corresponding sanggunian in setting the direction of economic and social development, and coordinating development efforts within its territorial jurisdiction.” (Section 106 of the LGC) “The provincial, city, and municipal development councils shall exercise the following functions: (1) Formulate long-term, medium-term, and annual socio-economic development plans and policies; (2) Formulate the medium-term and annual public investment programs;” (Section 109 [a] [1-2] of the LGC) “Local budget plans and goals shall, as far as practicable, be harmonized with national development plans, goals, and strategies in order to optimize the utilization of resources and to avoid duplication in the use of fiscal and physical resources;” (Section 305 [h] of the LGC) “Local budgets shall operationalize approved local development plans;” (Section 305 [i] of the LGC) 15 “LDCs shall submit to the local finance committee a copy of the approved local development plan and AIP prepared and approved during the fiscal year before the calendar for budget preparation in accordance with applicable laws, specifying therein projects proposed for inclusion in the local government budget as well as in the budgets of [National Government Agencies] NGAs or [Government- Owned or –Controlled Corporations] GOCCs concerned. The local finance committee shall use the plan to ensure that projects proposed for local funding are included in the budget. NGAs and GOCCs shall provide LGUs all necessary information on projects already funded in their respective budgets. Such information shall include specifically, among other things: name of project, location, sources, and levels of funding for said projects. The same information must be made available to the local finance committee concerned within the first quarter of the year to avoid duplications in funding project proposals.” (Article 410 of the IRR of the LGC) 2.2 Key Players in Policy-Based Budgeting LDC Chairman – The city or municipal development council shall be headed by the mayor (Section 107 [b] of the LGC). The provincial development council shall be headed by the governor (Section 107 [c] of the LGC). LDC Members – Each LGU shall have a comprehensive multi-sectoral development plan to be initiated by its development council and approved by its sanggunian. The development council at the provincial, city, municipal, or barangay level, shall assist the corresponding sanggunian in setting the direction of economic and social development, and coordinating development efforts within its territorial jurisdiction (Section 106 of the LGC). The composition of the provincial, city or municipal development council shall be consistent with Sections 107 (b) and (c) of the LGC. LDC Executive Committee – The executive committee shall exercise the following powers and functions under Section 111 (b) of the LGC: 1. Ensure that the decisions of the council are faithfully carried out and implemented; 2. Act on matters requiring immediate attention or action by the council; 3. Formulate policies, plans, and programs based on the general principles laid down by the council; and 4. Act on other matters that may be authorized by the council. 16 To do away with unwieldy and costly meetings of the development council, the creation of an executive committee composed of few members is authorized to do the execution and administrative functions of the council. Secretariat – There is hereby constituted for each LDC a secretariat which shall be responsible for providing technical support in the documentation of proceedings, preparation of reports, and such other assistance as may be required in the discharge of its functions. The secretariats of the provincial, city, and municipal development councils shall be headed by their respective planning and development coordinators. Sanggunian – Each LGU shall have a comprehensive multi-sectoral development plan to be initiated by its development council and approved by its sanggunian (Section 106 of the LGC). 2.3 Harmonizing Plans and Policies Section 106 of the LGC explicitly requires all LGUs to have a comprehensive multi-sectoral development plan, which shall be translated into PPAs through investment programs. To operationalize the aforementioned requirement, the planning manuals issued by the Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development (DHSUD), DILG, and National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA) require the LGUs to prepare the following: For Provinces 2.3.1 Provincial Development and Physical Framework Plan (PDPFP) The PDPFP is a document that identifies strategies and corresponding PPAs that serve as primary inputs to the provincial investment programming, budgeting and implementation. The PDPFP also serves as a key vertical influence in linking provincial development objectives with local, regional and national policies and priorities. 2.3.2 Provincial Development Investment Program (PDIP) The PDIP is a basic document linking the local development plan to the budget for provinces. It contains a prioritized list of PPAs which are derived from the PDPFP matched with financing resources, and to be implemented within a three (3) to six (6)-year period. For Cities and Municipalities 2.3.3 Comprehensive Development Plan (CDP) The CDP is the multi-sectoral plan formulated at the city or municipal level, which embodies the vision, sectoral goals, objectives, development strategies and policies within the terms of LGU officials and the medium-term. The CDP contains: (1) Ecological Profile; (2) Sectoral Development Plan; and (3) Implementing Instruments. 17 2.3.4 Local Development Investment Program (LDIP) The LDIP is a basic document linking the local development plan to the budget for cities and municipalities. It contains a prioritized list of PPAs which are derived from the CDP matched with financing resources, and to be implemented within a three (3) to six (6)-year period. The LDIP is the principal document for implementing the CDP. It translates the CDP into PPAs, and reflects those which shall be prioritized by the LGU for funding in the general fund budgets or through other fund generation schemes. 2.3.5 Comprehensive Land Use Plan (CLUP) The CLUP is the plan for the long-term management of the local territory that defines the guidelines on the allocation, utilization, development, and management of all lands according to the inherent qualities of the land itself and supportive economic, demographic, socio-cultural and environmental objectives of the city or municipality. It identifies areas where development can and cannot be located and directs public and private investment accordingly. It also contains PPAs related to land use and urban planning that should be integrated to the CDP, LDIP, and AIP. For Provinces, Cities, and Municipalities 2.3.6 Executive-Legislative Agenda (ELA) The ELA is a unifying document corresponding to the term of local elective officials that is developed and mutually agreed upon by both the executive and legislative departments of an LGU. The ELA supports existing LGU planning processes and adds greater value to the CLUP and CDP by moving them forward to getting implemented and monitored.8 2.3.7 Annual Investment Program (AIP) The AIP refers to the annual slice of the PDIP/LDIP, which constitutes the total resource requirements for all PPAs consisting of the annual capital expenditure (CapEx) and regular operating requirements of the LGU. As also provided under Section 305 (h) of the LGC and Article 410 of the IRR of the same law, the foregoing plans and investment programs should be harmonized with the plans and investment programs of higher level LGUs, as well as that of the national government (NG), to optimize the utilization of resources and to avoid duplication in the use of fiscal and physical resources. 8 Clarificatory Guidelines on the Formulation of the Executive-Legislative Agenda (ELA) (DILG Memorandum Circular No. 2019114 dated 18 July 2019) 18 Moreover, in formulating the investment programs, policies of both executive and legislative departments should also be considered. The ELA shall be mutually developed and agreed upon by the executive and legislative departments of the LGU. While the ELA is also a planning tool, it is not meant to replace or duplicate existing planning systems. Instead, it should reflect the policies of the current administration and should be used as an instrument to implement and monitor the long-term plans (PDPFP and CDP) of the LGUs.9 The processes for formulating the foregoing development plans and investment programs are detailed under the CLUP Guidebooks and Supplemental Guidelines, and subsequent amendments issued by DHSUD, the CDP Guide and Concise Illustrative Guide for the Preparation, Review, Monitoring and Updating of the CDP and LDIP issued by the DILG, Interim Guidelines on the Formulation of PDPFP, and the Manual for Provincial/Local Planning and Expenditure Management issued by the NEDA. 2.4 Linking the Budget to Harmonized Plans and Policies The IRR of the LGC is very instructive on how to ensure that local budgets are linked to harmonized local plans and policies. To reiterate, Article 410 of the IRR of the LGC provides that LDCs shall submit to the LFC a copy of the local development plan and AIP prepared and approved during the fiscal year before the calendar for budget preparation in accordance with applicable laws, specifying therein projects proposed for inclusion in the local government budget as well as in the budgets of NGAs and GOCCs concerned. The foregoing provision is clear on the following: 1. That the AIP should be prepared and approved before the start of the local budget preparation phase; and 2. That the local budgets shall fund PPAs included in the AIP. It may also be gleaned from the foregoing that the link between the plan and the budget is actually provided by the investment programs, particularly by the AIP (see Figure 2). Hence, to ensure plan-budget linkage wherein the local budgets truly operationalize approved local development plans, it is imperative that: 1. The investment programs contain priority PPAs that will directly contribute to the achievement of the goals and objectives of the LGU, as embodied in the development plans; and 2. The local budgets fund the PPAs included in the investment programs, particularly in the AIP. 9 Concise Illustrative Guide for the Preparation, Review, Monitoring and Updating of the CDP and LDIP issued by the DILG 19 Figure 2. Plan-Budget Link Model10 2.5 Synchronized Plan-Budget Process The planning-budgeting cycle commences in July of an election year when the LGUs reconstitute their Local Planning Teams. Provinces start setting the guidelines for the updating of the planning databases, while the cities and municipalities start preparing the work plan for the updating or preparation of the CDP and CLUP. From July to August, the provinces assess the implementation of their respective PDPFP and update their planning databases. The cities and municipalities, on the other hand, update their Rationalized Planning Indicator Data Sets (RaPIDS) or Local Development Indicator Set (LDIS) and their Ecological Profile. To help the provinces in updating their planning databases, the Bureau of Local Government Finance (BLGF), through the DILG, may provide them with data on financial indicators. The DILG also provides the RaPIDS and/or LDIS financial indicators to the cities and municipalities. Starting September, the LGUs reconstitute their Local Special Bodies – LDC, Peace and Order Council, Local Health Board (LHB), and Local School Board (LSB). From November to December, the Provincial Development Councils (PDCs) are convened to deliberate on the PDPFP and Structured List of PPAs of their component cities and municipalities for the purpose of harmonization. At the 10 Source: DILG Local Planning Illustrative Guide: Preparing and Updating the CDP 20 city and municipal levels, the LCE presents the Structured List of PPAs to the PDC. Within the said period, the Medium-Term Revenue Forecasts for planning purposes are generated by the Local Treasurers while the Medium-Term Forecasts of Current Operating Expenses (COE) and Capital Outlays (CO) for administrative/support services are prepared by the LFC, with the Local Budget Officer (LBO) in the lead. Table 3. Sample Template for Medium Term Revenue Forecast11 Past Four (4) Years Historical Values (in thousand pesos) Past Three (3) Years Historical Growth Rates Particulars 2018 2019 2020 2021 2019 2020 2021 With Negative Values? Three (3) Year Average RECEIPTS Local Sources Tax Revenue Non-tax Revenue External Sources National Tax Allotment (NTA) Shares other than NTA Non-Income Receipts Proceeds from Sale of Assets/ Investments (Bonds or Securities) Collection of Loans Receivable Receipts from Loans, Borrowings or Issuance of Bonds NOTES: 1. If there are negative values in any of the past three (3) years growth rate, input "1" on the appropriate box so that the three (3)-year average will be based on the median which will be less affected by the decline in the growth of the revenue item (e.g., business taxes). 2. The LGU may also seek guidance and assistance from the BLGF on revenue forecasting. The BLGF and DBM shall provide technical assistance to the Local Treasurer and LFCs, respectively, in coming up with the aforementioned forecasts. 11 Source: Figure 6 of eSRE 2015 BLGF Manual and Form 3.d Summary Medium Term Financing Plan of DILG CDP Illustrative Guide 21 Points to Consider in Formulating the Medium-Term Forecast of COE and CO for Administrative/Support Services Personal Services (PS) Based on the latest approved Plantilla of Personnel; Proposed creation and filling-up of positions shall be included as separate items; and Requirements for retirement benefits / terminal leave benefits, salary increases, and other authorized benefits shall be included. Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses (MOOE) Consider demand-driven changes e.g., population, cost of maintaining an ideal level of service; Consider budgetary implications of price changes (inflation), except those based on contracts or with fixed rates; and Include maintenance requirements of existing as well as newly-completed facilities and newly-acquired assets e.g., vehicles. Financial Expenses (FEs) Include Management Supervisions/Trusteeship Fees, Interest Expenses, Interest Paid to Residents other than General Government, Interest Paid to other General Government Units, Guarantee Fees, Bank Charges, Commitment Fees and Other Financial Charges, all other fees and charges related to loans payable, and losses incurred relative to foreign exchange transactions (Commission on Audit [COA] Government Accounting Manual Volume III). Capital Outlays (COs) Include office equipment and furniture and fixtures that have to be procured over the medium-term. The aforementioned forecasts are used as inputs to finalize the LDIP,12 which takes off from the Structured List of PPAs or the long list of the PPAs13 that will implement the goals and objectives reflected in the CDP, PDPFP, and CLUP. The Structured List of PPAs is subjected to further screening using the following tools:14 Urgency Test Matrix; Resource Impact Matrix; Conflict-CompatibilityComplementary Matrix; and Goal Achievement Matrix. Based on the results of the foregoing screening tools, a ranked list of PPAs is derived. The ranked list of PPAs shall be Tools for Prioritizing PPAs: Urgency Test Matrix compares the level of urgency of PPAs. Resource Impact Matrix compares how the PPAs will impact on LGU resources, including financial, manpower and natural resources. Conflict – Compatibility – Complementary Matrix checks if the PPAs will conflict with or complement each other. Goal Achievement Matrix checks how each PPA contributes to the achievement of the LGU vision or goals. 12 The process described hereinafter may also be adopted by the Provinces. The Structured List of PPAs or the Long List of PPAs is from the five (5) development sectors. This will be the main source of PPAs that will later be prioritized for implementation. Note that this list should be traceable or linked to the descriptors in the LGU Vision, Goals and Objectives. 14 Concise Illustrative Guide for the Preparation, Review, Monitoring and Updating of the CDP 13 22 considered for investment programming. It shall then be cross-matched with available resources, particularly with investible funds, as identified by the LFC, through the evaluation of the Medium-Term Revenue Forecasts vis-à-vis the Medium-Term Forecast of COE and CO for administrative/support services. Thereafter, the LGU will prepare the LDIP depending on the financing approach it will adopt. If it chooses to take a more conservative approach, then the PPAs to be included in the LDIP will be limited to the new investment financing potential of the LGU. New Investment Financing Potential = Medium Term Revenue Forecast – Medium Term Forecast of COE and CO for Administrative/Support Services If the LGU chooses to be pragmatic or developmental in its financing approach, then it will include PPAs in the LDIP that can be funded by the new investment financing potential of the LGU, as well as from additional funds resulting from resource generation measures and other financing options, e.g., borrowings, bond flotations, Public-Private Partnerships. The LDIP is considered as an implementation instrument of the CDP, PDPFP, and CLUP, thus, is approved with the CDP, together with other implementation instruments. 2.6 Preparation of the Annual Investment Program Based on the approved LDIP, the annual slice thereof is culled out to constitute the AIP. As defined under DILG-NEDA-DBM-DOF Joint Memorandum Circular (JMC) No. 1, dated November 18, 2016,15 AIP refers to the annual slice of the LDIP, which constitutes the total requirements for all PPAs consisting of the annual CapEx and regular operating requirements of the LGU. The AIP preparation flowchart (Figure 3) shows the sequence of activities from the time the LDC convened until the same is approved by the sanggunian concerned. Preparation and/or Approval of AIP by the LDC – The LDC shall meet at least once every six (6) months or as often as may be necessary (Section 110 of the LGC). The Synchronized Local Planning and Budgeting Calendar (SLPBC 2016) under the DILG-NEDA-DBM-DOF JMC No. 1, s. 2016 provides that the preparation of the AIP shall be done within the month of May of each year. Contents of the AIP – It is the responsibility of the LGUs to ensure that, apart from the PDPFP, CLUP, and CDP, the priorities and requirements of the following various plans were considered in the formulation of the AIP: ● DILG-endorsed Gender and Development Plan and Budget; 15 Updated Guidelines on the Harmonization of Local Planning, Investment Programming, Resource Mobilization, Budgeting, Expenditure Management, and Performance Monitoring and Coordination in Fiscal Oversight 23 ● Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Plan as reviewed by the appropriate reviewing authority consistent with RA No. 10121, its IRR, and pertinent issuances of the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC); ● Local Climate Change Action Plan; ● Peace and Order Plan; ● Local Youth Development Plan; ● Local Nutrition Action Plan; ● Annual Cultural Development Plan approved by the Local Culture and Arts Council through a Resolution; ● Indicative Annual Procurement Plan (APP); ● List of PPAs for the Local Council for the Protection of Children; ● List of PPAs for Senior Citizens and Persons with Disabilities; ● List of PPAs to Combat Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS); ● List of PPAs to Address the Problem of Illegal Drugs; and ● Other documents/plans as may be required and/or deemed necessary in the relevant Local Budget Memorandum to be issued by the DBM. Submission of LDC-approved AIP to the Sanggunian – Reasonable time prior to June 7 of each year. Approval of the AIP by the Sanggunian – The SLPBC 2016 under the DILGNEDA-DBM-DOF JMC No. 1, s. 2016 provides that the approval of the AIP by the sanggunian shall be made on or before June 7 of every year. Figure 3. AIP Preparation Flowchart 24 Unless otherwise modified, the AIP Summary Form below shall be used: Table 4. AIP Summary Form In filling out the AIP Summary Form, the following pointers shall be observed: 1. Column 1 – AIP Reference Code The AIP Reference Code is vital to ensuring the Plan-Budget Linkage. The code assigned to each PPA facilitates validation whether the PPAs funded in the budget are the same PPAs prioritized in the AIP. Figure 4. AIP Reference Code Guide The codes for the offices were included to establish the responsibility centers for the PPAs. 25 Services falling under each sector are presented under Annex C of this Manual while the suggested coding structure for the offices in the LGU are presented under Annex D of this Manual. 2. Column 2 – Program/Project/Activity Description Column 2 should reflect a concise description of the work to be done under a particular sector to achieve specific objectives. The scope and nature of the work to be undertaken by the LGU is better captured by presenting the PPAs in the following manner: PPA Structure I. Program A. Example I. Executive Governance Program 1. Activity 1 2. Activity 2 B. Project A. 1. General Management and Supervision 2. Public Affairs, Information, Communication and Technical Assistance 1. Project 1 B. Operationalization of the Internal Audit Unit (IAU) 1. Rehabilitation of Office Facilities for the IAU 2. Project 2 2. Purchase of Office Equipment and Furniture and Fixtures for the IAU The foregoing structure requires that all activities and projects be subsumed under a specific program, which, in turn, should be under the responsibility of a particular Office/Department in the LGU. Accordingly, the program(s) should be directly related to the mandate of the Office/Department as it should contribute to the achievement of the Office’s/Department’s organizational outcome(s). Program – an integrated group of activities that contribute to a particular continuing objective of a department/agency. Project – a special undertaking carried out within a definite time frame and intended to result in some predetermined measure of goods and services. Activity – a work process that contributes to the implementation of a program, sub-program or project. 3. Column 3 – Implementing Office/Department The implementing Office/Department refers to the Office/Department responsible for the execution of the PPAs, and for delivering the services as mandated by the LGC. The implementing Office/Department should be presented by sector. 4. Columns 4 and 5 – Schedule of Implementation The expected start and completion dates should be specified to provide a concrete basis for work plans, and to serve as a guide in procurement planning. 26 5. Column 6 – Expected Outputs Major Final Outputs (MFOs) shall be identified for each program while immediate outputs shall be identified for each project and activity. An MFO is a good or service that a department/agency is mandated to deliver to external clients through the implementation of PPAs. It may be defined relative to the outcomes that they contribute to, the client or community group it serves, and the business lines of the department/agency. 16 Immediate Output, for purposes of accomplishing the AIP Summary Form, refer to what is actually produced when the activities are undertaken. For Example: PPAs I. Executive Governance Program A. 1. General Management and Supervision 2. Public Affairs, Information, Communication and Technical Assistance B. Operationalization of the IAU 1. Rehabilitation of Office Facilities for the IAU 2. Purchase of Office Equipment and Furniture and Fixtures for the IAU MFO/Immediate Output Executive Governance Services PPA implementation managed LGU personnel supervised Information, Education and Communication activities and materials developed/disseminated Stakeholders assisted Internal Audit operationalized Office Facilities for the IAU rehabilitated Office Equipment and Furniture and Fixtures purchased Sample MFOs and their corresponding Performance Indicators (PIs) are presented under Annex B of this Manual. 6. Column 7 – Funding Source Consistent with the provisions of the LGC and its IRR, whereby the AIP should indicate the PPAs for inclusion in the local government budget as well as in the budgets of NGAs or GOCCs concerned, the following may be indicated under the column for funding source: 16 General Fund (GF) Proper; GF – Special Account (SA) – 20% Development Fund (DF); GF – Local Disaster Risk Reduction Management Fund (LDRRMF); Transfers from NGAs (Other than those accruing to the GF); Transfers from GOCCs (Other than those accruing to the GF); Transfers from other LGUs; Income of Local Economic Enterprises (LEEs) (for its own operations); Loan proceeds; and Others. The Organizational Performance Indicator Framework (OPIF) Reference Guide, 2012 27 7. Columns 8 to 12 – Estimated Cost The total cost of the PPAs is broken down into PS, MOOE, FE, and CO. For purposes of the AIP, the total PS and MOOE costs of a particular program or office, both line departments and administrative/legislative support services, shall represent the current operating cost for all regular activities. Meanwhile, management supervision/trusteeship fees, interest expenses, guarantee fees, bank charges, commitment fees and other financial charges incurred in owning or borrowing an asset property shall form part of the FE. Costs which add to the fixed assets of the LGU are categorized as CO. 8. Columns 13 to 15 – Amount of Climate Change PPAs Indicate the amount pertaining to PPAs for Climate Change Adaptation (CCA) and Climate Change Mitigation (CCM) under Columns 13 and 14, respectively. PPAs for CCA are measures that address the drivers of vulnerability. Vulnerability is the degree to which people or systems are susceptible to the adverse effects of climate change but are unable to cope with them. Vulnerability can be decreased by reduced exposure (e.g., shifting population or assets to less risky areas through zoning regulations), or by increasing coping capacity (e.g., well-targeted poverty reduction, income and livelihood diversification, health programs and dissemination of climate risk information). Measures that directly confront climate change impacts are PPAs that directly address the impacts or potential impacts of climate change variability such as construction of infrastructure that incorporate climate change risks in the design. Measures that build resilience to current and future climate risks, on the other hand, refer to those which increase the capacity of the social or ecological system to reach or maintain an acceptable level of functioning or structuring while undergoing changes. PPAs for CCM are measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions such as, but not limited to, improved energy efficiency, use of renewable energy, improved forest management, and improved transport systems. They also include measures to protect and enhance greenhouse gas sinks and reservoirs such as, but not limited to, Bantay Gubat, Bantay Bakawan, and reforestation. The entire cost of the PPA is reflected as Climate Change expenditure if the program/project profile indicates that the primary goal/objective of the PPA is to provide a direct adaptation or mitigation response. If CCA or CCM is not the primary objective of the PPAs, only the cost of specific components of the PPA that match those listed in the Climate Change Typologies in Annex A of the DBM-Climate Change Commission28 DILG JMC No. 2015-01 dated July 23, 201517 is reflected. 2.7 Procurement Planning and Budgeting Linkage Section 7 of RA No. 918418 and Section 7.3.2 of its IRR explicitly provides that all procurement should be within the approved budget of the Procuring Entity and should be meticulously and judiciously planned by the Procuring Entity concerned. The importance of painstakingly planning all procurement is underscored by the provision of RA No. 9184 that no government procurement shall be undertaken unless it is in accordance with the approved APP of the Procuring Entity. At the local level, as soon as the AIP has been approved by the respective local sanggunian, departments/offices or end-user units may start preparing their Project Procurement Management Plans (PPMPs) to support the requirements and/or cost estimates of the different PPAs, as embodied in the approved AIP. Individual department/office/end-user units shall prepare their respective PPMPs for all PPAs with proposed procurement of goods and services, civil works, and/or consulting services for the operation of their respective departments/offices. The PPMP shall include: (a) information on whether PPAs will be contracted out, implemented by administration, or consigned; (b) the type and objective of contract to be employed; (c) the extent/size of contract scopes/packages; (d) the procurement methods to be adopted, and indicating if the procurement tasks are to be outsourced; (e) the time schedule for each procurement activity and for the contract implementation; and (f) the estimated budget for the general components of the contract. The PPMP, as appended to the budget proposals of Departments/Offices, shall then be submitted to the procuring entity’s Budget Office for evaluation during the budget preparation phase. The PPMPs included in the budget proposal shall be forwarded to the Bids and Awards Committee (BAC) Secretariat for consolidation into an indicative APP, and to the BAC for the final recommendation of the appropriate procurement modality. In the consolidation of PPMPs, the BAC may adopt a strategy wherein similar items to be procured are packaged into one procurement undertaking under a single PPMP. For this purpose, the indicative APP shall include: (a) Name of Procurement Project; (b) Procurement Management Office/enduse/implementing unit; (c) Method of Procurement; (d) Schedule of identified procurement activities as reflected in the APP form approved by the GPPB; (e) Source of Funds; (f) Indicative Approved Budget for the Contract (ABC); and (g) other relevant descriptions of the project, if applicable. The indicative APP, an attachment to the budget proposal, shall be submitted to the Head of the Procuring Entity (HoPE) for approval. 17 Revised Guidelines for Tagging/Tracking Climate Change Expenditures in the Local Budget (Amending JMC 2014-01, dated August 7, 2014) 18 Government Procurement Reform Act 29 Factors to consider in preparing/consolidating the APP Inclusion of all procurement activities planned for the year; Include provisions to cover foreseeable emergencies or contingencies usually indicated by historical records; and Scheduling of procurement activities in the APP should be done in such a manner that the BAC and other offices/units involved in the procurement process in the LGU are able to efficiently manage the conduct of procurement transactions. Figure 5 shows the procurement planning and budgeting linkage with indicative schedules: Figure 5. Procurement Planning and Budgeting Linkage 30 CHAPTER 3. PERFORMANCE-INFORMED BUDGETING Performance-Informed Budgeting (PIB) is the budgeting approach that uses performance information to link funding to results and to provide a framework for a more informed resource allocation and management.19 PIB, therefore, enables the more meaningful presentation of the budget, whereby each peso is aligned with PIs and tangible targets set by the LGU. Emphasis of an output-driven organization, with corresponding PIs and targets, are discussed in this Manual as an expenditure approach to show full disclosure, transparency and accountability in the budget. 3.1 Legal Bases of PIB Budget proposals of LGUs shall include a brief description of the functions, projects, and activities for the ensuing fiscal year, expected results for each function, project, and activity, and the nature of work to be performed, including the objects of expenditure for each function, project, and activity (Section 317 [b] [3] of the LGC). “Local governments shall formulate sound financial plans, and local budgets shall be based on functions, activities, and projects, in terms of expected results.” (Section 305 [g] of the LGC) “Expected Results refers to the services, products, or benefits that shall accrue to the public, estimated in terms of performance measures or physical targets.” (Section 306 [g] of the LGC) 3.2 Key Players in PIB Local Planning and Development Coordinator (LPDC) – The LPDC shall: 19 Prepare a Logical Framework for all PPAs for implementation; Prioritize the PPAs according to urgency, economy and efficiency and general social welfare objectives; Baseline data of PPAs scheduled for implementation should be made available for target setting; PIB Brief, 2014 31 Coordinate with the LBO and all Department Heads in setting up their MFOs, PIs and corresponding targets for the budget year; Guide all department heads in formulating vision statements for their respective departments that should be aligned to the LGU Vision; and Assist in the monitoring and evaluation of the physical and financial performance of PPAs. Local Budget Officer – The LBO shall: Provide information on actual costs of implementing existing PPAs broken down by expense class and objects of expenditures for the past year and current year (first semester); Estimate costs of PPAs for the second semester of the current year and budget year; and Coordinate with Local Accountant and Local Treasurer in projecting realistic cost estimates for the budget year. Local Accountant – The Local Accountant shall provide information to all Department Heads of actual costs of implementing PPAs for the past year and first semester of the current year broken down by expense class and objects of expenditures. Department/Office Heads – The Department/Office Heads shall: Facilitate in the formulation of the vision for the Department/Office including the expected outcome of the various MFOs; Project the target outputs for each PI for all PPAs; and Maintain a database for all quantifiable information. Local Chief Executive – The LCE shall ensure the alignment of the various Departments/Offices Vision Statements to the major vision of the LGU, and guide all Departments/Offices to attain the expected organizational outcome. 3.3 Conceptual Framework of PIB The PIB Framework follows the Results Framework or the Logical Framework which each Department should establish, and which the LGU should consider in identifying and prioritizing PPAs during investment programming. It is noted that in prioritizing PPAs, the LGUs may use the Goal Achievement Matrix, which can validate the results framework, thus, enable the LGU to formulate its performance information. 32 PIB requires LGUs to strengthen the link between planning and budgeting and show this linkage in the presentation of the budget. The PIB uses performance information to assist in deciding where the government funds will go. Performance information, both financial and nonfinancial, are presented in the budget documents which provides the context for the PPAs pursued by the LGU. The PIB Conceptual Framework is presented in Figure 6 below: Figure 6. PIB Conceptual Framework In the budgeting process, the Departments/Offices of the LGU are required to identify their PPAs that will produce the corresponding MFOs, which in turn, contribute to the attainment of the Organizational Outcome. The Organizational Outcome, which could be more than one, should lead to the attainment of the Department’s mandate, mission and vision. Outcomes are the key desired endresults that an LGU seeks to achieve usually over a number of years in line with its socioeconomic development plan, through the delivery by departments and offices of their outputs and the implementation of PPAs.20 3.4 Key Features/Benefits of PIB21 The PIB as a core PFM reform program is seen as a critical tool in steering the LGU towards inclusive growth and delivers the following key benefits: 20 21 Reinforce the meaning of accountability as a commitment to perform; Empower citizens to participate in the utilization and allocation of resources with more transparent, accountable, and responsive budget documents; Enable LGUs to see opportunities on how activities fit in the broader development plan and how they could collaborate with other LGUs in achieving a common goal; Allow the Executive Branch to ensure that each peso spent is tightly linked to its priority outcomes, to reduce overlaps and to avoid duplicative or inefficient spending; See PIB Frequently-Asked Questions at https://pfm.gov.ph/ckfinder/userfiles/files/PIB%20FAQs%20v7%2021414.pdf Source: Technical Notes on the 2015 Proposed National Budget 33 3.5 Enable the sanggunian to better evaluate the budget proposals and exercise their oversight function to check if the LGU deliver the targeted results; and Ensure that projects and program are properly aligned with the local and national development goals and objectives. PIB Process The PIB process is undertaken as follows: 3.5.1 Formulate the Major Final Outputs. An MFO is a good or service that a department/office is mandated to deliver to external clients through the implementation of PPAs. It may be a single output or group of outputs that are similar in nature, targeted at the same organizational outcome and capable of being summarized by a common performance indicator. The formulation of MFOs involves analyzing the department/office mandate, mission and vision, and organizational outcome, and identifying the goods and services to be delivered to external clients.22 3.5.2 Determine the PPAs to be implemented. PPAs are activities undertaken by a department/office to achieve the purpose for which it is established or created, or to deliver its MFOs. A Program is an integrated group of activities that contributes to a particular continuing objective of a department/agency. A Project is a special department or agency undertaking carried out within a definite time frame and intended to result in some predetermined measure of goods and services. An Activity is a work process that contributes to a program or sub-program or project.23 3.5.3 Determine the relevant Performance Indicators. A PI is a characteristic of performance (quantity, quality, timeliness, or cost) that is to be measured and will illustrate the standard by which a department/office is expected to deliver its MFO. PIs should be verifiable, observable, credible and sustainable, especially for frontline functions of department/office.24 The application of the PIB in the budget process may be illustrated in the various budget forms/documents, as follows: Local Budget Preparation Form (LBP) No. 4 – Mandate, Vision/Mission, Major Final Output, Performance Indicators and Targets; 22 See Inter-Agency Task Force on the Harmonization of the National Government Performance Monitoring, Information and Reporting Systems (Administrative Order No. 25, s. 2011) Memorandum Circular No. 2012-1 dated August 13, 2012 23 See PIB Frequently-Asked Questions at https://pfm.gov.ph/ckfinder/userfiles/files/PIB%20FAQs%20v7%2021414.pdf 24 24 See Inter-Agency Task Force on the Harmonization of the National Government Performance Monitoring, Information and Reporting Systems (Administrative Order No. 25, s. 2011) Memorandum Circular No. 2012-1 dated August 13, 2012 34 Local Expenditure Program (LEP); Appropriation Ordinance – Illustrative Example of Ordinance Authorizing the Annual Appropriations; Local Budget Execution (LBE) Form No. 5 – Summary of Financial and Physical Performance Targets; Local Budget Accountability (LBAc) Form No. 2 – Quarterly Financial Report of Operations; LBAc Form No. 3 – Quarterly Physical Report of Operations; and LBAc Form No. 5 – Physical and Financial Performance Evaluation Form. 35 CHAPTER 4. NEW APPROACH IN BUDGETING To better address the slow pace of implementation of development projects, LGUs may consider adopting Cash Budgeting System (CBS) to expedite the implementation of programs or projects. 4.1 Cash Budgeting System As a general rule, unexpended balances of appropriations shall lapse at the end of the fiscal year pursuant to Sections 322 and 328 of the LGC. For CO appropriations, the same shall remain valid in the ensuing fiscal years until fully spent, reverted or the project is completed. Sections 322 and 328 of the LGC provide: “Unexpended balances of appropriations authorized in the annual appropriations ordinance shall revert to the unappropriated surplus of the general fund at the end of the fiscal year and shall not thereafter be available for the expenditure except by subsequent enactment. However, appropriations for capital outlays shall continue and remain valid until fully spent, reverted or the project is completed. Reversions of continuing appropriations shall not be allowed unless obligations therefor have been fully paid or otherwise settled. The balances of continuing appropriations shall be reviewed as part of the annual budget preparation and the sanggunian concerned may approve, upon recommendation of the local chief executive, the reversion of funds no longer needed in connection with the activities funded by said continuing appropriations subject to the provisions of this section.” (Section 322 of the LGC) “Appropriations for ordinary administrative purposes not duly obligated shall terminate with the fiscal year and all unexpended balances thereof shall be automatically reverted on the thirty-first (31st) day of December of each year to the general fund of the local government unit.” (Section 328 of the LGC) The CBS at the national level is mandated under EO No. 91, s. 2019.25 The strategy seeks to improve the fiscal planning of the NG to speed up the implementation of programs and to deliver goods and services to the people in a timely manner. The LCE and/or local sanggunian may provide for the adoption of the CBS in the General Provision of the AO authorizing the annual budget. 25 Adopting the Cash Budgeting System Beginning Fiscal Year 2019, and for Other Purposes 36 4.2 Fundamental Principles of CBS The adoption of a similar strategy in the LGUs may find basis under the following fundamental principles in local government budgeting, among others: “(g) Local governments shall formulate sound financial plans, and local budgets shall be based on functions, activities, and projects, in terms of expected results; (h) Local budget plans and goals shall, as far as practicable, be harmonized with national development plans, goals, and strategies in order to optimize utilization of resources and to avoid duplication in use of fiscal and physical resources;” (Section 305 [g] [h] of the LGC) The CBS suggests that the annual budget should only contain the projected budget requirements of PPAs that can be fully implemented and paid within the fiscal year covered by the AO. Hence, PPAs included in the annual budget should be completed by the end of the fiscal year. Under CBS, all appropriations for a fiscal year shall be available for obligation and disbursement only until the end of the same fiscal year. Specifically, the construction of infrastructure projects, delivery of goods and services, inspection, and acceptance shall be made within the fiscal year. Furthermore, the CBS suggests that corresponding payments shall be made within the same fiscal year, which may be extended until the end of the EPP, which shall be a period of three (3) months after the end of the validity of appropriations, unless another period has been determined by the sanggunian, upon recommendation of the LCE. To complement the CBS at the local level, the LGUs may undertake Early Procurement activities (EPA), especially for CO projects, subject to the appropriate guidelines on the matter. Transition to the CBS may include: (a) Multi-year planning activities; (b) Limiting budget provision to implementation-ready projects; and (c) Formulation of a Procurement Strategy and conduct of EPA to enable full implementation of PPAs within the fiscal year. Figure 7. Comparison Between Obligation-Based Budgeting and CBS26 26 Source: DBM Primer on Reforming the Philippine Budget 37 4.3 Benefits of Adopting CBS27 Some benefits of the CBS are: 1. LGUs will include only implementation-ready projects in their local budgets. 2. Once implementation schedules have aligned to the new shorter time horizon, LGUs will only need to focus on implementing the current year’s budget. 3. Completion of projects is facilitated which would translate to the immediate provision of intended public services. 4. Transactions with contractors and suppliers will be smoother, more transparent, and faster. 5. LGUs’ administrative load, as well as the accounting for the use of funds, will substantially decrease and be simplified. 6. Non-compliance by contractors and suppliers in contract agreements are likely lessened. 27 See also DBM Primer on Reforming the Philippine Budget. 38 PART II. THE LOCAL BUDGET PROCESS The budget process in LGUs is divided into five (5) phases: (1) Budget Preparation; (2) Budget Authorization; (3) Budget Review; (4) Budget Execution; and (5) Budget Accountability. These phases are interrelated and sequential, as can be seen from Figure 8 below: Figure 8. The Local Budget Process 39 CHAPTER 1. BUDGET PREPARATION PHASE Budget preparation is the first phase of the local budget process. It involves cost estimation per PPA, preparation of budget proposals, executive review of budget proposals, and preparation of the Local Expenditure Program (LEP) and the budget message. This phase starts with the issuance of the Budget Call, and ends with submission of the executive budget to the sanggunian on or before October 16 of each year. 1.1 Legal Basis of Budget Preparation “Upon receipt of the statements of income and expenditures from the treasurer, the budget proposals of the heads of departments and offices, and the estimates of income and budgetary ceilings from the local finance committee, the local chief executive shall prepare the executive budget for the ensuing fiscal year in accordance with the provisions of this Title.” (Section 318 of the LGC) 1.2 Key Players in Budget Preparation Local Chief Executive – The LCE shall prepare the executive budget for the ensuing fiscal year upon receipt of the statements of income and expenditure from the treasurer, the budget proposals from the heads of various departments and offices, and the estimates of income and budgetary ceilings from the LFC. The LCE shall submit the said executive budget to the sanggunian concerned not later than the 16th of October of the current fiscal year (Section 318 of the LGC). Local Finance Committee – The LFC, composed of the LPDC, LBO, and the Local Treasurer, shall have, among others, the following functions as defined in Section 316 of the LGC: Determine the income reasonably projected as collectible for the ensuing fiscal year; Recommend the appropriate tax and other revenue measures or borrowings which may be considered appropriate to support the budget; Recommend to the LCE concerned the level of annual expenditures and the ceilings of spending for economic, social, and general services based on the approved local development plans; 40 Recommend to the LCE concerned the proper allocation of expenditures for each development activity and between COEs and COs; and Recommend to the LCE concerned the amount to be allocated for COs under each development activity or infrastructure project. Local Treasurer – On or before the fifteenth (15th) day of July of each year, the Local Treasurer shall submit to the LCE a certified statement covering the income and expenditures of the preceding fiscal year, the actual income and expenditures of the first two (2) quarters of the current year, and the estimated income and expenditures for the last two (2) quarters of the current year (Section 315 of the LGC). Local Budget Officer - The LBO shall review and consolidate the budget proposals of different departments and offices of the LGU. The LBO shall also assist the LCE in the preparation of the budget and during budget hearings (Section 475 [b] [2-3] of the LGC). The LBO shall prepare the draft Budget Message and the LEP, in coordination with other members of the LFC prior to the submission of said documents to the LCE. Local Planning and Development Coordinator - The LPDC shall analyze the income and expenditure patterns, and formulate and recommend fiscal plans and policies for consideration of the LFC of the LGU concerned (Section 476 [b] [6] of the LGC). Local Accountant – The Local Accountant, jointly with the Local Treasurer, shall certify all statement of income and expenditure of the preceding fiscal year, the actual income and expenditures of the first two (2) quarters of the current year and the estimated income and expenditure for the last two (2) quarters of the current year (Article 411 of the IRR of the LGC). Heads of Departments/Offices and Heads of Local Economic Enterprises/Public Utilities - The Heads of Department/Offices/LEEs/PUs shall submit budget proposals for their respective departments or offices to the LCE thru the LFC on or before the fifteenth (15th) day of July of each year. The said budget proposal shall be prepared in accordance with such policy and program guidelines as the LCE concerned may issue in conformity with the local development plan, the budgetary ceilings prescribed by the local finance committee, and the general requirements prescribed in Title V, Book II of the LGC (Section 317 [a] of the LGC). The sanggunian is considered a separate office for purposes of Budget Preparation. Thus, the Vice-LCE shall prepare and submit to the LCE the budget proposal of the office of the sanggunian. 41 CSOs and the Private Sector Groups - The CSOs shall have the following functions shown in Table 5 based on the Handbook on the Participation of CSOs in the Local Budget Process: Table 5. Roles of CSOs in the Budget Preparation Phase ACTIVITY 1. ISSUE THE BUDGET CALL The Budget Call is a directive from the LCE that contains general objectives, policy decisions, strategies, and prioritized PPAs by sector/office as reflected in the AIP of the budget year. LGU ROLES CSO ROLES Provide a copy of the Check that AIP priorities Budget Call to the are highlighted in the accredited CSOs. Budget Call. Include in the Budget Call a requirement for the Department Heads to consult with accredited CSOs. 2. CONDUCT THE BUDGET FORUM A one-day forum wherein the LBO explains to Department Heads the major thrusts and policy directions, sources of income, spending ceilings, and budget strategies. Invite accredited CSOs to the Budget Forum. Ideally, the Budget Forum may provide information on why recommended priorities of accredited CSOs were not included in the identified PPAs. The CSOs may participate in the Budget Forum to gain an overall appreciation of the thrusts and priorities of the LGU for the budget year as contained in the Budget Call. LCE to ensure that the Department Heads consulted with accredited CSOs. The Budget Call may already prescribe such requirement. The accredited CSOs sectoral representative may partner with the Department Heads concerned in determining the target beneficiaries and funding requirements for the particular sector. The CSOs may also propose projects for consideration by the Department Heads concerned. 3. PREPARE AND SUBMIT BUDGET PROPOSALS Each Department Head prepares the budget proposals and submits these to the LBO for review and consolidation. He/she needs to determine the expected outputs for the budget year and estimated costs. 42 ACTIVITY LGU ROLES CSO ROLES In cases where CSOs’ proposed PPAs are not included in the budget, CSOs can request information from the LGU on the reasons for noninclusion. 4. CONDUCT BUDGET HEARINGS The technical budget hearings are conducted by the LFC to validate the revenue sources, PPAs, cost estimates, and expected outputs for the budget year. Invite accredited CSOs to the budget hearings in relation to sectoral concerns. The CSOs may participate in the budget hearings to provide inputs on sectoral concerns. 5. EVALUATE BUDGET PROPOSALS The LFC evaluates all budget proposals using the output and cost criteria. 6. SUBMIT EXECUTIVE BUDGET SANGGUNIAN May replicate the best May replicate the best practices of other LGUs practices of other CSOs in in engaging CSOs in engaging LFC. LFC. TO After consolidation of the budget proposal and approval thereof by the LCE, the LCE shall submit the proposed executive budget not later than October 16 of the current fiscal year pursuant to Section 318 of the LGC. Invite accredited CSOs May attend the State of to the State of the the Province/City/ Province/City/Municipal Municipality Address. ity Address. This is usually done through a State of the Province/City/ 43 ACTIVITY Municipality Address where the LCE presents the proposed annual budget to the sanggunian and other stakeholders. LGU ROLES CSO ROLES 1.3 The Budget Preparation Flowchart The budget preparation flowchart is shown in Figure 9. The sequence of activities in preparing the LEP should be synchronized with the mandated deadline of its submission to the local sanggunian. Figure 9. Budget Preparation Flowchart 1.4 Steps in the Budget Preparation Phase A. ANNUAL BUDGET Step 1. Issue the Budget Call The budget call signals the start of the budget preparation phase. This executive directive is issued based on the approved AIP, the LGC, and this Manual. 44 What is a Budget Call? A budget call is a directive from the LCE specifying the objectives, policy decisions, strategies, financing requirements, and prioritized PPAs by sector/office as reflected in the AIP. It provides clear guidelines in the preparation of individual budget proposals. This directive shall be disseminated not later than June 16 to allow more time for the Department Heads to submit reasonable proposals for the budget year. What are found in the Budget Call? 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Spending ceilings by major expenditure (PS, MOOE, FE, and CO); Resource allocation scheme or fiscal policy decisions; Objectives, strategies, and priority PPAs; Expected results; Budget Calendar and budget preparation forms; and Other administrative guidelines. All these elements are explained in budget preparation workshops prior to the preparation of budget proposals for the budget year. Departments and offices of the LGU shall be guided by the policies, ceilings, and targets embodied in the budget call. Budget proposals are reviewed as to their consistency with the AIP and budget call policies. Why is the Budget Call important? It emphasizes the policy objectives of the budget; It emphasizes the guidelines to be observed in the preparation of budget proposals; It focuses on the output aimed to be produced during the budget year; It firms up policy decisions on how the budget shall be financed; and It prescribes the budget preparation schedule and forms. How is the budget forum conducted? 1. Invite all stakeholders to a one-day budget forum to explain and discuss the following: Objectives for the budget year, major thrusts, and policy decisions; Sources of income for the past three (3) years; Income estimates and corresponding assumptions; Spending ceilings and budget strategies; Timelines of activities; and Forms to be used. 45 2. Use focused group discussion to engender group participation. 3. Close the forum by summarizing all issues raised. Step 2. Prepare and Submit Budget Proposals The budget proposals of various departments and offices shall be prepared using uniform templates to ensure the completeness and comprehensiveness of budget information, as well as to facilitate the consolidation of all proposals in an accurate and timely manner. A. Firm up MFOs, Identify PIs, and Set Targets The MFOs identified for the programs under the AIP shall be firmed up to ensure their alignment with the Department’s/Office’s organizational outcome, mandate, vision, and mission. Thereafter, the corresponding PIs shall be identified. PIs are the means to measure how well the goods or services were delivered. This is where we measure the quantity, quality, and timeliness of service delivery to the clients. Annex B of this Manual contains the proposed MFOs and their corresponding PIs of the different mandatory offices in LGUs. Taking into consideration resource availability vis-à-vis what should be delivered by the Department/Office, set the target/s for the budget year. B. Estimate Costs for the Budget Year There are three (3) types of costs that may be reflected in the budget: (i) COE; (ii) FE; and (iii) CO. Current Operating Expenditures refer to appropriations for the purchase of goods and services for the conduct of normal local government operations within the fiscal year, including goods and services that will be used or consumed during the budget year. These are expenses allocated to mandatory PS and other associated PS costs. These include salaries and wages, Personnel Benefit Contributions, Mid-Year Bonus, Year-End Bonus and Cash Gift, Representation Allowance and Transportation Allowance, among others. The other costs, which are variable, are the MOOE. These include Travel Expenses Office Supplies Expenses, Rent, Water, Electricity, Fuel, Telephone Expenses, Internet Expenses, Security Services, Repair and Maintenance Expenses, Confidential Expenses, Printing Expenses, Extraordinary and Miscellaneous Expenses, Representation Expenses, among others. 46 Financial Expenses are expenses which are not used in the actual operation of the LGU. These expenses include bank charges, interest expense, commitment fees, and other financial charges. Capital Outlays refer to appropriations for the purchase of goods and services, the benefits of which extend beyond the fiscal year and which add to the asset of the LGU concerned, including investment in public utilities (PUs) such as public markets and slaughter houses. C. Prepare the PPMP for the Budget Year The PPMP shall be prepared by all Departments/Offices for all PPAs with proposed procurement of goods, civil works, and consulting services. This shall be done by firming up the PPMP prepared based on the approved AIP, taking into consideration the available resources, particularly the budget ceilings of the Department/Office concerned. D. Consolidate PPMPs into APP The consolidation and evaluation of PPMPs will be made much faster and economical through the BAC. This means that decisions on the mode of procurement, type and specifications of items to be procured, when to procure, and costs have been considered. E. Review and Consolidate Budget Proposals The budget proposals by various Departments/Offices shall be reviewed by the LBO using the following criteria: Consistency with policies set forth in the budget call; Compliance with budgetary requirements, general limitations and other provisions under the LGC; and Accuracy of horizontal and vertical computations. Budget proposals not in conformity with policies and guidelines shall be returned for revision. All budget proposals shall be consolidated by the LBO for submission to the LFC to be used in the conduct of budget hearings. Step 3. Conduct Budget Hearings and Evaluate Budget Proposals The hearing and evaluation of budget proposals shall follow this procedure: A. Conduct technical budget hearings A technical budget hearing is conducted to: Review the rationale of the Department/Office; Review the PPAs by Department/Office; 47 Validate output projection; and Review costs estimates. This technical hearing may be conducted for at least ten (10) calendar* days (August 15 to 25). B. Evaluate budget proposals Members of the LFC shall evaluate all budget proposals using the following criteria: Rationale of the PPA; MFO and PIs criteria targets; and Cost criterion. Step 4. Prepare the Local Expenditure Program The LEP/Executive Budget shall primarily consist of two (2) parts: (i) estimates of receipts; and (ii) proposed appropriations for the budget year. Guidelines in the Preparation of the LEP PART 1. RECEIPTS PROGRAM The first part of the LEP is the Receipts Program. The receipts structure shall cover the immediate past year, the current year, and the budget year. Beginning cash balance shall be net of amounts earmarked for specific purposes (e.g., continuing appropriations, 20% Development Fund, payables, others [restricted funds]). Receipts sources are generated from the accomplished LBP Form No. 1, which reflects the following: A. Local (Internal) Sources 1. Tax Revenue 2. Non-Tax Revenue B. External Sources 1. Share from National Tax Allotment (NTA) (formerly known as Internal Revenue Allotment [IRA]) 2. Share from GOCCs (Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation [PAGCOR] and Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office [PCSO]) 3. Other Shares from National Tax Collections 4. Inter-Local Transfer 5. Extraordinary Receipts/Grants/Donation/Aids __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 48 C. Non-Income Receipts 1. Capital Investment Receipts 2. Receipts from Loans and Borrowings 3. Income of LEEs from its own operations The Receipts Program shall comply with the following: a. Taxes, fees, or charges identified as sources are in accordance with the revenue ordinances of the LGU (Section 132 of the LGC); and b. The estimated receipts from RPT correspond to the total amount of due and demandable RPT, including delinquent accounts. Any proposed measure/s to increase the income of the LGU shall be subject to approval by the sanggunian. These new revenue measures may include the following: New or additional local taxes, charges, fees, fines, or penalties; and Loan proceeds (to finance capital projects). PART 2. EXPENDITURE PROGRAM The second part of the LEP is the Expenditure Program. The details of the expenditure program shall include: A. Proposed New Appropriations by PPA. Each Department/Office shall present its Performance Information which includes its mandate, vision, mission, organizational outcome, MFOs and corresponding PIs, targets, and the proposed budgets by expense class (PS, MOOE, FE, and CO). Rules on the Preparation of the Expenditure Program of the LEP Each Department/Office shall ensure compliance with the following requirements: a. 20% of the National Tax Allotment for Development Projects (Section 287 of the LGC) Provision of no less than twenty percent (20%) of the NTA intended for development projects (Section 287 of the LGC and DBM-DOF-DILG JMC No. 1 dated November 4, 2020).28 The items that are not allowed to be charged against the 20% Development Fund are the following: 28 Revised Guidelines on the Appropriation and Utilization of the Twenty percent (20%) of the Annual Internal Revenue Allotment for Development Projects (LGUs) 49 PS expenditures, such as salaries, wages, overtime pay, and other personnel benefits; Administrative expenses, such as supplies, meals, representation, communication, water and electricity, petroleum products, and the like; Travelling expenses, whether domestic or foreign; Registration fees and other expenses related to the conduct of and participation in training, seminars, conferences or conventions; Purchase, maintenance or repair of administrative office’ furniture, fixtures, equipment or appliances; and Purchase, maintenance or repair of motor vehicles used for administrative purposes. b. Budgetary Requirements (Section 324 of the LGC) The aggregate amount appropriated does not exceed the estimates of income; Full provision shall be made for all statutory and contractual obligations of the LGU, and that the amount of appropriations for debt servicing do not exceed twenty percent (20%) of the regular income of the LGU; Provision of aid to component barangays shall be in amounts of not less than One Thousand Pesos (P1,000.00) per barangay; and Not less than five percent (5%) of the estimated revenue from regular sources shall be set aside as the Local Disaster Risk Reduction Management Fund (LDRRMF), of which thirty percent (30%) lumpsum allocation for Quick Response Fund (QRF) and seventy percent (70%) for disaster prevention and mitigation, preparedness, response, rehabilitation, and recovery (Section 21 of RA No. 10121 and NDRRMC-DBM-DILG JMC No. 2013-1 dated March 25, 2013).29 c. General Limitations 29 Total appropriations, whether annual or supplemental, for PS for one (1) fiscal year shall not exceed forty-five percent (45%) in the case of first to third class provinces, cities and Allocation and Utilization of the Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund (LDRRMF) 50 municipalities, and fifty-five percent (55%) in the case of fourth class or lower, of the total annual income from regular sources realized in the next preceding fiscal year (Section 325 [a] of the LGC). For the computation of the total PS cost for waived items and determination on PS Limitation compliance, the LGU may refer to Annexes A and B of Local Budget Circular No. 145 dated March 2, 2022,30 respectively; No official or employee shall be entitled to a salary rate higher than the maximum fixed for the position or other positions of equivalent rank by applicable laws or rules and regulations issued thereunder (Section 325 [b] of the LGC); No local fund shall be appropriated to increase or adjust salaries or wages of officials and employees of the national government, except as may be expressly authorized by law (Section 325 [c] of the LGC); In cases of abolition of positions and the creation of new ones resulting from the abolition of existing positions in the career service, such abolition or creation is made in accordance with pertinent provisions of the LGC and civil service laws, rules and regulations (Section 325 [d] of the LGC); Positions in the official plantilla for career positions which are occupied by incumbents holding permanent appointment shall be covered by adequate appropriations (Section 325 [e] of the LGC); No changes in designation or nomenclature of positions resulting in a promotion or demotion in rank or increase or decrease in compensation shall be allowed, except when the position is actually vacant, and the filling of such position shall be strictly made in accordance with civil service laws, rules and regulations (Sections 325 [f] of the LGC); The creation of new positions and salary increases or adjustments shall in no case be made retroactive (Section 325 [g] of the LGC); and The annual appropriations for discretionary purposes of the LCE shall not exceed two percent (2%) of the actual receipts derived from basic RPT in the next preceding calendar year. Discretionary funds shall be disbursed only for public purposes to be supported by appropriate vouchers and 30 Guidelines on the Implementation of Personal Services (PS) Limitation on Local Government Budgets and Determination of Waived PS Items Pursuant to Section 93 of the General Provisions (GPs) of the Fiscal Year (FY) 2022 General Appropriations Act (GAA), Republic Act (RA) No. 11639, and Years Thereafter 51 subject to such guidelines as may be prescribed by law. No amount shall be appropriated for the same purpose except as authorized under Section 325 [h] of the LGC. d. Budgetary Requirements by Attribution The following are budgetary requirements for specific sectors or concerns as prescribed by pertinent laws, rules and regulations that shall be included in the LGUs' annual budgets as contained in their respective local development plans and integrated in the AIP. The same may be provided in the annual budget as direct appropriation and/or by attribution. Gender and Development Budget (RA No. 7192, RA No. 9710; Philippine Commission on Women [PCW]-DILGDBM-NEDA Joint Memorandum Circular [JMC] No. 201301, as amended by PCW-DILG-DBM-NEDA JMC No. 201601 dated January 12, 2016); Local Council for the Protection of Children – One percent (1%) of the NTA of barangays, municipalities, and cities shall be allocated for the strengthening and implementation of the programs of the Local Council for the Protection of Children (LCPC) (Section 15 of RA No. 9344); PPAs and services that will address the needs of senior citizens (RA No. 7432, as amended by RA No. 9994 and RA No. 7876) and differently-abled persons (RA No. 7277, as amended by RA Nos. 9442 and 10070, and Batas Pambansa Blg. 344); Community-based Human Immunodeficiency Virus/Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (HIV/AIDS) prevention and care services (RA No. 11166); and PPAs to address the Problem of Illegal Drugs (Section 51 of RA No. 9165 and its IRR). e. Compliance with Other Applicable Laws, Rules and Regulations Plan – Budget Linkage – All PPAs shall be included/listed in the AIP (Section 305 [i] of the LGC); Confidential Fund – The total fund for Confidential Fund (CF) shall not exceed thirty percent (30%) of the total annual amount allocated for the LGU’s Peace and Order Program pursuant to Section 5.1.3.1 of Commission on Audit (COA)DBM-DILG-Government Commission for GOCCs (GCG)- 52 Department of National Defense (DND) Joint Circular (JC) No. 2015-01 dated January 8, 2015; and Other items of expenditure that are expressly prescribed or authorized under existing laws, rules, and regulations. Among others, verify if appropriations for specific purposes required by law, which may be attributed to regular PPAs, are fully provided. For guidance, the LGU may refer to LBR Form No. 2 in Part II, Chapter 3 of this Manual. f. Annual Operating Budget of Local Economic Enterprise – shall comply with the following requirements: The LGU maintains a special account in the General Fund (GF) for the LEE (Section 313 [a] of the LGC). Salaries, wages, representation, and transportation allowances of LEE officials and employees shall not be included in the annual or supplemental budget or in the computation of the maximum amount for PS of the LGU. The appropriations for PS of LEEs shall be charged to their respective budgets (Section 325 [a] of the LGC). No LEE official or employee is allowed a salary rate higher than the maximum fixed for the position or other positions of equivalent rank. PPAs of LEE are included in the AIP. Under Section 313 of the LGC, the rule on the treatment of the income of the LEE is as follows: a. The costs of improvement, repair, and other related expenses of the LEE shall be deducted from the income from the operation of the said LEE; b. The balance thereof shall first be applied for the return of advances or loans made; and c. Any excess shall form part of the GF of the LGU. The AOB of each LEE is presented separately in the LEP which shall be included for enactment by the sanggunian. B. Proposed New Appropriations by Object of Expenditures C. Special Purpose Appropriations shall be provided for the following purposes: 53 Appropriation for Development Projects – at least twenty percent (20%) of the NTA intended for development projects (Section 287 of the LGC); Appropriation for Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Program – Not less than five percent (5%) of estimated regular income for the budget year (Section 324 [d] of the LGC, as amended under Section 21 of RA No. 10121); Appropriation for Debt Service – Not exceeding twenty percent (20%) of the regular income (Section 324 [b] of the LGC); Advances or Loans to LEEs/PUs (Section 313 of the LGC); Aid to Barangays (Section 324 [c] of the LGC); and Other special purpose appropriations as authorized by law. D. Special Provisions. Policies on the use of funds, specific purpose/s or expected outputs and measures to reduce cost shall be provided after the presentation of the expenditure program for each Department/Office or Special Purpose of Appropriations, as may be applicable. PART 3. GENERAL PROVISIONS The LEP shall also include the General Provisions (GPs), which are policies and guidelines on receipts and expenditures. Explicit provisions on the manner and procedure for revenue generation and utilization shall be provided as guideposts for avoiding delays in the implementation of development projects and activities. General guidelines on the treatment of income from the operation of LEEs and PUs, and use of savings and/or augmentation shall be clearly provided. The GP shall also provide policies on the expenditure side, specifically for PS and all other personnel benefits, MOOE, FE, and CO. A provision on cost-cutting or economy measures may be included to all objects of expenditures. All items in the GP shall be supported by rules and policies issued by oversight agencies such as the COA, Civil Service Commission (CSC), DBM, and DILG. 54 PART 4. SUMMARY OF THE PROPOSED NEW APPROPRIATIONS The LEP shall also provide the Summary of New Appropriations by Expense Class, by Object of Expenditure and by Sector, and by Department/Office. It shall also include the Summary Statement of All Statutory and Contractual Obligations. The LEP shall be the material document for deliberation and authorization by the sanggunian. Step 5. Prepare the Budget Message The budget document shall contain a budget message of the LCE set forth in brief the significance of the executive budget, particularly in relation to the approved local development plan (Section 314 [b] [1] of the LGC). What is a Budget Message? A budget message is a summary of the proposed executive budget prepared by the LCE highlighting the following: Previous Years’ Fiscal performance; Development Goals and Objectives; Policy Thrusts; Priority PPAs; Estimate of Income and Sources Thereof; Major Items in the Expenditure Program; and MFOs/PIs/Targets. Contents of the Budget Message The budget message provides justification for the policy decisions contained in the proposed executive budget. It should include, among others, the following: Proposed budget by sector, office, and expenditure class; Justification for the need to expand (increased number of beneficiaries) without sacrificing quality of service delivery; Identification of new/additional beneficiaries if service delivery is expanded; and Justification for new PPAs to be implemented during the budget year. How to Prepare the Budget Message 1. Present the objectives, policies, strategies, and priority PPAs of the LGU for the budget year and relate their consistency with the proposed revenue and expenditure structure. 55 Explain the program thrusts and the justification or reasons why resources have to be focused on said programs. Include with the justification the expected results of the projects and activities that will rationalize budget allocation and accountability. 2. Identify the “flagship projects” by sector and by program and relate how they are envisioned to carry out the development goals for the next three (3) years. 3. Review the past five (5) years revenue and expenditure patterns and disclose what basic services and facilities were provided. Present in simple graphs or charts the income trend and expenditure pattern showing what results or output were produced during the period. 4. Discuss the current year’s income and expenditure performance and disclose any improvements in the production of results as compared with those during the past five (5) years. 5. Disclose service gaps to show the inability of the LGU to deliver basic services. This may be used as a major justification for proposals to expand the budget for a sector/office. Show the analysis in graphical form: The comparison of performance for the last five (5) years vis-à-vis the performance for the current year. Discuss and explain policy decisions that will improve service delivery in terms of quality, quantity, and timeliness criteria. Relate the funding to the issues being resolved by the proposed spending policies. Summarize the goods and services to be delivered for the budget year. These are the expected results of the budget designed to close the service gaps. An illustrative example of a budget message is shown in Item 1.6 of this Chapter. Step 6. Submit the Local Expenditure Program, together with the following documents, to the sanggunian not later than the 16th of October of the current fiscal year (Section 318 of the LGC): Budget Message; Plantilla of Personnel (LBP Form No. 3); Statement of Indebtedness (LBP Form No. 5); Annual Operating Budget of Local Economic Enterprise/s, if any; and AIP, duly approved by the local sanggunian. 56 It is the responsibility and accountability of the LGU to ensure that the priority PPAs are embodied in the relevant plans and/or documents as required by law, and are incorporated in the AIP. B. SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET General Rule All budgetary proposals shall be included and considered in the budget preparation process. After the LCE concerned shall have submitted the executive budget to the sanggunian, no ordinance providing for a supplemental budget shall be enacted (Section 321 of the LGC). Exceptions Changes in the annual budget may be done through supplemental budgets under the following circumstances (Article 417 of the IRR of the LGC, as amended by Administrative Order No. 47): 1. When supported by funds actually available as certified by the local treasurer Funds actually available refer to the amount of money actually collected, as certified by the local treasurer, at any given point during the fiscal year, which is over and above the estimated income collection for that point in the year. Thus, funds are actually available when realized income exceeds estimated income as of any given day, month, or quarter of a given fiscal year. Funds are likewise deemed actually available when there are savings. Savings refer to portions or balances as of any given point in the fiscal year or any programmed or allotted appropriation which remain free of any obligation or encumbrance and which are still available after the satisfactory completion or the unavoidable discontinuance or abandonment of the work, activity or purpose for which the appropriation was originally authorized, or which result from unobligated compensation and related costs pertaining to vacant positions and leaves of absence without pay (Article 454 [b] [1] of the IRR of the LGC). 2. If covered by new revenue source/s New revenue source refers to money measure not otherwise considered during the preparation and enactment of the annual budget. Such new revenue measures include ordinance passed by the sanggunian during the fiscal year but after the annual budget had already been enacted into 57 law which imposes new local taxes, charges, fees, fines or penalties, or which raises existing local taxes, charges, fees, fines or penalties. Such revenue sources also include new or higher remittances, contributions, subsidies or grants in aid from the NG or from government corporations and private entities which have not been included in the estimates of income which served as basis for the annual budget. 3. In times of public calamity By way of budgetary realignment to set aside appropriations for the purchase of supplies and materials or the payment of services, which are exceptionally urgent or absolutely indispensable to prevent imminent danger to, or loss of, life or property, in the jurisdiction of the LGU or in other areas declared in a state of calamity by the President or the local sanggunian (Section 321 of the LGC; Article 417 of the IRR of the LGC, as amended by Administrative Order No. 47; and National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council [NDRRMC] Memorandum Order No. 60, s. 2019).31 In such case, the AO shall clearly indicate the following: The sources of funds available for appropriations as certified under oath jointly by the local treasurer and the local accountant, and attested to by the LCE; The items of appropriations affected; and The reasons for the change. The LCE shall prepare the Supplemental Budget using LBP Form No. 8 – Statement of Funding Sources (Supplemental Budget) and LBP Form No. 9 – Statement of Supplemental Appropriation in Item 1.5 of this Chapter. 31 Revised Guidelines for the Declaration of a State of Calamity 58 1.5 Local Budget Preparation Forms LBP Form No. 1 BUDGET OF EXPENDITURES AND SOURCES OF FINANCING Local Government Unit: _____________________ GENERAL FUND Particulars (1) Account Code (2) Current Year Past Year (Actual)1 First Semester Second Semester (Actual) (Estimate) (3) (4) (5) Budget Year Total (Proposed) (6) (7) I. Beginning Cash Balance II. Receipts Regular Income A. Local Sources 1. Tax Revenue a. Real Property Tax (RPT) i. Basic RPT b. Business Tax c. Other Local Taxes Total Tax Revenue 2. Non-Tax Revenue a. Regulatory Fees b. Service/User Charges c. Receipts from Economic Enterprises d. Other Receipts Total Non-Tax Revenue Total Local Sources B. External Sources 1. National Tax Allotment (formerly Internal Revenue Allotment) 2. Share from Government-Owned and/or Controlled Corporations (Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation and Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office) 3. Other Shares from National Tax Collection a. Share from Special Economic Zone b. Share from Expanded Value-Added Tax c. Share from National Wealth d. Share from Tobacco Excise Tax Total External Sources Total Regular Income Non-Regular Income A. External Sources 1. Inter-Local Transfer 2. Extraordinary Receipts/Grants/Donations/ Aids Total External Sources B. Non-Income Receipts 1. Capital Investment Receipts a. Proceeds from Sale of Assets b. Proceeds from Sale of Debt Securities of Other Entities c. Collection of Loans Receivable Total Capital Investment Receipts 59 Particulars (1) Account Code (2) Current Year Past Year (Actual)1 First Semester Second Semester (Actual) (Estimate) (3) (4) (5) Total Budget Year (Proposed) (6) (7) 2. Receipts from Loans and Borrowings a. Acquisition of Loans b. Issuance of Bonds Total Receipts from Loans and Borrowings 3. Other Non-Income Receipts Total Non-Income Receipts Total Non-Regular Income Total Receipts III. Expenditures Personal Services Salaries and Wages – Regular/Others Personnel Economic Relief Allowance Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses Traveling Expenses Training and Scholarship Expenses Financial Expenses Capital Outlay Buildings Office Equipment Special Purpose Appropriations (SPAs) Appropriation for Development Programs/ Projects (20% Development Fund) Appropriation for Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Programs/Projects Appropriation for Debt Service Subsidy to Local Economic Enterprise/ Public Utilities Aid to Barangays Other Authorized SPAs Total Expenditures IV. Ending Balance 1/ Based on the Trial Balance for the Applicable Year We hereby certify that the information presented are true and correct. We further certify that the foregoing estimated receipts are reasonably projected as collectible for the Budget Year. ______________ Local Treasurer _________________ Local Budget Officer _____________________________________ Local Planning and Development Coordinator ______________ Local Accountant Approved by: __________________ Local Chief Executive 60 Instructions: Column 1 – Indicate the receipts by major source and expenditures by expense class. The beginning cash balance shall be net of amounts earmarked for specific purposes (e.g., continuing appropriations, 20% Development Fund). Column 2 – Indicate the account code for each itemized receipt using the Revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs, as prescribed under Commission on Audit Circular No. 2015-009 dated December 1, 2015. Column 3 – Indicate the past year’s actual receipts and expenditures. The past year’s and the first two quarters of the current year’s actual receipts and expenditures shall be jointly certified by the Local Treasurer and the Local Accountant, based on the Trial Balance for the applicable year. Columns 4 and 5 – Indicate the current year’s estimated receipts and expenditures, as follows: First semester – actual receipts and expenditures jointly certified by the Local Treasurer and the Local Accountant. Second semester – estimated receipts and expenditures prepared by the Local Budget Officer. Column 6 – Indicate the totals of the amounts under Columns 4 and 5. Column 7 – Indicate the proposed amount of receipts and expenditures for the budget year. Notes: 1. Prepare the same form for each local economic enterprise/public utility. 2. Regular revenues refer to taxes, fees, and receipts actually realized, including the NTA (formerly IRA) and other shares provided for in Sections 284, 290 and 291 of the LGC, but exclusive of non-recurring receipts such as national aids, grants, financial assistance, loan proceeds, sales of assets, miscellaneous income/receipts and other similar receipts (based on the Bureau of Local Government Finance Memorandum Circular No. 16-2015 dated June 19, 201532 which include the Guidebook for the New Local Government Financial Performance Monitoring System). 32 Local Public Financial Management Tools for the Electronic Statement of Receipts and Expenditures 61 LBP Form No. 2 PROGRAMMED APPROPRIATION AND OBLIGATION BY OBJECT OF EXPENDITURE Local Government Unit: ___________________ Department/Office: ______________________________ Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year (Actual) (1) (2) (3) Current Year First Second Semester Semester (Actual) (Estimates) (4) (5) Total Budget Year (Proposed) (6) (7) Personal Services Salaries and Wages Salaries and Wages – Regular Other Compensations Personal Economic Relief Allowance Personnel Benefit Contribution Other Personnel Benefit Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses Travelling Expenses Training and Scholarship Expenses Supplies and Materials Expenses Utility Expenses Communication Expenses Awards/Rewards Expenses Financial Expenses Capital Outlays Investment Property Land and Buildings Property, Plant and Equipment Land Land Improvement Special Purpose Appropriations (SPAs) Appropriation for Development Programs/Projects (20% Development Fund) Appropriation for Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management (LDRRM) Programs/Projects Appropriation for Debt Service Subsidy to Local Economic Enterprises/Public Utilities Aid to Barangays Other Authorized SPAs Total Appropriations Prepared by: Reviewed by: Approved by: __________________ Department Head ____________________ Local Budget Officer _____________________ Local Chief Executive 62 Instructions: Column 1 – Indicate the applicable Objects of Expenditure for the programmed appropriation and Special Purpose Appropriations, if any. Column 2 – Indicate account code using the Revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs, as prescribed under Commission on Audit Circular No. 2015-009 dated December 1, 2015. Column 3 - Indicate the actual expenditures incurred in the Past Year. Columns 4 and 5 - Indicate current year’s expenditures, as follows: First semester – actual expenditures as certified by the Local Accountant. Second semester – estimated expenditures prepared by the Department Head. The totals of this column for all Departments/Offices should tally with the amount of Expenditures per Columns 4 and 5 of LBP Form No. 1. Column 6 – Indicate the totals of the amounts under Columns 4 and 5. Column 7 – Indicate the proposed expenditures for the budget year. Note: The Local Budget Officer shall prepare a summary for all offices using LBP Form No. 1 of this Manual. 63 LBP Form No. 3 PLANTILLA OF PERSONNEL FY _____ Local Government Unit: _________________ Item Number Old New (1) (2) Position Title (3) Name of Incumbent (4) Current Year Authorized Rate/Annum Salary Grade Amount (SG)/Step (5) (6) Budget Year Proposed Rate/Annum SG/Step Amount (7) (8) Increase/Decrease (9) Prepared by: Reviewed by: Approved by: ______________________________ Human Resource Management Officer _________________ Local Budget Officer ________________ Local Chief Executive Instructions: Columns 1 and 2 - Indicate the old and new item numbers of the plantilla position. Columns 3 and 4 - Indicate the position title and the name of the incumbent occupying each position. If the position is unfilled, indicate the word “vacant” under Column 4. If the position is proposed for abolition, place the position title inside a bracket. If a position is proposed for reclassification, place the previous position title in a bracket and indicate the proposed position title below it. Columns 5 and 6 - Indicate the current SG/step and corresponding rate per annum of each position. Include as a footnote the compensation law/circular being implemented. For the initial implementation of changes, attach a copy of the Position Allocation List. Columns 7 and 8 - Indicate the SG/step and corresponding rate per annum of each position proposed for the budget year. Column 9 - Indicate the difference between the old and the new rates of compensation per annum for the budget year. Additional Instructions: 1. The plantilla of personnel shall be presented according to Department/Office. 2. Use the same form for each local economic enterprise/public utility. 3. Using the same form, a separate plantilla shall be prepared for Casual Employees whose salaries are chargeable against Personal Services appropriation. 4. Only funded vacant positions shall be included in the plantilla, unfunded positions shall be removed/deleted from the plantilla. 64 LBP Form No. 4 MANDATE, VISION/MISSION, MAJOR FINAL OUTPUT, PERFORMANCE INDICATORS AND TARGETS FY______ Local Government Unit: _________________ Department/Office Mandate Vision Mission Organizational Outcome Annual Investment Program Reference Code (1) : : : : : Program/ Project/ Activity Description Major Final Output Performance Indicator/ Output Target for the Budget Year (2) (3) (4) (5) Proposed Budget for the Budget Year PS MOOE FE CO Total (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Prepared by: Reviewed by: Local Finance Committee ________________ Department Head _________________ Local Planning and Development Coordinator _________________ Local Budget Officer _____________ Local Treasurer Approved by: __________________ Local Chief Executive Instructions: Department/Office: Indicate the Department/Office implementing the budget. Mandate: Quote the provision of the LGC on the mandate of the Department/Office. Vision: Indicate the future role of the Department/Office in the LGU’s development. Mission: Indicate the significant role of the Department/Office in attaining the vision. Organizational Outcome: The specific short-term benefits to clients and the community as a result of the LGU’s delivery of Major Final Outputs as defined in the organization’s results framework. Column 1 – Indicate the PPA reference code reflected in the AIP by each PPA. Column 2 – Indicate a concise description of the work to be done under a particular sector to achieve specific objectives. Present the PPAs following the structure prescribed in this Manual. 65 Column 3 – Indicate the good or service that a department/agency is mandated to deliver to external clients through the implementation of PPAs. Column 4 – Indicate the means for measuring the quantity, quality and timeliness of service delivery to the clients. Column 5 – Indicate the target for the budget year in terms of the performance indicator expressed in quantity, quality, and timeliness. Columns 6, 7, 8, and 9 – Indicate the proposed budget for the PPA, broken down by expense class - PS, MOOE, FE, and CO, including Special Purpose Appropriations attributed to and implemented by the Department/Office. Column 10 – Indicate the total amount of the proposed budget. Note: This form shall be prepared by the Department Head, reviewed by the Local Planning and Development Coordinator for the targets, and Local Budget Officer and Local Treasurer for the proposed budget, and approved by the Local Chief Executive. 66 LBP Form No. 5 STATEMENT OF INDEBTEDNESS Local Government Unit: _________________ Previous Payments Made Creditor Date Contracted Term Principal Amount Purpose (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) Amount Due Principal Interest Total Principal Interest Total (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) Certified Correct by: Noted by: __________________ Local Accountant ____________________ Local Chief Executive Balance of the Principal (12) Instructions: Column 1 – Indicate the full name of creditors with their corresponding addresses under each fund/special account and under each office. Column 2 – Indicate the date when the obligation is incurred. Column 3 – Indicate the period (months/years) within which to pay the loan. Column 4 – Indicate the principal amount of the loan. Column 5 – Indicate the purpose of the loan incurred. Columns 6, 7, and 8 – Indicate the total payments prior to budget year, including payments within the current year. Columns 9, 10, and 11 – Indicate the amounts due and budgeted for the budget year. Column 12 – Indicate the balance of the principal after deducting previous payments and amount due for the budget year (Columns 6 to 11). Note: Prepare the same form for each local economic enterprise/public utility. 67 LBP Form No. 6 STATEMENT OF STATUTORY AND CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATIONS AND BUDGETARY REQUIREMENTS FY _______ Local Government Unit: _________________ Description (1) 1. Statutory and Contractual Obligations 1.1 5% Metro Manila Development Authority Contribution for Local Government Units in National Capital Region only (Republic Act No. 7924) 1.2 Retirement Gratuity Benefits 1.3 Terminal Leave Benefits 1.4 Debt Service 1.5 Employees Compensation Insurance Premiums 1.6 PhilHealth Contributions 1.7 Pag-IBIG Contributions 1.8 Retirement and Life Insurance Premiums Amount (2) 2. Budgetary Requirements 2.1 20% of National Tax Allotment (formerly Internal Revenue Allotment) for Development Projects (20% Development Fund) 2.2 5% Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund 2.3 Financial Assistance to Barangays (Php1,000.00 minimum aid) TOTAL Certified Correct by: ________________ Local Budget Officer _______________ Local Treasurer ___________________________ Local Planning and Development Coordinator Approved by: ________________ Local Chief Executive Instructions: Column 1 – Indicate the Statutory and Contractual Obligations and Budgetary Requirements for the budget year. Column 2 – Indicate the amount for each Contractual Obligations and Budgetary Requirements for the budget year. Note: Prepare the same form for each local economic enterprise/public utility. 68 LBP Form No. 7 STATEMENT OF FUND ALLOCATION BY SECTOR FY _______ Local Government Unit: _________________ Particulars Account Code General Public Services (1) (2) (3) Social Economic Other Services Services Services (4) (5) (6) Total (7) Total Appropriations Certified Correct by: Approved by: __________________ Local Budget Officer ___________________ Local Chief Executive Instructions: Column 1 - Specify all allocations by sector/service, inclusive of lumpsum appropriations for 5% Disaster Risk Reduction Management Fund, 20% Development Fund, Aid to Barangays, and Financial Expenses. Column 2 - Indicate account code using the Revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs, as prescribed under COA Circular No. 2015-009 dated December 1, 2015. Column 3 - Indicate all PPAs that provide planning, financial, administrative, legal and legislative services to the front-line services of the LGU. Column 4 - Indicate all PPAs that promote the well-being and general welfare of constituents or people such as education, health, public safety, and protection of the marginalized and disadvantaged members of the society. Column 5 - Indicate all PPAs directed towards promoting growth in the economy, using all factors in production, such as increasing productivity in agriculture and all other industries, generating employment, and other livelihood projects. Column 6 - Indicate all PPAs that cannot be categorized in any of the sectors identified above. Column 7 – Indicate the total amount of all PPAs. Note: Prepare the same form for each local economic enterprise/public utility. 69 LBP Form No. 8 STATEMENT OF FUNDING SOURCES (SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET) FY ______ Local Government Unit: _________________ Fund/Special Account: ______________ Particulars (1) 1.0 New Revenue Sources Tax Revenue Loan Proceeds (Borrowings) 2.0 Actual Collection in Excess of the Estimated Income 3.0 Savings 4.0 Realignment Account Classification (2) Amounts (3) Certified Correct by: ___________________ Local Treasurer ___________________ Local Accountant Instructions: Column 1 - Indicate the appropriate funding sources. Column 2 - Indicate the appropriate account classifications as prescribed in the Revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs. Indicate the details of the funding sources (e.g., Tax Revenue: Real Property Tax/Real Property Transfer Tax/Fines and Penalties, etc.). Column 3 - Indicate the appropriate amount for each funding source. Note: The certification shall be signed by the Local Treasurer and/or Local Accountant depending on the funding source. 70 LBP Form No. 9 STATEMENT OF SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION FY______ Local Government Unit: _________________ Implementing Office Particulars/ Purpose (1) (2) Annual Investment Program Reference Code (3) Object of Expenditure Account Code Amount (4) (5) (6) Prepared by: Approved by: ___________________ Local Budget Officer ___________________ Local Chief Executive Instructions: Column 1 - Indicate the particular implementing office. Column 2 - Indicate the PPAs/particulars/purpose of appropriation based on the approved AIP. Column 3 - Indicate the AIP Reference Code of the related PPAs. Column 4 – Indicate the Object of Expenditure of the related PPAs. Column 5 - Indicate the appropriate account code prescribed under the revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs. Column 6 - Indicate the amount corresponding to each PPAs/particulars/purpose of appropriation and object of expenditure. 71 1.6 Illustrative Examples 1.6.1 Budget Call Provincial/City/Municipal Budget Memorandum No. 1-2023 16 June 2023 TO : All Heads of Offices, Department Heads, Chairperson of the Committee on Appropriations, Members of the Sanggunian and Others Concerned SUBJECT : Guidelines on the Preparation and Submission of Annual General Fund Budget of Departments/Offices for Fiscal Year (FY) 2024 I. Purpose: This Budget Call for FY 2024 is issued primarily to prescribe guidelines to be observed by departments/offices in the preparation of budget proposals consistent with the Annual Investment Program (AIP) for FY 2024 and the Local Government Code of 1991. II. Objectives and Policy Guidelines: Consistent with the approved AIP, the local government unit (LGU) shall focus its resources to the attainment of the following general objectives: 1.1 Increased per capita income of constituents by twenty percent (20%); 1.2 Delivered basic services to all constituents of the LGU; and 1.3 Provided full employment to poor urban residents. For FY 2024, the LGU shall direct its resources towards increased agricultural productivity; promote quality in the production of competitive products in the world and domestic markets; and provide health, social, education services geared towards promoting economic growth with equity to marginalized citizens. To support the budget for FY 2024 the following fiscal policies and measures were approved and endorsed by the Sanggunian: 1. Enhanced tax collection efficiency by launching a vigorous tax info campaign supported by an intensified tax collection effort. 2. Upgraded the scale of fees comparable with other LGUs belonging to the same class; and 3. Financed the completion of the _____ Bridge in Barangay _____ through borrowing from the Development Bank of the Philippines in the amount of P3.1 M payable in ten (10) years at ten percent (10%) per annum. The allocation scheme of the net amount available for appropriation for FY 2024 shall be based on the following priority: 72 Priority 1 2 3 4 5 Amount (P000) 58.1 3.4 23.7 20.9 8.6 114.7 Functional Activity Basic Services Operation Support to Basic Service Gen. Policy/Legislative Development Projects Statutory/Contractual Percentages of Total 51% 3% 20% 18% 8% 100% Guidelines to be observed in the allocation of “free resources”. 1st Priority 2nd Priority 3rd Priority Expansion of existing services/facilities Execution of new development projects Increased personnel benefits of local personnel III. Receipts Estimates and Spending Ceiling The receipts estimates for FY 2024 are to be generated from the following sources: Sources of Financing Amount National Tax Allotment (formerly Internal Revenue Allotment) National Wealth Local Tax Revenues Operating and Misc. Income Borrowings Others (Grants and Sale of Fixed Assets) % to Total 103,841 90.00% 1,143 3,516 3,151 3,100 1.00% 3.50% 2.80% 2.70% 100.00% 114,751 A. General Services Sector Particulars Office of the Local Chief Executive (LCE) Sanggunian Treasurer Accounting Office Budget Planning and Development Office Legal General Services TOTAL PS 1500 MOOE 500 2500 800 300 300 300 200 200 6100 500 500 200 100 200 100 100 2200 PS 5100 1000 4000 1500 11600 MOOE 4000 500 3000 2000 9500 FE CO 500 TOTAL 2500 100 300 300 100 100 100 14000 15500 3100 1600 800 500 600 400 14300 23800 CO 1000 1400 1000 3400 TOTAL 10100 1500 8400 4500 24500 B. Social Services Sectors Particulars Health Services Day Care Social, Welfare and Development Population Development TOTAL FE 73 C. Economic Services Sector Particulars Engineering Assessor Agricultural Services Environment and Natural Resources Development of Cooperatives Veterinary Services PS 3500 1500 3500 2500 MOOE 2000 1500 1500 1000 2500 5500 TOTAL GRAND TOTAL FE CO 24600 10500 1500 TOTAL 30100 3000 15500 5000 500 3400 1000 3000 9900 19000 9900 37600 66500 36700 21600 56500 114800 0 IV. Budget Calendar and Budget Preparation All concerned are enjoined to follow the schedule as directed in the memorandum, particularly on the submission of budget proposals at designated inclusive dates and on the prescribed forms herein attached. 1. Schedule of Activities 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 Activity Issuance of the Budget Call Budget Forum Preparation/Submission of Budget Proposals Technical Budget Hearings Consolidation of Budget Proposal Preparation of the Budget Message and Local Expenditure Program (LEP) Submission of the LEP Inclusive Date June 16 June 16 June 24-28 August 26 – September 15 September 16 – 30 October 1 – 15 October 16 2. The following local budget preparation (LBP) forms shall be submitted: 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 LBP Form LBP Form No. 1 – Budget of Expenditures and Sources of Financing LBP Form No. 2 – Programmed Appropriation and Obligation by Object of Expenditure LBP Form No. 3 – Plantilla of Personnel LBP Form No. 4 – Mandate, Vision/Mission, Major Final Output, Performance Indicators and Targets by Department/Office LBP Form No. 5 – Statement of Indebtedness LBP Form No. 6 – Statement of Statutory and Contractual Obligations and Budgetary Requirements Responsible Officer Prepared by the Local Finance Committee (LFC) and Local Accountant, and approved by the LCE Prepared by the Department Head, reviewed by the Local Budget Officer (LBO), and approved by the LCE Prepared by the Human Resource Management Officer, reviewed by the LBO, and approved by the LCE Prepared by the Department Head, reviewed by the LFC, and approved by the LCE Certified correct by the Local Accountant, and noted by the LCE Certified correct by the LFC, and approved by the LCE 74 1.7 1.8 1.9 LBP Form LBP Form No. 7 – Statement of Fund Allocation by Sector LBP Form No. 8 – Statement of Funding Sources (Supplemental Budget) LBP Form No. 9 – Statement Supplemental Appropriation of Responsible Officer Certified correct by the LBO, and approved by the LCE Certified correct by the Local Treasurer and/or Local Accountant depending on the funding source Prepared by the LBO, and approved by the LCE LBP Form Nos. 2, 3 and 4 shall be submitted to the LFC, through the LBO, on or before August 15 for consolidation and review. Any queries, clarificatory question, issues and observations relative to these guidelines shall be referred at once to the LFC for resolution during the budget workshop. Technical and other assistance in the preparation of the FY 2024 Annual Budget may be requested from the LBO. Please be guided accordingly. ___________________ Local Chief Executive 75 1.6.2 Local Expenditure Program OFFICIAL SEAL OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNIT LOCAL EXPENDITURE PROGRAM January 1 to December 31, 2024 76 PART 1. RECEIPTS PROGRAM RECEIPTS PROGRAM FY 2022-2024 (In 000 Pesos) Particulars (1) Account Code (2) Past Year Current Year (Actual) First Semester Second Semester (Actual) (Estimate) (3) (4) (5) Total (6) Budget Year (Proposed) (7) I. Beginning Cash Balance II. Receipts Regular Income A. Local Sources 1. Tax Revenue a. Real Property Tax (RPT) i. Basic RPT b. Business Tax c. Other Local Taxes Total Tax Revenue 2. Non-Tax Revenue a. Regulatory Fees b. Service/User Charges c. Receipts from Economic Enterprises d. Other Receipts Total Non-Tax Revenue Total Local Sources B. External Sources 1. National Tax Allotment (NTA) (formerly Internal Revenue Allotment [IRA]) 2. Share from Government-Owned and/or Controlled Corporations (Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation and Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office) 3. Other Shares from National Tax Collections a. Share from Ecozone b. Share from eVAT c. Share from National Wealth d. Share from Tobacco Excise Tax Total External Sources Total Regular Income Non-Regular Income A. External Sources 1. Inter-Local Transfer 2. Extraordinary Receipts/Grants/Donations/Aids Total External Sources B. Non-Income Receipts 1. Capital Investment Receipts a. Proceeds from Sale of Assets b. Proceeds from Sale of Debt Securities of Other Entities c. Collection of Loans Receivable Total Capital Investment Receipts 77 2. Receipts from Loans and Borrowings a. Acquisition of Loans b. Issuance of Bonds Total Receipts from Loans and Borrowings 3. Other Non-Income Receipts Total Non-Income Receipts Total Non-Regular Income Total Available Appropriation Resources for PART 2. EXPENDITURE PROGRAM A. OFFICE OF THE MAYOR Mandate: Vision: Mission: Organizational Outcome: 1. Proposed New Appropriations by Program, Project, and Activity (PPA) Annual Investment Program (AIP) Reference Code PPA Major Final Output (MFO) Proposed Budget Performance Indicator (PI) Target Personal Services (PS) Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses (MOOE) Financial Expenses (FE) Capital Outlay (CO) Total 2. Proposed New Appropriations, by Object of Expenditures Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) PS Salaries and Wages – Regular Salaries and Wages – Casual/Contractual Personnel Economic Relief Allowance Representation Allowance Transportation Allowance Clothing/Uniform Allowance Honoraria Year-End Bonus Cash Gift Other Bonuses and Allowances Retirement and Life Insurance Premiums Pag-IBIG Contributions PhilHealth Contributions Employees Compensation Insurance Premium (ECIP) Terminal Leave Benefits TOTAL PS MOOE Travelling Expenses Training and Scholarship Expenses Telephone Expenses – Landline Telephone Expenses – Mobile Postage and Deliveries 78 Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) Subscription Expenses Rent/Lease Expense Office Supplies Expenses Fuel, Oil, and Lubricant Expenses Repairs and Maintenance – Land Transport Equipment Repairs and Maintenance – Office Equipment Repairs and Maintenance – Building and Other Structures Donations Representation Expenses Confidential Expenses Other Professional Expenses TOTAL MOOE FE Management Supervision/Trusteeship Fees Interest Expenses Guarantee Fees Bank Charges Commitment Fees Other Financial Charges TOTAL FE CO Office Equipment Technical and Scientific Machinery Equipment Land Improvements TOTAL CO TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS 3. Special Purpose Appropriations 3.1 LOCAL DISASTER RISK REDUCTION AND MANAGEMENT FUND A. Proposed New Appropriations Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) QUICK RESPONSE FUND (30%) DISASTER PREPAREDNESS, PREVENTION, MITIGATION, RESPONSE, REHABILITATION AND RECOVERY (70%) MOOE Training Expenses Telephone Expenses – Landline Telephone Expenses – Mobile Insurance Expenses Rent/Lease Expense Supplies and Medicines Fuel, Oil and Lubricant Expenses Repairs and Maintenance – School Buildings TOTAL MOOE 79 CO Rescue Equipment Building and Structure Land Improvements TOTAL CO TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS B. Special Provisions 1. Use and Release of Fund. The amount herein appropriated shall be used in accordance with Republic Act No. 10121, “The Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Act of 2010,” which shall include relief, rehabilitation, reconstruction, and other works or services, including predisaster activities, in connection with the occurrence of natural calamities, epidemics as declared by the Department of Health, and other catastrophes. Provided, that the projects and activities are incorporated in the Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management (LDRRM) Plan, and integrated in the approved Annual Investment Program. Provided further, that the utilization of the Fund shall be in accordance with the provisions of National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council-Department of Budget and Management (DBM)-Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) Joint Memorandum Circular (JMC) No. 2013-1 dated March 25, 2013. 2. Quick Response Fund. Of the amount appropriated for LDRRM Fund, thirty percent (30%) shall be allocated as Quick Response Fund (QRF) or stand-by fund for relief, and recovery programs in order that the situation and living conditions of people in the communities or areas stricken by disasters, calamities, epidemics, or complex emergencies, may be normalized as quickly as possible. The release and use of QRF shall be supported by a resolution of the Sanggunian declaring the local government unit (LGU) under state of calamity or a Presidential declaration of state of calamity. 3. In no case shall the QRF be used for the pre-disaster, nor be realigned for any other purpose. 3.2 APPROPRIATIONS FOR DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS AND PROJECTS A. Proposed New Appropriations Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) MOOE CO TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS 80 B. Special Provisions Use and Release of Fund. The 20% Development Fund shall be strictly utilized in accordance with the general policies provided in DBM-Department of Finance-DILG JMC No. 1 dated November 4, 2020, and for the projects included in the approved Annual Investment Program of the [LGU] for the Fiscal Year 2024. The development projects identified shall be consistent with the Local Development Plan duly approved by the Local Development Council and the local sanggunian. The disbursement of this fund shall be based on the approved Project Procurement Management Plan for the Fiscal Year 2024, and subject to all existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing laws, rules and regulations. 3.3 OTHER SPECIAL PURPOSE APPROPRIATIONS A. Proposed New Appropriations Office/Program/ Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) a. Office of the Mayor b. Office of the Sanggunian c. etc. B. Special Provisions Use and Release of Fund. The release, utilization, and disbursement of the appropriation herein provided shall be subject to all existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing laws, rules and regulations. 3.4 APPROPRIATIONS FOR LOCAL ECONOMIC ENTERPRISES A. Proposed New Appropriations Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) SUBSIDY TO LOCAL ECONOMIC ENTERPRISE (LEE) OPERATING EXPENSES FUNDED BY INCOME OF THE LEE TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS B. Special Provisions Appropriation for Programs and Specific Activities. The amount appropriated herein for subsidies and programs of the LEE shall be used specifically for the identified activities subject to existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing laws, rules and regulations. 81 PART 3. GENERAL PROVISIONS Section 1. Availability of Appropriations. Unexpended balances of appropriations authorized in the annual appropriations ordinance shall revert to the unappropriated surplus of the general fund at the end of the fiscal year and shall not thereafter be available for the expenditure except by subsequent enactment. However, appropriations for CO shall continue and remain valid until fully spent, reverted or the project is completed. Reversions of continuing appropriations shall not be allowed unless obligations therefor have been fully paid or otherwise settled. Section 2. Limitation on Cash Advance. Notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary, cash advances shall not be granted until such time that the earlier cash advances availed of by the officials or employees or employees concerned shall have been liquidated pursuant to pertinent accounting. Section 3. Meaning of Savings. Savings refer to portions or balances as of any given point in the fiscal year or any programmed or allotted appropriation which remain free of any obligation or encumbrance and which are still available after the satisfactory completion or the unavoidable discontinuance or abandonment of the work, activity or purpose for which the appropriation was originally authorized, or which result from unobligated compensation and related costs pertaining to vacant positions and leaves of absence without pay. Section 4. Use of Savings and Augmentation. Funds shall be available exclusively for the specific purpose for which they have been appropriated. No ordinance shall be passed authorizing any transfer of appropriations from one item to another. However, the local chief executive or the presiding officer of the sanggunian concerned may, by ordinance, be authorized to augment any item in the approved annual budget for their respective offices from savings in other items within the same expense class of their respective appropriations. PART 4. SUMMARY OF THE FY 2024 PROPOSED NEW APPROPRIATIONS 1. Proposed New Appropriations, by Object of Expenditure and by Sector Object of Expenditure Account Code General Public Services Social Services Economic Services Other Services Total 1. PS (specify object of expenditure) Total, PS 2. MOOE (specify object of expenditure) Total, MOOE 3. FE (specify object of expenditure) Total, FE 4. CO (specify object of expenditure) Total, CO 5. Special Purpose Appropriations (SPA) (specify object of expenditure) Total, SPA Total Appropriations 82 2. Proposed New Appropriations, by Office Office a. Office of the Mayor b. Office of the Sanggunian c. etc. 3. PS MOOE FE CO Total Particulars 1. Statutory and Contractual Obligations 1.1 5% Metro Manila Development Authority Contribution for Local Government Units in National Capital Region only (Republic Act No. 7924) 1.2 Retirement Gratuity Benefits 1.3 Terminal Leave Benefits 1.4 Debt Service 1.5 Employees Compensation Insurance Premiums 1.6 PhilHealth Contributions 1.7 Pag-IBIG Contributions 1.8 Retirement and Life Insurance Premiums Amount Summary Statement of All Statutory and Contractual Obligations 2. Budgetary Requirements 2.1 20% of NTA (formerly IRA) for Development Projects (20% Development Fund) 2.2 5% LDRRM Fund 2.3 Financial Assistance to Barangays (Php1,000.00 minimum aid) TOTAL 83 1.6.3 Budget Message Republic of the Philippines Province/City/Municipality of _______________ ___(Date)___ BUDGET MESSAGE The Honorable Members Sangguniang Panlalawigan/Panlungsod/Bayan [Local Government Unit] Ladies/Gentlemen: May I submit the proposed Annual Budget for FY 2024 of the Provincial/City/Municipal Government for both the General Fund and Operation of Economic Enterprise pursuant to Section 318 of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC). A. INTRODUCTION This Executive Budget was prepared after a thorough deliberation with all concerned departments/offices and interested citizens to make it an effective tool for equitably allocating the limited resources of government to the different sectors, thus, making the Budget an instrument for the economic and social upliftment of our people. We have substantially committed funds for the programs, projects, and activities needed for an efficient and effective delivery of the basic services enumerated in the LGC. It is important to stress that the preparation of this Budget has been open to the public through private sector representation to make decisions more participative and democratic. This is also in keeping with government’s thrust for transparency and accountability in the budget-making process. We take full cognizance of the significant roles demonstrated by non-government organizations, other private sector associations, and the general public in the planning and pre-budget preparation stage by way of their membership in the Local Development Council Executive Committee. Moreover, this Budget integrates the Provincial/City/Municipal Development Plan into the expenditure program by proposing only those projects which have been ranked as priority in the Annual Investment Program. The Expenditure Program and Sources of Financing are illustrated in Exhibits 1 and 2. 84 Exhibit 1. Expenditure Program (Distribution by Sector) Budget Year (in million pesos) Exhibit 2. Distribution by Type of Revenue Budget Year (in million pesos) B. GOALS AND OBJECTIVES The province/municipality expects to attain the following objectives during the plan period: o Increase per capita income by a stated realistic percentage; o Provide accessibility to all basic needs and services; o Realistic percentage of citizens/constituents of the province; o Provide expanded employment opportunities to the urban poor residents; and o Increase agricultural productivity and enhance delivery of health care services. 85 C. FISCAL POLICIES Revenue-generating measures include enhanced tax collection via a vigorous tax information campaign and intensified tax collection effort. Exhibit 3 shows the trend of expenditures for FY 2022 to FY 2024. The Health, Nutrition and Population Control Sector has registered sizeable increases for the three-year period. This is attributed to the absorption of devolved health services. Expenditure for Economic Sector has also been increasing due to the provision of more infrastructure projects and bigger allocation for the agriculture sub-sector. Exhibit 3. Expenditure Program by Sector Comparative Trend for FY 2022 to 2024 (in millions) It has long been recognized that in order for a local government unit to achieve efficient and effective operation, it should aim for the improvement of the ratio of its overhead costs to cost of production and service delivery. Thus, it is important to present in this Message, through the chart below, the direct cost of public goods and services produced and delivered vis-à-vis their associated costs. This presentation slices the budget pie on the basis of functional activity. Exhibit 4. Distribution of LGU Budget by Functional Activity Budget Year (in million pesos) 86 The distribution of the LGU budget (Exhibit 4), shows that P58,092,677 or 51% is allocated for the operation of frontline services; P23,751,197.00 or 21% is provided for General Policy, Administration and Finance Services; P20,923,547.00 or 18% will be spent for development projects; P8,625,845.00, representing 7% of the total budget will be for Other Purposes (Aid to Barangays, Reserve for Calamity and Debt Service); and P3,441,320 or 3% is provided as support to frontline services. D. DISTRIBUTION BY MAJOR EXPENSE CLASS Personal Services (PS) The total expenditures for PS for the budget year amounted to P50,138,976, inclusive of the provision for Salary Standardization of P9,418,928. Total PS accounts for 44% of the total LGU budget. Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses (MOOE) The amount of P34,687,449 has been set aside for MOOE, representing 30% of the budget. Capital Outlays (CO) Expenditures for (CO) will amount to P23,628,361 or 21% of the total expenditures. It includes provisions for development projects, Loan Outlay, Livestock and Crops Outlays, Equipment Outlays in the amounts of P20,288,000, P2,361,291, P879,070 and P100,000, respectively. The amount of P20,288,000 for development projects include P16,800,000 funded from the 20% Development Fund. Other Purposes The amounts of P5,479,975 and P816,000 are set aside as reserve for Calamity and Aid to Barangays, respectively. E. OPERATION OF ECONOMIC ENTERPRISE The proposed Budget for the Operation of Economic Enterprise (Operation of Telephone Service) in FY 2024 shall be sourced from the estimated Telephone Service Income of P33,400,000 allocated as follows: Particulars PS MOOE CO Transfer to General Fund Debt Servicing 5% Reserve Unappropriated Balance TOTAL Amount 7,600,000 3,420,000 7,980,000 6,000,000 6,200,000 1,670,000 530,000 33,400,000 % to Total 22 10 24 18 19 5 2 100 87 CONCLUSION Submitted together with this Message are the Local Expenditure Program, Plantilla of Personnel, Annual Operating Budget of LEEs, approved Annual Investment Program and other supporting schedules. Gentlemen and Ladies of the Sanggunian, this budget proposal manifests our determination to lay a strong foundation for a greater and progressive province/city/municipality. Let us join our hands together as we go about our mission of provider a brighter future for our constituents. Very truly yours, ____________________________________ NAME OF THE LOCAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE 88 1.6.4 Local Budget Preparation Form No. 4 MANDATE, VISION/MISSION, MAJOR FINAL OUTPUT, PERFORMANCE INDICATORS AND TARGETS FY 2024 Local Government Unit: ________________________ Department/Office : Office of the Local Planning and Development Coordinator Mandate : a. Formulate integrated economic, special physical and other development plans and policies for consideration of the Local Development Council; and b. Monitor and evaluate the implementation of the different programs, activities and projects in the LGU in accordance with approved development plan. Vision : Towards effective and sustainable planning for the Province’s progress and advancement. Mission : Initiate and cause the participatory formulation, coordination and integration of effective and comprehensive development plans; analyze income and expenditure patterns; provide sufficient and reliable information; conduct researches and continuing studies for project planning; monitor and evaluate the implementation of programs and projects with feedback mechanism in support of the LGU vision. Organizational Outcome : Sound planning and development management effected. Annual Investment Program Reference Code (1) 1000-1-01004-001 Program/ Project/ Activity Description (2) Project Monitoring and Evaluation Program Major Final Output (3) Monitoring and Evaluation Services Performance Indicator/ Output (4) Percentage of Projects Implemented and Monitored Proposed Budget for the Budget Year Target for the Budget Year PS (5) 75% MOOE FE CO (6) (7) (8) (9) 200,000 100,000 Prepared by: Reviewed by: Local Finance Committee ________________ Department Head _________________ ________________ Local Planning and Local Budget Officer Development Coordinator Total (10) 300,000 ____________ Local Treasurer Approved by: ________________ Local Chief Executive 89 CHAPTER 2. BUDGET AUTHORIZATION PHASE Budget Authorization is the second phase in the local budget process. This phase starts from the time the sanggunian receives the LEP submitted by the LCE, and ends with the enactment of the AO and approval thereof by the LCE. Authorization of the budget is done through an AO enacted by the local sanggunian in accordance with the fundamental principle that: “No money shall be paid out of the local treasury except in pursuance of an appropriations ordinance or law.” (Section 305 [a] of the LGC) 2.1 Legal Basis of Budget Authorization* “On or before the end of the current fiscal year, the sanggunian concerned shall enact, through an ordinance, the annual budget of the local government unit for the ensuing fiscal year on the basis of the estimates of income and expenditures submitted by the local chief executive.” (Section 319 of the LGC) 2.2 Key Players in Budget Authorization Local Chief Executive – The LCE shall submit the LEP to the sanggunian concerned for authorization (Section 318 of the LGC). After the enactment of the AO, the LCE shall approve or veto the same (Sections 54 and 55 of the LGC). Sanggunian – As the legislative body of the LGU, the sanggunian shall enact the annual and supplemental budgets and appropriate funds for specific programs, projects, services and activities, or for other purposes not contrary to law, in order to promote the general welfare of the locality and its inhabitants (Sections 447 [a] [2] [i], 458 [a] [2] [i], and 468 [a] [2] [i] of the LGC). The sanggunian may, by ordinance, authorize the LCE or the Presiding Officer of the Sanggunian to augment any item in the approved annual budget for their respective offices from savings in other items within the same expense class of their respective appropriations (Section 336 of the LGC). Committee on Appropriation/Finance – The Committee on Appropriation/Finance, as one of the standing committees of the sanggunian, shall be responsible for conducting a preliminary review and evaluation of the LEP. It shall submit its report and recommendation to the sanggunian proper. __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 90 Secretary to the Sanggunian – The Secretary to the Sanggunian shall stamp the AO with the seal of the sanggunian and record the same, with the dates of passage and publication, in a book kept for the purpose. He/she shall affix his signature to the enacted AO and present the same to the Presiding Officer for his signature and forward copies thereof to the LCE for approval (Section 469 [c] of the LGC). Subsequently, he/she shall cause the posting of an ordinance or resolution in the bulletin board at the entrance of the provincial capitol and the city, municipal, or barangay hall and in at least two (2) conspicuous places in the LGU concerned not later than five (5) days after approval thereof (Section 59 [b] of the LGC). Local Finance Committee – The LFC shall assist the sanggunian in the analysis and review of the annual and supplemental budgets of the LGU to determine compliance with statutory and administrative requirements (Section 316 [g] of the LGC). Heads of Departments and Offices – Upon request of the sanggunian coursed through the LCE, Heads of the Departments and Offices may appear before the body or the Committee on Appropriation/Finance to explain or justify their proposals. CSOs and the Private Sector Groups – Should the sanggunian allow the CSOs to participate in the budget authorization phase, it may refer to the following roles as shown in Table 6 below based on the Handbook on the Participation of CSOs in the Local Budget Process. Table 6. Roles of CSOs in the Budget Authorization Phase33 33 ACTIVITY 1. DELIBERATE ON THE BUDGET LGU ROLES CSO ROLES The Sanggunian shall consider the executive budget as a priority measure which shall take precedence over all other pending and proposed measures. As a rule, all sanggunian sessions shall be open to the public, unless otherwise provided by law. Sanggunian to post notice of the budget deliberation schedule in three (3) conspicuous places at least seven (7) days before the conduct of said activity. Observing the Internal Rules of Procedure (IRP) of the Sanggunian, the accredited CSOs may: Invite accredited CSOs to attend and provide inputs during the budget deliberation sessions, including committee hearings. a. Provide inputs on sectoral concerns; and b. Raise questions on changes in the Executive Budget not found in the approved AIP. Source: Handbook on the Participation of Civil Society Organizations in the Local Budget Process 91 ACTIVITY 2. AUTHORIZE THE ANNUAL BUDGET LGU ROLES The sanggunian Sanggunian may allow authorizes the annual accredited CSOs to budget through an AO. observe the voting for the enactment of the AO. CSO ROLES The accredited CSOs may observe the voting conducted by the sanggunian. 3. APPROVE THE APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE The AO enacted by the sanggunian shall be presented to the LCE for approval, in which case the LCE shall affix his/her signature in every page thereof. Otherwise, the LCE may exercise veto power. LCE to consider formal comments and observations of accredited CSO, if any, subject to the fifteen (15) and ten (10) days reglementary period for approval, for provinces, and cities or municipalities, respectively, pursuant to Section 54 (b) of the LGC. The accredited CSOs may inform the LCE in writing of their observation in the deliberation and enactment of AO, subject to the applicable reglementary period. 4. POST THE APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE The secretary to the sanggunian is required to post the AO, in Filipino or English and in the language or dialect understood by the majority of the people in the LGU concerned, on a bulletin board at the entrance of the provincial capitol or city, or municipal hall, as the case may be, and in at least two (2) other conspicuous places in the LGU concerned. Comply with the Full Disclosure Policy pursuant to existing DILG issuances. The accredited CSOs may monitor the posting pursuant to the requirements under the LGC of the approved Comply with the posting AO, and may assist in requirement under making this known to the Section 59 (a) (b) of the public. LGC. 92 2.3 The Budget Authorization Flowchart The flowchart in Figure 10 describes the sequence of activities in budget authorization. Figure 10. Budget Authorization Flowchart 2.4 Steps in the Budget Authorization Phase There are only four (4) major steps to follow in Budget Authorization: Step 1. Enact the Appropriation Ordinance Section 319 of the LGC* provides that: “On or before the end of the current fiscal year, the sanggunian concerned shall enact, through an ordinance, the annual budget of the local government unit for the ensuing fiscal year on the basis of the estimates of income and expenditures submitted by the local chief executive.” __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 93 2.4.1.1 Check the Submitted Budget Documents Using Local Budget Authorization (LBA) Form Nos. 1A and 1B (Checklists on Documentary and Signature Requirements for the Annual/Supplemental Budget) in this Chapter, the sanggunian, with the assistance of the LFC, shall check if the required documents with the prescribed signatures are submitted. 2.4.1.2 Evaluate the Budget The sanggunian, with the assistance of the LFC, shall evaluate and deliberate on the LEP in terms of compliance with the budgetary requirements and general limitations. Receipts Program – shall comply with the following requirements: a. Taxes, fees, or charges identified as sources are in accordance with the revenue ordinances of the LGU (Section 132 of the LGC); and b. The estimated receipts from RPT correspond to the total amount of due and demandable RPT, including delinquent accounts. Expenditure Program – shall comply with the following budgetary requirements: a. Budgetary Requirements (Section 324 of the LGC) The aggregate amount appropriated does not exceed the estimates of income; Full provision shall be made for all statutory and contractual obligations of the LGU, and that the amount of appropriations for debt servicing do not exceed twenty percent (20%) of the regular income of the LGU; Provision of aid to component barangays shall be in amounts of not less than One Thousand Pesos (P1,000.00) per barangay; and Not less than five percent (5%) of the estimated revenue from regular sources shall be set aside as the Local Disaster Risk Reduction Management Fund (LDRRMF), of which thirty percent (30%) lumpsum allocation for Quick Response Fund (QRF) and seventy percent (70%) for disaster prevention and mitigation, preparedness, response, rehabilitation, and recovery (Section 21 of RA No. 10121 and NDRRMC-DBM-DILG 94 JMC No. 2013-1 dated March 25, 2013).34 b. 20% of the National Tax Allotment for Development Projects Provision of no less than twenty percent (20%) of the NTA intended for development projects (Section 287 of the LGC and DBM-DOF-DILG JMC No. 1 dated November 4, 2020).35 c. General Limitations Total appropriations, whether annual or supplemental, for PS for one (1) fiscal year shall not exceed forty-five percent (45%) in the case of first to third class provinces, cities and municipalities, and fifty-five percent (55%) in the case of fourth class or lower, of the total annual income from regular sources realized in the next preceding fiscal year (Section 325 [a] of the LGC). The sanggunian may use Local Budget Review (LBR) Form Nos. 2A and 2B in Part II, Chapter 3 of this Manual; No official or employee shall be entitled to a salary rate higher than the maximum fixed for the position or other positions of equivalent rank by applicable laws or rules and regulations issued thereunder (Section 325 [b] of the LGC); Compare the authorized salary grade and salary for each position with the authorized rate in the Salary Schedule being implemented by the LGU. The Plantilla of Personnel and the Index of Occupational Services36 may be used for the purpose; No local fund shall be appropriated to increase or adjust salaries or wages of officials and employees of the national government, except as may be expressly authorized by law (Section 325 [c] of the LGC); In cases of abolition of positions and the creation of new ones resulting from the abolition of existing positions in the career service, such abolition or creation is made in accordance with pertinent provisions of the LGC and civil service laws, rules and regulations (Section 325 [d] of the LGC); 34 Allocation and Utilization of the Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund (LDRRMF) Revised Guidelines on the Appropriation and Utilization of the Twenty percent (20%) of the Annual Internal Revenue Allotment for Development Projects (LGUs) 36 Local Budget Circular No. 137 dated July 13, 2021 35 95 Positions in the official plantilla for career positions which are occupied by incumbents holding permanent appointment shall be covered by adequate appropriations (Section 325 [e] of the LGC); No changes in designation or nomenclature of positions resulting in a promotion or demotion in rank or increase or decrease in compensation shall be allowed, except when the position is actually vacant, and the filling of such position shall be strictly made in accordance with civil service laws, rules and regulations (Sections 325 [f] of the LGC); The creation of new positions and salary increases or adjustments shall in no case be made retroactive (Section 325 [g] of the LGC); and The annual appropriations for discretionary purposes of the LCE shall not exceed two percent (2%) of the actual receipts derived from basic RPT in the next preceding calendar year. Discretionary funds shall be disbursed only for public purposes to be supported by appropriate vouchers and subject to such guidelines as may be prescribed by law. No amount shall be appropriated for the same purpose except as authorized under Section 325 [h] of the LGC. d. Compliance with Provisions of Other Applicable Laws, Rules and Regulations Projects in the AO are found in the approved Annual Investment Program (Section 305 [i] of the LGC); No items in the AO are specifically prohibited by law; and Other items of expenditure are expressly prescribed or authorized under existing laws, rules, and regulations. Among others, verify if appropriations for specific purposes required by law, which may be attributed to regular PPAs, are fully provided. For guidance, the sanggunian may refer to LBR Form No. 2 in Part II, Chapter 3 of this Manual. The proposed APP, which is the consolidation of PPMPs of all Departments/Offices or end-user units in the LGU, which includes all procurement activities and schedules planned for the budget year that are integrated in the AIP, may be used by the sanggunian in its evaluation of the LEP, among others. 96 e. Annual Operating Budget of Local Economic Enterprise – shall comply with the following requirements: The LGU maintains a special account in the General Fund (GF) for the LEE (Section 313 [a] of the LGC). Salaries, wages, representation, and transportation allowances of LEE officials and employees shall not be included in the annual or supplemental budget or in the computation of the maximum amount for PS of the LGU. The appropriations for PS of LEEs shall be charged to their respective budgets (Section 325 [a] of the LGC). No LEE official or employee is allowed a salary rate higher than the maximum fixed for the position or other positions of equivalent rank. PPAs of LEE are included in the AIP. Under Section 313 of the LGC, the rule on the treatment of the income of the LEE is as follows: a. The costs of improvement, repair, and other related expenses of the LEE shall be deducted from the income from the operation of the said LEE; b. The balance thereof shall first be applied for the return of advances or loans made; and c. Any excess shall form part of the GF of the LGU. The AOB of each LEE is presented separately in the LEP which shall be included for enactment by the sanggunian. The sanggunian may refer to Local Budget Circular (LBC) No. 111 dated June 10, 2016 prescribing the Manual on the Setting Up and Operation of LEE. 2.4.1.3 Deliberate the Budget The sanggunian shall consider the LEP as a priority measure if certified as urgent by the LCE, thus, shall take precedence over all other pending and proposed measures. 97 All sanggunian sessions shall be open to the public unless a closeddoor session is ordered by an affirmative vote of majority of the members present, there being a quorum, in the public interest or for reasons of security, decency, or morality. No two (2) sessions, regular or special, may be held in a single day (Section 52 [c] of the LGC). Presentation of the Executive Budget to the Sanggunian On the first day of the deliberation on the LEP, the LCE may address the members of the sanggunian to present the thrusts, programs and priorities of the budget under consideration. The LCE may likewise brief the sanggunian on the level of proposed expenditures; how they are strategically allocated among the three (3) mandated sectoral services (social, economic, and general services) and the sources of financing, i.e., revenues, other receipts and borrowings that will support the budget. Deliberation Proper The procedures observed in the budget deliberation may vary from one LGU to another depending on the IRP adopted by the sanggunian. The Committee on Appropriations/Finance may conduct its own budget hearing and may call upon the LFC and Heads of Departments and Offices during the preliminary review and evaluation of the budget. The Committee then renders its report and recommendations to the sanggunian proper. The LFC, in assisting the sanggunian, shall: o Make available pertinent data to enable the sanggunian and the Committee on Appropriations/Finance to carry out a more objective review and analysis of the proposed expenditure program and its component activities, the projected revenues and other sources of financing; and o Be present during committee hearings and sanggunian sessions as may be required by the legislative body to explain any detail of the LEP that the members may wish to be clarified on. When allowed in the IRP, the accredited CSOs may be invited to attend and provide inputs during budget deliberation sessions, including committee hearings. 98 The sanggunian shall, among others, ensure that the provisions on budgetary requirements and general limitations under the LGC and other laws are strictly complied with. During budget deliberation, the sanggunian may use the following guide questions, among others: o Is the budget consistent with the approved AIP? o Do the estimated revenues and other receipts have reasonable probability of collection? o Are new taxes and other revenue measures proposed to finance the budget covered by tax ordinances? o Are the proposed borrowing or other credit financing within the capability of the LGU to pay? o Does the budget adequately provide funds for the delivery of basic services and maintenance of facilities enumerated under Section 17 of the LGC? o Are the requirements of component LGUs considered and equitably provided for in the budget? o Is the proposed expenditure program within the recommended ceiling for economic, social, and general public services? o Are the existing/proposed organizational structure and staffing pattern designed and implemented taking into consideration the service requirements and financial capability of the LGU subject to the minimum standards and guidelines of the CSC and the provisions of the LGC? o Does the existing/proposed staffing complement have the capability to implement the plans and programs and deliver basic public services? o Are there expenditures that need to be reduced to ensure an effective and efficient use of resources in local government operations? o Are there projects or activities that need to be “fasttracked”? o Are there procedures to be simplified to optimize utilization of resources? 99 The Heads of Departments and Offices, as authorized by the LCE, when requested to appear before the sanggunian to explain or justify their budgets, may present the following: o The mandate, vision and mission, MFOs, PIs, targets, functions, and corresponding projects of the Department/Office and their relevance to the total development efforts of the LGU; o The nature of the work to be performed for each PPA measured in terms of expected results, as well as the level of funding being proposed, including organizational setup/staffing modification, if any, and the personnel complement tasked to perform the work; and o The accomplishment of the Department/Office for the preceding fiscal year, particularly the extent to which it has met its targets. 2.4.1.4 Authorize the Annual Budget After budget deliberation, the sanggunian authorizes the annual budget through an AO. (Please see illustrative example in Item 2.6 of this Chapter.) An appropriation refers to an authorization made by ordinance, directing the payment of goods and services from local government funds under specified conditions or for specific purposes (Section 306 [b] of the LGC). Contents of the Appropriation Ordinance The AO shall contain, among others, the following: Assigned number, title or caption, enacting or ordaining clause, and the date of proposed effectivity (Article 107 [b] of IRR of the LGC); A provision identifying the documents appended to the AO that will form part of the authorized budget, such as, but not limited to, the following: o o Plantilla of Personnel; and AOB/s of LEE/s, if any; Receipts Program; Expenditure Program by Department/Office: 100 o mandate, vision, mission and organizational outcome, MFO, PIs, and targets; o new appropriations of PPA, expense class, and object of expenditures; and o special provisions, if any; Special Purpose Appropriations, including provision on loan payment, if any, shall be reflected under the appropriate implementing Department/Office; General Provisions may include authority on the use of savings and augmentation, among others; and Summary of new appropriations by Expense Class, by Object of Expenditure by Sector, by Department/Office, and Summary Statement of all Statutory and Contractual Obligations. Rules Governing the Enactment of an Appropriation Ordinance The enactment of the proposed AO shall be governed by the rules prescribed under Section 54 of the LGC and Article 107 of its IRR, as well as the IRP adopted by the sanggunian concerned. In summary, the following may constitute basic requirements and process of enactment: o A majority of all the members of the sanggunian who have been elected and qualified shall constitute a quorum to transact official business. Should a question of quorum be raised during a session, the Presiding Officer shall immediately proceed to call the roll of the members and thereafter announce the results (Section 53 [a] of the LGC and Article 106 [a] [b] of its IRR). o The proposed AO shall be accompanied by a brief explanatory note containing the justification for its approval (Article 107 [b] of the IRR of the LGC). o The proposed AO shall be signed by the author or authors and submitted to the Secretary to the Sanggunian who shall report the same to the sanggunian at its next meeting (Article 107 [b] of the IRR of the LGC). o No ordinance shall be considered on second reading in any regular meeting unless it has been reported out by the proper committee to which it was referred, normally the Committee on Appropriations, or certified as urgent by the LCE (Article 107 [d] of the IRR of the LGC). 101 o The proposed AO, if certified as urgent by the LCE, may be presented to and considered by the sanggunian at the same meeting when it was first reported to the sanggunian, whether or not it is included in the calendar of business without need of suspending the rules (Article 107 [e] of the IRR of the LGC). o The Secretary to the Sanggunian shall prepare copies of the proposed AO in the form it was passed during the second reading, and shall distribute to each sanggunian member a copy thereof for the third reading and final consideration (Article 107 [f] of the IRR of the LGC). o If the proposed AO is certified as urgent by the LCE, it may be submitted for final voting immediately after debate or amendment during the second reading (Article 107 [f] of the IRR of the LGC). o An ordinance authorizing or directing the payment of money or creating liability shall require the affirmative vote of a majority of all the sanggunian members for its passage (Article 107 [g] of the IRR of the LGC). o The approved AO shall be stamped with the seal of the sanggunian and recorded in a book kept for the purpose (Article 107 [h] of the IRR of the LGC). o The Secretary to the Sanggunian shall affix his signature to the enacted AO and present the same to the Presiding Officer for his signature (Section 469 [c] [2] of the LGC). o The Secretary to the Sanggunian shall forward the AO enacted by the Sanggunian and duly certified by the Presiding Officer to the LCE for approval (Section 469 [c] [3] of the LGC). Voting Requirement to Enact an Appropriation Ordinance o An AO requires the affirmative vote of a majority of all the sanggunian members (Municipality of Corella vs. Philkonstrak [Corella], G.R. No. 218663, February 28, 2022). o For purposes of ascertaining if a quorum exists, the ViceGovernor/Vice-Mayor, as In determining the total membership of the Sanggunian, the ViceGovernor or the Vice-Mayor, as the case may be, is included (Romeo Gamboa, Jr vs. Marcelo Aguirre, Jr. and Juan Araneta, G.R. No. 134213, July 20, 1999). 102 the Presiding Officer, shall be considered a part of the sanggunian. In determining the number which constitutes the majority vote, the Vice-Governor/Vice-Mayor shall be excluded. Their right to vote is merely contingent and arises only when there is a tie to break (J. Tobias Javier and Vincent Piccio III vs. Rhodora Cadiao, et al., G.R. No.185369, August 3, 2016). Simple Majority means the majority vote of all those present in a session there being a quorum, while Qualified Majority refers to the majority vote of all the members duly elected and qualified regardless of whether or not all of them were present or not in a particular session (La Carlota City vs. Atty. Rex Rojo, G.R. No. 181367, April 24, 2012). In the case of Corella, the Supreme Court (SC) ruled as follows: o Article 107 (g) of the IRR of the LGC provides the general rule that no ordinance or resolution shall be passed by the sanggunian without the prior approval of a majority of all the members present. o The exception to the general rule is that for ordinances or resolutions authorizing or directing the payment of money or creating liability, what is needed is the affirmative vote of a majority of all the sanggunian members, whether present or not. o The term “appropriation,” as defined under Section 306 (b) of the LGC “refers to an authorization made by ordinance, directing the payment of goods and services from local government funds under specified conditions or for specific purposes.” o Juxtaposing this definition with the exception in Article 107(g) of the IRR of the LGC, that “any ordinance x x x authorizing or directing the payment of money x x x, shall require the affirmative vote of a majority of all the sanggunian members,” it is express and clear that an “appropriation ordinance” is one such ordinance contemplated in the exception. When an AO will serve as the Sanggunian authorization for the LCE to enter into contracts o “The question of whether a sanggunian authorization separate from the [AO] is required should be resolved depending on the particular circumstances of the case. 103 Resort to the [AO] is necessary in order to determine if there is a provision therein which specifically covers the expense to be incurred or the contract to be entered into. Should the [AO], for instance, already contain in sufficient detail the project and cost of a capital outlay such that all the [LCE] needs to do after undergoing the requisite public bidding is to execute the contract, no further authorization is required, the [AO] already being sufficient.” (Hon. Gabriel Luis Quisumbing, et al. vs. Hon. Gwendolyn Garcia, et al., G.R. No. 175527, December 8, 2008). o In Corella, the SC explained, “[i]n the landmark case of Quisumbing v. Garcia (Quisumbing), the Court delineated when a sangguniang bayan authorization is still necessary to accompany the appropriation ordinance and when it is not. Depending on the circumstances of the case, if the project is provided for in sufficient detail in the appropriation ordinance, meaning the transactions, bonds, contracts, documents, and other obligations the mayor would enter into in behalf of the municipality, among others, are enumerated, then no separate authorization is necessary. On the other hand, if the project is merely couched in general and generic terms, then a separate approval by the sangguniang bayan in accordance with the law is required.” o “The recent case of Verceles, Jr. v. Commission on Audit (Verceles)37 citing Quisumbing, elaborated on this issue, thus: Explained simply, the [Local Government Code] requires the local chief executive to secure prior authorization from the sanggunian before he can enter into contracts on behalf of the LGU. A separate prior authorization is no longer required if the specific projects are covered by appropriations of the LGU. The appropriation ordinance passed by the sanggunian is the local chief executive's authority to enter into a contract implementing the project. As required in Quisumbing, the local chief executive must inquire if the provisions in the appropriation ordinance specifically covers the expense to be incurred or the contract to be entered into. If the project or program is identified in the appropriation ordinance in sufficient detail, then there is no more need to obtain a separate or additional authority from the sanggunian. In such 37 G.R. No. 211553 dated September 13, 2016 104 case, the project and the cost are already identified and approved by the sanggunian through the appropriation ordinance. To require the local chief executive to secure another authorization for a project that has been specifically identified and approved by the sanggunian is antithetical to a responsive local government envisioned in the Constitution and in the [Local Government Code]. (Emphasis supplied) As the Verceles case explained, "sufficient authority" in an appropriation ordinance simply means specifically and expressly setting aside an amount of money for a certain project or program.” Limitations on Legislative Action The local sanggunian may not increase the proposed amount in the executive budget nor include new items except to provide for statutory and contractual obligations but in no case shall it exceed the total appropriations in the executive budget (Article 415 [a] of the IRR of the LGC). The doctrine enunciated in the case of Andres Sarmiento, et al. vs. The Treasurer of the Philippines, et al. (G.R. Nos. 125680 and 126313, September 4, 2001) may be applied where the SC ruled that: “For his part, the Solicitor General claims that the phrase "for the operation of the government" means that Congress is enjoined from increasing the total budget for the operation of the government as recommended by the President, not the individual items of appropriations. We agree. Records of the 1986 Constitutional Commission reveals that the purpose of the above-quoted provision is to avoid the possibility of a big budget deficit if Congress were given an unbridled hand in passing upon the appropriations recommended by the President as specified in the budget. The constitutional prohibition against such increase is an assurance that the expected income of the government will be sufficient for the operational expenses of its different agencies and projects specified in the appropriations law.” It may be noted that the subject provision of the LGC prohibiting the increase in the proposed amount in the executive budget is similar to the provision in Executive Order No. 292, s. 1987 (Administrative Code of 1987), particularly Section 24, Chapter 4 on Budget Authorization, Book VI, in the case of national government budgeting, to wit: 105 “SECTION 24. Prohibition Against the Increase of Appropriation. – The Congress shall in no case increase the appropriation of any project or program of any department, bureau, agency or office of the Government over the amount submitted by the President in his budget proposal. In case of any reduction in the proposed appropriation for a project or program, a corresponding reduction shall be made in the total appropriation of the department, office or agency concerned in the total of the General Appropriations Bill.” Step 2. Approve the Appropriation Ordinance The AO enacted by the sanggunian shall be presented to the LCE. If the LCE approves the same, he/she shall affix his signature on every page thereof (Sample Format No. 3 – Approval Letter of the LCE). Otherwise, he/she shall veto it and return the same with his objections to the sanggunian, which may proceed to reconsider the same (Section 54 [a] of the LGC). As clearly inferred from Section 55 (b) of the LGC, a veto may be partial (Sample Format No. 4 – Veto Message [Partial]) or total (Sample Format No. 5 – Veto Message [Total Veto]). The veto shall be communicated by the LCE concerned to the sanggunian within fifteen (15) days in the case of a province, and ten (10) days in the case of a city or a municipality; otherwise, the ordinance shall be deemed approved as if he/she had signed it (Section 54 [b] of the LGC). A. Veto power of the LCE (Section 55 of the LGC) Based on Section 55 (a) (b) and (c) of the LGC, the following are apparent: The LCE may veto any ordinance on the ground that it is ultra vires (i.e., “beyond the powers”) or prejudicial to the public welfare, stating his reasons therefor in writing. The LCE, except the Punong Barangay, shall have the power to veto any particular item or items of an appropriation ordinance, an ordinance or resolution adopting a local development plan and public investment program, or an ordinance directing the payment of money or creating liability. The veto shall not affect the item or items which are not objected to. The LCE has to sign the AO even if he has vetoed certain items in the AO. The vetoed item or items shall not take effect unless the sanggunian overrides the veto; otherwise, the item or items in the AO of the previous year corresponding to those vetoed, if any, shall be deemed reenacted. As gleaned from the foregoing, the LCE has to sign the AO in every page thereof even if he has vetoed an item or items of an AO. He/she should state his reasons in writing for the vetoed items. 106 The LCE may veto an ordinance or resolution only once. B. Override of the Veto Pursuant to Section 55 (c) of the LGC, the sanggunian may override the veto of the LCE by two-thirds (2/3) vote of all its members. Such override will make the ordinance effective even without the approval of the LCE concerned. Step 3. Post the Appropriation Ordinance The Secretary to the Sanggunian concerned shall cause the posting of an ordinance or resolution in the bulletin board at the entrance of the provincial capitol or city, municipality, or barangay hall, as the case may be, and in at least two (2) conspicuous places in the LGU concerned not later than five (5) days after the approval thereof (Section 59 [a] of the LGC and Article 113 of its IRR). The text of the ordinance or resolution shall be disseminated and posted in Filipino or English or in the language or dialect understood by the majority of the people in the LGU concerned, and the Secretary to the Sanggunian shall record such fact in a book kept for the purpose, stating the dates of approval and posting (Section 59 [b] of the LGC). In the case of highly-urbanized cities (HUCs) and independent component cities (ICCs), the main feature of the ordinance or resolution duly enacted or adopted shall, in addition to being posted, be published once in a local newspaper of general circulation within the city; provided that in the absence thereof the ordinance or resolution shall be published in any newspaper of general circulation (Section 59 [d] of the LGC). As a general rule, under Section 59 (a) of the LGC, an ordinance or a resolution approving the local development plan and public investment program shall take effect after ten (10) days from the date a copy thereof is posted in a bulletin board at the entrance of the provincial capitol or city, municipal, or barangay hall, as the case may be, and in at least two (2) other conspicuous places in the LGU concerned, unless otherwise stated. Step 4. Forward copies of the approved Appropriation Ordinance to the reviewing authority For component cities and municipalities, the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod or Sangguniang Bayan, as the case may be, shall forward to the Sangguniang Panlalawigan within three (3) days after approval, copies of the approved AO for review in accordance with Section 327 of the LGC (Section 56 of the LGC in relation to Section 327 of the LGC). For provinces, HUCs, ICCs, and municipalities within the MMA, the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlalawigan, Sangguniang Panlungsod, or Sangguniang Bayan, as the case may be, shall transmit to the DBM within three (3) days after its approval, copies of the approved AO for review in accordance with Section 107 327 of the LGC (Section 56 of the LGC in relation to Sections 326 and 327 of the LGC). The AO shall be supported with the documentary requirements bearing the prescribed signatures as specified in LBR Form Nos. 1A and 1B in the Budget Review Phase, Part II, Chapter 3 of this Manual. Effectivity of the Annual/Supplemental Budget “The ordinance enacting the annual budget shall take effect at the beginning of the ensuing calendar year. An ordinance enacting a supplemental budget, however, shall take effect upon its approval or on the date fixed therein.” (Section 320 of the LGC) Changes in the Annual Budget Pursuant to Section 321 of the LGC and Article 417 of its IRR, as amended by Administrative Order No. 47 dated April 12, 1993, changes in the annual budget may be done through supplemental budgets. No ordinance providing for a supplemental budget shall be enacted except for the following: 1. When supported by funds actually available as certified by the local treasurer; 2. If covered by new revenue sources; and 3. In times of public calamity by way of budgetary realignment. The detailed discussion on the enactment of the AO authorizing a Supplemental Budget is presented in the Budget Preparation Phase, Part II, Chapter 1 of this Manual. 108 2.5 Local Budget Authorization Forms LBA Form No. 1A CHECKLIST ON DOCUMENTARY AND SIGNATURE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ANNUAL BUDGET DOCUMENT SIGNATORY Budget Message Local Chief Executive (LCE) Local Expenditure Program LCE Plantilla of Personnel Human Resource Management Officer REMARKS Local Budget Officer (LBO) LCE Annual Operating Budget of Local Economic Enterprise, if any Head of the Local Economic Enterprise LCE Annual Investment Program (AIP) (As approved by the sanggunian through a Resolution) 1. AIP Local Planning and Development Coordinator LBO LCE 2. Resolution Secretary to the Sanggunian Presiding Officer LCE 109 LBA Form No. 1B CHECKLIST ON DOCUMENTARY AND SIGNATURE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET DOCUMENT SIGNATORY REMARKS Funds Actually Available: Certified Statement of Additional Realized Income Local Treasurer Local Accountant Certification of Savings with Sanggunian Resolution covering the reversion of savings, unless reversion is also covered in the AO Local Treasurer Local Accountant New Revenue Measure/s: Certified Statement of Income from New Revenue Measures Copy of duly enacted Tax Ordinance which imposes new local taxes, charges, fees, fines or penalties or which raises existing local taxes, charges, fees, fines, or penalties Local Treasurer Local Accountant Secretary to the Sanggunian Presiding Officer Local Chief Executive (LCE) Copy of official communication stating that the LGU is a recipient of new or higher remittances, contributions, subsidies or grants in aid from the National Government or from government corporations and private entities Copy of official communication / document covering the approved loan Realignment of appropriations in times of Public Calamity: Certificate, under oath, of Source of Funds Available for Appropriation Local Treasurer Local Accountant LCE Statement of Appropriations Supplemental Local Budget Officer (LBO) LCE 110 DOCUMENT SIGNATORY REMARKS Supplemental Annual Investment Program (AIP) (As approved by the sanggunian through a Resolution) 1. Supplemental AIP Local Planning and Development Coordinator LBO LCE 2. Resolution Secretary to the Sanggunian Presiding Officer LCE 111 2.6 Illustrative Examples Sample Format No. 1 – Ordinance Authorizing the Annual Appropriations* APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE NO. _____ Series of ____ AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ANNUAL BUDGET OF (NAME OF LGU) IN THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF _________________ (P____________) COVERING THE VARIOUS EXPENDITURES FOR THE OPERATION OF THE (PROVINCIAL/CITY/ MUNICIPAL) GOVERNMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR (FY) ______, AND APPROPRIATING THE NECESSARY FUNDS FOR THE PURPOSE Introduced by: Be it ordained in Regular Session assembled: Section 1. The Annual Budget of the (Name of LGU) in the total amount of ___________________ (P_______) covering the various expenditures for the operation of the (Provincial/City/Municipal) Government for FY _____ is hereby approved. The following budget documents are incorporated herein, and made integral part of this Ordinance: 1. Plantilla of Personnel; and 2. Annual Operating Budget of Local Economic Enterprise/s, if any. Section 2. Sources of Funds RECEIPTS PROGRAM FY 2022-2024 (In 000 Pesos) Particulars (1) Account Code (2) Past Year Current Year (Actual) First Semester Second Semester (Actual) (Estimate) (3) (4) (5) Total (6) Budget Year (Proposed) (7) I. Beginning Cash Balance II. Receipts Regular Income A. Local Sources 1. Tax Revenue a. Real Property Tax (RPT) i. Basic RPT b. Business Tax c. Other Local Taxes Total Tax Revenue 2. Non-Tax Revenue a. Regulatory Fees b. Service/User Charges c. Receipts from Economic Enterprises d. Other Receipts Total Non-Tax Revenue Total Local Sources __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 112 B. External Sources 1. National Tax Allotment (NTA) (formerly Internal Revenue Allotment [IRA]) 2. Share from Government-Owned and/or Controlled Corporations (Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation and Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office) 3. Other Shares from National Tax Collection a. Share from Ecozone b. Share from eVAT c. Share from National Wealth d. Share from Tobacco Excise Tax Total External Sources Total Regular Income Non-Regular Income A. External Sources 1. Inter-Local Transfer 2. Extraordinary Receipts/Grants/Donations/Aids Total External Sources B. Non-Income Receipts 1. Capital Investment Receipts a. Proceeds from Sale of Assets b. Proceeds from Sale of Debt Securities of Other Entities c. Collections of Loans Receivable Total Capital Investment Receipts 2.Receipts from Loans and Borrowings a. Acquisition of Loans b. Issuance of Bonds Total Receipts from Loans and Borrowings 3. Other Non-Income Receipts Total Non-Income Receipts Total Non-Regular Income Total Available Appropriation Resources for Section 3. Use of Fund A. OFFICE OF THE MAYOR Mandate: Vision: Mission: Organizational Outcome: 1. New Appropriations by Program, Project, and Activity (PPA) Annual Investment Program (AIP) Reference Code PPA Major Final Output (MFO) Proposed Budget Performance Indicator (PI) Target Personal Services (PS) Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses (MOOE) Financial Expenses (FE) Capital Outlay (CO) Total 113 2. New Appropriations, by Object of Expenditures Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) PS Salaries and Wages – Regular Salaries and Wages – Casual/Contractual Personnel Economic Relief Allowance Representation Allowance Transportation Allowance Clothing/Uniform Allowance Honoraria Year-End Bonus Cash Gift Other Bonuses and Allowances Retirement and Life Insurance Premiums Pag-IBIG Contributions PhilHealth Contributions Employees Compensation Insurance Premium (ECIP) Terminal Leave Benefits TOTAL PS MOOE Travelling Expenses Training and Scholarship Expenses Telephone Expenses – Landline Telephone Expenses – Mobile Postage and Deliveries Subscription Expenses Rent/Lease Expense Office Supplies Expenses Fuel, Oil, and Lubricant Expenses Repairs and Maintenance – Land Transport Equipment Repairs and Maintenance – Office Equipment Repairs and Maintenance – Building and Other Structures Donations Representation Expenses Confidential Expenses Other Professional Expenses TOTAL MOOE FE Management Supervision/Trusteeship Fees Interest Expenses Guarantee Fees Bank Charges Commitment Fees Other Financial Charges TOTAL FE 114 Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) CO Office Equipment Technical and Scientific Machinery Equipment Land Improvements TOTAL CO TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS 3. Special Purpose Appropriations 3.1 LOCAL DISASTER RISK REDUCTION AND MANAGEMENT FUND A. New Appropriations Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) QUICK RESPONSE FUND (30%) DISASTER PREPAREDNESS, PREVENTION, MITIGATION, RESPONSE, REHABILITATION AND RECOVERY (70%) MOOE Training Expenses Telephone Expenses – Landline Telephone Expenses – Mobile Insurance Expenses Rent/Lease Expense Supplies and Medicines Fuel, Oil and Lubricant Expenses Repairs and Maintenance – School Buildings TOTAL MOOE CO Rescue Equipment Building and Structure Land Improvements TOTAL CO TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS B. Special Provisions 1. Use and Release of Fund. The amount herein appropriated shall be used in accordance with Republic Act No. 10121, “The Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Act of 2010,” which shall include relief, rehabilitation, reconstruction, and other works or services, including pre-disaster activities, in connection with the occurrence of 115 natural calamities, epidemics as declared by the Department of Health, and other catastrophes. Provided, that the projects and activities are incorporated in the Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management (LDRRM) Plan, and integrated in the approved Annual Investment Program. Provided further, that the utilization of the Fund shall be in accordance with the provisions of National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council-Department of Budget and Management (DBM)Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) Joint Memorandum Circular (JMC) No. 2013-1 dated March 25, 2013. 2. Quick Response Fund. Of the amount appropriated for LDRRM Fund, thirty percent (30%) shall be allocated as Quick Response Fund (QRF) or stand-by fund for relief, and recovery programs in order that the situation and living conditions of people in the communities or areas stricken by disasters, calamities, epidemics, or complex emergencies, may be normalized as quickly as possible. The release and use of QRF shall be supported by a resolution of the Sanggunian declaring the local government unit (LGU) under state of calamity or a Presidential declaration of state of calamity. 3. In no case shall the QRF be used for the pre-disaster, nor be realigned for any other purpose. 3.2 APPROPRIATIONS PROJECTS FOR DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS AND A. New Appropriations Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) MOOE CO TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS B. Special Provisions Use and Release of Fund. The 20% Development Fund shall be strictly utilized in accordance with the general policies prescribed under DBMDepartment of Finance-DILG JMC No. 1 dated November 4, 2020, and for the projects included in the approved AIP of the [LGU] for FY 2024. The development projects identified shall be consistent with the local development plan duly approved by the Local Development Council and local sanggunian. The disbursement of this fund shall be based on the approved Project Procurement Management Plan for FY 2024, and shall be subject to all existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing laws, rules, and regulations. 116 3.3 OTHER SPECIAL PURPOSE APPROPRIATIONS A. New Appropriations Office/Program/ Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) a. Office of the Mayor b. Office of the Sanggunian c. etc. B. Special Provisions Use and Release of Fund. The release, utilization, and disbursement of the appropriation herein provided shall be subject to all existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing laws, rules and regulations. 3.4 APPROPRIATIONS FOR LOCAL ECONOMIC ENTERPRISES A. New Appropriations Object of Expenditure SUBSIDY ECONOMIC (LEE) Account Code Past Year Expenditures (Actual) Current Year Expenditures (Actual and Estimate) Budget Year Expenditures (Proposed) TO LOCAL ENTERPRISE OPERATING EXPENSES FUNDED BY INCOME OF THE LEE TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS B. Special Provisions Appropriation for Programs and Specific Activities. The amount appropriated herein for subsidies and programs of the LEE shall be used specifically for the identified activities subject to existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing laws, rules and regulations. 4. Summary of the FY 2024 New Appropriations 4.1 New Appropriations, by Object of Expenditure and by Sector Object of Expenditure Account Code General Public Services Social Services Economic Services Other Services Total 1. PS (specify object of expenditure) Total, PS 2. MOOE (specify object of expenditure) Total, MOOE 117 3. FE (specify object of expenditure) Total, FE 4. CO (specify object of expenditure) Total, CO 5. Special Purpose Appropriations (SPA) (specify object of expenditure) Total, SPA Total Appropriations 4.2 New Appropriations, by Office Office a. Office of the Mayor b. Office of the Sanggunian c. etc. PS MOOE FE CO Total 4.3 Summary of Statement of All Statutory and Contractual Obligations Particulars 1. Statutory and Contractual Obligations 1.1 5% Metro Manila Development Authority Contribution for Local Government Units in National Capital Region only (Republic Act No. 7924) 1.2 Retirement Gratuity Benefits 1.3 Terminal Leave Benefits 1.4 Debt Service 1.5 Employees Compensation Insurance Premiums 1.6 PhilHealth Contributions 1.7 Pag-IBIG Contributions 1.8 Retirement and Life Insurance Premiums Amount 2. Budgetary Requirements 2.1 20% of NTA (formerly IRA) for Development Projects (20% Development Fund) 2.2 5% LDRRM Fund 2.3 Financial Assistance to Barangays (Php1,000.00 minimum aid) TOTAL Section 4. General Provisions The following policies are hereby adopted for the fiscal year: 4.1 Availability of Appropriations. Unexpended balances of appropriations authorized in the annual appropriations ordinance shall revert to the unappropriated surplus of the general fund at the end of the fiscal year and shall not thereafter be available for the expenditure except by subsequent enactment. However, appropriations for CO shall continue and remain valid until fully spent, reverted or the project is completed. Reversions of continuing appropriations shall not be allowed unless obligations therefor have been fully paid or otherwise settled. 118 4.2 Limitation on Cash Advance. Notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary, cash advances shall not be granted until such time that the earlier cash advances availed of by the officials or employees or employees concerned shall have been liquidated pursuant to pertinent accounting. 4.3 Meaning of Savings. Savings refer to portions or balances as of any given point in the fiscal year or any programmed or allotted appropriation which remain free of any obligation or encumbrance and which are still available after the satisfactory completion or the unavoidable discontinuance or abandonment of the work, activity or purpose for which the appropriation was originally authorized, or which result from unobligated compensation and related costs pertaining to vacant positions and leaves of absence without pay. 4.4 Use of Savings and Augmentation. Funds shall be available exclusively for the specific purpose for which they have been appropriated. No ordinance shall be passed authorizing any transfer of appropriations from one item to another. However, the local chief executive or the presiding officer of the sanggunian concerned may, by ordinance, be authorized to augment any item in the approved annual budget for their respective offices from savings in other items within the same expense class of their respective appropriations. Section 5. Separability Clause. If, for any reason, any Section or provision of this Appropriation Ordinance is disallowed in Budget Review or declared invalid by proper authorities, other Sections or provisions hereof that are not affected shall continue to be in full force and effect. Section 6. Effectivity. The provisions of this Appropriation Ordinance shall take effect on January One, Two Thousand and ________. ENACTED: This ____ day of _______ at __________. x--------------------------------------x I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS ORDINANCE IS DULY ENACTED BY THE SANGGUNIAN ON ____________. NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE SECRETARY TO THE SANGGUNIAN NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE PRESIDING OFFICER APPROVED: NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE LOCAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE DATE OF APPROVAL 119 Sample Format No. 2 – Ordinance Authorizing Supplemental Appropriations APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE NO. _____ Series of _______ AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET NO. _____, SERIES OF _____ INVOLVING AN AMOUNT OF ___________ (P_______) FOR _________(PURPOSE)____________. Be it ordained in Regular Session assembled. Section 1. The Supplemental Budget of the (Name of LGU) for Fiscal Year ____ in the total amount of _______ (P________) for ___________________ is hereby approved. The following budget documents are incorporated herein and made integral part of this Ordinance: 1. 2. 3. 4. Section 2. Sources of Funds. The sources for the Supplemental Budget in the total amount of ________________ (P__________) shall be as follows: FUND SOURCE Funds Actually Available: a) Additional Realized Income b) Savings Sub-Total AMOUNT P_____________ _____________ P_____________ New Revenue Measures a) New local taxes, charges, fines or penalties b) Remittances/Contributions/Subsidies/Grants from NGAs/Government Corporations/Private Entities Sub-Total P_____________ _____________ P_____________ Total P_____________ Section 3. Use of Funds. The amount of _______________ (P_______) is hereby appropriated for the Supplemental Budget of the (Name of LGU), as follows: 1. Appropriations by Office, Program, Project, Activity (PPA), and Performance Indicator (PI) Annual Investment Program (AIP) Reference Code Office/ PPA Major Final Output (MFO) Proposed Budget PI Target Personal Services (PS) Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses (MOOE) Financial Expenses (FE) Capital Outlay (CO) Total TOTAL NEW APPROPRIATIONS 120 2. Appropriations by Object of Expenditures Object of Expenditure Account Code Past Year Current Year Budget Year PS Total, PS MOOE Total, MOOE FE Total, FE CO Total, CO TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS Section 4. Separability Clause. If, for any reason, any section or provision of this Ordinance is declared invalid or unconstitutional, other sections or provisions thereof which are not affected thereby shall continue to be in full force and effect. Section 5. Effectivity. The provisions of this Ordinance shall take effect on _______________. ENACTED: This ____ day of _________ at _______________. x------------------------------------------x I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS ORDINANCE IS DULY ENACTED BY THE SANGGUNIAN ON ____________. NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE SECRETARY TO THE SANGGUNIAN NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE PRESIDING OFFICER APPROVED: NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE LOCAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE DATE OF APPROVAL 121 Sample Format No. 3 - Approval Letter of the LCE ____Date____ THE HONORABLE PRESIDING OFFICER THE HONORABLE MEMBERS OF THE SANGGUNIAN [LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNIT] Ladies/Gentlemen: Today, I sign Appropriation Ordinance No. ________, Series of ______, entitled, AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ANNUAL BUDGET OF (NAME OF LGU) IN THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF _________________ (P____________) COVERING THE VARIOUS EXPENDITURES FOR THE OPERATION OF THE (PROVINCIAL/CITY/ MUNICIPAL) GOVERNMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR ______, AND APPROPRIATING THE NECESSARY FUNDS FOR THE PURPOSE (or AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET NO. _____, SERIES OF _____ INVOLVING AN AMOUNT OF _________________ [P___________] FOR ________[PURPOSE]______). With the passage of the FY _____ Annual/Supplemental Budget of the (Name of LGU) under Appropriation Ordinance No._____, Series of _____, we will be giving better basic services to our constituents. In accordance with the law, I am returning the approved Appropriation Ordinance No.____, Series of ______ to the Sanggunian. Very truly yours, NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE LOCAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE 122 Sample Format No. 4 – Veto Message (Partial Veto) ____Date____ THE HONORABLE PRESIDING OFFICER THE HONORABLE MEMBERS OF THE SANGGUNIAN [LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNIT] Ladies/Gentlemen: Today, I sign Appropriation Ordinance No. ________, Series of ______, entitled, AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ANNUAL BUDGET OF (NAME OF LGU) IN THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF _________________ (P____________) COVERING THE VARIOUS EXPENDITURES FOR THE OPERATION OF THE (PROVINCIAL/CITY/ MUNICIPAL) GOVERNMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR ______, AND APPROPRIATING THE NECESSARY FUNDS FOR THE PURPOSE (or AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET NO. _____, SERIES OF _____ INVOLVING AN AMOUNT OF _________________ [P___________] FOR ________[PURPOSE]______). However, pursuant to the powers vested in me by the Local Government Code of 1991, I am duty bound to veto some items of appropriation in the above-mentioned Appropriation Ordinance on the grounds that they result from ultra vires acts of the Sanggunian and are prejudicial to public welfare, as follows: (Enumerate the vetoed item/s and the particular reason/s for veto.) With the passage of the FY _____ Annual/Supplemental Budget of the (Name of LGU) under Appropriation Ordinance No._____, Series of _____, we will be giving better basic services to our constituents. In accordance with the law, I am returning the approved Appropriation Ordinance No.____, Series of ______ together with my partial veto to the Sanggunian. Very truly yours, NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE LOCAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE 123 Sample Format No. 5 – Veto Message (Total Veto) ____Date____ THE HONORABLE PRESIDING OFFICER THE HONORABLE MEMBERS OF THE SANGGUNIAN [LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNIT] Ladies/Gentlemen: Today, I veto Appropriation Ordinance No. ________, Series of ______, entitled, AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE ANNUAL BUDGET OF (NAME OF LGU) IN THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF _________________ (P____________) COVERING THE VARIOUS EXPENDITURES FOR THE OPERATION OF THE (PROVINCIAL/CITY/ MUNICIPAL) GOVERNMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR ______, AND APPROPRIATING THE NECESSARY FUNDS FOR THE PURPOSE (or AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET NO. _____, SERIES OF _____ INVOLVING AN AMOUNT OF _________________ [P___________] FOR ________[PURPOSE]______). Pursuant to the powers vested in me by the Local Government Code of 1991, I veto all items of appropriation embodied in the above-mentioned Appropriation Ordinance on the grounds that they result from ultra vires acts of the Sanggunian and are prejudicial to public welfare, as follows: (Enumerate the vetoed item/s and the particular reason/s for veto.) Hence, I am respectfully returning the approved Appropriation Ordinance No.____, Series of _____ together with the Veto Message to the Sanggunian. Very truly yours, NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE LOCAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE 124 Sample Format No. 6 – Ordinance Authorizing Use of Savings and Augmentation ORDINANCE NO. __________ Series of _______ AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE GOVERNOR/MAYOR AND/OR THE PRESIDING OFFICER OF THE SANGGUNIAN TO USE SAVINGS FOR AUGMENTATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT CODE OF 1991 Be it ordained in Regular Session assembled: Section 1. Use of Savings and Augmentation. In accordance with Section 336 of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991, the Governor/Mayor and/or the Presiding Officer of the Sanggunian is/are authorized to augment any item in the approved annual budget for their respective offices from savings in other items within the same expense class of their respective appropriations. For this purpose, “savings” refer to portions or balances of any programmed appropriation free from any obligation or encumbrance still available after the satisfactory completion or unavoidable discontinuance or abandonment of the work, activity or purpose for which the appropriation is authorized, or arising from unpaid compensation and related costs pertaining to vacant positions and leaves of absence without pay. “Augmentation” implies the existence in the budget of an item, project, activity or purpose with an appropriation which, upon implementation or subsequent evaluation of needed resources, is determined to be deficient. Section 2. Priority in the Use of Personal Services (PS) Savings. Priority shall be given to the personnel benefits of local employees in the use of PS savings. Section 3. Separability Clause. If, for any reason, any section or provision of this Ordinance is declared invalid or unconstitutional, other sections or provisions thereof which are not affected thereby shall continue to be in full force and effect. Section 4. Effectivity. _______________. The provisions of this Ordinance shall take effect on ENACTED: This ____ day of __________ at ____________________. x--------------------------------------------x I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS ORDINANCE IS DULY ENACTED BY THE SANGGUNIAN ON ____________. 125 NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE SECRETARY TO THE SANGGUNIAN NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE PRESIDING OFFICER APPROVED: NAME AND SIGNATURE OF THE LOCAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE DATE OF APPROVAL (Note: This form may be adopted in case the sanggunian decides to grant the authority for use of savings and augmentation under Section 336 of the LGC and the same authority was not incorporated in the ordinance authorizing the Annual Budget of the LGU.) 126 CHAPTER 3. BUDGET REVIEW PHASE Budget Review is the third phase in the local budget process. Its primary purpose is to determine whether the AO has complied with the budgetary requirements and general limitations set forth in the LGC, as well as provisions of other applicable laws. It starts from the time the reviewing authority receives the AO for review and ends with the issuance of the review action. 3.1 Legal Bases of Budget Review “The Department of Budget and Management shall review ordinances authorizing the annual or supplemental appropriations of provinces, highlyurbanized cities, independent component cities, and municipalities within the Metropolitan Manila Area in accordance with the immediately succeeding section.” (Section 326 of the LGC) “The sangguniang panlalawigan shall review the ordinance authorizing annual or supplemental appropriations of component cities and municipalities in the same manner and within the same period prescribed for the review of other ordinances.” (Section 327 of the LGC) 3.2 Key Players in Budget Review Secretary to the Sanggunian – Within three (3) days after the approval of the ordinance authorizing annual or supplemental appropriations, the Secretary to the Sanggunian shall forward the said ordinance to the DBM Regional Office (RO) or Sangguniang Panlalawigan for review (Section 56 [a] in relation to Sections 326 and 327 of the LGC). Department of Budget and Management Regional Office – The DBM RO shall review the ordinances authorizing the annual or supplemental appropriations of provinces, HUCs, and ICCs within its jurisdiction, and municipalities within the Metropolitan Manila Area. The DBM RO shall, within the reglementary period of review, advise the Sangguniang Panlalawigan, Sangguniang Panlungsod, or Sangguniang Bayan concerned, through the LCE, of any action in the AO under review (Section 326 in relation to Section 327 of the LGC). Sangguniang Panlalawigan – The Sangguniang Panlalawigan shall review the ordinance authorizing annual or supplemental appropriations of component cities and municipalities within the province. The Sangguniang Panlalawigan shall, within the reglementary period of review, advise the Sangguniang Panlungsod or Sangguniang Bayan concerned, through the LCE, of any action in the AO under review (Section 327 of the LGC). 127 Provincial Finance Committee – The Provincial Finance Committee shall assist the Sangguniang Panlalawigan in the review and evaluation of budget of component cities and municipalities and recommend the appropriate action thereon (Section 316 [f] of the LGC). CSOs and the Private Sector Groups – The CSOs may request for a copy of the budget review findings from the LGU as shown in Table 7 below. Table 7. Roles of CSOs in the Budget Review Phase ACTIVITY ISSUE THE REVIEW ACTION LGU ROLES CSO ROLES The reviewing authority If the arrangement is May request for a copy may declare the AO as: allowed in the terms of of the review action from engagement between the LGU. a) Operative in its the LGU and CSO, the entirety; or LGU may furnish a copy of the review action to b) Operative in its the accredited CSOs. entirety, subject to conditions; or c) Inoperative entirety; or in its d) Inoperative in part. 3.3 Reglementary Period of Review The AOs of provinces, HUCs, ICCs, component cities, and municipalities shall be reviewed within ninety (90) days from receipt of copies of such ordinances (Section 327 of the LGC). 3.4 The Budget Review Flowchart The budget review flowchart (Figure 11) shows the sequence of activities from the time the Secretary to the Sanggunian submits the approved AO to the reviewing body/office until the same is returned together with the review action to the Sangguniang Panlalawigan, Sangguniang Panlungsod, or Sangguniang Bayan concerned through the LCE. 128 Figure 11. Budget Review Flowchart 3.5 Steps in the Budget Review Phase Step 1. Check the Appropriation Ordinance with the Appended Budget Documents Using LBR Form Nos. 1A and 1B (Checklists on Documentary and Signature Requirements for the Annual Budget and Supplemental Budget, respectively, found in Item 3.6 of this Chapter), the DBM RO or Sangguniang Panlalawigan, as the case may be, shall check if the required documents with the appropriate signatures have been submitted together with the AO. All AOs must carry the seal of the LGU (Section 469 [c] [2] of the LGC). Incomplete Submission If the AO submitted for review lacks any of the documents or the required signatures mentioned in LBR Form Nos. 1A and 1B in this Chapter, the said AO shall not be reviewed, and shall be officially returned in writing by the DBM RO or Sangguniang Panlalawigan to the LGU concerned, through its Secretary to the Sanggunian, requiring the resubmission of the same with the necessary budget documents and/or signatures. 129 Step 2. Review the Appropriation Ordinance Using LBR Form No. 2 in Item 3.6 of this Chapter, the DBM RO or Sangguniang Panlalawigan shall validate the provisions in the AO for compliance with the budgetary requirements and general limitations pursuant to Sections 324 and 325 of the LGC, respectively, and other provisions of applicable laws, rules, and regulations. Step 3. Prepare and Issue the Review Action The DBM RO or Sangguniang Panlalawigan may prepare and issue the Review Action based on the Summary of Findings and Recommended Review Actions using LBR Form No. 2 in Item 3.6 of this Chapter. A. Review Actions After the evaluation of the AO and its supporting documents, the DBM RO or Sangguniang Panlalawigan may take any of the following actions: Declare the AO operative in its entirety. The AO shall be declared operative in its entirety when it fully complies with the budgetary requirements and general limitations set forth under Title V on Local Fiscal Administration of the LGC and other provisions of applicable laws, rules, and regulations (Section 327 of the LGC). Meanwhile, the AO may be subjected to conditions in the following cases: o Certain items of appropriation require prior clearance or documentation; o Certain items of appropriation require prior approval by appropriate authorities; o Certain items of appropriation are found to be deficient from what is prescribed by law and need to be increased (e.g., insufficient provisions for Philippine Health Insurance Corporation (PhilHealth), Government Service Insurance System premiums for some employees, etc.), except in cases where the AO has to be declared inoperative in its entirety; and/or o Other conditions that need to be complied with to make the parts of the AO operative. Declare the AO inoperative in its entirety. The AO shall be declared inoperative under any of the following cases: 130 o When appropriation exceeds estimates of income (Section 324 [a] of the LGC); o Non-provision or insufficient provision for any of the budgetary requirements under Section 324 of the LGC; o Non-provision or insufficient provision of the twenty percent (20%) of the NTA for development projects (Section 287 of the LGC); o When all the PPAs included in the AO are different from those listed in the AIP; o When the AIP is not approved/adopted by the sanggunian before the enactment of the AO authorizing the annual budget, pursuant to Section 305 (i) of the LGC, which states that, “[l]ocal budgets shall operationalize approved local development plans;” and/or o When no sufficient appropriation is provided for loans and other indebtedness incurred or when no provision is made to redeem or retire bonds, debentures, securities, notes and other obligations issued (Section 303 of the LGC). Declare the AO inoperative in part. The AO may be declared inoperative in part under the following instances: o When some items are contrary to the limitation or in excess of the amount prescribed by the LGC, such as, but not limited to, funds for discretionary purposes, PS, confidential expenses, debt servicing; o When some items have no legal basis (e.g., rice subsidy, cost of living allowance, and the like); o When some PPAs not included in the approved AIP are funded; and/or o When the amount appropriated in the AO is higher than the amount provided in the AIP for the same PPA. B. Effects of the Review Action When the AO is declared operative in its entirety, it shall continue to be in full force and effect. When the AO is declared operative in its entirety, subject to conditions, those items not subject to conditions shall continue to be in full force 131 and effect. The items of appropriation subject to conditions shall take effect only upon compliance with the conditions imposed. When the AO is declared inoperative in its entirety: o The AO loses force and effect; o The LGU concerned shall operate under a reenacted budget effective immediately until such time that the new ordinance authorizing the annual appropriations is enacted and approved; o The Local Treasurer shall not make further disbursements of funds from any of the items of appropriation declared inoperative, disallowed, or reduced (Section 327 of the LGC); and o The budget shall be revised to comply with the provisions of laws, rules, and regulations, and authorized through another AO, which shall then be submitted to the reviewing authority. When the AO is declared inoperative in part: o The Local Treasurer shall not make further disbursements of funds from any of the items of appropriation declared inoperative, disallowed, or reduced (Section 327 of the LGC); and o Only the items of appropriation that have not been declared inoperative, or have not been disallowed, shall continue to be in full force and effect. C. Format of the Review Action The review action by the DBM RO shall be in the form of a letter, while that of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan shall be in the form of a resolution. All the findings must be disclosed in the review action as shown in the illustrative examples of review letters and resolutions in Item 3.7 of this Chapter. D. Nature of the Review Action The review action does not amend the act of the sanggunian as embodied in the AO. o The primary purpose of the review is to determine whether the AO has complied with the applicable provisions of laws, rules, and regulations. 132 o The findings of the reviewing authority are merely enumeration of infractions of budgetary requirements, general limitations, other provisions of the LGC, and other applicable laws, rules, and regulations, as well as recommendations of what specific actions the sanggunian will undertake to comply with the provisions of law. The sanggunian shall take immediate action to correct or remedy any identified infractions. o The condition requiring provision for deficiencies shall be acted upon in the next supplemental budget. If the affected PPA is prioritized as urgent, a complete reallocation of resources is necessary to provide for deficiencies. The review action, likewise, does not authorize an item or items of appropriation that is/are specifically prohibited by law. E. Stamp of Review The stamp of review of the DBM RO or Sangguniang Panlalawigan shall be affixed on every page of the reviewed AO and duly signed by the Regional Director or by the Secretary to the Sanggunian and/or the Presiding Officer, as the case may be (See sample format of the Stamp of Review in Item 3.8 of this Chapter). F. Return of the Reviewed Appropriation Ordinance to the LGU concerned The DBM RO or Sangguniang Panlalawigan shall, within ninety (90) days from receipt of the copy of the AO, advise the sanggunian concerned, through the LCE, of the action on the AO reviewed (Section 327 of the LGC). G. Failure to Review the Appropriation Ordinance within the Mandated Period If after the ninety (90) days reglementary period of review, the DBM RO or Sangguniang Panlalawigan takes no action on the AO for review, the same shall be deemed to have been reviewed in accordance with law and shall continue to be in full force and effect (Section 327 of the LGC). H. Review Actions and Corrective Measures The review actions and its corresponding corrective measures are shown in Table 8. 133 Table 8. Review Actions and Corrective Measures REVIEW ACTIONS AO is declared inoperative in its entirety. CORRECTIVE MEASURES Appropriation exceeds estimates of income; Non-provision or insufficient provision for any of the budgetary requirements; The LGU, through the Local Treasurer, shall not make further disbursements of funds from any of the items of appropriation declared inoperative, disallowed, or reduced. Non-provision or insufficient provision of twenty percent (20%) of the NTA for development projects; When all projects included in the AO are different from those listed in the AIP; When the AIP is not approved/adopted by the sanggunian before the enactment of the AO authorizing the annual budget; and/or When no sufficient appropriation is provided for loans and other indebtedness incurred or when no provision is made to redeem or retire bonds, debentures, securities, notes and other obligations issued. The LGU shall revise its LEP to comply with the review findings and enact a new ordinance authorizing the annual appropriations for submission to the reviewing authority. AO is declared inoperative in part. For items without legal basis; and/or The LGU, through the Local Treasurer, shall not make further disbursements of funds from any of the items of appropriation declared inoperative, disallowed, or reduced. 134 REVIEW ACTIONS I. CORRECTIVE MEASURES For items that are contrary to limitations or in excess of the amount prescribed by law. The LGU shall reduce the appropriated amount accordingly. AO is declared operative in its entirety, subject to conditions The LGU shall comply with the conditions imposed before any disbursements are made, and the LCE shall notify the reviewing authority of such action. Enforcement of Ordinances or Resolutions after Disapproval by Reviewing Authority Any attempt to enforce any ordinance or resolution approving the local development plan and public investment program, after disapproval thereof, shall be sufficient ground for the suspension or dismissal of the official or employee concerned (Section 58 of the LGC). 135 3.6 Local Budget Review Forms LBR Form No. 1A CHECKLIST ON DOCUMENTARY AND SIGNATURE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ANNUAL BUDGET ______________ Date Received ______________ Deadline ______________________________ Local Government Unit (LGU) ______________ Class ______________ Title _______________ Fund DOCUMENT SIGNATORY a. Transmittal Letter Secretary to the Sanggunian b. Budget Message Local Chief Executive (LCE) c. Appropriation Ordinance (AO), carrying the seal of the LGU, together with the following documents: Secretary to the Sanggunian Presiding Officer REMARKS Letter dated: _____________ AO No.: __________________ Date Approved: ____________ Amount: __________________ LCE Annual Investment Program (AIP) Local Planning Development Coordinator Local Budget Officer (LBO) LCE Resolution approving the AIP Secretary to the Sanggunian Resolution No.: ____________ Date: ____________________ Presiding Officer LCE d. Annual Operating Budget of each Local Economic Enterprise (LEE), if any, and the AO for the newlycreated LEE Department Head e. Veto Message, if any LCE f. Sanggunian’s action on veto, if any Secretary to the Sanggunian LBO LCE Presiding Officer Prepared by: ________________________ Reviewing Officer 136 LBR Form No. 1B CHECKLIST ON DOCUMENTARY AND SIGNATURE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET ______________ Date Received ______________ Deadline _________________________________ Local Government Unit (LGU) ______________ Class ______________ Title _______________ Fund DOCUMENT SIGNATORY REMARKS a. Transmittal Letter Secretary to the Sanggunian Letter dated: ______________ b. Appropriation Ordinance (AO), carrying the seal of the LGU Secretary to the Sanggunian AO No.: __________________ Date Approved: ____________ Presiding Oficer Local Chief Executive (LCE) c. Funds Actually Available Local Treasurer Certified Statement of Additional Realized Income Local Accountant Certification of Savings Local Treasurer Local Accountant d. New Revenue Measure/s: Local Treasurer Certified Statement of Income form New Revenue Measures Local Accountant Copy of duly enacted Tax Ordinance which imposes new local taxes, charges, fees, fines or penalties or which raises existing local taxes, charges, fees, fines, or penalties Copy of official communication stating that the LGU is a recipient of new or higher remittances, contributions, subsidies or grants in aid from the National Government or from government corporations and private entities. Copy of official communication/document covering the approved loan 137 DOCUMENT e. f. g. SIGNATORY Realignment of Appropriations in Times of Public Calamity Local Treasurer Certificate of Source of Funds Available for Appropriations LCE Statement of Supplemental Appropriation, unless included in the AO Local Budget Officer (LBO) Supplemental Annual Investment Program (AIP), if applicable, approved by the Sanggunian Local Planning Development Coordinator REMARKS Local Accountant LCE LBO LCE Resolution approving the supplemental AIP Secretary to the Sanggunian Presiding Officer LCE h. Veto Message, if any LCE i. Sanggunian’s action on veto, if any Secretary to the Sanggunian Presiding Officer Prepared by: ________________________ Reviewing Officer 138 LBR Form No. 2 SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS _____________________________ Local Government Unit (LGU) _____________________ Title COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) NO (2) I. BUDGETARY REQUIREMENTS (Section 324 of the Local Government Code of 1991 [LGC] and Article 419 of its Implementing Rules and Regulations [IRR] and other pertinent laws) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) If the aggregate amount appropriated exceeds the estimates of income, declare AO inoperative in its entirety. a. The aggregate amount appropriated shall not exceed the estimates of income. Estimates of Income vs. Total Appropriations (Section 324 [a] of the LGC and Article 419 [c] of its IRR) Total Estimates of Income P ____________ Less: Total Appropriations Unappropriated Balance/ (Excess Appropriation) ____________ ____________ b. Full provision shall be made for all statutory and contractual obligations of the LGU concerned provided that the amount of appropriations for debt servicing shall not exceed twenty percent (20%) of the regular income of the LGU concerned. Debt Servicing Cap (Section 324 [b] of the LGC and Article 419 [b] of its IRR) Regular Income (Budget Year) Multiply by 20% _____________ x 20% Allowable Ceiling Less: Appropriations ____________ ____________ Balance/(Excess Appropriation) ____________ Declare AO inoperative in its entirety when no sufficient appropriation is provided for loans and other indebtedness. Disallow the amount in excess of the twenty percent (20%) of the regular income. Hence, declare the AO inoperative in part. 139 COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) NO (2) c. In the case of provinces, cities, and municipalities, aid to barangays shall be provided in amounts of not less than One Thousand Pesos (P1,000.00) per barangay. RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) Declare AO inoperative in its entirety for non-provision or insufficient provision of Aid to Barangays. Aid to Barangays (Section 324 [c] of the LGC and Article 419 [c] of its IRR) Number of Barangays Multiply by P1,000.00 x P1,000.00 Minimum Requirement Less: Appropriations Deficiency/(Allowable appropriation over minimum requirement) d. Not less than five percent (5%) of the estimated revenue from regular sources shall be set aside as the Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund (LDRRMF) to support disaster risk management activities such as, but not limited to, pre-disaster preparedness programs including training, purchasing life-saving rescue equipment, supplies and medicines, for post-disaster activities, and for the payment of premiums on calamity insurance. (Section 21 of Republic Act [RA] No. 1012138 and Rule 18, Section 1 of its IRR). Declare AO inoperative in its entirety for non-provision or insufficient provision of LDRRMF. Cite as condition if provision of QRF is more or less than thirty percent (30%).39 LDRRMF Regular Income (Budget Year) Multiply by 5% x 5% Minimum Requirement Less: Appropriations Deficiency/(Allowable appropriation over minimum requirement) Total Appropriations - LDRRMF 38 An Act Strengthening the Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and Management System, Providing for the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Framework and Institutionalizing the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Plan, Appropriating Funds Therefor and for Other Purposes 39 Of the amount appropriated for LDRRMF, thirty percent (30%) shall be allocated as Quick Response Fund (QRF) or stand-by fund for relief and recovery programs in order that situation and living conditions of people in communities or areas stricken by disasters, calamities, epidemics, or complex emergencies, may be normalized as quickly as possible. (Section 21 of RA No. 10121 and Rule 18, Section 2 of its IRR). 140 FINDINGS COMPLIANT? YES (1) NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) Appropriated for 70% LDRRMF Appropriated for 30% QRF II. GENERAL LIMITATIONS (Section 325 of the LGC and Article 420 of its IRR) a. The total appropriations, whether annual or supplemental, for Personal Services (PS) of an LGU for one (1) fiscal year shall not exceed forty-five percent (45%) in the case of first to third class provinces, cities, and municipalities, and fiftyfive percent (55%) in case of fourth class or lower, of the total annual income from regular sources realized in the next preceding fiscal year. The appropriations for salaries, wages, representation and transportation allowances of officials and employees of the public utilities and economic enterprises owned, operated, and maintained by the LGU concerned shall not be included in the annual budget or in the computation of the maximum amount for PS. The appropriations for the PS of such economic enterprises shall be charged to their respective budgets. Disallow amount in excess of the PS Limitation. Hence, declare AO inoperative in part. For the computation of the total PS cost for waived items and determination on PS Limitation compliance, the reviewing authority may refer to LBR Form Nos. 2A and 2B, respectively. b. No official or employee shall be entitled to a salary rate higher than the maximum fixed for his position or other positions of equivalent rank by applicable laws or rules and regulations issued thereunder. Disallow amount in excess of the prescribed salary rates for positions. Hence, declare AO inoperative in part. (Validation could be done through cross-checking of the list of positions in the LGU's Plantilla of Personnel [POP] and the Index of Occupational Services, Position Titles, and Salary Grades in the Local Government [IOS-LGU], CY 2021 Edition pursuant to Local Budget Circular [LBC] No. 137 dated July 13, 2021).40 c. No local fund shall be appropriated to increase or adjust salaries or wages of officials and employees of the national government, except as may be expressly authorized by law. d. In cases of abolition of positions and the creation of new ones resulting from the abolition of existing positions in the career service, such abolition or creation shall be made in accordance with pertinent provisions of the LGC and civil service laws, rules, and regulations. 40 Disallow appropriation except those expressly authorized by law. Hence, declare AO inoperative in part. Cite as condition if noncompliant Index of Occupational Services, Position Titles and Salary Grades in the Local Government (IOS-LGU), CY 2021 Edition 141 COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) e. Positions in the official plantilla for career positions which are occupied by incumbents holding permanent appointments shall be covered by adequate appropriations. f. NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) Cite as condition if noncompliant No changes in designation or nomenclature of positions resulting in a promotion or demotion in rank, or increase or decrease in compensation shall be allowed, except when the position is actually vacant, and the filling of such positions shall be strictly made in accordance with civil service law, rules and regulations. If non-compliant, disallow and declare AO inoperative in part. g. The creation of new positions and salary increase or adjustments shall in no case be made retroactive. Cite as condition if noncompliant h. The annual appropriations for discretionary purposes of the Local Chief Executive (LCE) shall not exceed two percent (2%) of the actual receipts derived from basic real property tax in the next preceding calendar year. Discretionary funds shall be disbursed only for public purposes to be supported by appropriate vouchers and subject to such guidelines as may be prescribed by law. No amount shall be appropriated for the same purpose except as authorized in Section 325 of the LGC. Declare the AO inoperative in part if appropriation is in excess of the amount allowed by the LGC. Discretionary Expenses Actual receipts derived from basic real property tax in the next preceding year* Multiply by 2% x 2% Maximum Allowable Amount Appropriations Balance/(Excess Appropriation) *Next preceding fiscal year refers to two (2) years prior to the budget year. 142 COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) III. 20% of the National Tax Allotment for Development Projects (Section 287 of the LGC) Each LGU shall appropriate in its annual budget no less than twenty percent (20%) of its annual National Tax Allotment (NTA) for development projects pursuant to Section 287 of the LGC. Appropriation for development projects shall be itemized in the budget (Department of Budget and Management [DBM]Department of Finance [DOF]-Department of the Interior and Local Government [DILG] Joint Memorandum Circular [JMC] No. 1 dated November 4, 2020).41 NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) Declare AO inoperative in its entirety for non-provision or insufficient provision of the 20% DF. 20% Development Fund (DF) Allocation Total NTA Multiply by 20% P x Minimum Requirement Less: Appropriations P P Deficiency/(Allowable appropriation over minimum requirement) P 20% Items not allowed to be charged against the 20% DF (DBMDOF-DILG JMC No. 1, s. 2020): Disallow items included in the negative list 1. PS expenditures, such as salaries, wages, overtime pay, and other personnel benefits; 2. Administrative expenses, such as supplies, meals, representation, communication, water and electricity, petroleum products, and the like; 3. Travelling expenses, whether domestic or foreign; 4. Registration fees and other expenses related to the conduct of and participation to trainings, seminars, conferences or conventions; 5. Purchase, maintenance, or repair of administrative office furniture, fixtures, equipment or appliances; and 6. Purchase, maintenance, or repair of motor vehicles used for administrative purposes. 41 Revised Guidelines on the Appropriation and Utilization of the Twenty Percent (20%) of the Annual Internal Revenue Allotment for Development Projects 143 COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) IV. Budgetary Requirements by Attribution NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) The following are budgetary requirements for specific sectors or concerns as prescribed by pertinent laws, rules and regulations that shall be included in the LGUs' annual appropriations as contained in their respective local development plans and integrated in the corresponding Annual Investment Programs (AIPs). The same may be provided in the annual appropriations as direct appropriation and/or by attribution: 1. Gender and Development Budget (RA No. 7192,42 RA No. 9710;43 Philippine Commission on Women [PCW]DILG-DBM-National Economic Development Authority [NEDA] JMC No. 2013-01,44 as amended by PCW-DILGDBM-NEDA JMC No. 2016-01 dated January 12, 2016)45 Cite as condition LGUs shall formulate their annual Gender and Development (GAD) Plans and Budgets (GPBs) within the context of their mandates to ensure gender mainstreaming in their policies, programs and projects. GAD planning and budgeting shall be integrated in the regular activities of the LGUs, the cost of implementation of which shall be at least five percent (5%) of their total annual budgets. At least five percent (5%) of the total LGU budget appropriations authorized under the annual budget shall correspond to activities supporting GAD programs, projects, and activities (PPAs). The GAD budget shall be drawn from the LGU’s PS, Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses, and Capital Outlay. The five percent (5%) GAD budget shall endeavor to influence the remaining 95% of the LGU budget toward genderresponsiveness. GAD Budget Total Appropriations Multiply by 5% x 5% Minimum Requirement GAD Budget Deficiency/(Allowable appropriations over minimum requirement 42 An Act Promoting the Integration of Women as Full and Equal Partners of Men in Development and Nation Building and for Other Purposes 43 An Act Providing for the Magna Carta of Women 44 Guidelines on the Localization of the Magna Carta of Women 45 Amendments to PCW-DILG-DBM-NEDA JMC No. 2013-01: Guidelines on the Localization of the Magna Carta of Women 144 COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) 2. Local Council for the Protection of Children NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) Cite as condition One percent (1%) of the NTA of barangays, municipalities, and cities shall be allocated for the strengthening and implementation of the programs of the Local Council for the Protection of Children (Section 15 of RA No. 9344).46 Total NTA Multiply by 1% P x 1% Total Requirement Less: Appropriations Excess/(Deficiency) 3. Programs, projects, activities and services that will address Cite as observation the needs of senior citizens (RA No. 7432,47 as amended by RA No. 999448 and RA No. 7876)49 and differently-abled persons (RA No. 7277,50 as amended by RA Nos. 944251 and 10070,52 and Batas Pambansa Blg. 344)53 Total appropriations for Senior Citizens P Total appropriations for Differently-abled P 4. Community-based Human Immunodeficiency Virus/ Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (HIV/AIDS) prevention and care services (RA No. 11166)54 Total appropriations for PPAs to combat HIV/AIDS Cite as observation P 46 An Act Establishing a Comprehensive Juvenile Justice and Welfare System, Creating the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council under the Department of Justice, Appropriating Funds Therefor and for Other Purposes 47 An Act to Maximize the Contribution of Senior Citizens to Nation Building, Grant Benefits and Special Privileges and for Other Purposes 48 An Act Granting Additional Benefits and Privileges to Senior Citizens, Further Amending Republic Act No. 7432, as amended, otherwise known as “An Act to Maximize the Contribution of Senior Citizens to Nation Building, Grant Benefits and Special Privileges and for Other Purposes” 49 An Act Establishing a Senior Citizens Center in All Cities and Municipalities of the Philippines, and Appropriating Funds Therefor 50 An Act Providing for the Rehabilitation, Self-Development and Self-Reliance of Disabled Person and their Integration into the Mainstream of Society and for Other Purposes 51 An Act Amending Republic Act No. 7277, Otherwise Known as the “Magna Carta for Disabled Persons, and for Other Purposes” 52 Establishing Institutional Mechanism to Ensure the Implementation of Programs and Services for Persons with Disabilities in Every Province, City and Municipality, Amending Republic Act No. 7277, Otherwise Known as the Magna Carta for Disabled Persons, as amended, and for Other Purposes 53 An Act to Enhance the Mobility of Disabled Persons by Requiring Certain Buildings, Institutions, Establishments and Public Utilities to Install Facilities and Other Devices 54 An Act Strengthening the Philippine Comprehensive Policy on Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) And Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) Prevention, Treatment, Care, and Support, and, Reconstituting the Philippine National Aids Council (PNAC), Repealing for the Purpose Republic Act No. 8504, Otherwise Known as the "Philippine Aids Prevention and Control Act of 1998", and Appropriating Funds Therefor 145 COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) 5. Programs, projects, and activities to address the Problem of Illegal Drugs (Section 51 of RA No. 916555 and its IRR) Total appropriations for PPAs to address problem of Illegal Drugs NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) Cite as observation P V. Compliance with Other Applicable Laws, Rules and Regulations 1. Plan-Budget Linkage Local budgets shall operationalize approved development plans (Section 305 [i] of the LGC). local a. The LGU has an approved AIP. Declare AO inoperative in its entirety if the AIP is not approved/ adopted by the sanggunian before the enactment of the AO. b. All PPAs in the AO are included/listed in the AIP. Declare AO inoperative in its entirety when all the PPAs included in the AO are different from those listed in the AIP. Declare AO inoperative in part when some PPAs not included in the approved AIP are funded under the annual budget/ supplemental budget. 2. Confidential Fund The Confidential Fund (CF) shall not exceed thirty percent (30%) of the total annual amount allocated for the LGU’s Peace and Order Program pursuant to Section 5.1.3.1 of Commission on Audit (COA)-DBM-DILG-Government Commission for GOCCs (GCG)-Department of National Defense (DND) Joint Circular (JC) No. 2015-01 dated January 8, 2015.56 Total Budget for Peace and Order Programs Multiply by 30% P x Maximum Allowable Amount P Declare AO inoperative in part when appropriation is in excess of the amount prescribed. 30% 55 An Act Instituting the Comprehensive Dangerous Drugs Act of 2002, Repealing Republic Act No. 6425, Otherwise Known as the Dangerous Drugs Act of 1972, as amended, Providing Funds Therefor, and for Other Purposes 56 Guidelines on the Entitlement, Release, Use, Reporting and Audit of Confidential and/or Intelligence Funds 146 COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) Less: Appropriations for CF P Balance/(Excess Appropriation) P NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) 3. Monthly cash subsidy for Solo Parents (RA No. 8972,57 as amended by RA No. 11861)58 Cite as condition 4. Share from National Taxes Cite as condition The proceeds from the share of LGU’s from national taxes shall be appropriated and utilized for PPAs in accordance with pertinent laws, rules and regulations: a. Share in Tobacco Excise Tax pursuant to RA No. 7171,59 as incorporated in RA No. 8424,60 as amended by RA No. 1134661 (Virginia Tobacco); P ____________ b. Share in Tobacco Excise Tax pursuant to RA No. 8240,62 as amended by RA No. 10351,63 and as further amended by RA No. 11346 (Burley and Native Tobacco Products); P ____________ c. Share in the proceeds from the utilization and development national wealth under Sections 289 and 290 of the LGC and RA No. 9513;64 P ____________ d. Share in the Gross Income Taxes Paid by All Businesses and Enterprises within the Special Economic Zones pursuant to RA No. 7922,65 as P ____________ 57 An Act Providing for Benefits and Privileges to Solo Parents and their Children, Appropriating Funds Therefor and for Other Purposes 58 An Act Granting Additional Benefits to Solo Parents, amending for the Purpose Republic Act No. 8972, entitled “An Act Providing for Benefits and Privileges to Solo Parents and their Children, Appropriating Funds Therefor and for Other Purposes 59 An Act to Promote the Development of the Farmer in the Virginia Tobacco Producing Provinces 60 An Act Amending the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended, and for Other Purposes 61 An Act Increasing the Excise Tax on Tobacco Products, Imposing Excise Tax on Heated Tobacco Products and Vapor Products, Increasing the Penalties for Violations of Provisions on Articles Subject to Excise Tax, and Earmarking a Portion of the Total Excise Tax Collection from Sugar-Sweetened Beverages, Alcohol, Tobacco, Heated Tobacco and Vapor Products for Universal Health Care, amending for this Purpose Sections 144, 145, 146, 147, 152, 164, 260, 262, 263, 265, 288, And 289, Repealing Section 288(B) and 288(C), and Creating New Sections 263-A, 265-B, and 288-A of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended by Republic Act No. 10963, and for Other Purposes 62 An Act Amending Sections 138, 140, & 142 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended, and for Other Purposes 63 An Act Restructuring the Excise Tax on Alcohol and Tobacco Products by Amending Sections 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 8, 131 and 288 of Republic Act No. 8424. Otherwise Known as the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended by Republic Act No. 9334, and for Other Purposes 64 An Act Promoting the Development, Utilization and Commercialization of Renewable Energy Resources and for Other Purposes 65 An Act Establishing a Special Economic Zone and Free Port in the Municipality of Santa Ana and the Neighboring Islands in the Municipality of Aparri, Province of Cagayan, Providing Funds Therefor, and For Other Purposes 147 COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) amended by RA No. 9400,66 and RA No. 8748;67 NO (2) e. Share in Value-Added Tax (VAT) pursuant to RA No. 7643;68 P ____________ f. Share in VAT in lieu of Franchise Tax pursuant to RA No. 795369 and RA No. 8407;70 P ____________ g. Share in two percent (2%) Special Privilege Tax (MiniHydroelectric) pursuant to RA No. 7156;71 and P ____________ h. Others (please specify). P ____________ RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) 5. The appropriation for Donations shall be spent solely for public purpose pursuant to Sections 305 (b), 335 and 351 of the LGC. Cite as condition 6. The purchase and specifications of the motor vehicle shall be subject to the provisions of Administrative Order No. 14 dated December 10, 201872 and Budget Circular (BC) No. 2022-1 dated February 11, 2022,73 and BC No. 2022-1A dated March 1, 2023.74 Cite as condition 7. Prohibition Against Expenses for Reception Entertainment (Section 343 of the LGC) Cite as condition and No money shall be appropriated, used, or paid for entertainment or reception except to the extent of the representation allowances authorized by law or for the reception of visiting dignitaries of foreign governments or foreign missions, or when expressly authorized by the President in specific cases. 66 An Act Amending Republic Act No. 7227, as amended, Otherwise Known as the Bases Conversion and Development Act of 1992, and for Other Purposes 67 An Act Amending Republic Act No. 7916, Otherwise Known as the “Special Economic Zone Act of 1995” 68 An Act to Empower the Commissioner of Internal Revenue to Require the Payment of the Value-Added Tax Every Month and to Allow Local Government Units to Share in VAT Revenue, Amending for this Purpose Certain Sections of the National Internal Revenue Code 69 An Act Amending Republic Act Numbered Sixty-Six Hundred Thirty-Two Entitled ‘An Act Granting the Philippine Racing Club, Inc., a Franchise to Operate and Maintain a Race Track for Horse Racing in the Province of Rizal’, and Extending the Said Franchise by Twenty-Five Years from the Expiration of the Term Thereof 70 An Act Amending Republic Act Numbered Sixty-Six Hundred Thirty-One Entitled "An Act Granting Manila Jockey Club, Inc., a Franchise to Construct, Operate and Maintain a Racetrack for Horse Racing in the City of Manila or Any Place within the Provinces of Bulacan, Cavite or Rizal" and Extending the Said Franchise by Twenty-Five Years (25) from the Expiration of the Term Thereof 71 An Act Granting Incentives to Mini-Hydroelectric Power Developers and for Other Purposes 72 Consolidating and Rationalizing the Rules on the Acquisition of Government Motor Vehicles, Adopting a Centralized System of Procurement Therefor, and for Other Purposes 73 Omnibus Guidelines on the Acquisition, Use, Rental, and Replacement of Government Motor Vehicles 74 Supplemental Guidelines on the Acquisition, Use, Rental, and Replacement of Government Motor Vehicles 148 FINDINGS (1) COMPLIANT? YES NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) 8. The grant of Terminal Leave Benefits and Monetization of Leave Credits shall be in accordance with CSC Omnibus Rules on Leave pursuant to CSC Memorandum Circular No. 41, s. 1998,75 BC No. 2013-1 dated April 12, 2013,76 and BC No. 2016-2 dated March 29, 2016.77 Cite as condition 9. Magna Carta Benefits of Public Health Workers Cite as condition Appropriations for Magna Carta Benefits of Public Health Workers shall be in accordance with DBM-Department of Health (DOH) JC No. 1 dated November 29, 2012,78 as amended by DBM-DOH JC No. 1 dated July 15, 2016.79 10. Magna Carta Benefits of Public Social Workers Cite as condition Appropriations for Magna Carta Benefits of Public Social Workers shall be in accordance with DBM-Department of Social Welfare and Development JC No. 1 dated December 27, 2018.80 11. Appropriation for wages - Casual/ Contractual Cite as condition The appropriation for wages - Casual/Contractual shall be subject to pertinent budgeting, accounting, and auditing rules and regulations, and to the following provisions of CSC's 2017 Omnibus Rules on Appointments and Other Human Resource Actions, as follows: 1. Employees under contractual or casual appointment are entitled to the same benefits enjoyed by regular employees; and 2. In no case shall a casual appointment be issued to fill a vacant plantilla position or a casual employee perform the duties and responsibilities of the vacant plantilla position. 12. The appropriation for Honoraria shall be spent in accordance with BC Nos. 2007-1 dated April 23, 200781 and 2007-2 dated October 1, 2007,82 as may be applicable. Cite as condition 75 Amendments to Rules I and XVI of the Omnibus Rules Implementing Book V of the Administrative Code of 1987 (Executive Order 292) 76 Guidelines Prescribing the Documentary Requirements and Procedures in Processing/Payment of Retirement Benefits of Government Employees 77 Computation and Funding of Terminal Leave Benefits and Monetization of Leave Credits 78 Rules and Regulation on the Grant of Compensation-Related Magna Carta Benefits to Public Health Workers (PHWs) 79 Amendment to DBM-DOH Joint Circular No. 1 s. 2012 Regarding the Rules and Regulations on the Grant of CompensationRelated Magna Carta Benefits to Public Health Workers (PHWs) 80 Rules and Regulations on the Grant of Compensation-Related Magna Carta Benefits to Public Social Workers (PSWs) 81 Guidelines on the Grant of Honoraria to Lecturers, Resource Persons, Coordinators and Facilitators 82 Guidelines on the Grant of Honoraria Due to Assignment in Government Special Projects 149 FINDINGS (1) 13. Night Shift Differential shall be in accordance with RA No. 11701,83 item 6.0 of DOH-DBM JC No. 1 dated November 29, 2012, and CSC-DBM-GCG Joint Circular No. 1 dated August 1, 2023. COMPLIANT? YES NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) Cite as condition 14. Overtime Pay shall be pursuant to CSC-DBM JC No. 2 dated November 25, 2015.84 Cite as condition 15. Personnel Economic Relief Allowance shall be pursuant to BC Nos. 2009-3 dated August 18, 2009,85 and 2011-2 dated September 26, 2011.86 Cite as condition 16. Representation and Transportation Allowance shall be pursuant to LBC No. 103 dated May 15, 2013,87 the specific rates per position is indicated in Annex B of the same LBC. Cite as condition 17. Uniform/Clothing Allowance shall be pursuant to BC No. 2018-1 dated March 8, 2018,88 and the pertinent general provision in the annual General Appropriations Act. Cite as condition 18. Productivity Enhancement Incentive shall be pursuant to Item 6.0 of BC No. 2017-4 dated December 4, 201789 – not exceeding P5,000. Cite as condition 19. Anniversary Bonus shall be pursuant to LBC No. 65 dated March 3, 199790 - not exceeding P3,000 for every milestone year Cite as condition 20. Loyalty Pay shall be pursuant to CSC MC No. 6 dated March 1, 200291 - P10,000 for the first ten (10) years in government service and P5,000 for the succeeding every five (5) years thereafter. Cite as condition 21. Mid-Year Bonus shall be pursuant to BC No. 2017-2 dated May 8, 201792 and BC No. 2019-4 dated July 5, 201993 equivalent to one (1) month basic pay. Cite as condition 83 An Act Granting Night Shift Differential Pay to Government Employees Including those in Government-Owned or -Controlled Corporations and Appropriating Funds Therefor 84 Policies and Guidelines on Overtime Services and Overtime Pay for Government Employees 85 Rules and Regulations on the Grant of the Personnel Economic Relief Allowance at P2,000 per Month 86 Amendatory Rules on the Grant of the Personnel Economic Relief Allowance (PERA) 87 Amended Rules and Regulations on the Grant of Representation and Transportation Allowances 88 Rules and Regulations on the Grant of Uniform/Clothing Allowance (U/CA) to Civilian Government Personnel 89 Guidelines on the Grant of the Productivity Enhancement Incentive (PEI) to Government Employees for Fiscal Year (FY) 2017 and Years Thereafter 90 Guidelines on the Grant of Anniversary Bonus in the Local Government 91 Revised Policies on the Grant of Loyalty Award 92 Rules and Regulations on the Grant of the Mid-Year Bonus for FY 2017 and Years Thereafter 93 Clarification on the Grant of Mid-Year Bonus to Government Employees on Scholarship 150 FINDINGS (1) 22. Position Titles and Classifications COMPLIANT? YES NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) Cite as condition Pursuant to Manual on Position Compensation and Classification as prescribed under Circular Letter No. 2007-6 dated February 19, 2007,94 in classifying positions, LGUs shall be guided by the IOS-LGU under LBC No. 137 dated July 13, 2021. All positions in the LGUs shall be allocated to their proper position titles and salary grades in accordance with the IOS-LGU. 23. Other relevant policies, rules, and regulations Cite as condition Cite as condition VI. Review of Annual Operating Budget of Local Economic Enterprise/s (Sections 313 [a] and 325 of the LGC) 1. The LGU maintains a special account in the General Fund (GF) for the LEE. 2. Salaries, wages, representation, and transportation allowances of LEE officials and employees shall not be included in the annual or supplemental budget in the computation of the maximum amount for PS of the LGU. 3. The appropriations for PS of LEEs shall be charged to their respective budgets. 4. LEE official or employee is not allowed a salary rate higher than the maximum fixed for the position or other positions of equivalent rank. 5. Each LEE has its own separate AOB. 6. PPAs of LEE is included in the AIP. 7. The profits or income derived from the operation of LEE are applied as follows: a. The costs of improvement, repair, and other related expenses of the LEE shall be deducted from the income from the operation of the said LEE; b. The balance thereof shall first be applied for the return of advances or loans made; and c. Any excess shall form part of the GF of LGU. 94 Manual on Position Classification and Compensation 151 COMPLIANT? FINDINGS YES (1) NO (2) RECOMMENDED REVIEW ACTIONS (3) 8. The AOB of each LEE is presented separately in the LEP which shall be included for enactment by the sanggunian. 9. Compliance regulations. to other applicable laws, rules, and OVERALL REVIEW ACTION The Appropriation Ordinance is operative in its entirety. The Appropriation Ordinance is operative in its entirety, subject to conditions The Appropriation Ordinance is inoperative in its entirety. The Appropriation Ordinance is inoperative in part. Prepared by: Reviewed by: Approved by: ______________________ ______________________ ______________________ Instructions: A. The Local Budget Review (LBR) Form No. 2 (Summary of Findings and Recommended Review Actions) shall be prepared by the Reviewing Officer. B. LBR Form No. 2 is intended to reflect the following: Column 1 – The findings shall indicate the relevant existing laws, rules, and regulations applicable to the budget in review. Column 2 – Check the appropriate box whether or not the LGU has complied with the requirements specified in Column 1. Column 3 – Indicate the recommended review actions. 152 LBR Form No. 2A TOTAL PERSONAL SERVICES (PS) COST FOR WAIVED ITEMS Local Government Unit: _________________ (a) Cost of hospital services transferred from the Province of _________ to the City of _________________: Salaries Step Increments Personnel Economic Relief Allowance Uniform/Clothing Allowance Representation and Transportation Allowances Mid-Year Bonus Productivity Enhancement Incentive Year-End Bonus and Cash Gift Magna Carta Benefits of Public Health Workers (itemized per kind of allowance/benefit) Magna Carta Benefits of Public Social Workers (itemized per kind of allowance/benefit) ECC Contributions PHILHEALTH Contributions PAG-IBIG Contributions Retirement and Life Insurance Contributions Other Personnel Benefits Sub-Total (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) Retirement Gratuity Terminal Leave Benefits Monetization of Leave Credits Special benefits authorized to be granted to LGU personnel during emergency situations Salaries and Benefits of Health/Medical personnel that may be hired to perform functions related to emergency situations Salary Differentials of LGU hired Public Health Workers Sub-Total Total PS Cost for Waived Items Prepared by: Reviewed by: Approved by: _____________________ _________________ ________________ Note: The list of waived items shall be based on the General Provision of the applicable General Appropriations Act and the corresponding guidelines to be issued for the purpose. 153 LBR Form No. 2B* DETERMINATION ON PERSONAL SERVICES (PS) LIMITATION COMPLIANCE Local Government Unit: _______________________ A. Total Income from Regular Sources (TIRS) realized in the next preceding fiscal year B. PS Limitation (45% or 55% of TIRS) Salaries of existing permanent positions Salaries of existing temporary, contractual and casual positions Step Increments Personnel Economic Relief Allowance Uniform/Clothing Allowance Representation and Transportation Allowances Mid-Year Bonus Productivity Enhancement Incentive Year-End Bonus and Cash Gift Magna Carta Benefits of Public Health Workers (itemized per kind of allowance/benefit) Magna Carta Benefits of Public Social Workers (itemized per kind of allowance/benefit) Monetization of Leave Credits Other legally authorized allowances/benefits ECC Contributions PHILHEALTH Contributions PAG-IBIG Contributions Retirement and Life Insurance Contributions Retirement Gratuity Terminal Leave Benefits C. Total Annual PS Budget D. Less: Total PS Cost for Waived Items (from LBR Form No. 2A) E. Difference: Total Annual PS Budget, Net of Waived Items (E = C – D) F. Additional Allowable PS Budget or Excess Over the PS Limitation (F = B – E) Prepared by: Reviewed by: Approved by: _____________________ _________________ ________________ Note: Local Budget Review Form No. 2B is based on Annex B of Local Budget Circular No. 145 dated March 2, 2022. __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 154 3.7 Illustrative Examples Review Letter Declaring the Appropriation Ordinance Operative in its Entirety* ________ Date The Honorable Members of the Sanggunian Province/City/Municipality of ________ Thru: The Provincial Governor/City/Municipal Mayor Ladies/Gentlemen: Pursuant to the provisions of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC), our review of the FY 2024 Annual/Supplemental Budget No. ___ (General Fund/Local Economic Enterprise, a special account under the General Fund) of the Province/City/Municipality of ____________, involving a total appropriation of P_________ under Appropriation Ordinance No. ______, submitted to this Office for review on ________, reveals substantial compliance with the same law and its Implementing Rules and Regulations and other applicable laws, rules and regulations. Accordingly, the said Appropriation Ordinance is declared operative in its entirety effective on _______________, subject to the posting requirement under Section 59 of the LGC. Further, please be reminded of Section 56 in relation with Sections 326 and 327 of the LGC which provides that within three (3) days after approval of the Ordinance authorizing annual or supplemental appropriations, the Secretary to the Sanggunian shall forward the said Ordinance to the appropriate reviewing authority. (state as may be applicable) It is understood that this review action does not authorize any item of appropriation that is specifically prohibited by or inconsistent with the provisions of law. Compliance with all existing laws, rules, and regulations shall be the responsibility of the province/city/municipality. Very truly yours, By Authority of the Secretary of Budget and Management: ________________ Director IV __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 155 Review Letter Declaring the Appropriation Ordinance Operative in its Entirety, Subject to Conditions _________ Date The Honorable Members of the Sanggunian Province/City/Municipality of ________ Thru: The Provincial Governor/City/Municipal Mayor Ladies/Gentlemen: Pursuant to the provisions of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC), our review of the FY 2024 Annual/Supplemental Budget No. ___ (General Fund / Local Economic Enterprise, a special account under the General Fund) of the Province/City/Municipality of __________, involving an appropriation of P___________ under Appropriation Ordinance No. ______, submitted to this Office for review on ________, reveals substantial compliance with the same law and its Implementing Rules and Regulations and other applicable laws rules and regulations, except for the following: 1. 2. Notwithstanding the above, the Appropriation Ordinance is declared operative in its entirety effective on _________, subject to the posting requirement under Section 59 of the LGC, and further subject to the following condition/s: 1. 2. Further, please be reminded of Section 56 in relation with Sections 326 and 327 of the LGC which provides that within three (3) days after approval of the Ordinance authorizing annual or supplemental appropriations, the Secretary to the Sanggunian shall forward the said Ordinance to the appropriate reviewing authority. (state as may be applicable) It is understood that this review action does not authorize any item of appropriation that is specifically prohibited by or inconsistent with the provisions of law. Compliance with all existing laws, rules and regulations shall be the responsibility of the province/city/municipality. Very truly yours, By Authority of the Secretary of Budget and Management: _______________ Director IV 156 Review Letter Declaring the Appropriation Ordinance Inoperative in its Entirety _________ Date The Honorable Members of the Sanggunian Province/City/Municipality of ________ Thru: The Provincial Governor/City/Municipal Mayor Ladies/Gentlemen: Pursuant to the provisions of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC) and other applicable laws, rules and regulations, our review of the FY 2024 Annual/Supplemental Budget No. ___ (General Fund/Local Economic Enterprise, a special account under the General Fund) of the Province/City/Municipality of __________, involving an appropriation of P___________ under Appropriation Ordinance No. ______, submitted to this Office for review on ________, shows that it has not complied with the budgetary requirements and general limitations as well as other provisions of law as enumerated hereunder: 1. 2. In view thereof, the said Appropriation Ordinance is declared inoperative in its entirety effective immediately. Consequently, the previous year’s budget is deemed reenacted pending the submission of a new Ordinance authorizing the annual appropriations, taking into account the above-mentioned findings. Nevertheless, it is understood that, in the implementation of the reenacted budget, only the annual appropriation for salaries and wages of existing positions, statutory and contractual obligations and essential operating expenses authorized in the annual and supplemental budgets for the preceding year shall be deemed reenacted in accordance with Section 323 of the LGC. Further, please be reminded of Section 56 in relation with Sections 326 and 327 of the LGC which provides that within three (3) days after approval of the Ordinance authorizing annual or supplemental appropriations, the Secretary to the Sanggunian shall forward the said Ordinance to the appropriate reviewing authority. (state as may be applicable) Very truly yours, By Authority of the Secretary of Budget and Management: _______________ Director IV 157 Review Letter Declaring the Appropriation Ordinance Inoperative in Part _________ Date The Honorable Members of the Sanggunian Province/City/Municipality of ________ Thru: The Provincial Governor/City/Municipal Mayor Ladies/Gentlemen: Pursuant to the provisions of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC), our review of the FY 2024 Annual/Supplemental Budget No. ___ (General Fund/ Local Economic Enterprise, a special account under the General Fund) of the Province/City/Municipality of __________, involving an appropriation of P___________ under Appropriation Ordinance No. ______, submitted to this Office for review on ________, reveals substantial compliance with the same law and its Implementing Rules and Regulations and other applicable laws rules and regulations, except for the following items of appropriation which are hereby disallowed in the total amount of P________: 1. 2. In view of the above, the budget is declared inoperative in part effective on ______, subject to the posting requirements under Section 59 of the LGC. Further, please be reminded of Section 56 in relation with Sections 326 and 327 of the LGC which provides that within three (3) days after approval of the Ordinance authorizing annual or supplemental appropriations, the Secretary to the Sanggunian shall forward the said Ordinance to the appropriate reviewing authority. (state as may be applicable) It is understood that this review action does not authorize any item of appropriation that is specifically prohibited by or inconsistent with the provisions of law. Compliance with all existing laws, rules and regulations shall be the responsibility of the province/city/municipality. Very truly yours, By Authority of the Secretary of Budget and Management: ______________________ Director IV 158 Resolution Declaring the Appropriation Ordinance Operative in its Entirety Resolution No. _______ A RESOLUTION DECLARING THE APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE NO. _____ OF THE CITY/MUNICIPALITY OF __________________ OPERATIVE IN ITS ENTIRETY WHEREAS, Appropriation Ordinance No. ____ of the City/Municipality of ______ authorizing its Annual Budget for Fiscal Year _____, involving an appropriation of P________, was submitted to this Sanggunian for review on ______ pursuant to the provisions of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC); WHEREAS, the subject Appropriation Ordinance shows substantial compliance with the same law and its Implementing Rules and Regulations; NOW, THEREFORE, on motion of SP Member ________duly seconded by SP Member ____; THE SANGGUNIANG PANLALAWIGAN IN SESSION DULY ASSEMBLED: RESOLVED, to declare Appropriation Ordinance No. ____ of the City/Municipality of _________ OPERATIVE IN ITS ENTIRETY, effective _________, subject to the posting requirements under Section 59 of the LGC. RESOLVED FURTHER, to inform the City/Municipality that this review action does not authorize any item of appropriation that is specifically prohibited by or inconsistent with the provisions of law. RESOLVED FINALLY, to send a copy of this Resolution to the Sangguniang Panlungsod/Bayan of the City/Municipality of ___________ through the City/Municipal Mayor. ADOPTED. (Date) . x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x We hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and accurate copy of the Resolution which was duly adopted by the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of _______ during its Regular Session held on ___________. ________________________ Secretary to the Sanggunian ________________ Presiding Officer 159 Resolution Declaring the Appropriation Ordinance Operative in its Entirety, Subject to Conditions Resolution No. _______ A RESOLUTION DECLARING THE APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE NO. _____ OF THE CITY/MUNICIPALITY OF __________________ OPERATIVE IN ITS ENTIRETY, SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS WHEREAS, Appropriation Ordinance No. ____ of the City/Municipality of ______ authorizing its Annual Budget for Fiscal Year _____, involving an appropriation of P_________, was submitted to this Sanggunian for review on ________ pursuant to the provisions of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC); WHEREAS, the subject Appropriation Ordinance reveals substantial compliance with the same law and its Implementing Rules and Regulations except for the following: 1. 2. NOW, THEREFORE, on motion of SP Member ________ duly seconded by SP Member _______; THE SANGGUNIANG PANLALAWIGAN IN SESSION DULY ASSEMBLED: RESOLVED, to declare Appropriation Ordinance No. ____ of the City/Municipality of ________ OPERATIVE IN ITS ENTIRETY, effective _________, subject to the posting requirements under Section 59 of the LGC, and subject to the following conditions: 1. 2. RESOLVED FURTHER, to inform the City/Municipality that this review action does not authorize any item of appropriation that is specifically prohibited by or inconsistent with the provisions of law. RESOLVED FINALLY, to send a copy of this Resolution to the Sangguniang Panlungsod/Bayan of the City/Municipality of ___________ through the City/Municipal Mayor. ADOPTED. (Date) . x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x We hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and accurate copy of the Resolution which was duly adopted by the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of _______ during its Regular Session held on ___________. ________________________ Secretary to the Sanggunian ________________ Presiding Officer 160 Resolution Declaring the Appropriation Ordinance Inoperative in its Entirety Resolution No. _______ A RESOLUTION DECLARING THE APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE NO. _____ OF THE CITY/MUNICIPALITY OF ________________ INOPERATIVE IN ITS ENTIRETY WHEREAS, Appropriation Ordinance No. ____ of the City/Municipality of ______ authorizing its Annual Budget for Fiscal Year _____, involving an appropriation of P_________, was submitted to this Sanggunian for review on ________ pursuant to the provisions of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC); WHEREAS, the subject Appropriation Ordinance has not complied with the budgetary requirements and general limitations as well as other provisions of law as enumerated hereunder: 1. 2. NOW, THEREFORE, on motion of SP Member ________ duly seconded by SP Member _______; THE SANGGUNIANG PANLALAWIGAN IN SESSION DULY ASSEMBLED: RESOLVED, to declare Appropriation Ordinance No. ____ of the City/Municipality of _________ INOPERATIVE ITS ENTIRETY, effective immediately. RESOLVED FURTHER, to inform the Sangguniang Panlungsod/Bayan of the City/Municipality of ________, through the City/Municipal Mayor, that the previous year’s budget is deemed reenacted pending the submission and enactment/approval of the new Ordinance authorizing the annual appropriations, taking into account the above-mentioned findings, and that, in the implementation of the reenacted budget, only the annual appropriation for salaries and wages of existing positions, statutory and contractual obligations, and essential operating expenses authorized in the annual and supplemental budgets for the preceding year shall be deemed reenacted. RESOLVED FINALLY, to send a copy of this Resolution to the Sangguniang Panlungsod/Bayan of the City/Municipality of ___________ through the City/Municipal Mayor. ADOPTED. (Date) . x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x We hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and accurate copy of the Resolution which was duly adopted by the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of _______ during its Regular Session held on ___________. ________________________ Secretary to the Sanggunian ________________ Presiding Officer 161 Resolution Declaring the Appropriation Ordinance Inoperative in Part Resolution No. _______ A RESOLUTION DECLARING THE APPROPRIATION ORDINANCE NO. _____ OF THE CITY/MUNICIPALITY OF __________________ INOPERATIVE IN PART WHEREAS, Appropriation Ordinance No. ____ of the City/Municipality of ______ authorizing its Annual Budget for Fiscal Year _____, involving an appropriation of P_________, was submitted to this Sanggunian for review on ________ pursuant to the provisions of Republic Act No. 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991 (LGC); WHEREAS, the subject Appropriation Ordinance has substantially complied with the budgetary requirements and general limitations as well as other provisions of law, except for the following items of appropriation which are hereby disallowed in the total amount of P________: 1. 2. NOW, THEREFORE, on motion of SP Member ________ duly seconded by SP Member _______; THE SANGGUNIANG PANLALAWIGAN IN SESSION DULY ASSEMBLED: RESOLVED, to declare Appropriation Ordinance No. ____ of the City/Municipality of _________ INOPERATIVE IN PART, effective _________, subject to the posting requirements under Section 59 of the LGC. RESOLVED FURTHER, to inform the City/Municipality that this review action does not authorize any item of appropriation that is specifically prohibited by or inconsistent with the provisions of law. RESOLVED FINALLY, to send a copy of this Resolution to the Sangguniang Panlungsod/Bayan of the City/Municipality of ___________ through the City/Municipal Mayor. ADOPTED. (Date) . x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x We hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and accurate copy of the Resolution which was duly adopted by the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of _______ during its Regular Session held on ___________. ________________________ Secretary to the Sanggunian ________________ Presiding Officer 162 3.8 Stamp of Review REVIEWED PURSUANT TO THE PROVISIONS OF REPUBLIC ACT NO. 7160 BY AUTHORITY OF THE SECRETARY OF BUDGET AND MANAGEMENT __________________ Director IV REFERENCE: REVIEW LETTER DATED: ___________ Seal of the Province REVIEWED PURSUANT TO THE PROVISIONS OF REPUBLIC ACT NO. 7160 BY AUTHORITY OF THE SANGGUNIANG PANLALAWIGAN __________________________________________________ (Authorized Signatory/ies per the Internal Rules of Procedure) REFERENCE: RESOLUTION NO. ______ DATED: ___________ 163 CHAPTER 4. THE BUDGET EXECUTION PHASE The execution of the budget in accordance with existing laws, rules, and regulations is the fourth phase of the budget process in local governments. After the usual recording of appropriations in the proper registries, the execution of the budget involves the release of allotments, the certification of available appropriations and cash, the recording of actual obligations and disbursements of funds for approved PPAs, and the delivery of goods and services to target clients in the most efficient, effective, economical, and ethical way. A critical aspect of this phase is the collection and/or receipt of revenues to ensure that cash is available for payment of obligations and for timely implementation of programs and projects. 4.1 Legal Bases of Budget Execution The fundamental principles governing all financial transactions in local governments are covered in Section 305 of the LGC. The responsibility, however, for the execution of annual and supplemental budgets shall be vested primarily in the LCE concerned (Section 320 of the LGC). The use of appropriated funds pursuant to Section 336 of the LGC shall be available exclusively for the specific purpose for which they have been appropriated. Another legal basis in the budget execution is the certification requirement under Section 344 of the LGC which provides that, “[n]o money shall be disbursed unless the local budget officer certifies to the existence of appropriation that has been legally made for the purpose, the local accountant has obligated said appropriation, and the local treasurer certifies to the availability of funds for the purpose.” Disbursements of local funds shall be made in accordance with the ordinance authorizing the annual or supplemental appropriations even without the prior approval of the sanggunian concerned (Section 346 of the LGC). In case of reenacted budget, Section 323 of the LGC states that, “[i]n the implementation of such reenacted ordinance, the local treasurer concerned shall exclude from the estimates of income for the preceding fiscal year those realized from nonrecurring sources, like national aids, proceeds from loans, sale of assets, prior year adjustments, and other analogous sources of income. No ordinance authorizing supplemental appropriations shall be passed in place of the annual appropriations.” 164 4.2 Key Players in Budget Execution Local Chief Executive - The LCE shall be responsible for the execution of the AO authorizing the annual budget and all subsequent supplemental budgets (Section 320 of the LGC). The Governor/Mayor is the HoPE (Section 5 [j] [iii] of RA No. 9184). Vice Governor/Vice Mayor - The Vice-LCE shall sign all warrants drawn on the provincial/city/municipal treasury for all expenditures appropriated for the operation of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan/Panlungsod/Bayan (Sections 466 [a] [1], 456 [a] [1], and 445 [a] [1] of the LGC). Likewise, he/she can sign appointments for officials and employees of the local sanggunian if their salaries are derived from the appropriation specifically for the said local legislative body (Ramon M. Atienza vs. Jose T. Villarosa, G.R. No. 161081, May 10, 2005). Local Budget Officer - The LBO shall be responsible for: (1) the preparation of release documents (Allotment Release Order [ARO]) for COE and CO; and (2) the certification on the availability of appropriations for obligation requests. The LBO shall coordinate with the Local Treasurer, Local Accountant, and the LPDC in the release of appropriations and allotments pursuant to Section 475 of the LGC. Local Treasurer- The Local Treasurer shall be responsible for the custody and proper management of the funds of the LGU concerned. He/she takes custody and exercise proper management of the local government funds, takes charge of the disbursement of all local government funds and such other funds the custody of which may be entrusted to him/her by law or other competent authority, and the maintenance and updating of the tax information system of the LGU (Section 470 of the LGC). The Local Treasurer also certifies as to the availability of funds prior to any disbursements and prepares the Cash Program for the LGU. Local Accountant – The Local Accountant shall be responsible for ensuring validity, reliability, and propriety of all financial transactions of the LGU concerned. The Local Accountant also reviews supporting documents before the preparation of vouchers to determine completeness of requirement (Section 474 of the LGC), and keeps and maintains the Books of Accounts pursuant to the New Government Accounting System (NGAS). The Local Accountant performs regular functions (e.g. pre-audit) because it is an inherent function of the accounting unit to ensure that disbursements are in compliance with laws, rules, and regulations that they are properly documented. Local Planning and Development Coordinator – The LPDC shall be responsible for the formulation of an integrated economic, social, physical, and other development plans and policies for consideration of the LDC; monitoring and evaluation of the implementation of the different development PPAs in the LGU concerned in accordance with the approved development plan; analysis of income and expenditure patterns; and formulation and recommendation of fiscal plans and policies for consideration of the LFC (Section 476 of the LGC). 165 Department Head – The Department Head shall be responsible for the preparation of financial and physical performance targets and obligation requests for authorized PPAs of the Department/Office concerned, implementation of PPAs to deliver goods and services to target clients, and monitoring and evaluation of actual performance of PPAs to ensure smooth and proper implementation. CSOs and the Private Sector Groups – The CSOs shall have the following roles in the budget execution phase as shown in Table 9 below: Table 9. Roles of CSOs in the Budget Execution Phase ACTIVITY 1. RELEASE ALLOTMENTS LGU ROLES CSO ROLES Post information on AROs in three (3) conspicuous places in the LGU within twenty (20) days from the release of the allotment. Monitor the LGU compliance on the release of allotments. Post information on receipts and expenditures in three (3) conspicuous places in the LGU within ten (10) days after the end of the month, and within twenty (20) days after the end of the first quarter as required under the Full 95 Disclosure Policy of the DILG. Monitor the postings as required under the LGC and the Full Disclosure Policy of the DILG. THE The ARO is issued to effect the comprehensive release allotment for a Department/ Office. Release of reserve amounts shall also be effected through the use of ARO/s. Inform beneficiaries and communities concerned of the release of allotments through tri-media or conduct meetings with the beneficiaries and communities concerned. 2. POST THE STATEMENT OF RECEIPTS AND EXPENDITURES IN THE LGU WEBSITE The LGU shall post the monthly Statement of Receipts and Expenditures within ten (10) days following the end of every month and for at least two (2) consecutive weeks. 95 Advocate for the citizen’s awareness of posted information through tri-media. DILG Memorandum Circular No. 2019-149 dated August 30, 2019 166 ACTIVITY 3. PREPARE CASH PROGRAM AND FINANCIAL AND PHYSICAL PERFORMANCE TARGETS LGU ROLES CSO ROLES The Local Treasurer shall prepare the Cash Program. The LFC/Department Heads shall prepare the Summary of Financial and Physical Performance Targets for the entire year. The detailed financial and performance targets present the quarterly breakdown of the financial allocation needed to accomplish a specific level of target. Post information on the Cash Program, and Financial and Physical Performance Targets in three (3) conspicuous places in the LGU within twenty (20) days after the end of each quarter as required under the Full Disclosure Policy of the DILG. Monitor the LGU compliance on the preparation of cash program and financial and physical performance targets. Invite accredited CSOs, if qualified as observers, in the procurement process at least five (5) calendar days before each procurement activities in compliance with Section 13.3 of the Revised IRR of RA No. 9184. Attend as observer in the procurement process and carry out the responsibilities provided under Section 13.4 of the Revised IRR of RA No. 9184. May use as reference the GPPB-issued 2014 Procurement Observers Guide. Inform beneficiaries and communities concerned of the information through trimedia or conduct meetings with the beneficiaries and communities concerned. 4. PROCURE, AND OBLIGATE AND DISBURSE FUNDS FOR PPA IMPLEMENTATION Procurement Process To enhance the transparency of the process, the BAC shall, in all stages of procurement process, invite, in addition to the representative of COA, at least two (2) observers to sit in its proceedings, one (1) from a duly recognized private group in a sector or discipline relevant to the procurement at hand. PPA Execution The responsibility for the Invite accredited May participate in the execution of the annual and CSOs to spot check monitoring of ongoing supplemental budget shall or track projects and prepare 167 ACTIVITY LGU ROLES be vested primarily in the implementation of LCE concerned. In the ongoing projects. implementation of PPAs, the following must be ensured: (This may be differentiated from the monitoring activity in Standards of service; the Budget Accountability Phase Quality of work; which is done on periods, Timeliness of scheduled i.e., quarterly, midimplementation; term and annual, and Pricing of goods, aimed at comparing contracts and services; accomplishments vs. targets.) PPA fund release/utilization; and Proper delivery to target beneficiaries. CSO ROLES Monitoring Report (Annex F of this Manual) for submission to the LCE. The CSO may check the following, among others: ● Standards of service; ● Quality of work; ● Timeliness of implementation; ● Pricing of goods, contracts, and services; ● PPA fund release/ utilization; and ● Proper delivery to target beneficiaries. May assist the LGU in undertaking appropriate interventions on negative deviations on PPA execution, which may include providing possible support for service and/or resource gaps in the delivery of services. May check the LGU compliance with the review action. 168 4.3 The Budget Execution Flowchart The flowchart in Figure 12 shows the sequence of activities in the budget execution phase. Figure 12. Budget Execution Flowchart 4.4 Budgetary Accounts in Budget Execution The budgetary accounts to be maintained during the budget execution process include the following: Appropriation: An authorization made by ordinance, directing the payment of goods and services from local government funds under specified conditions or purposes. Allotment: An authorization issued by the LCE to a Department/Office of the LGU which authorizes it to incur obligations for a specific amount within its appropriation. Obligation: The specific amount within the allotment which is committed to be paid by the LGU for any lawful expenditure made by an accountable officer for and in behalf of the LGU concerned. Disbursement: The settlement of obligations and/or accounts payable by cash, check, or other authorized modes of payment. 169 4.5 Steps in the Budget Execution Phase Step 1. Release of Allotments on the Basis of the Authorized and Approved Appropriation Ordinance 1. Record the AO in the Registries of Appropriation, Allotment, Obligations (RAAOs) for each expense class. 2. Prepare the AROs. On the basis of the authorized and approved AO, the following AROs shall be released by the LBOs: a. ARO for PS and Associated PS Costs (Local Budget Execution [LBE] Form No. 1) shall be issued (either comprehensively released for the whole year or quarterly, as applicable) to release the appropriations for salaries and wages of regular permanent positions and contractual and non-permanent positions. The itemized plantilla positions of contractual and non-permanent positions shall be used as basis for the release. This shall avoid the creation of lumpsum amounts for PS except for authorized salary increase pending issuance of pertinent guidelines. b. The allotment for MOOE shall also be released (either comprehensively for the whole year or quarterly, as applicable), using LBE Form No. 1A in Item 4.8 of this Chapter. The appropriations pertaining to the “For Later Release” portion of MOOE shall be for contingent purposes i.e., to respond to shortfalls in revenues and other unforeseen events. c. The allotment for FE shall also be released comprehensively for the whole year, using LBE Form No. 1B in Item 4.8 of this Chapter. d. The allotment for CapEx shall be released on the basis of the work program and the ranking of PPAs as presented in the approved AIP and as authorized and prioritized in the AO, using LBE Form No. 1C in Item 4.8 of this Chapter. The ARO gives the authority to spend within the confines of the PPAs, as defined in the AO. The ARO is issued to each Department/Office to give the Department Head the comprehensive authority to incur obligations up to the amount of the released allotment. The imposition of an amount “For Later Release” is to provide safeguards for shortfalls in the collection of revenues during the budget year. It is noted that these are all policy-based actions that should be consistent with the General Provisions (GPs) of the AO. 170 The following information shall be reflected in the ARO: Source of Appropriation: whether it is authorized under the annual budget, supplemental budget, or reenacted budget; and PPA Reference Code is the same as the AIP Reference Code. 3. Provide copies of ARO after its approval by the LCE. The released amount shall be stamped with the official seal of the LGU and shall be recorded in the proper registry by the LBO and Local Accountant. Copies of the ARO, as approved, shall be distributed as follows: Original Duplicate Triplicate Quadruplicate Quintuplicate – LBO – Department Head – Local Accountant – Records – Local Treasurer Release of ARO for Supplemental Budgets, as well as the realignment of savings from one expense class to another, shall follow the same process outlined above. But for augmentation of deficiencies in allotment within the same expense class for offices within the executive or legislative departments, the ARO shall be the release document to effect the changes. The former requires the submission of a supplemental budget for authorization by the sanggunian. The latter, on the other hand, can be done pursuant to a new ordinance or resolution of the sanggunian granting the LCE or the Presiding Officer the authority for the purpose. Step 2. Prepare the Detailed and Summary of Financial and Physical Performance Targets and Cash Program 4.5.2.1 Prepare the Detailed Financial and Physical Performance Targets by PPA and Performance Indicator The Department Heads shall prepare the Detailed Financial and Physical Performance Targets by PPA. This document presents the quarterly breakdown of the financial allocation that is needed to accomplish a specific level of targets. It enables the Department/Offices to match available resources with the level of effort to deliver their goods/services or outputs, and determine the magnitude and timing of additional releases. 4.5.2.2 Prepare the Summary of Financial and Physical Performance Targets On the basis of the detailed financial and physical performance targets of the different Departments/Offices, the LFC shall prepare the summary of financial and physical performance targets for the entire calendar year to serve as basis in comparing actual level of 171 accomplishment for the preceding year and knowing the available resources for the budget year. 4.5.2.3 4.5.2.4 Prepare the Cash Program Determine a realistic cash inflow on a monthly basis. Use as basis the actual inflow of revenues for the past three (3) years. Consider the months where revenue is high, like when payments of taxes become due, or months where revenue collection is low. A line graph may be used to show the high and low points of revenue collection to provide a historical or empirical basis of cash inflows. The Cash Flow Model of the BLGF may be used as reference. Determine a realistic cash outflow on a monthly basis. Analyze in detail the timing of expected payments affecting regular operations (payment of PS and MOOE including COs such as acquisition of equipment) and payments for the acquisition of civil works under RA No. 9184 (land and land improvements and building construction). Also, include in the projected cash outflows the financial requirements for calamities and emergencies, accounts payables and outstanding obligations due for payment, as well as debt servicing. The detailed financial and physical performance targets shall be considered in determining the magnitude and timing of cash outflows. Compute the difference between the cash inflows and outflows within a given period, month by month to be more specific, to determine the net cash flow. A projected cumulative net cash flow will indicate the capacity to generate surplus. Conversely, a cumulative negative cash flow will reveal the amount of additional cash requirements to sustain operations. Revise and adjust the PPMP and corresponding APP As soon as the AO authorizing the annual/supplemental budget is enacted and approved, and where there are significant changes in the amount authorized by the sanggunian, the Department Heads of the LGU concerned shall adjust/revise their respective PPMPs, taking into consideration cash availability and time of procurement which were formulated during the budget preparation phase. This budget for the contracts shall be matched with the amount released through the AROs. If the amount is reduced, then there should be corresponding reduction in the quantity to be procured and vice versa. Consequently, the APP shall be adjusted. In cases where the authorized amount in the ARO is the same as the proposed amount submitted during budget preparation, the PPMP/APP need 172 not be adjusted. The revised PPMPs shall be submitted to the BAC, through its Secretariat, for consolidation and finalization of the modes of procurement under the APP, subject to approval by the HoPE. No procurement shall be undertaken unless it is in accordance with the approved APP of the LGU. The individual PPMPs and consolidated approved APP shall be maintained and updated regularly at least every six (6) months or as often as may be necessary. 4.5.2.5 Procure Goods/Civil Works and Consulting Services Based on the adjusted/approved APP, the Departments/Offices shall procure the goods, services, equipment, civil works, and consulting services required for the implementation of PPAs. In these procurement activities, the provisions of RA No. 9184 and its Revised IRR shall be observed and strictly complied with. Step 3. Obligate and Disburse Funds Pursuant to the modified accrual system under the NGAS, obligations shall be taken up in the registry (RAAO) as they are incurred (please refer to COA Circular No. 2001-005 dated October 30, 2001).96 Accordingly, expenditures and obligations incurred during the fiscal year shall be taken up in the accounts of that year. Obligations already incurred but not yet paid (accounts payable) shall be settled in accordance with existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing rules and regulations. Step 4. Adjust Cash Program for Shortages and Overages The Local Treasurer adjusts the cash program where there are increases or decreases on actual cash collections, and on the basis of the adjusted cash program, the LFC adjusts the financial and physical targets. The LFC shall determine amounts considered as over-collection of taxes, and effect upward adjustments in the cash program to match the increase in the cash receipts forecast. If this is not done, a significant amount of cash will be idle at the end of the year. Identify amounts considered as under-collection of taxes and revenues. This is a signal that the original cash receipts forecast is overstated. It becomes necessary to decrease the cash disbursement program for the remaining months to prevent the incurrence of a cash overdraft. 96 New Government Accounting System 173 Step 5. Implement Corrective Measures as Proposed by the Local Finance Committee and approved by the Local Chief Executive 4.5.5.1 4.6 The LFC shall compare the actual performance in both the financial and physical accomplishments vis-à-vis the targets for the quarter. If the actual financial performance is greater than the estimated cost, it means that there was overspending beyond the available resources. This reflects inefficiency if the actual physical performance is below the target. This needs corrective action. If the actual financial performance is lower than the estimated cost, it means that the estimated cost was overstated and performance is ineffective if the physical targets were not met. This also needs corrective action. If the actual physical performance is greater than the target, it indicates that financial resources were utilized to the maximum resulting in better than ordinary performance. This is assuming that targets were realistically set and not understated. In this case, no corrective action is needed. If the actual physical performance is lower than the target, it indicates that the targets were overambitious or the people worked below par. Corrective action is needed in this case. 4.5.5.2 The Department Heads shall explain substantial negative deviations, and recommend remedial measures to address negative deviations. 4.5.5.3 The Department Heads shall prepare adjustments in the original targets to catch up with plans for the fiscal year. 4.5.5.4 Proposed corrective action shall be submitted by the Department Heads concerned to the LPDC for review and evaluation after which it shall be discussed with the LFC members for final deliberation. The proposed corrective action is then recommended by the LFC to the LCE for approval. Upon approval, the Department Head concerned shall implement corrective action to get back on track with planned targets for the fiscal year. Changes in the Annual Budget Use of Savings and Augmentation General Rule Funds shall be available exclusively for the specific purpose for which they have been appropriated. No ordinance shall be passed authorizing any transfer of appropriations from one item to another (Section 336 of the LGC). 174 Exception The LCE or the Presiding Officer of the sanggunian may, by ordinance, be authorized to augment any item in the approved annual budget for their respective offices from savings in other items within the same expense class of their respective appropriations (Section 336 of the LGC and Article 454 [b] of its IRR). Savings refer to portions or balances of any programmed appropriation free from any obligation or encumbrance still available after the satisfactory completion or the unavoidable discontinuance or abandonment of the work, activity or purpose for which the appropriation is authorized, or arising from unpaid compensation and related costs pertaining to vacant positions and leaves of absence without pay (Article 454 [b] [1] of the IRR of the LGC). Augmentation implies the existence in the budget of an item, project, activity or purpose with an appropriation which upon implementation or subsequent evaluation of needed resources is determined to be deficient (Article 454 [b] [2] of the IRR of the LGC). The ordinance authorizing the annual budget may include in its GP an omnibus authority to the LCE or the Presiding Officer of the sanggunian to augment any item in the approved annual budget for their respective offices from savings in other items within the same expense class of their respective appropriations (refer to the Illustrative Example in Section 2.6 of Chapter 2 of this Manual). LBE Form No. 2 in Item 4.8 of this Chapter shall be used for augmentation. Difference between the Use of Savings through Supplemental Budget and Augmentation under Sections 321 and 336 of the LGC Table 10. Difference of the Use of Savings through Supplemental Budget and Augmentation Requirement Use of savings through Supplemental Budget Use of savings and augmentation (Section 321 of the LGC) (Section 336 of the LGC) 1. What is the instrument required for authority? AO covering supplemental budget the Ordinance (if condition on the use of Savings is not included in the General Provisions of the AB) 2. Is there a need for a supplemental budget? Supplemental budget needed No need for a supplemental budget 3. What is the purpose of savings? For re-appropriation—may be to a different expense class For augmentation of existing item/s of expenditure within the same expense class 4. Where should the proposal emanate? From the LCE only From the LCE sanggunian 5. For provinces or highly urbanized cities, will the ordinance be subject to review by DBM? Yes No or the 175 4.7 Reenacted Budget Pursuant to Section 323 of the LGC, the LGU will operate under a reenacted budget in the following instances: 1. Failure of the sanggunian to pass the ordinance authorizing the annual appropriations at the beginning of the ensuing fiscal year; By implication, this includes the failure of the LCE to prepare the annual budget for the ensuing fiscal year; and 2. When the AO authorizing the annual budget is declared inoperative in its entirety by the reviewing authority under Sections 326 and 327 of the LGC. Reenacted Items of Appropriation Only the annual appropriations for salaries and wages of existing positions, statutory and contractual obligations, and essential operating expenses authorized in the annual and supplemental budgets for the preceding year shall be deemed reenacted and disbursement of funds shall be in accordance therewith (Section 323 of the LGC). Preparing the Reenacted Budget The LGU may prepare the reenacted budget, as follows: The Local Treasurer shall exclude from the estimates of income for the preceding fiscal year those realized from nonrecurring sources, like national aids, proceeds from loans, sale of assets, prior year adjustments, and other analogous sources of income. The Local Treasurer may use LBE Form No. 3 in Item 4.8 of this Chapter for the purpose. The LBO shall reflect the annual appropriations for salaries and wages of existing positions, statutory and contractual obligations, and essential operating expenses authorized in the annual and supplemental budgets for the preceding fiscal year. The LBO may use LBE Form No. 4 in Item 4.8 of this Chapter to identify the reenacted appropriations of the annual and supplemental budgets. If the revised income estimates are sufficient to cover the aggregate appropriation, then the reenacted budget shall remain in full force and effect until the ordinance authorizing the proposed appropriations is passed by the sanggunian concerned. In case the revised income estimates be less than the aggregate reenacted appropriations, the Local Treasurer concerned shall accordingly advise the sanggunian concerned which shall, within ten (10) days from the receipt of such advice, make the necessary adjustments or reductions. The revised appropriations authorized by the sanggunian concerned shall then be the basis for disbursements (Section 323 of the LGC). 176 Limitations under a Reenacted Budget A reenacted budget will have implied disadvantages such as, but not limited to, the following: 1. No new PPAs shall be implemented; 2. No utilization of the increase in NTA allocation for the year may be allowed since the same is not covered by an AO; 3. No supplemental appropriations shall be enacted; 4. No implementation of non-recurring activities no matter how vital they may be; and 5. No creation of new positions. 177 4.8 Local Budget Execution Forms LBE Form No. 1 Annual Budget Supplemental Budget Reenacted Budget ALLOTMENT RELEASE ORDER FOR PERSONAL SERVICES (ARO for PS) FY_________ Local Government Unit (LGU): ______________________ Fund Code: ______ Department/Office: __________________________ Purpose: _________________________________________________________________ PPA Code PPA Description (1) (2) Object Class/ Account Code (3) Authorized Appropriation for PS For Later Release Previously Released Amount This Release (4) (5) (6) (7) TOTAL AMOUNT IN WORDS _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ NOTES: _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ The allotments herein released shall be used solely for the purposes indicated, and disbursements thereto shall be made in accordance with existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing rules and regulations. It is the primary responsibility of the head of the Department/Office or Unit concerned to keep expenditures within the limits of the amount allotted. Recommended by: Approved by: ____________________ Local Budget Officer _____________________ Local Chief Executive ARO No.___________ Date of Issue: _______ Page ____ of ______ 178 Instructions: Check the box corresponding to the source of appropriation which may either be: Annual Budget, Supplemental Budget or Reenacted Budget. Local Government Unit: Indicate the name of the province, city, and municipality implementing the budget. Department/Office: Indicate the Department/Office concerned. Purpose: Indicate the purpose. Fund Code: Indicate the Fund Code (e.g., 100 - General Fund or 200 - Special Education Fund). Column 1 - Indicate the PPA reference code as identified in the Annual Investment Program Summary Form. Column 2 - Briefly describe the PPA to be implemented. Column 3 - Indicate the Account Code for the Object Classification Code based on the Revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs. Column 4 - Indicate the Authorized Appropriation for PS. Column 5 - Indicate the amount of standby appropriation for PS to answer for unforeseen events and shortfalls in revenue collection. Column 6 - Indicate the amount previously released. Column 7 - Indicate the amount of PS to be released comprehensively for the entire year/released of allotment under For Later Release portion. For control purposes, each ARO should be numbered, indicating the date of issuance and page number. 179 LBE Form No. 1A Annual Budget Supplemental Budget Reenacted Budget ALLOTMENT RELEASE ORDER FOR MAINTENANCE AND OTHER OPERATING EXPENSES (ARO for MOOE) FY_____________ Local Government Unit: ______________________ Fund Code:______ Department/Office: __________________________ Purpose: __________________________________________________________________ PPA Code PPA Description Object Class/ Account Code (1) (2) (3) Authorized Appropriation for MOOE (4) For Later Release (5) Previously Released Amount (6) This Release (7) TOTAL AMOUNT IN WORDS _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ NOTES: _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ The allotments herein released shall be used solely for the purposes indicated, and disbursements thereto shall be made in accordance with existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing rules and regulations. It is the primary responsibility of the head of the Department/Office or Unit concerned to keep expenditures within the limits of the amount allotted. Recommended by: Approved by: ____________________ Local Budget Officer _____________________ Local Chief Executive ARO No.___________ Date of Issue: _______ Page ____ of ______ 180 Instructions: Check the box corresponding to the source of appropriation which may either be: Annual Budget, Supplemental Budget or Reenacted Budget. Local Government Unit: Indicate the name of the province, city, and municipality implementing the budget. Department/Office: Indicate the Department/Office concerned. Purpose: Indicate the purpose. Fund Code: Indicate the Fund Code (e.g., 100 - General Fund or 200 - Special Education Fund). Column 1 - Indicate the PPA reference code as identified in the AIP Summary Form. Column 2 - Briefly describe the PPA to be implemented. Column 3 - Indicate the Account Code for the Object Classification Code based on the Revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs. Column 4 - Indicate the Authorized Appropriation for MOOE. Column 5 - Indicate the amount of standby appropriation for MOOE to answer for unforeseen events and shortfalls in revenue collection. Column 6 - Indicate the amount previously released. Column 7 - Indicate the amount of MOOE to be released comprehensively for the entire year/released of allotment under For Later Release portion. For control purposes, each ARO should be numbered, indicating the date of issuance and page number. 181 LBE Form No. 1B Annual Budget Supplemental Budget Reenacted Budget ALLOTMENT RELEASE ORDER FOR FINANCIAL EXPENSES (ARO for FE) FY_____________ Local Government Unit: ______________________ Fund Code:______ Department/Office: __________________________ Purpose: __________________________________________________________________ PPA Code PPA Description (1) (2) Object Class/Account Code (3) Authorized Appropriation for FE (4) For Later Release (5) Previously Released Amount (6) This Release (7) TOTAL AMOUNT IN WORDS _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ NOTES: _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ The allotments herein released shall be used solely for the purposes indicated, and disbursements thereto shall be made in accordance with existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing rules and regulations. It is the primary responsibility of the head of the Department/Office or Unit concerned to keep expenditures within the limits of the amount allotted. Recommended by: Approved by: ____________________ Local Budget Officer _____________________ Local Chief Executive ARO No.___________ Date of Issue: _______ Page ____ of ______ 182 Instructions: Check the box corresponding to the source of appropriation which may either be: Annual Budget, Supplemental Budget, or Reenacted Budget. Local Government Unit: Indicate the name of the province, city, and municipality implementing the budget. Department/Office: Indicate the Department/Office concerned. Purpose: Indicate the purpose. Fund Code: Indicate the Fund Code (e.g., 100 - General Fund or 200 - Special Education Fund). Column 1 - Indicate the PPA reference code as identified in the AIP Summary Form. Column 2 - Briefly describe the PPA to be implemented. Column 3 - Indicate the Account Code for the Object Classification Code based on the Revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs. Column 4 - Indicate the Authorized Appropriation for FE. Column 5 - Indicate the amount of standby appropriation for FE to answer for unforeseen events and shortfalls in revenue collection. Column 6 - Indicate the amount previously released. Column 7 - Indicate the amount of FE to be released comprehensively for the entire year/released of allotment under For Later Release portion. For control purposes, each ARO should be numbered, indicating the date of issuance and page number. 183 LBE Form No. 1C Annual Budget Supplemental Budget Reenacted Budget ALLOTMENT RELEASE ORDER FOR CAPITAL EXPENDITURES (ARO for CapEx) FY_____________ Local Government Unit: ______________________ Fund Code:______ Department/Office: __________________________ Purpose: __________________________________________________________________ PPA Code PPA Description (1) (2) Object Class/Account Code (3) Authorized Appropriation for CapEx (4) For Later Release (5) Previously Released Amount (6) This Release (7) TOTAL AMOUNT IN WORDS _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ NOTES: _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ The allotments herein released shall be used solely for the purposes indicated, and disbursements thereto shall be made in accordance with existing budgeting, accounting, and auditing rules and regulations. It is the primary responsibility of the head of the Department/Office or Unit concerned to keep expenditures within the limits of the amount allotted. Recommended by: Approved by: ____________________ Local Budget Officer _____________________ Local Chief Executive ARO No.___________ Date of Issue: _______ Page ____ of ______ 184 Instructions: Check the box corresponding to the source of appropriation which may either be: Annual Budget, Supplemental Budget, or Reenacted Budget. Local Government Unit: Indicate the name of the province, city, and municipality implementing the budget. Department/Office: Indicate the Department/Office concerned. Purpose: Indicate the purpose. Fund Code: Indicate the Fund Code (e.g., 100 - General Fund or 200 - Special Education Fund). Column 1 - Indicate the PPA reference code as identified in the AIP Summary Form. Column 2 - Briefly describe the PPA to be implemented. Column 3 - Indicate the Account Code for the Object Classification Code based on the Revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs. Column 4 - Indicate the Authorized Appropriation for CapEx. Column 5 - Indicate the amount of standby appropriation for CapEx to answer for unforeseen events and shortfalls in revenue collection. Column 6 - Indicate the amount previously released. Column 7 - Indicate the amount of CapEx to be released comprehensively for the entire year/released of allotment under For Later Release portion. For control purposes, each ARO should be numbered, indicating the date of issuance and page number. 185 LBE Form No. 2* AUGMENTATION FORM FY ________ Local Government Unit: ______________________ Office: Executive/Sanggunian Ordinance No.: ______________ Sources of Funds FROM Object of Expense Amount Expenditures Class (1) (2) (3) Uses of Funds TO Object of Expense Expenditures Class (4) (5) TOTAL TOTAL Prepared by: Certified Correct by: ________________ Local Budget Officer ___________________ Local Accountant Amount (6) Approved by: _______________________________ Local Chief Executive (LCE)/Vice-LCE Instructions: Local Government Unit (LGU): Indicate the name of the province, city, or municipality. Ordinance No.: Indicate the number of the ordinance authorizing the use of savings for augmentation. Columns 1 to 3 – Identify the sources of funds, i.e., object of expenditures, expense class, and amount. Columns 4 to 6 – Indicate the uses of funds, i.e., object of expenditures, expense class, and amount. Notes: 1. Savings can augment only existing items of appropriation in the Appropriation Ordinance. 2. Savings can augment only items of appropriation in the same expense (e.g., PS to PS and MOOE to MOOE). Savings from CO cannot be used for augmentation purposes. 3. An ordinance is needed to authorize the augmentation unless provision of the same is already reflected in the General Provisions of the Appropriation Ordinance covering the annual budget of the LGU. __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 186 LBE Form No. 3 ADJUSTED RECEIPTS PROGRAM FOR REENACTED APPROPRIATIONS Local Government Unit: _______________________ Sources of Income Income Classification (1) (2) Amount of the Preceding Fiscal Year Estimates (3) Adjustments (Amounts of Non-Recurring Sources) Adjusted Income Estimates (4) (5) = (3) – (4) Regular Income A. Local Sources 1. Tax Revenue a. Real Property Tax (RPT) i. Basic RPT b. Business Tax c. Other Local Taxes Total Tax Revenue 2. Non-Tax Revenue a. Regulatory Fees b. Service/User Charges c. Receipts from Economic Enterprises d. Other Receipts Total Non-Tax Revenue Total Local Sources B. External Sources 1. National Tax Allotment (formerly Internal Revenue Allotment) 2. Share from GOCCs (PAGCOR and PCSO) 3. Other Shares from National Tax Collection a. Share from Ecozone b. Share from EVAT c. Share from National Wealth d. Share from Tobacco Excise Tax Total External Sources Total Regular Income Non-Regular Income A. External Sources 1. Inter-Local Transfer 2. Extraordinary Receipts/Grants/Donations/Aids Total External Sources B. Non-Income Receipts 1. Capital Investment Receipts a. Proceeds from Sale of Assets b. Proceeds from Sale of Debt Securities of Other Entities c. Collections of Loans Receivable Total Capital/Investment Receipts 2. Receipts from Loans and Borrowings a. Acquisition of Loans b. Issuance of Bonds Total Receipts from Loans and Borrowings 3. Other Non-Income Receipts Total Non-Income Receipts Total Non-Regular Income Total Receipts Certified Correct by: Approved by: ________________ Local Treasurer ________________ Local Chief Executive 187 Instructions: Local Government Unit: Indicate the name of the province, city, or municipality implementing the budget. Column 1 – Using the Appropriation Ordinance of the preceding fiscal year, indicate the sources of income covering the annual and supplemental budgets. Column 2 – Indicate the income classification on every item of receipt. Column 3 – Reflect the amounts for the recurring and non-recurring sources for the preceding fiscal year. Column 4 – Reflect the non-recurring sources of funds. Column 5 – Indicate the difference between the amount of the preceding fiscal year estimates and the amount of the non-recurring sources of funds for the adjusted income estimates (Column 3 – Column 4). 188 LBE Form No. 4 REENACTED APPROPRIATIONS OF THE ANNUAL AND SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGETS Local Government Unit: _________________________ Expenditure Program Department/Office Mandate Vision Mission Organizational Outcome : _____________________________ : _____________________________ : _____________________________ : _____________________________ : _____________________________ Particulars Account Code (1) (2) Appropriations of the Preceding Year (Actual) (3) Adjustments (Essential Operating Expenses) (4) Adjusted Appropriations (5) Reenacted Appropriations by Expense Class and Object of Expenditures 1. 2. 3. Personal Services Salaries and Wages of existing positions Other Compensation Personal Economic Relief Allowance Personnel Benefit Contribution Other Personnel Benefit Sub-Total Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses Sub-Total Special Purpose Appropriation Appropriation for Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Programs/Projects Appropriation for Debt Service Aid to Barangays Sub-Total Total Reenacted Appropriations Certified Correct by: Approved by: ________________ Local Budget Officer Certified Correct by: ________________ Local Chief Executive 189 Instructions: Department/Office: Indicate the Department/Office implementing the budget. Mandate: Quote the provision of the LGC on the mandate of the Department/Office. Vision: Indicate the future role of the Department/Office in the LGU’s development. Mission: Indicate the significant role of the Department/Office in attaining the vision. Organizational Outcome: The specific short-term benefits to clients and the community as a result of the LGU’s delivery of Major Final Outputs as defined in the organization’s results framework. Column 1 – Specify the object of expenditures by expense class and by Department/Office, and the special purpose appropriations. Column 2 - Indicate the account code using the COA Revised Chart of Accounts for Local Governments. Column 3 - Indicate the actual expenditure items of the previous year’s annual and supplemental Appropriation Ordinance. Column 4 – Reflect the essential operating expenses from the preceding year’s annual and supplemental Appropriation Ordinance as identified by the Local Chief Executive (LCE) for the executive branch and/or the Vice-LCE for the legislative branch. Column 5 – Indicate the adjusted appropriation. 190 LBE Form No. 5* SUMMARY OF FINANCIAL AND PHYSICAL PERFORMANCE TARGETS FY_____________ Local Government Unit Department/Office Major Final Output (MFO) Program/ Project/ Activity (PPA) (1) : ___________________________ : ___________________________ : ___________________________ Total Cost Performance Indicator Prior Year Accomplishments (Actual) Physical Targets Remarks (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) Prepared by: ___________________ Local Planning and Development Coordinator ____________________ Local Budget Officer ___________________ Local Treasurer Approved by: ___________________ Local Chief Executive Instructions: Local Government Unit: Indicate the name of the province, city, or municipality implementing the budget. Department/Office: Indicate the Department/Office concerned. Major Final Output: Indicate the MFO(s) which shall be delivered as a result of the implementation of PPAs. o Services which are not directly consumed by the external clients such as the following shall be subsumed under executive services: Example: MFO: Executive Services (Accounting and Internal Services) PPA: Preparation and submission of reports Performance Indicator: 90% of financial reports submitted on time Column 1 – Indicate the PPAs that will deliver the MFO/s (Example: MFO – Agricultural Services; PPA – Swine Dispersal Program). Column 2 – Indicate the amount approved for the current year by allotment class. __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 191 Column 3 – Indicate the performance standards/criteria and indicators set in Local Budget Preparation Form No. 4 (Mandate, Vision, Mission, MFO, Performance Indicators and Targets) that will be accomplished by the LGU (e.g., No. of beneficiaries of swine dispersal program). Column 4 – Indicate the accomplishment during the preceding year. Column 5 – Indicate the targets for each performance indicator to be accomplished for the current year. Column 6 – Indicate other information relative to the performance. 192 LBE Form No. 5A DETAILED FINANCIAL AND PHYSICAL PERFORMANCE TARGETS Local Government Unit Department/Office Major Final Output Program/Project/ Activity (PPA)/ Performance Indicator/s (1) : _______________________ : _______________________ : _______________________ Financial Allocation 1st 2nd Quarter Quarter Physical Targets 3rd 4th 1st Quarter Quarter Quarter (2) 2nd Quarter 3rd Quarter 4th Quarter (3) Prepared by: Approved by: ___________________ Department Head _________________ Local Chief Executive Instructions: Local Government Unit: Indicate the name of the province, city, or municipality implementing the budget. Department/Office: Indicate the Department/Office concerned. Major Final Output/s: Indicate the Major Final Output/s (MFO/s) which shall be delivered as a result of the implementation of PPAs by different Departments/Offices to external clients, such as, but not limited to, the following: Executive Services Legislative Services Veterinary Services Health Services Agricultural Services Social Services Engineering Services Budget and Management Services Column 1 – Indicate the PPAs which are identifiable to the Major Final Output (MFO), Example: MFO – Agricultural Services; PPA – Swine Dispersal Program. Performance indicators shall also be indicated in each of the PPAs. Column 2 – Indicate the quarterly financial allocation based on the currently approved budget for the Department/Office. Column 3 – Indicate the quarterly physical targets for each performance indicator per PPA. Note: LBE Form No. 5A shall be prepared within seven (7) days after the approval of the Appropriation Ordinance and the same shall be submitted to the LCE. 193 CHAPTER 5. THE BUDGET ACCOUNTABILITY PHASE Budget accountability is the last and final phase of the budget process. Budget accountability, in simple terms, is accounting for the budget. It involves the use of management control techniques to assist in tracking receipts of income/revenues and expenditures. The budget cycle is incomplete without accountability. This mechanism provides a venue for the LCE, local sanggunian, and stakeholders to be continuously informed of the status of implementation of PPAs. It covers the monitoring and analysis of all financial transactions, the recording of budgetary accounts in the registries, recording in the books of accounts of all receipts and expenditures, and financial reporting of their current status. An integral part of accountability is the evaluation of the financial and physical performance of the LGU. The assessment of performance is necessary to introduce improvements and reforms to make the budget more transparent to the people and stakeholders. In this Manual, the focus of discussion is accounting for the budget, and not the audit of accounts. The examination of the legality and propriety of obligations and expenditures incurred in the process of executing the budget is within the realm of COA for external audit. Auditing is discussed in another field. It is understood, however, that in the execution of the budget, officials and employees involved shall strictly observe and follow the existing law, rules, and regulations of COA, DBM, BLGF, DILG, and other oversight agencies. 5.1 Legal Bases of Budget Accountability “Any officer of the local government unit whose duty permits or requires the possession or custody of local government funds shall be accountable and responsible for the safekeeping thereof in conformity with the provisions of this Title. Other local officers who, though not accountable by the nature of their duties, may likewise be similarly held accountable and responsible for local government funds through their participation in the use or application thereof.” (Section 340 of the LGC) “Fiscal responsibility shall be shared by all those exercising authority over the financial affairs, transactions, and operations of the local government units.” (Section 305 [l] of the LGC) 5.2 Key Players in Budget Accountability Local Chief Executive – The LCE shall be primarily responsible for the execution of the annual and supplemental budgets and the accountability therefor (Section 320 of the LGC). 194 Specifically, the LCE shall: Ensure that all taxes and other revenues of the LGU are collected, and that local government funds are applied to the payment of expenses and settlement of obligations, in accordance with law or ordinance (Sections 444 [b] [3] [iii]; 455 [b] [3] [iii]; and 465 [b] [3] [iii] of the LGC); Cause the periodic examination of books, records, and other documents maintained by accountable officials, agents, or employees of the LGU to ensure that income collection and disbursements are properly recorded (Sections 444 [b] [1] [xi]; 455 [b] [1] [xi]; and 465 [b] [1] [xi] of the LGC); Ensure that accountable officials are able to submit periodic reports in such forms as may be required under this Manual and by applicable rules; Ensure that all executive officials and employees faithfully discharge their duties and functions as provided by law and the LGC (Sections 444 [b] [1] [x]; 455 [b] [1] [x]; and 465 [b] [1] [x] of the LGC); and Submit to the sanggunian concerned, on or before March 31 of each year, an annual report covering the immediately preceding calendar year which shall contain among others the budgetary/financial performance as well as physical accomplishments of the LGU (Section 97 of the LGC and Article 189 of its IRR). Local Treasurer – The Local Treasurer shall: Collect all local taxes, fees, and charges (Section 170 of the LGC); Report regularly to the LCE on the tax collection efforts in the LGU (Section 470 [b] of the LGC); Advise the LCE, the sanggunian, and other local and national government officials concerned regarding the disposition of local government funds, and on such other matters relative to public finance (Section 470 [d] [1] of the LGC); Take custody and exercise proper management of the funds of the LGU concerned (Section 470 [d] [2] of the LGC); Take charge of the disbursement of all local government funds and such other funds the custody of which may be entrusted to him by law or other competent authority (Section 470 [d] [3] of the LGC); Submit periodic reports to the LCE through the LFC in such forms prescribed under this Manual; 195 Post the required reports on monthly collections and disbursements at prominent places in the main office building of the LGU, its plaza and main street (Section 513 of the LGC); and Exercise such other powers and perform such other duties and functions as may be prescribed by law or ordinance (Section 470 [e] of the LGC). Local Accountant – The Local Accountant shall: Prepare and submit financial statements to the LCE and to the sanggunian concerned (Section 474 [b] [2] of the LGC); Appraise the sanggunian and other local government officials on the financial condition and operations of the LGU concerned (Section 474 [b] [3] of the LGC); Install and maintain an internal audit system in the LGU concerned (Section 474 [b] [1] of the LGC); The accountant performs pre-audit of government financial transactions as it is inherent to the accounting and fiscal control processes of the government. Hence, the conduct of such activity is part of the establishment and maintenance of an adequate internal control system to ensure that disbursements are in compliance with laws, rules, and regulations, and they are properly documented. Meanwhile, an internal audit is undertaken ex post facto or after the fact/transaction. Being part of a separate internal control component (monitoring and evaluation), it is instituted to determine whether internal controls are well-designed and properly implemented. Foregoing considered, pre-audit activity of the Local Accountant is considered as a non-internal audit task and is separate from the post-audit functions (e.g. compliance, management and operations audits) of the Internal Auditor. Record all financial transactions in the appropriate journals and keep all supporting documents attached thereto, as follows: statement of cash advances, liquidation, salaries, allowances, reimbursement, and remittances pertaining to the LGU; statement of journal entry vouchers and liquidation of the same and other adjustments related thereto; and maintain individual ledger for officials and employees of the LGU pertaining to payroll and deductions; 196 Record and post in the index cards detail of purchased furniture, fixture, and equipment, including disposal thereof, if any; Maintain and update all general and subsidiary ledgers both manual and electronic data recording; and Prepare and submit periodic reports to the LCE through the LFC in such forms prescribed under this Manual. Local Budget Officer – The LBO shall: Certify the availability of appropriations and allotments to which expenditures and obligations may be properly charged (Section 344 of the LGC); In coordination with the Local Accountant, Local Treasurer, and LPDC, monitor and evaluate budget performance of all PPAs (financial and physical evaluation of actual results vs targets) (Sections 316 [h] and 475 [c] of the LGC); Together with the members of the LFC, propose corrective actions for negative deviations (financial and physical) to the LCE through the LFC; and Prepare and submit periodic budgetary reports to the LCE through the LFC and to the DBM in such forms prescribed under this Manual (Section 475 [b] [5] of the LGC). Local Planning and Development Coordinator - The LPDC shall: Monitor and evaluate the implementation of the different development PPAs in the LGU concerned in accordance with the approved development plan (Section 476 [b] [4] of the LGC); Analyze the income and expenditure patterns, and formulate and recommend fiscal plans and policies for consideration of the LFC of the LGU concerned (Section 476 [b] [6] of the LGC); and Prepare and submit periodic reports to the LCE through the LFC in such forms prescribed under this Manual. Heads of Departments/Offices – The Heads of Departments/Offices shall: Monitor the implementation of all PPAs under their respective supervision to ensure adherence to plans, targets, and performance indicators; Monitor physical and financial performance of MFOs identified with his Department/Office using performance indicators as basis of evaluating performance; and 197 Prepare and submit periodic reports to the LFC in such forms as prescribed under this Manual. Local Finance Committee – The LFC shall: Conduct a semi-annual review and general examination of expenditures and actual accomplishments against performance standards in undertaking development projects (Section 316 [h] of the LGC); and Post the semi-annual and general examination report in conspicuous and publicly accessible places in the LGU, and furnish a copy of the report to the LCE and the sanggunian concerned (Section 316 [h] of the LGC). CSOs and the Private Sector Groups – The CSOs shall perform their duties and responsibilities as shown in Table 11 below based on the Handbook on the Participation of CSOs in the Local Budget Process. Table 11. Roles of CSOs in the Budget Accountability Phase ACTIVITY EVALUATE OUTPUTS AND RESULTS OF PPAs LGU ROLES CSO ROLES The appropriations recorded in the books shall be compared with the actual collections and disbursements for the same period. Invite accredited CSOs May participate in the to participate in the local project evaluation. project monitoring activities. Enhance CSOs own technical capability in Post financial project evaluation. information in three (3) Expenditures are conspicuous places in May provide tracked and monitored the LGU within twenty recommendations vis-à-vis the outputs and (20) days after the end of based on evaluation accomplishments each quarter. results. Invite accredited CSOs in the mid-year and yearend assessment of the overall performance of the LGU. May organize citizens’ fora with the LGU to provide feedback to the community. Invite accredited CSOs in the impact assessment of the programs and projects, and the overall performance of the LGU. 198 ACTIVITY 5.3 LGU ROLES Make use of available and existing monitoring tools such as the Citizens Satisfaction Report Card (from the Caucus of Development NGO Networks) and the LGU Fiscal Sustainability Scorecard (from BLGF). CSO ROLES The Budget Monitoring and Evaluation Framework The following summarizes the role of the budget accountability phase in the planning, programming, and budgeting cycle: provides feedback for PPA implementation adjustments during execution of the budget; provides information to the general public on the performance of the LGU; and provides necessary input information to the planning and programming of PPAs for inclusion in the budget preparation forms. The monitoring and evaluation of agreed outputs of individual Departments/Offices together with agreed corresponding performance indicators shall be the main function of Department/Office Heads: monitoring of financial performance shall include actual obligation and disbursements for each PPA that is being implemented; monitoring of actual financial performance shall see to it that the extent of deviation from the budget are controlled and managed; monitoring of physical performance for each PPA shall include actual physical output produced at a given time for each performance indicator identified and agreed after a group consultation; the evaluation of the financial performance of all PPAs being implemented which should include a variance analysis between actual obligations and disbursements vs authorized appropriations; the evaluation of the physical performance of all PPAs (their outputs and performance indicators) should include a variance analysis between actual outputs vs targets; and 199 a periodic report of the overall performance of all ranked PPAs shall be reported by Department/Office Head to the LFC and LCE for purposes of improving and refining the financial and physical performance of PPAs implemented by the LGU. To improve and refine the outputs of Departments/Offices, a menu of PIs per MFO shall first be agreed by all Departments/Offices in coordination with the LFC, LCE, and local sanggunian. These PIs may be further enhanced by giving opportunity to interested stakeholders or CSOs to give their suggestions and ideas for improvement. The final PIs for implementation shall pass the local sanggunian for adoption. Please refer to samples of PPAs, their MFOs, and menu of PIs for each output in Annex B of this Manual. The entire process of monitoring and evaluation of the financial and physical performance of ranked PPAs and their PIs is illustrated in the following conceptual framework: Figure 13. Budget Monitoring and Evaluation Framework 200 Figure 14. Budget Accountability Flowchart 5.4 Steps in the Budget Accountability Phase Budget accountability is accounting for the local budget, which involves the following three (3) steps: Step 1. Monitor receipts and expenditures The budgets of the LGU are accounted for starting on the first day of the fiscal year. All transactions are recorded, documented, monitored, and evaluated. The estimated receipts and appropriations are in amounts approved, reviewed, and recorded in the books where they shall be compared with actual collections and disbursements for the same period. This simple monitoring process is necessary to keep track of all receipts and expenditures for a particular period. Monitoring of Receipts The required accountability report to undertake the monitoring of receipts or income/revenue/borrowings is shown in Local Budget Accountability (LBAc) Form No. 1 or the Quarterly Report of Receipts in Item 5.5 of this Chapter. This is certified by the Local Accountant based on the actual collections from the Local Treasurer’s Report of Daily Collections. This report keeps track of all receipts (income/revenue and borrowings) for each month of the quarter and shows the variance between estimated receipts and actual receipts collected as of the end of the quarter. 201 Monitoring of Expenditures The monitoring of expenditures includes the monitoring of appropriations, allotments, obligations, and disbursements. The LBO shall keep track of the appropriations released through allotments and subsequently obligated by the various departments and offices. This ensures that funds used for the PPAs funded in the budget are used exclusively for the specific purpose/s for which they have been appropriated pursuant to Sections 336 and 305 (a) of the LGC. The LBO and the Local Accountant shall ensure that lawful expenditures and obligations incurred during a fiscal year shall be taken up in the accounts of that year pursuant to Section 350 of the LGC. The LBO shall prepare LBAc Form No. 2 or the Quarterly Financial Report of Operations in Item 5.5 of this Chapter that will give a picture of the efficiency and effectiveness of the rate of utilization of appropriations by the various Departments/Offices of the LGU. The Local Treasurer, LBO, and the Local Accountant shall prepare LBAc Form No. 4 or the Statement of Receipts and Expenditures (SRE) in Item 5.5 of this Chapter pursuant to Section 352 of the LGC for the fiscal year. The Local Treasurer, Local Accountant, LBO, and other accountable officials shall post the approved SRE in at least three (3) publicly accessible and conspicuous places in the LGU within thirty (30) days from the end of the fiscal year. A copy of the SRE, furnished to the LBO, shall be submitted to the DBM through its RO within the same period. Monitoring of Physical Outputs and Accomplishments Each Department/Office Head shall prepare LBAc Form No. 3 or the Quarterly Physical Report of Operations in Item 5.5 of this Chapter that shows the actual performance per activity vs target output. Also, the LGU shall prepare the LBAc Form No. 6 or Monitoring of Physical and Financial Accomplishments in Item 5.5 of this Chapter to reflect the actual physical accomplishments vis-à-vis targeted outputs for PPAs with corresponding plans, e.g., GAD, LDRRM, etc. A Project Monitoring Report, which shall cover all procurement activities in the APP, whether ongoing and completed, shall be prepared by the BAC on a semestral basis to be approved by the HoPE and submitted to the GPPB within fourteen (14) calendar days after the end of each semester. 202 Step 2. Submit Accountability Reports It is imperative that the Local Accountant, Local Treasurer, LBO, LPDC, and Heads of Departments/Offices shall submit the required accountability reports for monitoring purposes. They establish a database of the performance record of the various Departments/Offices of the LGU concerned. A summary of these forms/reports are listed in the Table 12 below: Table 12. Required Accountability Reports LBAc Form No. Description Report of Responsible Official/s Local Treasurer and Local Accountant LBO Date of Submission Ten (10) days after the end of each quarter Ten (10) days after the end of each quarter LBAc Form No. 1 Quarterly Receipts LBAc Form No. 2 Quarterly Financial Report of Operations LBAc Form No. 3 Quarterly Physical Report of Operations Department/Office Heads and LPDC Ten (10) days after the end of each quarter LBAc Form No. 4 Statement of Receipts and Expenditures Local Treasurer, LBO, Local Accountant, and LCE Within thirty (30) days from the end of fiscal year LBAc Form No. 5 Physical and Financial Performance Evaluation Form LFC Within thirty (30) days from the end of each semester LBAc Form No. 6 Monitoring of Physical and Financial Accomplishments LPDC and LCE Within thirty (30) days from the end of each semester Step 3. Evaluate Performance of each Department/Office Pursuant to Sections 316 (h) and 320 of the LGC, the LFC and LCE are tasked to conduct semi-annual review and general examination of expenses and accomplishments against performance standards applied in the implementation of development projects and delivery of basic services. The assessment of performance shall primarily be a review of outputs per PPA for each Department/Office. Since there is no standard performance for identified performance indicators as of date, the review will be limited to a variance analysis of actual results vis-à-vis planned targets for each performance indicator. Similar approach will be used to the expenditure per PPA and per performance indicator. The format for this variance analysis is shown in the following example: 203 Table 13. Variance Analysis of Output/Physical Performance PPA Code (1) 8000-1-1 PPA Description (2) Extension Services in Agriculture Performance Indicators (3) Number of trained farmers Number of Womenfolk trained in Home Gardening Variance % (4) 150 Actual Output (5) 50 (6) = (5) – (4) (100) (7) = (6) / (4) (67%) 100 120 20 20% Target This process of review shall be improved gradually as standards of performance are developed for each performance indicator. A similar variance analysis approach shall be used for assessing the financial performance of the PPA as shown in the example below: Table 14. Variance Analysis of Financial Performance PPA Code (1) 8000-1-1 PPA Description (2) Extension Services in Agriculture Performance Indicators (3) Number of trained farmers Target (4) P2500 Actual Output (5) P3000 Variance % (6) = (5) – (4) P500 (7) = (6) / (4) 20% The review and analysis of the output and financial performance per PPA and per indicator are done to have a complete picture of the extent of performance. The LFC shall report the results of the evaluation to the LCE, local sanggunian, oversight agencies, and other observers to promote transparency and accessibility to LGU budget performance. It will also serve as bases for re-evaluating current policies and practices. The LGU may either sustain good performance or remedy shortcomings to enable it to be on track in its plans for the year and subsequent years. Use LBAc Form No. 5 in Item 5.5 of this Chapter to evaluate physical and financial performance of the LGU. 204 5.5 Local Budget Accountability Reports LBAc Form No. 1 QUARTERLY REPORT OF RECEIPTS For the Quarter Ending _________ Account Title/ Description of Income (1) Account Code (2) Estimated Income Previous Quarter (3) Estimated Income This Quarter (4) Total Estimated Income to Date (5) Actual Income for the Quarter 1st Month 2nd Month 3rd Month (6) (7) (8) Total Actual Income to Date (9) Variance Remarks Amount % (10) (11) Prepared by: Certified Correct by: ___________________ Local Treasurer Date: ______________ ___________________ Local Accountant Date: ______________ (12) Instructions: Column 1 – Indicate the appropriate account classification and nature of the actual income generated during the period as appearing in Columns 3 to 9 in accordance with the NGAS, i.e., Other Taxes, Community Tax, Share from Internal Revenue Collection, Share from Expanded Value-Added Tax, and Share from National Wealth. Column 2 – Indicate the account code pursuant to the Revised Chart of Accounts for LGUs. Column 3 – Indicate the estimated income of the previous quarter. Column 4 – Indicate the estimated income of the current quarter reported based on BLGF reportorial requirements. Column 5 – Indicate the estimated income from January to the end of the quarter reported. Columns 6 to 8 – Indicate the actual income realized during the three (3) months of the quarter reported. Column 9 - Indicate the cumulative total of each income category from January 1 to the end of the quarter reported. Said total should tally with the income account per Trial Balance as of date. Column 10 – Indicate the difference between the estimated income and actual income to date (Column 9 – Column 5). Column 11 – Indicate the percentage increase/(decrease) in the income (Column 10 / Column 5). Column 12 – Identify additional information/reasons for the material increase or decrease of actual income realized during the period compared with estimates. Note: This report shall be submitted directly to the LFC thru the LBO on or before the 10th day of the month following the quarter reported. 205 LBAc Form No. 2* QUARTERLY FINANCIAL REPORT OF OPERATIONS For the Quarter Ending _________ Appropriation Allotment Released Obligations Incurred MFO/ PPA Implementing Unit Continuing Current Total Previous Quarters This Quarter Total Balance of Appropriation (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) Previous Quarters This Quarter Total Unobligated Allotment Remarks (10) (`11) (12) (13) (14) Certified Correct by: _______________________ Local Budget Officer Date: __________________ Instructions: Column 1 - Indicate the MFO and PPA Code of the activity as listed in the General Fund Budget. Column 2 – Identify the implementing unit, i.e. General Services Department, Accounting Department, among others. Column 3 – Indicate the unreleased appropriation of the past year which can still be released during the current year. Column 4 – Indicate the current year’s appropriation in the approved budget, whether from the annual budget or from supplemental budgets. Column 5 – Indicate the total appropriation (Column 3 + Column 4). Column 6 – Indicate the current year’s allotment released in the previous quarters and prior years’ unobligated allotment. The prior years’ unobligated allotment and obligations shall be shown separately for full disclosure. Column 7 – Indicate the allotment released during the quarter being reported. Column 8 – Indicate the total allotment released as of end of the quarter being reported (Column 6 + Column 7). Column 9 - Indicate the unreleased appropriation as of end of the quarter being reported (Column 5 – Column 8). Column 10 – Indicate the current year obligations incurred in the previous quarters as recorded in the Registry of Appropriations, Allotment and Obligation (RAAO). Column 11 – Indicate the obligations incurred during the quarter being reported as recorded in the RAAO. 206 Column 12 – Indicate the total obligations incurred as of end of the quarter being reported (Column 10 + Column 11). Column 13 – Indicate the unobligated allotment which should tally with the balance shown in the Statement of Allotments, Obligations, and Balances as of end of the quarter being reported (Column 8 – Column 12). Column 14 – Identify other relevant information for which no appropriate column is provided. Note: This report shall be submitted directly to the LFC on or before the 10th day of the month following the quarter being reported. __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 207 LBAc Form No. 3 QUARTERLY PHYSICAL REPORT OF OPERATIONS For the Quarter Ending ___________ Department/Office: ______________________ PPA Code (1) Target Output Major Final Output Performance Indicator (2) (3) Actual Performance 1st Quarter 2nd Quarter 3rd Quarter 4th Quarter Total 1st Quarter 2nd Quarter 3rd Quarter 4th Quarter Total Variance as of (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) Prepared by: _______________________ Department/Office Head Date: __________________ Remarks ________ ______________________________ Local Planning and Development Coordinator Date: __________________ Instructions: Column 1 – Indicate the code assigned to the PPA as reflected in the AIP. Column 2 – Identify the goods and services that a Department/Office is mandated to deliver to external clients through the implementation of the PPA. Column 3 – Indicate the predetermined measure of the results of an PPA against a standard of performance required to achieve set policy objectives within a given period. Columns 4 to 8 – Indicate the annual target output with quarterly breakdown. The total of which (Column 8) shall be consistent with LBE Form No. 5 (Summary of Financial and Physical Performance Targets). Columns 9 to 13 – Indicate the quarterly actual performances and cumulative performance of a given quarter. Column 14 – Indicate the total variance between the actual performances versus target outputs as of the quarter covered by the report. Column 15 – Indicate the relevant information/reasons/justifications for increase or decrease in actual performance vs target output as of the quarter covered by the report. Note: This report shall be prepared by each Department/Office Head, in coordination with the LPDC, and submitted to the LFC or before the 10th day of the month following the quarter reported. 208 (15) LBAc Form No. 4 STATEMENT OF RECEIPTS AND EXPENDITURES For the Fiscal Year Ending __________ Local Government Unit: ________________________ Particulars (1) I. Beginning Cash Balance Account Code (2) Amounts Estimate (3) Actual (4) Variance Amounts (5) % (6) Remarks (7) II. Receipts: A. Local Sources 1. Tax Revenue a. Real Property Tax (RPT) i. Basic RPT b. Business Tax c. Other Local Taxes Total Tax Revenue 2. Non-Tax Revenue a. Regulatory Fees b. Service/User Charges c. Receipts from Economic Enterprises c. Other Receipts Total Non-Tax Revenue Total Local Sources B. External Sources 1. National Tax Allotment (formerly Internal Revenue Allotment) 2. Share from GOCCs 3. Other Share from National Tax Collection a. Share from Ecozone b. Share from EVAT c. Share from National Wealth d. Share from Tobacco Excise Tax 4. Extraordinary Receipts/Grants/Donations/ Aids 5. Inter-Local Transfers Total External Sources C. Non-Income Receipts 1. Capital Investment Receipts a. Proceeds from Sale of Assets b. Proceeds from Sale of Debt Securities of Other Entities c. Collection of Loans Receivable Total Capital Investment Receipts 2. Receipts from Loans and Borrowings a. Acquisition of Loans b. Issuance of Bonds Total Receipts from Loans and Borrowing 3. Other Non-Income Receipts Total Non-Income Receipts Total Receipts 209 Particulars Account Code (1) (2) Amounts Estimate Actual (3) (4) Variance Amounts % (5) (6) Remarks (7) III. Expenditures A. General Public Services B. Economic Services C. Social Services D. Other Services Total Expenditure Prepared by: _______________________ Local Treasurer Date: _________________ _______________________ Local Budget Officer Date: _________________ Certified Correct by: Approved by: _______________________ Local Accountant Date: __________________ _______________________ Local Chief Executive Date: __________________ Instructions: Column 1 – Indicate the details of the income/receipts and expenditures. Beginning cash balance shall be net of amounts earmarked for specific purposes (e.g., continuing appropriations, 20% Development Fund, payables, others [restricted funds]). Column 2 – Indicate the account code using the Revise Chart of Accounts for LGUs. Column 3 – Indicate the estimated income/receipts and expenditures for the fiscal year being reported. Column 4 – Indicate the actual income/receipts and expenditures for the fiscal year being reported. Column 5 - Indicate the difference between the estimated and actual income/receipts and expenditures for the fiscal year reported (Column 3 – Column 2). Column 6 – Indicate the variance expressed in percentage (Column 5 / Column 3). Column 7 – Indicate other relevant information/reasons/justifications for increase or decrease in actual vis-à-vis target receipts and expenditures. Note: This report shall be prepared by the Local Treasurer and LBO, certified correct by the Local Accountant, and submitted to the LCE within thirty (30) days from the end of the fiscal year. The LBO shall furnish the DBM a copy of the report, through its Regional Office, within the same period. 210 LBAc Form No. 5 PHYSICAL AND FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE EVALUATION FORM As of the ____ Semester Ending ______ Department/Office: ______________________ PPA Code (1) PPA Description/ Major Final Output (2) PHYSICAL PERFORMANCE Target Output Actual Output (3) (4) Variance % of Accomplishment Allotment Released (5) = (4) –(3) (6) = (4) / (3) (7) FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE Actual Obligations Variance Incurred (8) (9) = (8) - (7) Absorptive Capacity (10) = (8) / (7) TOTAL Prepared by: Local Finance Committee _____________________________________ Local Planning and Development Coordinator Date: ___________________ _________________ Local Budget Officer Date: ___________ ________________ Local Treasurer Date: ____________ Instructions: Column 1 – Indicate the code assigned to the PPA as reflected in the AIP. Column 2 – Indicate the MFOs of various PPA of the Department/Office. Column 3 – Indicate the target output for the semester reported. Column 4 – Indicate the actual output for the semester reported. Column 5 – Indicate the difference between Columns 4 and 3. Column 6 – Indicate the physical accomplishment expressed in percentage (Column 4 / Column 3). Column 7 – Indicate the allotment released for the Department/Office for the semester being reported. Column 8 – Indicate the actual obligations incurred as reflected in the Registry of Appropriations, Allotments and Obligations for the semester being reported. Column 9 – Indicate the difference between Columns 8 and 7. Column 10 – Indicate the financial accomplishment expressed in percentage (Column 8 / Column 7) Note: This report shall be prepared by the LFC and submitted to the LCE within thirty (30) days after the end of each semester. 211 LBAc Form No. 6* [LGU Name] Monitoring of Physical and Financial Accomplishments FY _______ Plan/PPAs (1) Target Output AIP Reference Code Implementing Office/ Department AIP AB (2) (3) (4) (5) Actual Accomplishment/s (6) Estimated Cost AIP AB (7) (8) Actual Expenditures Remarks (9) (10) GAD Plan and Budget 1. PPA 1 2. PPA 2 Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Plan 1. PPA 1 2. PPA 2 Local Climate Change Action Plan 1. PPA 1 2. PPA 2 List of PPAs for the Local Council for the Protection of Children 1. PPA 1 2. PPA 2 List of PPAs for Senior Citizens and Persons with Disabilities 1. PPA 1 2. PPA 2 Peace and Order Plan 1. PPA 1 2. PPA 2 List of PPAs to Combat Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome 1. PPA 1 2. PPA 2 Other Reports/Plan as required by DILG/DBM issuances 1. PPA 1 2. PPA 2 Prepared by: Approved by: ____________________________________ Local Planning and Development Coordinator ________________ Local Chief Executive 212 Instructions: Column 1 – Indicate the programs, projects and activities identified/mainstreamed for each plan (e.g. GAD, LDRMMF, etc.). Column 2 - Indicate the AIP Reference Code. Column 3 – Indicate the Implementing Office/Department per PPA. Column 4 – Indicate the target output as indicated in the AIP. Column 5 – Indicate the target output for the specific PPA as reflected in the Annual Budget. Column 6 – Indicate the actual accomplishment/s for the year reported. Column 7 – Indicate the amount for the specific PPA as reflected in the AIP. Column 8 – Indicate the amount for the specific PPA as reflected in the Annual Budget. Column 9 – Indicate the actual expenditures incurred for the year reported. Column 10 – Indicate other relevant information such as status of the implementation and reasons for the delay, if any. __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 213 PART III: ALLOCATIONS TO LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS The 1973 Constitution laid down the principle of local autonomy based on self-reliance. The enactment of the 1987 Constitution marked more resolute efforts towards the attainment of the nation’s dream of genuine and meaningful local autonomy. Section 2, Article X of the 1987 Constitution provides that, “[t]he territorial and political subdivisions shall enjoy local autonomy.” This Constitutional mandate is embodied in the LGC, which provides for the establishment of a more responsive and accountable government structure instituted through a system of decentralization. Effective sharing of political and administrative powers between the national and local governments, on the other hand, is anchored, in part, on the equitable diffusion of national tax among the different levels of government as well as the sharing of proceeds from the development of national wealth and other special shares with the inhabitants of a particular community by the way of direct benefits. This part of the Manual delves into the provisions of law as well as the procedures set forth by different issuances by which LGUs may effectively access the different allocations to LGUs. 214 CHAPTER 1. NATIONAL TAX ALLOTMENT (FORMERLY INTERNAL REVENUE ALLOTMENT) The NTA, formerly known as IRA, refers to the shares of LGUs from the national taxes equivalent to 40% of the total annual revenue collection of the 3rd year preceding the current fiscal year which is released directly without the need for any further action, to the provincial, city, municipal, or barangay treasurer, as the case may be. 1.1 Legal Bases Section 6, Article X, General Provisions of the 1987 Philippine Constitution provides that LGUs shall have a just share, as determined by law, in the national taxes which shall be automatically released to them. Section 284 of the LGC provides that LGUs shall have forty percent (40%) share in the national internal revenue taxes (NIRT) based on the collection of the third fiscal year preceding the current fiscal year. Sections 18 and 286 of the LGC and Articles 383 and 390 of its IRR provide that the share of LGUs shall be automatically and directly released to the provincial, city, municipal, or barangay treasurer without the need for any further action, and shall not be subject to any lien or holdback that may be imposed by the national government (NG). Section 4 of RA No. 9358, appropriating a supplemental budget for FY 2006, provides, among others, that the IRA/NTA is considered automatically appropriated which means that the same need not pass through congressional approval before it is released to the LGUs. This provision of the law makes the release of NTA shares more predictable and allows LGUs to plan/program the use of their NTA fund more effectively. 1.2 Supreme Court Ruling on the Mandanas-Garcia Case Background The SC Ruling on the Mandanas-Garcia Case refers to the SC’s final decision on the two (2) separate petitions filed before the SC: (1) the petition filed by Congressman Hermilando I. Mandanas and other local officials vs Executive Secretary Paquito N. Ochoa, Jr., et al. (G.R. No. 199802, April 10, 2019); and (2) Congressman Enrique T. Garcia, Jr. vs Executive Secretary Paquito N. Ochoa, Jr., et al. (G.R. No. 208488, April 10, 2019). Both petitions challenged the manner in which the NG computed the IRA shares of LGUs. In particular, the petitioners pleaded with the SC to mandate the NG to compute the IRA based on the “just shares” of the LGUs. In its July 3, 2018 Decision, the SC granted the Mandanas-Garcia petitions, declaring as unconstitutional the phrase “internal revenue” appearing in Section 284 of the LGC. As such, the SC ordered the deletion of the said phrase. 215 The SC ruled that the determination of the just share of the LGUs should not be based solely on NIRT but on all national taxes. The SC also ruled that any mention of “internal revenue allotment” in the LGC shall be understood as pertaining to the allotment of the LGUs derived from the national taxes. It further ordered the Secretaries of Finance and Budget and Management, Commissioners of Internal Revenue and Customs, as well as the National Treasurer to include all collections of national taxes in the computation of the base of the just share of the LGUs, based on the ratio provided in the nowmodified Section 284 of the LGC. The SC Ruling became final and executory on April 10, 2019, affirming its earlier decision promulgated in July 3, 2018. Following the SC ruling, the IRA, referred to as the NTA, now covers the share of LGUs in all national taxes. National Taxes include the following: Income tax; Estate tax and donor’s tax; Value-added tax (VAT); Other percentage taxes; Taxes imposed by special laws, such as travel tax; Customs duties; and Taxes and duties by other collecting agencies. Moreover, since the SC Resolution declared unconstitutional the phrase “internal revenue” appearing in pertinent sections of the LGC, the nomenclature in lieu of the term “Internal Revenue Allotment” shall be “National Tax Allotment” starting FY 2022 General Appropriations Act (GAA). Impact of the Supreme Court Ruling on the Mandanas-Garcia Case The impact of the SC decision significantly increased the tax base on which the share of the LGUs is computed from, thus, strengthening fiscal decentralization. It clarifies the distinction between “national internal revenue taxes” and “national taxes” as the base in the computation of the IRA of LGUs. NIRT includes only taxes collected by the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) while “National taxes,” consists of all taxes and duties collected by the NG through the BIR, the Bureau of Customs (BOC), and other collecting agencies. Implications of the Supreme Court Ruling on the National Government and the Local Government Units The significant increase in the shares of LGUs presents a unique opportunity for the LGUs to assume the functions that have been devolved to them under the LGC and other subsequent and pertinent laws. 216 1.3 Distribution of Shares Pursuant to Section 285 of the LGC and Article 382 (a) of its IRR, the just share of LGUs in the national taxes is allocated in the following manner for the four (4) levels of LGUs: Provinces Cities Municipalities Barangays - Twenty-three percent (23%) Twenty-three percent (23%) Thirty-four percent (34%) Twenty percent (20%) Figure 15. NTA Share per LGU Level The distribution of the shares of individual provinces, cities, and municipalities is based on the following formula prescribed in Section 285 of the LGC: Table 15. Distribution of NTA Shares Formula Factor Population Sharing (%) 50% Basis Based on the Census of Population conducted by the Philippine Statistics Authority every five (5) years as approved by the President through a proclamation Land Area 25% Based on the Masterlist of land area prepared by the Land Management Bureau of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) Equal Sharing Total 25% 100% 217 The issuance of RA No. 11683 amended Section 450 of the LGC which provides for the portability of the NTA of a newly-converted city. The said NTA portability provides that the newly converted city shall bring its latest NTA as a municipality to the allotment of cities. The total share of the cities plus the amount equal to the newly converted city’s most recent NTA share as a municipality shall be allocated to cities based on population, land area, and equal sharing as prescribed in Section 285 of the LGC. Moreover, the remaining municipal shares shall also be allocated to the municipalities in the same manner. The said portability shall be effective for a period of three (3) years, upon the effectivity of the conversion into cityhood. In the case of barangays, the allocation of the individual share, shall be P80,000 for each barangay with a population of not less than one hundred (100) inhabitants. The balance to be distributed shall be based on population - 60% and equal sharing - 40%. 1.4 Uses of the Fund Pursuant to Section 17 of the LGC, the fund shall be used to provide for basic services and facilities, particularly those which have been devolved by the NG. Section 287 of the LGC and Article 384 of its IRR direct LGUs to set aside no less than twenty percent (20%) of its annual NTA to fund development projects as identified in the LGUs’ development plans. The DBM, DOF, and DILG issued JMC No. 1 dated November 4, 202097 to increase the responsiveness of the guidelines and promote greater autonomy, transparency, and accountability in LGUs’ appropriation and utilization of their respective twenty percent (20%) DF, as provided under the LGC. Essentially, the said JMC no longer prescribes the specific allowable development projects that may be funded by the LGUs out of their respective 20% DFs. Instead, said JMC sets the general policies and guidelines to be observed by LGUs in identifying and implementing development projects to be funded under the 20% DF, including the prescription of the prohibited expenditure items enumerated below: a. PS expenditures, such as salaries, wages, overtime pay, and other personnel benefits; b. Administrative expenses, such as supplies, meals, representation, communication, water and electricity, petroleum products, and the like; 97 Revised Guidelines on the Appropriation and Utilization of the Twenty Percent (20%) of the Annual Internal Revenue Allotment for Development Projects 218 c. Travelling expenses, whether domestic or foreign; d. Registration fees and other expenses related to the conduct of and participation in training, seminars, conferences or conventions; e. Purchase, maintenance or repair of administrative office’ furniture, fixtures, equipment or appliances; and f. Purchase, maintenance or repair of motor vehicles used for administrative purposes. 1.5 It must be noted that one important provision of the JMC is the policy that the development projects that may be included by the LGUs under their respective 20% DFs shall be those that are necessary, appropriate, or incidental to the efficient and effective local governance, and those which are essential to the promotion of the general welfare of the people, which is anchored on Section 16 of the LGC. Lastly, Item 6.0 of the DBM-DOF-DILG JMC No. 1, s. 2020 provides that the LGUs shall prepare quarterly reports on the utilization of the 20% DF, consistent with the reporting requirements prescribed by the DOF-BLGF. Fund Release Procedures The release of the NTA shares of LGUs follows these procedures: a. For budget preparation purposes, the BIR, BOC, and the Bureau of the Treasury (BTr) submit certifications on the LGU shares from the actual collections of national taxes to the DBM which is equivalent to forty percent (40%) of the total annual revenue collection of the third fiscal year preceding the current fiscal year; b. The DBM programs the equivalent amount of NTA in the National Expenditure Program. Based on the certifications issued by the BIR, BOC, and BTr, the DBM computes the individual share of each LGU using the codal formula, and informs the beneficiary LGUs of their respective NTA shares through a Local Budget Memorandum issued not later than June 15 of the current fiscal year for the purpose; c. At the beginning of the year, the DBM prepares and releases comprehensively the corresponding release documents to the BTr; d. The BTr, in turn downloads the fund through the issuance of Authority to Debit Account to the Authorized Government Servicing Bank (AGSBs), which credits the shares of the beneficiary LGUs to their respective accounts. 219 CHAPTER 2. SHARE IN THE UTILIZATION AND DEVELOPMENT OF NATIONAL WEALTH 2.1 Legal Bases Sections 289 and 290 of the LGC and Articles 386 and 387 of its IRR provide that the LGUs are entitled to forty percent (40%) of the gross collection by the NG from the preceding fiscal year out of the proceeds derived from the utilization and development of national wealth within the LGUs’ respective areas. The following are the four (4) types of national wealth with the corresponding collecting agency: Table 16. Types of National Wealth with Corresponding Collecting Agency Particulars Forest Charges Royalty Income from Mineral Reservation Energy Resources Production Mining Taxes Collecting Agency DENR DENR-Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) Department of Energy (DOE) BIR LGUs shall also have a share from proceeds derived by any government agency or GOCC engaged in the utilization and development of the national wealth based on the following formula whichever will produce a higher share for the LGU: 2.2 One percent (1%) of the gross sales or receipts of the preceding calendar year; or Forty percent (40%) of the mining taxes, royalties, forestry, energy resources production, and such other taxes, fees and charges, including interests and fines the government agency or GOCC would have paid if it were not otherwise exempt (Section 291 of the LGC and Article 388 of its IRR). Distribution of Shares Pursuant to Section 292 of the LGC and Article 389 of its IRR, the distribution of LGU shares from national wealth shall be as follows: Where the natural resources are located in the province, the province will have a share of 20%, the component city/municipality, 45%; and the barangay, 35%. Where the natural resources are located in a HUC/ICC, the city will have a share of 65%, and the barangay, 35%. However, where natural resources are located in two (2) or more cities, the allocation of shares shall be computed on the basis of population (70%) and land area (30%). 220 Figure 16. Distribution of Shares from National Wealth Figure 17. Distribution of Shares from National Wealth (where the natural resources are located in the province) (where the natural resources are located in HUC or ICC) 2.3 Uses of the Fund LGU share from proceeds of national wealth shall be used to finance local development and livelihood projects of the recipient LGU. In the case of proceeds derived from the development and utilization of hydrothermal, geothermal and other sources of energy, eighty percent (80%) of the proceeds shall be applied solely to lower the cost of electricity in the LGU where such source of energy is located (Section 294 of the LGC and Article 391 of its IRR). In the case of any government agency or GOCCs engaged in the utilization and development of the national wealth, such share shall be directly remitted by the government agency/GOCC concerned to the provincial, city, municipal, or barangay treasurer within five (5) days after the end of each quarter (Section 293 of the LGC and Article 390 [c] of its IRR). 2.4 Fund Release Procedures DBM-DOF-DENR-DOE JC No. 2006-1 dated February 13, 2006,98 DOF-DBMDILG-DENR JC No. 2009-1 dated March 31, 2009,99 DENR-DOF-DBM-DILG JC No. 2010-1 dated June 25, 2010,100 and DOF-DBM JC 2016-1 dated January 4, 2016101 prescribe the guidelines and procedures for the release of LGU shares in the proceeds from the utilization and development of national wealth, summarized as follows: 98 Revised Guidelines and Procedures on the Release of the Share of [LGUs] in the Proceeds from the Development and Utilization of National Wealth 99 Updated Guidelines and Procedures on the Release of the Share of Local Government Units from the Collections Derived by the National Government from Mining Taxes 100 Share of Local Governments Derived by the National Government from Royalty Income Collected from Mineral Reservations 101 Guidelines for the Direct Release of Funds by the Bureau of the Treasury (BTr) to Local Government Units (LGUs) in FY 2016 and Thereafter 221 a. The collecting agencies, i.e., BIR, DENR, DENR-MGB, and DOE, submit to DBM a certification of the projected total shares of LGUs based on the immediately preceding year’s collections as basis for provision of appropriations cover; b. During budget execution, the collecting agencies and BTr submit to DBM a reconciled certification on actual collections and actual remittances from the immediately preceding year; c. Based on the reconciled certification/s submitted by the collecting agencies and BTr, the DBM prepares and releases the corresponding release documents to the BTr; and d. The BTr, in turn, downloads the fund through the issuance of Authority to Debit Account to the AGSBs, which credits the shares of the beneficiary LGUs to their respective accounts. 222 CHAPTER 3. SHARE IN THE GROSS INCOME TAXES PAID BY ALL BUSINESSES AND ENTERPRISES WITHIN THE SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONES 3.1 Legal Bases RA No. 7922, entitled, “An Act Establishing a Special Economic Zone and Free Port in the Municipality of Santa Ana and the Neighboring Islands in the Municipality of Aparri, Province of Cagayan, Providing Funds Therefor, and for Other Purposes;” and DBM-DOF Joint Circular No. 2 dated August 7, 2014.102 (Note: The other shares of LGUs in ECOZONEs, such as those specified under RA No. 7227, are already remitted to the beneficiary LGUs pursuant to RA No. 9400.)103 3.2 Computation of Shares LGUs within the Cagayan Special Economic Zone (CSEZ) are entitled to a share in the five percent (5%) final tax on Gross Income Earned (GIE) paid by registered enterprises within the CSEZ, as follows: 3.3 One percent (1%) to the Province of Cagayan; and One-half percent (1/2%) to be shared by the municipalities affected by the declaration of the CSEZ in proportion to their income from business activities within the CSEZ. Uses of the Fund The shares of LGUs from the final tax on GIE paid by registered enterprises within the CSEZ shall be used for local development projects. 3.4 Fund Release Procedures The following procedures are applied in releasing the shares of LGUs in the gross income taxes paid by all businesses and enterprises within the ECOZONES: a. For budget preparation purposes, the BIR submits to the DBM on or before March 15 of every year a certification on the total computed LGU shares based on the actual revenue collections corresponding to thirty percent (30%) of the total final tax collected on GIE for the base year, which is two (2) years immediately preceding the current year; 102 Guidelines and Procedures on the Release of the Shares of Local Government Units from the Gross Income Earned by All Businesses within the Cagayan Special Economic Zone for FY 2012 and Subsequent Years 103 An Act Amending Republic Act No. 7227, as amended, Otherwise Known as the Bases Conversion and Development Act of 1992, and for Other Purposes 223 b. During budget execution, the BIR and BTr submit reconciled certification/s of actual collections and remittances to the DBM; c. Based on the reconciled certification/s submitted by the BIR and BTr, the DBM prepares and releases the corresponding release documents to the BTr; and d. The BTr, in turn, downloads the fund through the issuance of Authority to Debit Account to the AGSBs, which credits the shares of the beneficiary LGUs to their respective accounts. 224 CHAPTER 4. SHARE IN VALUE-ADDED TAX 4.1 Legal Bases VAT is the internal revenue tax imposed under Sections 106 and 108 of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) of 1997, as amended by RA No. 10963. In addition to its NTA shares, RA No. 7643 allows LGUs to share from VAT revenues equivalent to fifty percent (50%) of the excess in VAT collection from the immediately preceding year, to be distributed as follows: Twenty percent (20%) to the city/municipality; and Eighty percent (80%) to the national government. DBM-DOF-DILG Joint Circular No. 1-02 dated February 6, 2002104 prescribes the guidelines and procedures on the release of the twenty percent (20%) of the fifty percent (50%) share of LGUs in the incremental collection VAT. 4.2 Computation of Shares LGUs are entitled to a share in VAT only when there is an incremental collection from VAT which refers to the excess in the annual increase in actual collection of VAT in the immediately preceding year over the annual increase in the second preceding year, illustrated as follows: Year VAT Collection (in Php) Increase (in Php) 2023 2022 2021 64.55M 43.383M 23.886 M 20.972 M 19.700 M - Formula for the distribution of LGUs’ share in the Incremental Collection from VAT: 2023 increase in collection Less: 2022 increase in collection Excess of increase in collection 50% share in incremental collection Distributed as follows: 20% share of LGUs (city/municipality) 80% share of national government P 20.972 M P 19.700 M P 1.272 M P 0.636 M P 0.127 M P 0.509 M P 0.636 M 104 Guidelines and Procedures on the Release of the Twenty Percent (20%) of the Fifty Percent (50%) Share of Local Government Share of Local Government Units (LGUs) in the Incremental Collection from Value-Added Tax (VAT) 225 Figure 18. Formula for the Computation of LGUs' VAT Shares 4.3 Uses of the Fund Consistent with Section 21 of RA No. 9337 which amended Section 288 of the NIRC of 1997, fifty percent (50%) of the share from the incremental revenue from the VAT shall be allocated and used exclusively for the following purposes: Fifteen percent (15%) for public elementary and secondary education, to finance the construction of buildings, purchases of school furniture, and in-service teacher training; Ten percent (10%) for health insurance premiums of enrolled indigents as a counterpart contribution of the local government to sustain the universal coverage of the national health insurance program; Fifteen percent (15%) for environmental conservation to fully implement a comprehensive national reforestation program; and Ten percent (10%) for agricultural modernization to finance the construction of farm-to-market roads and irrigation facilities. 226 Such allocations shall be segregated as separate trust funds by the national treasury and shall be over and above the annual appropriation for similar purposes. 4.4 Fund Release Procedures The following procedures are applied in releasing the VAT shares of LGUs: a. For budget preparation purposes, the BIR submits to DBM a certification of estimated revenue collections corresponding to twenty percent (20%) of the fifty percent (50%) of the incremental collection from VAT collections; b. During budget execution, the BIR submits to DBM a certification of actual revenue collections corresponding to twenty percent (20%) of the fifty percent (50%) of the incremental collection from VAT collections; c. Based on the certification submitted by the BIR, the DBM prepares and releases the corresponding release documents to the BTr; and d. The BTr, in turn, downloads the fund through the issuance of Authority to Debit Account to the AGSBs, which credits the shares of the beneficiary LGUs to their respective accounts. 227 CHAPTER 5. SHARE IN TOBACCO EXCISE TAXES 5.1 Legal Bases 5.1.1 RA No. 7171, entitled, “An Act to Promote the Development of Farmers in the Virginia Tobacco Producing Provinces;” 5.1.2 RA No. 8240, as amended by RA No. 10351, entitled, “An Act Restructuring the Excise Tax on Alcohol and Tobacco Products by Amending Sections 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 8, 131 and 288 of RA No. 8424, Otherwise Known as the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as Amended by RA No. 9334, and for Other Purposes;” 5.1.3 RA No. 11346, entitled, “An Act Increasing the Excise Tax on Tobacco Products, Imposing Excise Tax on Heated Tobacco Products and Vapor Products, Increasing the Penalties for Violations of Provisions on Articles Subject to Excise Tax, and Earmarking a Portion of the Total Excise Tax Collection from Sugar-Sweetened Beverages, Alcohol, Tobacco, Heated Tobacco and Vapor Products for Universal Health Care, Amending for this Purpose Sections 144, 145, 146, 147, 152, 164, 260, 262, 263, 265, 288, and 289, Repealing Section 288(B) and 288(C), and Creating New Sections 263-A, 265-B, and 288-A of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as Amended by Republic Act No. 10963, and for Other Purposes;” 5.1.4 Department of Agriculture (DA)-DBM-National Tobacco Administration JMC No. 2020-1 dated June 25, 2020, entitled, “Guidelines on the Allocation, Release, and Utilization of the Shares of Local Government Units (LGUs) from the Revenues from Excise Taxes on Tobacco Products Pursuant to Republic Act (RA) No. 8240, as amended by RA No. 10351, and as further amended by RA No. 11346, and Collections from the Proceeds of the Excise Taxes on Locally Manufactured Virginia-Type Cigarettes Pursuant to RA No. 7171, as incorporated in RA No. 8424, as amended;” and 5.1.5 Memorandum Circular (MC) No. 61-A dated November 28, 1993, entitled “Amending Memorandum Circular No. 61 Prescribing the Guidelines for the Implementation of RA No. 7171 dated January 9, 1992.” 5.2 Computation of Shares of LGUs 5.2.1 Excise Taxes on Locally Manufactured Virginia-Type Cigarettes under RA No. 7171, as amended a. The fund equivalent to fifteen percent (15%) of the collections from the proceeds of the excise taxes on locally manufactured Virginiatype cigarettes, but not exceeding Seventeen Billion Pesos (Php 17 Billion), shall be computed based on the actual collections, as certified by the BIR, for the second calendar year preceding the year of distribution, as appropriated in the GAA; and 228 b. National Tobacco Administration-certified list of qualified tobaccoproducing LGUs and their corresponding volume of production (in kilograms) for the second year preceding the year of distribution. 5.2.2 Burley and Native Tobacco Excise Taxes Pursuant to RA No. 8240, as amended a. The fund equivalent to five percent (5%) of the revenues collected from excise tax on tobacco products pursuant to RA No. 8240, as amended by RA No. 10351, and as further amended by RA No. 11346, but not exceeding Four Billion Pesos (Php 4 Billion), shall be computed based on actual collections, as certified by the BIR for the second calendar year preceding the year of distribution, as appropriated in the GAA; and b. National Tobacco Administration-certified list of qualified tobaccoproducing LGUs and their corresponding volume of production (in kilograms) for the second year preceding the year of distribution. 5.3 Uses of the Fund 5.3.1 Shares of LGUs from the Collection of Excise Tax on Locally Manufactured Virginia-Type Cigarettes under RA No. 7171, as amended by RA No. 11346 Cooperative projects that will enhance better quality of products, increase productivity, guarantee the market and as a whole increase farmers’ income; Livelihood projects particularly the development of alternative farming systems to enhance farmers’ income; Agro-industrial projects that will enable tobacco farmers in the Virginia tobacco-producing provinces to be involved in the management and subsequent ownership of these projects such as post-harvest and secondary processing like cigarette manufacturing and by-product utilization; Infrastructure projects such as farm-to-market roads, bridges, schools, hospitals, rural health facilities, and irrigation systems; Programs and projects that will promote, enhance, and develop the tourism potential of Virginia tobacco-growing provinces; and Programs that will provide financial assistance for tobacco farmers that were displaced or who cease to produce tobacco. 229 5.3.2 Shares of LGUs from the Collection of Burley and Native Tobacco Excise Tax Pursuant to RA No. 8240, as amended by RA No. 11346 5.4 Programs that will provide inputs, training, and other support for tobacco farmers who shift to production of agricultural products other than tobacco including, but not limited to, high-value crops, spices, rice, corn, sugarcane, coconut, livestock and fisheries; Programs that will provide financial support for tobacco farmers who are displaced or who cease to produce tobacco; Cooperative programs to assist tobacco farmers in planting alternative crops or implementing other livelihood projects; Livelihood programs and projects that will promote, enhance, and develop the tourism potential of tobacco-growing provinces; Infrastructure projects such as farm-to-market roads, bridges, schools, hospitals, rural health facilities, and irrigation systems; and Agro-industrial projects that will enable tobacco farmers to be involved in the management and subsequent ownership of projects, such as post-harvest and secondary processing like cigarette manufacturing and by-product utilization. Fund Release Procedures The following procedures are applied in releasing the shares of LGUs from tobacco excise taxes: a. The BIR submits to DBM on or before April 15 the estimated collection and the shares of the LGUs from tobacco excise tax for purposes of providing appropriations cover; b. During budget execution, the DA endorses and submits a National Tobacco Administration-certified list of beneficiary tobacco-producing LGUs and their corresponding volume of production (in kilograms) for the second year preceding the year of distribution to serve as basis for determining the respective shares of beneficiary LGUs; c. Based on the National Tobacco Administration-certified list of beneficiary tobacco-LGUs and their corresponding volume of tobacco production, as endorsed and submitted by the DA, the DBM computes the individual share of the beneficiary LGUs, and releases the corresponding release documents to the BTr; and d. The BTr, in turn, downloads the fund through the issuance of Authority to Debit Account to the AGSBs, which credits the shares of the beneficiary LGUs to their respective accounts. 230 5.5 Treatment of the Shares Pursuant to item 2.4 of the DA-DBM-National Tobacco Administration JMC No. 2020-1 dated June 25, 2020,105 the shares of the beneficiary LGUs from tobacco excise taxes shall be treated as a special account under the general fund of the LGUs, to be utilized exclusively for programs and projects pursuant to Sections 14 and 16 of RA No. 11346 and its guidelines. 105 Guidelines on the Allocation, Release, and Utilization of the Shares of Local Government Units (LGUs) from the Revenues from Excise Taxes on Tobacco Products Pursuant to Republic Act (RA) No. 8240, as Amended by RA No. 10351, and as Further Amended by RA No. 11346, and Collections from the Proceeds of the Excise Taxes on Locally Manufactured Virginia-Type Cigarettes Pursuant to RA No. 7171, as Incorporated in RA No. 8424, as Amended 231 PART IV – SPECIAL FUNDS CHAPTER 1. SPECIAL EDUCATION FUND 1.1 Legal Bases The Special Education Fund (SEF) is one of the special funds that shall be maintained in every provincial, city, or municipal treasury. The SEF arises from the proceeds of the additional one percent (1%) real property tax which shall be in addition to the basic real property tax. Section 309 (a) of the LGC provides that the SEF “shall consist of the respective shares of provinces, cities, municipalities and barangays in the proceeds of the additional tax on real property to be appropriated for purposes prescribed in Section 272 of [the LGC].” Section 272 of the LGC also provides that proceeds from the additional one percent (1%) tax on real property accruing to the SEF shall be automatically released to the Local School Boards (LSBs). In the case of provinces, the proceeds shall be divided equally between the provincial and municipal school boards. Likewise, the same section also provides that the SEF shall be allocated to the following: a. b. c. d. e. f. Operation and maintenance of public schools; Construction and repair of school buildings; Facilities and equipment; Educational research; Purchase of books and periodicals; and Sports development. Further, Section 100 (c) of the same law provides that the annual school board budget shall give priority to the following: a. Construction, repair, and maintenance of school buildings and other facilities of public elementary and secondary schools; b. Establishment and maintenance of extension classes where necessary; and c. Sports activities at the division, district, municipal, and barangay levels. Section 7 (b) of RA No. 10410, otherwise known as the "Early Years Act of 2013", provides that LGUs shall include allocations from their SEF for the Early Childhood Care and Development (ECCD) Program. 232 1.2 Policy Guidelines The implementing guidelines on the utilization of the SEF are clarified in the following Joint Circulars (JCs) issued by the Department of Education (DepEd), DBM, DILG: 1.3 JC No. 1, s. 2017 dated January 19, 2017, entitled, “Revised Guidelines on the Use of the Special Education Fund (SEF);” JC No. 1, s. 2020 dated August 27, 2020, entitled, “Addendum to DepEdDBM-DILG JC No. 1, s. 2017 dated January 19, 2017, entitled, “Revised Guidelines on the Use of the Special Education Fund (SEF)””; and JC No. 2, s. 2020 dated October 23, 2020, entitled, “Addendum No. 2 [Clarification to DepEd-DBM-DILG JC No. 1, series of 2017 dated January 19, 2017, entitled, “Revised Guidelines on the Use of the Special Education Fund (SEF).” Allowable Expenses Chargeable against the SEF In all instances, the allocation for the following expenditure items chargeable against the SEF shall be net of the budgetary provision for the same or related item(s) in the budget for the DepEd and the ECCD Council, as may be determined by the LSB, and that which may be funded out of the Special Purpose Funds: 1.3.1 Operation and maintenance of public schools: 1.3.1.1 Payment of compensation/allowances of teachers locallyhired in elementary and secondary schools identified to have shortages per the teacher deployment analysis of DepEd; the rates of compensation/allowances shall be determined by the LSB based on funds available, but not to exceed the salary schedule being implemented by the LGU concerned: Provided, that for the purpose of hiring teachers chargeable against the SEF, the LSB in each province, city or municipality shall utilize the list found in the Registry of Qualified Applicants (RQA); 1.3.1.2 Payment of salaries/wages of utility workers and security guards hired in public elementary and secondary schools which have not been provided such position in the DepEd budget; 1.3.1.3 Payment of expenses pertaining to the operation of schools, which may include utilities and communication expenses; 1.3.1.4 Payment of compensation/allowances of locally-hired dentists and/or dental aide positions to serve in public elementary and secondary schools; Provided, that the rates 233 of compensation shall be determined by the LSB based on funds available, but not to exceed the salary schedule being implemented by the LGU concerned; Provided further, that the grant of Magna Carta benefits to said personnel shall be subject to the provisions of DBM-Department of Health (DOH) JC No. 1, s. 2012, as amended by DBM-DOH JC No. 1, s. 2016; Provided finally, that for the purpose of hiring dentists and/or dental aides positions chargeable against the SEF, the LSB in each province, city and municipality shall strictly comply with the existing Civil Service laws, rules and regulations; 1.3.1.5 Payment of expenses pertaining to the operation of schools, which may include, but not limited to, utilities, communication expenses, scouting activities (jamboree, camping, hiking, outdoor activities, scout trainings, and instructional drills/exercises) of the Boy Scouts of the Philippines and the Girl Scouts of the Philippines, programs to promote campus journalism, Parents-Teachers Association activities, Student Council Government Activities, and other extra-curricular activities that promote leadership and values as may be provided under the corresponding DepEd issuances. Such expenses may be included in the Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses allocation of schools; 1.3.1.6 Payment of dental supplies and other related expenses pertaining to the operation of dental facilities in public elementary and secondary schools; 1.3.1.7 Establishment of dental facilities, and acquisition of apparatus and/or equipment, subject to the prevailing requirements and specifications set by the DepEd, in consultation with the DOH; 1.3.1.8 Payment of costs and expenses in connection with the acquisition, production, reproduction, and printing of learning materials for the learners such as, self-learning modules, textbooks, activity sheets, and study guides/manuals approved by DepEd; 1.3.1.9 Purchase of external storage devices (compact disc/digital versatile disc, USB storage, and hard drive); 1.3.1.10 Communication expenses such as, but not limited to, landline phone for communication, load (call, text, and data) for mobile phone communication and Wi-Fi connection; 1.3.1.11 Payment of subscription fee for videoconferencing or remote communication tools/application or platforms; 234 1.3.1.12 Payment of honoraria and allowances of locally-hired personnel, trained and qualified tutors or learning facilitators; 1.3.1.13 Training/webinars for teaching and non-teaching personnel, school leaders, parents, learning facilitators, and community education volunteers; 1.3.1.14 Payment of cost and expenses in the distribution and retrieval of learning materials for the learners such as, but not limited to, transportation expenses of DepEd personnel and expenses in the distribution on the retrieval of selflearning modules, and shipment, delivery, and courier services; and 1.3.1.15 Health and Sanitation Expenses: 1.3.2 personal Protective Equipment such as, but not limited to, facemasks, face shields, hand gloves, surgical caps, hats, eye goggles, and hazmat suits; medical devices such as, but thermal/temperature scanners, thermometers; vaccines, vitamins supplements; hand sanitizers, alcohol, disinfectants, anti-bacterial or germicidal soaps, cleaning equipment, bleach, foot bath; and psychosocial first aid, mental and physical examination or check-up for teaching and non-teaching personnel and learners, and medical doctor’s consultation. and not limited to, and digital minerals; and food Construction and repair of school buildings: 1.3.2.1 Construction, repair and maintenance of school buildings and other facilities for public elementary and secondary schools, which are deemed to have shortage of classrooms or of other facilities, as the case may be, per DepEd classroom deployment analysis, subject to existing standards/specifications set by DepEd and/or Department of Public Works and Highways; furthermore, this item shall be given priority in the SEF Budget; 1.3.2.2 Acquisition and titling of school sites; and 235 1.3.2.3 1.3.3 1.3.4 Installation of health areas or facilities such as, but not limited to, school clinics and wash areas. Facilities and equipment: 1.3.3.1 Acquisition of laboratory, technical and similar apparatus, and information technology equipment and corollary supporting services (e.g. internet connection, maintenance, etc.), subject to the prevailing requirements and specifications set by the DepEd; 1.3.3.2 Personal computer, laptop computer, tablet, notebook, and smartphone; 1.3.3.3 Printer, scanner, photocopying machine, and other printing or photocopying equipment and their consumables; 1.3.3.4 Television set, antenna/cable satellite connection, radio with AM/FM channel, two-way radio for remote/off the grid areas; and 1.3.3.5 Primary and secondary batteries, car battery, and solar panel. Educational research: Educational research other than the research subject areas funded in the DepEd budget, subject to the prevailing policies and guidelines of the DepEd. 1.3.5 Purchase of books and periodicals: Purchase of library books and periodicals for the libraries of the different elementary and secondary schools in the province, city, and municipality, and purchase of instructional materials, workbooks and textbooks needed by public elementary and secondary schools, subject to the prevailing policies and guidelines of the DepEd. 1.3.6 Sports development: Expenses for school sports activities at the national, regional, division, district, municipal and barangay levels, as well as for other DepEdrelated activities, subject to the prevailing requirements and specifications set by the DepEd. 1.3.7 Funding for the ECCD Program for the following purposes: 1.3.7.1 Direct services related to the implementation of the ECCD program, such as salaries/allowances of locally-hired Child Development Teachers and/or Day Care Workers, etc.; 236 1.3.8 1.4 1.3.7.2 Organization and support of parent cooperatives to establish community-based ECCD programs; 1.3.7.3 Provision of counterpart funds for the continuing professional development of ECCD public service providers; 1.3.7.4 Provision of facilities for the conduct of the ECCD Program; and 1.3.7.5 Payment of expenses pertaining to the operations of National Child Development Centers, including, but not limited to, utilities (i.e. electricity and water expenses) and communication (i.e. telephone expenses). Funding for the implementation of the National Feeding Program for undernourished children in public day care, kindergarten and elementary schools, particularly for the following purpose (RA No. 11037, DepEd-DBM-DILG JC No. 1, s. 2020): 1.3.8.1 Supplemental Feeding Program for Day Care Children; 1.3.8.2 School-Based Feeding Program; 1.3.8.3 Milk Feeding Program; 1.3.8.4 Micronutrient Supplements; 1.3.8.5 Health Examination, Vaccination, and Deworming; 1.3.8.6 Gulayan sa Paaralan; 1.3.8.7 Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene (WASH); and 1.3.8.8 Integrated Nutrition Education, Behavioral Transformation, and Social Mobilization. Planning and Budgeting for the SEF 1.4.1 Budget Preparation The LSB shall formulate a three-year program indicating strategic prioritization policies in the allocation of the SEF to schools taking into consideration equitable sharing, priority needs and such factors as enrollment ratio, distance of the schools, performance, drop-out rate, and location of schools, as well as the goals and objectives of the LGU's Comprehensive Development Plan (CDP), and the expenditures, programs, projects and activities in the LGU's Local Development Investment Program (LDIP) prior to the formulation and preparation of its Annual Budget for the incoming year. It is understood that the DepEd representative to the LSB shall be responsible for coordinating municipal/city school plans with 237 that of the province and ensuring that the School Improvement Plan (SIP) and the Division Education Development Plan (DEDP) are formulated collaboratively with the stakeholders in the community. Step 1. The budget preparation phase of the SEF starts only after the official issuance by the LFC of the Estimated Proceeds of the Special Levy on Real Property, constituting the SEF, and the criteria set by the DepEd on the annual budgeting needs for the operation and maintenance of public schools. The annual budgetary requirements of public schools shall be based on the DepEd-approved SIP and DEDP in the implementation of ECCD Program, kindergarten, elementary and secondary, formal and non-formal education programs, chargeable to their respective SEFs. Step 2. In accordance with the criteria set by the DepEd, the Local School Board determines the annual supplemental budgetary needs for the operation and maintenance of public schools within the province, city or municipality, as the case may be, and the supplementary local cost of meeting such needs, which shall be reflected in the form of an Annual School Board Budget corresponding to its share of the proceeds of the special levy on real property constituting the SEF (Section 99 [a] of the LGC). Step 3. The division superintendent, city superintendent, or district supervisor, as the case may be, shall prepare the budget of the School Board concerned. Such budget shall be supported by PPAs of the School Board for the ensuing fiscal year (Section 100 [b] of the LGC). The provincial SEF Budget shall, as much as possible, fill the funding gap in the needs of all the public schools covered by the province. Finally, the corollary budget allocation shall be complementary to the budget of the national programs. 1.4.2 Budget Authorization Step 4. The SEF budget prepared by the division superintendent, city superintendent or district supervisor, as the case may be, shall be submitted to the School Board, chaired/co-chaired by the LCE and the division superintendents of schools, for approval. The affirmative vote of the majority of all the members of the LSB shall be necessary to approve the SEF budget, through an LSB Resolution (Section 100 [b] of the LGC). 238 1.4.3 Budget Execution Step 5. The SEF shall be released exclusively for the specific purpose for which they have been allocated in the approved School Board Budget. Step 6. Disbursements shall be made in accordance with the “authority to disburse” issued by the LSB to the provincial, city, and municipal treasurer (Section 99 [b] of the LGC), subject to existing accounting and auditing rules. 1.4.4 Budget Accountability Step 7. A quarterly report of the SEF utilization shall be prepared and submitted by the LSB to the DepEd Regional Offices (ROs), copy furnished the DBM ROs and the DILG ROs. The quarterly reports shall be submitted one (1) week after the end of each quarter. For this purpose, the Report of SEF Utilization shown in SEF Budget Accountability Form No. 1 shall be used (Annex B of DepEd-DBM-DILG JC No. 1, s. 2017). Step 8. The LSB shall post the utilization report of the SEF Budget in the website of the LGU and/or in at least three (3) conspicuous public places for transparency and accountability in compliance with the Full Disclosure Policy of the DILG. 239 CHAPTER 2. SPECIAL HEALTH FUND 2.1 Legal Basis Section 41 (d) of RA No. 11223, otherwise known as the Universal Health Care (UHC) Act, specifies that the LGUs that commit to the integration of local health systems into Province-Wide/City-Wide Health Systems (P/CWHS) shall exhibit managerial integration in the first three (3) years from the enactment of the UHC Act, and financial integration within the next three (3) years thereafter. Section 20 of the same Act provides that all resources intended for health services to finance population-based and individual-based health services, health system operating costs, capital investments, and remuneration of additional health workers and incentives for all health workers shall be pooled to the Special Health Fund (SHF). 2.2 Policy Guidelines The implementing guidelines on the utilization of the SHF was provided in the DOH- DBM- DOF- DILG-Philippine Health Insurance Corporation (PhilHealth) JMC No. 2021-0001 dated January 13, 2021, entitled, “Guidelines on the Allocation, Utilization, and Monitoring of, And Accountability for, the Special Health Fund.” The SHF shall be treated as a separate type of Special Fund by the Province, HUC and ICC levels participating in the P/CWHS, and is deemed automatically appropriated for health expenditures. 2.3 Fund Sources of SHF The fund sources for the SHF shall be as follows, consistent with Section 20.1 of the IRR of the UHC Act: a. Financial grants and subsidies from NGAs, such as the DOH, as included in the GAA in accordance with Section 22 of the IRR of the UHC Act; b. Income from PhilHealth payments as provided under Section 21 of the IRR of the UHC Act; c. Donations and financial grants from CSOs, including faith-based organizations, and official development assistance from the International Health Partners (IHPs); and d. Other fund sources, which may include, among others, provincial, city, and municipal budgets intended for health through a mechanism of cooperative undertakings as provided under Section 33 of the LGC. 240 2.4 Allowable Expenses Chargeable Against the SHF The SHF shall be used to augment LGU funds for health for the following expenditure items as determined and approved by the Provincial/City Health Board (P/CHB) consistent with Section 20.2 of IRR of RA No. 11223: 2.4.1 Population-based health services, which include the following: a. Environmental health services, including vector control, water quality, and sanitation; b. Health promotion programs or campaigns; c. Epidemiology and disease surveillance; d. Services related to disease elimination; e. Services related to preparedness and response to public health emergencies or disasters; and f. Other health services will be classified by DOH as population-based health services in subsequent guidelines. 2.4.2 Individual-based health services, which include the following: a. Ambulatory and inpatient care; b. Medicines; c. Laboratory tests and procedures; and d. Other health services will be classified by DOH and PhilHealth as individual-based health services in subsequent guidelines. 2.4.3 Health systems operating costs, which include the following: a. Support to the management of the health system, including the operations of the P/CHWS, health board, and operations and hiring of personnel for the Management Support Unit as provided in DOHDBM-DOF-DILG-PhilHealth JMC No. 2021-0001; b. Gasoline for ambulances, patient transport vehicles, vehicles used for delivery of health services and transportation of health commodities and diagnostic specimens; c. Fees that form part of accreditation and licensing requirements; 241 d. Learning and development interventions or capacity building activities, including registration/participation fees related to the efficient and effective delivery of health services and management of the health systems, as determined by the P/CHB; and e. Conduct of trainings, seminars, conferences or conventions relevant to the management of health systems and delivery of health services. 2.4.4 Capital investments based on health facility development plan, which include the following: a. Health infrastructure, including facility improvements related to direct delivery of health services; b. Health equipment and instruments; c. Information technology and equipment for health facilities; d. Ambulances and patient transport vehicles, subject to existing guidelines; and e. Mobile clinics and other ambulatory health services, subject to existing guidelines. 2.4.5 Remuneration of additional health workers until such time that the LGUs have implemented incremental creation of plantilla positions to hire the required number of health care workers based on the standards determined by the DOH, subject to PS Limitation pursuant to Section 325 (a) of the LGC. The salary schedule shall be based on prevailing Salary Standardization Laws and other relevant laws, rules, and regulations governing the salaries and benefits of public health workers. The corresponding salary shall not exceed the rates being implemented in the concerned LGU. 2.4.6 Incentives for all health workers, including Barangay Health Workers and Barangay Nutrition Scholars, within the territorial jurisdiction of the P/CHB. The allocation mechanism shall be decided upon by the Health Board. 2.5 Steps in the Establishment of the SHF 2.5.1 An SHF depository bank account shall be created in accordance with the existing DOF-BLGF Guidelines on AGSBs and other relevant issuances. The P/CHB to issue a resolution on the opening of the SHF account. The concerned Sanggunian Panlalawigan/ Panlungsod (SP) will then issue a resolution endorsing the P/CHB resolution on the opening of the SHF account. 242 2.5.2 A separate book of accounts with complete financial reporting obligations shall be created and maintained by the Provincial/ City Accountant at the Province, HUC, and ICC levels. Subsidiary ledgers shall likewise be created for each identified fund source. 2.5.3 If funds shall be transmitted to the component LGUs from the SHF, these funds shall be transferred to the Trust Fund of the component LGUs. A subsidiary ledger in the Trust Fund shall be created for this purpose. 2.6 Planning and Budgeting for the SHF The P/CHB, through the Provincial/ City Health Office, shall facilitate the formulation of the Local Investment Plan for Health (LIPH) and Annual Operational Plan (AOP) of the P/CWHS. These plans shall be aligned with the Local Development Plan, and Medium-Term and AIP of the concerned LGUs. The LIPH and AOP shall then serve as the bases for SHF budget preparation, PPMP and APP to support the requirements and/or cost estimates of the different expenditure items as embodied in the proposed budget. Timelines for the SHF planning and budgeting shall be in accordance with LGU planning and budgeting guidelines issued by DBM and other concerned NGAs. The P/CHB shall consider the timelines of the local budget process to effectively integrate into its annual budget the local counterpart funds of the participating LGUs. Budget Preparation P/CHB to convene and prepare the estimates of income from PhilHealth payments and indicative amounts from DOH, among others, that will form part of the SHF, and expenditure items that will be sourced from the SHF. This shall include the percentage of the SHF that shall be retained at the provincial/city level and those that shall be downloaded to the component LGUs. The SHF Budget shall be presented by PPAs and by expense class using SHF Budget Preparation Form No. 1. The allocation of the SHF shall be decided upon by the P/CHB, in consultation with component LGUs and based on their respective investment plan for health. The P/CHB may transfer either an agreed amount or percentage to the component LGUs/LEE or through a mechanism based on the performance of the component LGUs/LEE. The setting-up and operation of LEE shall be in accordance with existing DBM guidelines. The amount that will be retained at the province level shall be used for operating expenses and equity considerations, as decided upon by the PHB. At the minimum, the number of Geographically Isolated and Disadvantaged 243 Areas, number of Indigenous Cultural Communities/Indigenous Peoples, and health status of component LGUs, prioritizing national health indicators in the national plans, shall serve as bases for additional financial support to component LGUs. Budget Authorization A P/CHB Resolution approving the budget for priority health programs, projects and activities within the P/CWHS shall be formulated using the SHF Budget Authorization Form No. 1. The P/CHB Resolution on the SHF budget, as well as the LIPH, AOP and annual budgetary proposals, shall be deliberated, endorsed and/or approved by the chairperson, the vice-chairperson and a majority of the members of the P/CHB. The P/CHB shall furnish the DOH and PhilHealth copies of the approved SHF budget. Budget Execution The Provincial/City Budget Officer, Treasurer, and Accountant shall be furnished with a copy of the approved Board Resolution as basis for certification of availability of funds, disbursement and for recording purposes A copy of approved Board Resolution shall be furnished to Component LGUs, hospitals and/or LEE for recording purposes. The Provincial/City Accountant shall issue the certification of availability of funds for the SHF. The SHF shall be released exclusively for the specific purpose for which they have been allocated in the approved SHF Budget. In addition to existing government budgeting, accounting, and auditing rules and regulations, all disbursements from the SHF shall be in accordance with: 1. Allowable expenses chargeable against the SHF; 2. The LIPH and AOP; 3. Contractual arrangement between DOH and the P/CHB; 4. Contractual arrangement between PhilHealth and the P/CHB; and 5. Contractual arrangement between the CSO/ IHP, and P/CHB. The authorized signing official/s for the disbursement of funds shall be in accordance with the LGC and the UHC Act. Any procurement chargeable against the SHF shall be in accordance with RA No. 9184, its IRR as amended, GPPB guidelines and other related issuances. 244 Budget Accountability Quarterly and annual reports shall be submitted to DOH and PhilHealth using the SHF Budget Accountability Form Nos. 1 and 2 on SHF utilization and other prescribed forms, copy furnished the component LGUs, P/CHO and hospitals. The utilization reports of the SHF budget shall be posted in the website of the P/CHWS and involved LGUs, and/or in at least three (3) conspicuous public places in compliance with the Full Disclosure Policy of DILG. The budget process of the SHF may be guided by the following timelines: Table 17. Timelines for the Budget Process of SHF PlanningBudgeting Framework Planning for SHF Specific Activities Formulation P/CWHS of the AOP Timeline of the 4th quarter, two (2) years prior to the budget year covered by the AOP Submission of copies of the AOP to the 3rd quarter of the year DOH and PhilHealth. preceding the budget year covered by the AOP Budget Preparation Preparation of the estimates of 3rd quarter of income and expenditure items that will preceding year be sourced from the SHF Budget Authorization Issuance of resolution to authorize and 1st quarter of the current approval of the SHF budget and the year utilization of funds. the Submission of the copies of approved SHF budget to the DOH and PhilHealth Budget Execution Submission of the copy of approved 1st quarter of the current Board Resolution to the Provincial/ City year Budget Officer, Treasurer and Accountant Issuance of certification of availability 1st quarter of the current of funds for the SHF by the Provincial/ year City Accountant Furnishing a copy of approved Board 1st quarter of the current Resolution to Component LGUs, year hospitals and/or LEE for recording purposes 245 PlanningBudgeting Framework Budget Accountability Specific Activities Timeline Submission of required quarterly and Quarterly Reports: Not annual reports using the SHF Budget later than the 20th day Accountability Form No. 1 on SHF after the end of the utilization and other prescribed forms quarter Annual Reports: Not later than the 15th day of February of the following year Submission of liquidation reports of cash advances and other supporting documents End of the current year or not later than the 20th of January of the following year Posting of the utilization report of the SHF budget 1st quarter of succeeding year the 246 2.7 SHF Budget Preparation Forms SHF Budget Preparation Form No. 1 INCOME AND EXPENDITURES ESTIMATES FOR FY _____ Provincial/City Health Board of _______ Province/City Estimated Income for Budget Year Financial Grants and Subsidies from NGAs ………………………………………………… PhilHealth Payments ………………………………………………………………………… Donations from CSOs, and IHPs ……………………………………………………………. Concerned LGUs’ Local Budget intended for Health ……………………………………….. Other Sources ………………………………………………………………………………… Add: Previous Years Unexpended Balances (including Continuing Appropriation) xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx TOTAL Less: Continuing Appropriation Net Amount Available for Appropriation xxx xxx xxx xxx Proposed Expenditures for Budget Year Source of Fund (NGA grants, PhilHealth payments, donations, LGU budget, others) Personal Services Total Expenditures for FY xxx xxx Balance/Deficit xxx xxx Rank Program/ Project/ Activity Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses Capital Outlays Total xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx Prepared by: ________________________ Chairman of Provincial/City Local Health Board or his/her Authorized Representative 247 SHF Budget Authorization Form No. 1* Provincial/City Board of _______________ Local Health Board of _________________________________ Province/City ______________ Regular Session Begun and held in ______________, ________________, on ________ day of ________________, ____________. Provincial/City Health Board Resolution No. _________________________ A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE BUDGET FOR PRIORITY HEALTH PROGRAMS, PROJECTS AND ACTIVITIES WITHIN THE PROVINCE-WIDE/CITY-WIDE HEALTH SYSTEM Be it resolved by the Provincial/City Health Board of _____________________________ in Council assembles: Section 1. Source of Funds. The following income as indicated herein are hereby declared as sources of funds, particularly income derived from PhilHealth payments shall accrue to the Special Health Fund, necessary to finance the implementation of priority health programs, projects and activities of the Province/City of _______ from January 1 to December 31, 20__, except otherwise specifically provided herein: Estimated Income for Budget Year Financial Grants and Subsidies from NGAs PhilHealth Payments Donations from CSOs and IHPs Concerned LGUs’ Local Budget intended for Health Other Sources Add: Previous Years Unexpended Balances (including Continuing Appropriation) Gross Income Less: Continuing Appropriation Net Amount Available for Appropriation P________ ________ ________ ________ ________ ________ ________ ________ ________ Section 2. Allocation of Funds. The following sums are hereby allocated out of the herein sources of the Special Health Fund and any unexpended balances thereof in the Local Treasury of the Province/City for the implementation of priority health programs, projects and activities in the Province/City of _______ from January 1 to December 31, 20__: Expenditure Program for Budget Year Rank Total Program/ Project/ Activity (NGA grants, PhilHealth payments, donations, LGU budget, others) Personal Services Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses Capital Outlays Total xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx Source of Fund 248 Expenditure Program for Budget Year Rank Program/Project/Activity Expected Output Schedule of Delivery Section 3. Effectivity. This Resolution shall take effect immediately upon its approval. Date Adopted: _________________ Carried Unanimously, Provincial/City Health Board Members Names _____________________ _____________________ _____________________ Signatures _____________________ _____________________ _____________________ I HEREBY CERTIFY to the correctness of the above-quoted Provincial/City Health Board Resolution. ________________________ Secretary-Designate of LHB ATTESTED BY: _______________________ Vice-Chairperson of P/CHB APPROVED BY: __________________________ Chairperson of P/CHB or his/her Authorized Representative Date: _____________________ __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 249 SHF Budget Accountability Form No. 1 REPORT OF UTILIZATION For the Quarter Ending _____ Province/City Health Board of ________________ Receipt for the SHF Less: P ______________ DISBURSEMENTS (broken down by source of fund, expense class and by object of expenditures) Personal Services _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Capital Outlays _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Sub-total Balance _______________ P ______________ Prepared by: ________________________ Provincial/City Accountant Approved by: _____________________________ Chairman of Provincial/City Health Board or his/her Authorized Representative 250 SHF Budget Accountability Form No. 2 REPORT OF UTILIZATION For the Quarter Ending _____ Province/City Health Board of ________________ Receipt for the SHF P ______________ Less: DISBURSEMENTS (broken down by source of fund, expense class and by object of expenditures) Sources of Fund (Principal PHB/CHB share) Financial Grants and Subsidies from NGAs _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ Share to component LGUs/LEEs _______________ PhilHealth Payments _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Donations from CSOs and IHPs _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Concerned LGUs’ local Budget intended for Health _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Share to component LGU 1 _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Share to component LGU 2 _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Share to LEE 1 _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ 251 Share to LEE 1 _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _________________________________________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Sub-total Balance _______________ P ______________ Prepared by: ________________________ Provincial/City Accountant Approved by: _____________________________ Chairman of Provincial/City Health Board or his/her Authorized Representative 252 PART V. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQs) Budget Preparation 1. Does the LCE need to approve the Sanggunian Resolution approving the AIP? Yes. Section 54 (a) of the LGC provides that, “[e]very ordinance enacted by the sangguniang panlalawigan, sangguniang panlungsod, or sangguniang bayan shall be presented to the provincial governor or city or municipal mayor, as the case may be. If the [LCE] concerned approves the same, he shall affix his signature on each and every page thereof; otherwise, he shall veto it and return the same with his objections to the sanggunian, which may proceed to reconsider the same. The sanggunian concerned may override the veto of the [LCE] by two-thirds (2/3) vote of all its members, thereby making the ordinance or resolution effective for all legal intents and purposes.” Further, Section 55 (b) of the LGC provides that, “[t]he [LCE], except the punong barangay, shall have the power to veto any particular item or items of an appropriations ordinance, an ordinance or resolution adopting a local development plan and public investment program, or an ordinance directing the payment of money or creating liability. In such a case, the veto shall not affect the item or items which are not objected to. The vetoed item or items shall not take effect unless the sanggunian overrides the veto in the manner herein provided; otherwise, the item or items in the appropriations ordinance of the previous year corresponding to those vetoed, if any, shall be deemed reenacted.” Conversely, Section 55 (c) of the same law provides that, “[t]he [LCE] may veto an ordinance or resolution only once. The sanggunian may override the veto of the [LCE] concerned by two-thirds (2/3) vote of all its members, thereby making the ordinance effective even without the approval of the [LCE] concerned.” 2. Should the projects covered by continuing appropriations still be included as part of the current year’s AIP? No. It is no longer necessary to include projects covered by continuing appropriations in the current year’s AIP considering that the said projects already formed part of previously approved AIP/s covered by appropriation ordinance/s enacted in prior year/s. 3. Can the AIP cover only the twenty percent (20%) of the annual NTA for development projects (20% DF) and not the total resource requirements for a particular budget year? No. The AIP should cover the total resource requirements, i.e., current operating expenditures and capital outlays, including development projects chargeable against the 20% DF, and not only the 20% DF for a particular budget year. 253 DILG-NEDA-DBM-DOF Joint Memorandum Circular (JMC) No. 1 dated November 18, 2016 defines AIP as the annual slice of the Local Development Investment Program, which constitutes the total resource requirements for all PPAs consisting of the annual capital expenditure (CapEx) and regular operating requirements of the LGU. 4. Do current year’s excess collections from business and real property taxes and prior year’s surplus fall under the category of “funds actually available” which may be used to fund a supplemental budget?* Yes. Both fall under the category of funds actually available. The current year’s excess collections on business and real property taxes may be used as funding source for supplemental budget, as long as they are shown to be in excess of the target revenue collections for the year. Article 417 of the IRR of the LGC, as amended by Administrative Order No. 47 dated April 12, 1993, provides, among others, that: “No ordinance providing for a supplemental budget shall be enacted except for the following: (a) When supported by funds actually available as certified by the local treasurer; Funds actually available refer to the amount of money actually collected as certified by the local treasurer at any given point during the fiscal year which is over and above the estimated income collection for that point in the year. Thus, funds are actually available when realized income exceeds estimated income as of the said fiscal year. Funds are likewise deemed actually available when there are savings. For this purpose, savings refer to portions or balances as of any given point in the fiscal year of any programmed or allotted appropriation which remain free of any obligation or encumbrance and which are still available after the satisfactory completion or the unavoidable discontinuance or abandonment of the work, activity or purpose for which the appropriation was originally authorized, or which result from unobligated compensation and related costs pertaining to vacant positions and leaves of absence without pay. x x x” Likewise, prior year’s excess collections may be utilized to fund a supplemental budget pursuant to Section 322 of the LGC which provides in part that, “[u]nexpended balances of appropriations authorized in the annual appropriations ordinance shall revert to the unappropriated surplus of the general fund at the end of the fiscal year and shall not thereafter be available for the expenditure except by subsequent enactment.” 5. In the case of supplemental budgets, what amount will be certified as actually available by the local treasurer and when is the fund considered actually available?* Article 417 of the IRR of the LGC, as amended by Administrative Order No. 47 dated April 12, 1993, provides, in part, as follows: “ARTICLE 417. Changes in the Annual Budget. — Changes in the annual budget may be done through supplemental budgets. No ordinance providing for a supplemental budget shall be enacted except for the following: __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 254 (a) When supported by funds actually available as certified by the local treasurer: Funds actually available refer to the amount of money actually collected as certified by the local treasurer at any given point during the fiscal year which is over and above the estimated income collection for that point in the year. Thus, funds are actually available when realized income exceeds estimated income as of the said fiscal year. Funds are likewise deemed actually available when there are savings. For this purpose, savings refer to portions or balances as of any given point in the fiscal year of any programmed or allotted appropriation which remain free of any obligation or encumbrance and which are still available after the satisfactory completion or the unavoidable discontinuance or abandonment of the work, activity or purpose for which the appropriation was originally authorized, or which result from unobligated compensation and related costs pertaining to vacant positions and leaves of absence without pay. (b) If covered by new revenue source(s) New revenue source refers to money measures not otherwise considered during the preparation and enactment of the annual budget. Such new revenue measures include ordinance passed by the Sanggunian during the fiscal year but after the annual budget had already been enacted into law which imposes new local taxes, charges, fees, fines or penalties, or which raises existing local taxes, charges, fees, fines or penalties. Such revenue sources also include new or higher remittances, contributions, subsidies or grants in aid from the National Government or from government corporations and private entities which have not been included in the estimate of income which served as basis for the annual budget. “An ordinance providing for a supplemental budget may also be enacted in times of public calamity by way of budgetary realignment to set aside appropriations for the purchase of supplies and materials or the payment of services, which are exceptionally urgent or absolutely indispensable to prevent imminent danger to, or loss of, life and property, in the jurisdiction of the local government unit or in other areas declared in a state of calamity by the President. Such ordinance shall clearly indicate the sources of funds available for appropriations, as certified under oath jointly by the local treasurer and the local accountant and attested by the local chief executive, and various items of appropriations affected, and the reasons for the changes.” 6. Can the surplus from the Special Education Fund (SEF) be used to fund a supplemental budget? No. Surplus from the SEF or those arising from unexpended balances from the previous year’s SEF may not be used to fund a supplemental budget of the General Fund. Section 272 of the LGC provides, among others, that, “the proceeds [referring to SEF] shall be allocated for the operation and maintenance of public schools, construction and repair of school buildings, facilities and equipment, educational research, purchase of books and periodicals, and sports development as determined and approved by the local school board.” Relatedly, Section 309 (a) of the LGC requires every provincial, city, or municipal treasury to maintain a special fund, particularly an SEF, “which shall consist of the respective shares of provinces, cities, municipalities, and barangays in the proceeds 255 of the additional tax on real property to be appropriated for purposes prescribed in Section 272 of [the] Code.” Article 448 (b) of the IRR of the LGC prescribes that the special funds maintained by the provincial, city or municipal treasury shall be deemed automatically appropriated for purposes indicated therefor. 7. What is Personal Services (PS)? Section 306 [k] of the LGC defines PS as appropriations for the payment of salaries, wages, and other compensation of permanent, temporary, contractual, and casual employees of the LGU. Other compensation consists of the following:106 Authorized Allowances/Benefits Personnel Economic Relief Allowance Uniform/Clothing Allowance Representation and Transportation Allowances Mid-Year Bonus Year-End Bonus and Cash Gift Magna Carta Benefits of Public Health Workers Magna Carta Benefits of Public Social Workers Step Increment and Merit Increase Productivity Enhancement Incentive Other legally authorized allowances/benefits (e.g., Loyalty Award, Anniversary Bonus, among others) Fixed Personnel Expenditures Employees' Compensation Commission Contributions PhilHealth Contributions Pag-IBIG Contributions Retirement and Life Insurance Contributions Other Personnel Benefits Retirement Gratuity Benefits Terminal Leave Benefits Monetization of Leave Credits 106 See Local Budget Circular No. 145 dated March 2, 2022, entitled, “Guidelines on the Implementation of Personal Services (PS) Limitation on Local Government Budgets and Determination of Waived PS Items Pursuant to Section 93 of the General Provisions (GPs) of the Fiscal Year (FY) 2022 General Appropriations Act (GAA), Republic Act (RA) No. 11639, and Years Thereafter” 256 8. What is the legal basis for the PS Limitation? Section 325 (a) of the LGC prescribes that, “[t]he total appropriations, whether annual or supplemental, for personal services of a local government unit for one (1) fiscal year shall not exceed forty-five percent (45%) in the case of first to third class provinces, cities and municipalities, and fifty-five percent (55%) in the case of the fourth class or lower, of the total annual income from regular sources realized in the next preceding fiscal year. The appropriations for salaries, wages, representation and transportation allowances of officials and employees of the public utilities and economic enterprises owned, operated, and maintained by the local government unit concerned shall not be included in the annual budget or in the computation of the maximum amount for personal services. The appropriations for the personal services of such economic enterprises shall be charged to their respective budgets.” Section 331 (b) of the same law provides that, “[t]he total annual appropriations for personal services of a barangay for one (1) fiscal year shall not exceed fifty-five percent (55%) of the total annual income actually realized from local sources during the next preceding fiscal year.” 9. How is the PS Limitation computed for existing LGUs? The PS Limitation in an LGU budget for a budget year shall be determined as follows:107 For an Existing Province, City, or Municipality a. Compute the Total Annual Income from Regular Sources realized in the next preceding fiscal year (TIRS), based on the trial balance as of December 31 of said year which should be the amount reflected in the Local Budget Preparation Form No. 1 (Budget of Expenditures and Sources of Financing). b. Compute the PS Limitation by using the following formula, as applicable: PS Limitation, 1st to 3rd class PCM = (45%) (TIRS) PS Limitation, 4th to 6th class PCM = (55%) (TIRS) For an Existing Barangay a. Compute the Total Income Actually Realized from Local Sources during the next preceding fiscal year (TILS), based on the trial balance as of December 31 of said year. b. Compute the PS Limitation by using the following formula: PS Limitation, Barangay = (55%) (TILS) 107 See Local Budget Circular No. 145 dated March 2, 2022, entitled, “Guidelines on the Implementation of Personal Services (PS) Limitation on Local Government Budgets and Determination of Waived PS Items Pursuant to Section 93 of the General Provisions (GPs) of the Fiscal Year (FY) 2022 General Appropriations Act (GAA), Republic Act (RA) No. 11639, and Years Thereafter” 257 10. How is the PS Limitation computed for new LGUs? For the initial year of its creation, the PS Limitation on the annual and supplemental budget/s of a newly-created LGU shall be based on the total estimated income to be generated by the LGU during the year from both internal sources, such as share from local taxes, fees, and charges, and external sources, such as shares of LGUs from the National Tax Allotment (NTA) and utilization and development of the national wealth, among others. It must be understood that, in determining the total estimated income, the LGU shall not include the financial subsidies/assistance that it may receive from the National Government and other extraordinary receipts, such as loans, donations, capital income, and other non-recurring income. For the year immediately following the initial year of its creation, the PS Limitation on the annual and supplemental budget/s of a newly-created LGU shall be based on the total income generated by the LGU in the preceding year, applying the specific types of income to be included and excluded as cited in the preceding paragraph. In the succeeding years, Sections 325 (a) and 331 (b) of the LGC, as the case may be, shall already govern the computation of the PS limitation on the annual and supplemental budget/s of newly-created LGUs.108 11. What are waived PS Items? Waived PS items are those that are excluded from the computation of PS Limitation prescribed under Sections 325 (a) and 331 (b) of the LGC.109 The waived PS items are specified in the pertinent General Provision (GP) of the annual General Appropriations Act (GAA). For FY 2023, pursuant to Section 95 of the GPs of the FY 2023 GAA, RA No. 11963, the enforcement of the PS Limitation under Sections 325 (a) and 331 (b) of the LGC, shall be waived to enable LGUs to: a. Absorb the cost of hospital services transferred from provinces to newlycreated cities; b. Pay the Collective Negotiation Agreement Incentives of their employees; c. Pay the Retirement Gratuity Benefits and Terminal Leave Benefits, including the monetization of Leave Credits of their employees; d. Pay the minimum Year-End Bonus of One Thousand Pesos (P1,000) for the Punong Barangay and Six Hundred Pesos (P600) for other mandatory barangay officials, and their Cash Gifts; e. Pay the salaries and benefits of health/medical personnel that may be hired to perform functions related to emergency situations; 108 See Local Budget Circular No. 145 dated March 2, 2022, entitled, “Guidelines on the Implementation of Personal Services (PS) Limitation on Local Government Budgets and Determination of Waived PS Items Pursuant to Section 93 of the General Provisions (GPs) of the Fiscal Year (FY) 2022 General Appropriations Act (GAA), Republic Act (RA) No. 11639, and Years Thereafter” 109 Same as above 258 f. Pay the special benefits that may be authorized to be granted to LGU personnel during emergency situations; g. Pay the salary differentials of LGU-hired Public Health Workers to fully implement the provisions of RA No. 7305; and h. Pay the salaries and other benefits of additional personnel that may be hired by the LGUs to implement the devolved basic services and functions, subject to the guidelines issued by the Department of Budget and Management (DBM). 12. In relation to the creation of non-mandatory positions and offices, does the requirement of full implementation of the Salary Standardization Law (SSL) refer to the implementation of 100% of a specific tranche or 100% implementation of the four (4) tranches? The “full Implementation of the SSL” as a requirement for the creation of nonmandatory positions and offices is complied with when the salary rates of LGU personnel already correspond to the maximum allowable percentage of the salary schedule applicable to the particular LGU based on its income class for a specific year or tranche. For instance, a first-class province is considered to have fully implemented the SSL if the modified salary schedule that it adopts for a specific year or tranche is one hundred percent (100%) of the salary schedule for NGAs prescribed for the same specific year or tranche, as authorized pursuant to RA No. 11466 or the Salary Standardization Law of 2019 and the pertinent guidelines issued by the DBM. On the other hand, a sixth-class province is considered to have fully implemented the SSL if the modified salary schedule that it adopts for a specific year or tranche is seventy-five percent (75%) of the authorized salary schedule for NGAs prescribed for the same specific year or tranche. 13. Is the inclusion of appropriation for Early and Voluntary Separation Incentive Program (EVSIP) legally tenable? No. It is not legally tenable. An early retirement program to be valid should be by virtue of a valid reorganization pursuant to a law passed by Congress. Although local autonomy grants local governments the power to streamline and reorganize as may be inferred from Sections 16 and 76 of the LGC, it does not confer authority upon any LGU to create a separate and supplementary retirement benefit plan. Section 28 (b) of Commonwealth Act No. 186, as amended, prohibits government agencies from establishing supplementary retirement or pension plans from the time the Government Service Insurance System charter took effect, while those plans already existing when the charter was enacted were declared abolished. The purpose behind the proscription found in Section 28 (b), as amended, was to address the need to prevent the proliferation of iniquitous plans. According to the Supreme Court: 259 “x x x Sec. 28 (b) as amended by RA 4968 in no uncertain terms bars the creation of any insurance or retirement plan – other than the GSIS – for government officers and employees, in order to prevent undue and inequitous proliferation of such plans. x x x. To ignore this and rule otherwise would be tantamount to permitting every other government office or agency to put up its own supplementary retirement benefit plan under the guise of such ‘financial assistance’.”110 14. Can the LGU provide appropriations for Monetization of Leave Credits?* Generally, Monetization of Leave Credits is chargeable against savings. However, under CSC-DBM Joint Circular No. 2, s. 2003, Monetization of Leave Credits, [CNA Incentive],111 Overtime Pay, and such other benefits that are authorized by law but are chargeable against savings of the LGUs may also be included by direct appropriation either in the annual budget or supplemental budget of the LGU concerned, provided these are within the PS Limitation, as stipulated under Section 325 (a) of the LGC. (Emphasis ours) 15. How is the CNA Incentive classified in the budget? The CNA Incentive shall be taken up as PS Expenditure. Budget Authorization 16. Does the proposed ordinance covering the grant of authority to the LCE and/or the Presiding Officer of the Sanggunian to use savings and augment within the same expense class in their respective appropriations under Section 336 of the LGC need to emanate from the LCE like that of a supplemental budget? No. The proposed ordinance granting the authority to use savings under Section 336 of the LGC need not emanate from the LCE unlike that of a supplemental budget. A supplemental budget reflects changes in the annual budget under the conditions provided in Section 321 of the LGC and Article 417 of its IRR as amended by Administrative Order No. 47 dated April 12, 1993. Accordingly, since the annual budget emanates from the LCE as provided under Section 318 of the LGC, the supplemental budget should likewise emanate from the LCE. On the other hand, the proposed ordinance granting authority to use savings under Section 336 of the LGC is not a budget and need not emanate from the LCE. 110 Conte vs. Commission on Audit, G.R. No. 116422, November 4, 1966 Pursuant to the provisions of the Budget Circulars and the General Provisions of the applicable annual appropriations law, the grant of CNA Incentive should, however, be charged against savings from the available MOOE allotments as a result of costcutting and systems improvement measures, and not by direct appropriations. 111 __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 260 17. Can the Sanggunian increase items of appropriation in the executive budget? Yes, provided that the aggregate increase does not result to an excess over the total proposed amount in the executive budget pursuant to Article 415 (a) of the IRR of the LGC. As a reference, the ruling in Sarmiento, et al. vs. The Treasurer of the Philippines, et al., may be applied wherein the Supreme Court agreed with the claim of the Solicitor General that, “Congress is enjoined from increasing the total budget for the operation of the Government as recommended by the President, not the individual items of appropriations.” “Records of the 1986 Constitutional Commission reveal that the purpose of the above-quoted provision [Section 25 (1), Article VI of the 1987 Constitution] is to avoid the possibility of a big budget deficit if Congress were given an unbridled hand in passing upon the appropriations recommended by the President as specified in the budget. The constitutional prohibition against such increase is an assurance that the expected income of the government will be sufficient for the operational expenses of its different agencies and projects specified in the appropriations law.112 It may be noted that the subject provision of the LGC prohibiting the increase in the proposed amount in the executive budget is similar to the provision in Executive Order No. 292 (the Administrative Code of 1987), particularly Section 24, Chapter 4 on Budget Authorization, Book VI, in the case of national government budgeting, to wit: “SEC. 24. Prohibition Against the Increase of Appropriation. – The Congress shall in no case increase the appropriation of any project or program of any department, bureau, agency or office of the Government over the amount submitted by the President in his budget proposal. In case of any reduction in the proposed appropriation for a project or program, a corresponding reduction shall be made in the total appropriation of the department, office or agency concerned in the total of the General Appropriations Bill.” 18. Can the LCE veto an item of appropriation that was deleted by the sanggunian during budget authorization? No. The LCE can only veto existing items of appropriations in the annual budget approved by the sanggunian. Since the items of appropriations have been deleted by the sanggunian, there is no existing item of appropriation that could be validly vetoed by the LCE. Section 55 (b) of the LGC expressly provides that, “[t]he local chief executive, except the punong barangay, shall have the power to veto any particular item or items of an appropriations ordinance x x x.” 112 G.R. Nos. 125680 and 126313, September 4, 2001 261 19. What are the effects of veto by the LCE? Section 55 (b) of the LGC provides that the veto shall not affect the item or items which are not objected to. Further, the vetoed item or items shall not take effect, unless the sanggunian overrides the veto by two-thirds (2/3) vote of all its members pursuant to Section 55 (c) of the LGC. In the event that the sanggunian fails to override the veto, the item or items in the appropriations ordinance of the previous year corresponding to those vetoed, if any, shall be deemed reenacted (Section 55 [b] of the LGC). 20. Can the appropriation for development projects of no less than twenty percent (20%) of the NTA be appropriated in a lumpsum amount? Generally, the appropriation for the 20% Development Fund (DF) should be in the form of itemized projects. Section 287 of the LGC provides that each LGU shall appropriate in its annual budget no less than twenty percent (20%) of its annual NTA for development projects. Article 384 of the IRR of the LGC further provides that it shall be mandatory for each LGU to set aside in its annual budgets amounts no less than twenty percent (20%) of its NTA for the next year as appropriation for local development projects that are embodied or contained in local development plans. Article 454 (d) of the same IRR provides further, to wit: (d) Disbursements of Appropriations for Development Projects — Art. 391 of Rule XXXII of these Rules mandate each LGU to appropriate their share in the proceeds from the development and utilization of the national wealth to finance local development and livelihood projects, respectively. Disbursements from such special accounts under the General Fund shall proceed from itemized appropriations in the budgets of LGU instead of by lumpsum. Such itemized appropriations shall be for specific development projects/activities embodied in the local development plan and/or public investment program formulated and prioritized by the Local Development Council and approved by the sanggunian concerned. x x x” 21. What is the implication if the LGU appropriated the 20% DF in lumpsum amount? In the case of Verceles vs. COA (G.R. No. 211553, September 13, 2016), the SC ruled in part, as follows: “While a blanket authority is not per se ineffective, it does not suffice for purposes of implementing projects funded by lump-sum appropriations. The nature of lump-sum appropriations vis-a-vis the power of the purse of the SP (as the legislative organ of the LGU) requires the local chief executive to obtain definite and specific authorizations before he can enter into contracts funded by lump262 sum appropriations. The exception is when the appropriation ordinance already identifies the specific projects and the costs of the projects to be funded by lumpsum appropriations. We elaborate on these points below. First, the nature of a lump-sum appropriation requires specific authorization from the SP before projects funded by it can be implemented. The LGC defines appropriation as the authorization made by ordinance, directing the payment of goods and services from local government funds under specified conditions or for specific purposes. The power of appropriation involves (a) the setting apart by law (in the case of LGUs, by ordinance) of a certain sum from the public revenue for (b) a specified purpose. Lump-sum, on the other hand, means 'consisting of a single sum of money.' Lump-sum appropriation is thus a single sum of money set aside by the legislature for a specified purpose. Relevant in the present case is the EDF, a lump-sum fund intended for the economic development projects of the Province. The description 'economic development,' by itself, is a generic term as it does not readily specify the projects that may be covered by the lump-sum appropriation. To stress, the CY 2001 appropriation ordinance did not at all identify the projects to be funded by the EDF. On this basis, Verceles should have clearly obtained prior approval from the SP before he entered into the first MOA. Quisumbing instructs us that should the appropriation ordinance describe the projects in generic terms, there is a need for a covering contract for every specific project that in turn requires approval by the sanggunian. Thus, the blanket authority, even granting that Verceles vetoed its revocation, was not a sufficient authority for him to enter into the first MOA as he was not specifically authorized to do so. Second, the power of the purse of the SP requires the governor to obtain prior authority before he can implement projects funded by lump-sum appropriations. The SP, as the legislative organ of the province, exercises the power of the purse in much the same way as the Congress does at the national level. The SP decides how the provincial budget will be spent; what projects, activities and programs to fund; and the amounts of money to be spent for each project, activity or program. On the other hand, the governor, as the local chief executive tasked to enforce ordinances, is expected to faithfully execute the appropriation ordinance and to spend the budget in accordance with its provisions. In the landmark case of Belgica v. Secretary Ochoa, the Court had the opportunity to discuss the characteristics of the Priority Development Assistance Fund (PDAF) as a lump-sum amount of money given to individual legislators. We held that [w]hat beckons constitutional infirmity are appropriations which merely provide for a singular lump-sum amount to be tapped as a source of funding for multiple purposes. Since such appropriation type necessitates 263 the further determination of both the actual amount to be expended and the actual purpose of the appropriation which must still be chosen from the multiple purposes stated in the law, it cannot be said that the appropriation law already indicates a "specific appropriation of money" and hence, without a proper line-item which the President may veto. [emphasis and underscoring supplied] Using this as parameter, we note that the CY 2001 EDF is akin to the PDAF as they are both singular lump-sum amounts to be tapped as a funding source for multiple purposes. They are both described in generic terms (‘economic development fund’ and ‘priority development assistance fund’), which requires the further determination of the actual amount to be spent and the actual purpose of the appropriation. We employ the above analogy to emphasize that the 2001 EDF was not a specific appropriation of money as Verceles would want the Court to believe in his attempt to justify the first MOA. At the time the SP enacted the 2001 appropriation ordinance, it had not yet set apart certain sums of money from the EDF for specified purposes. In other words, the SP had not yet completely exercised its power of the purse such that all the governor had to do was to implement the projects identified in the appropriation ordinance. On the contrary, the 2001 EDF did not specify the projects to be funded. Further, Section 6 of the 2001 appropriation ordinance stated that ‘appropriations under the 20% EDF shall be approved by the Sanggunian Panlalawigan.’ Obviously, the SP wanted to ensure that the projects to be funded by the EDF still go through the deliberations of the SP members precisely because these projects had not been previously identified and approved by the SP. Since the 2001 EDF was a lump-sum amount not yet apportioned to specified development projects, Verceles needed to secure prior authority from the SP. Having failed to secure prior authority, the first MOA was unauthorized and properly disallowed.” (Emphasis supplied) 22. Is an Appropriation Ordinance necessary to authorize utilization of loan proceeds? Yes. An Appropriation Ordinance is necessary to authorize utilization of loan proceeds. Section 313 of the LGC provides that LGUs shall maintain special accounts in the general fund for loans, interests, bond issues, and other contributions for specific purposes. In this regard, the rule under Section 305 (a) of the LGC shall apply, which prescribes that no money shall be paid out of the local treasury except in pursuance of an Appropriation Ordinance or law. 23. Is an Appropriation Ordinance necessary to authorize the use of the shares in the proceeds from the development and utilization of the national wealth? Yes. Article 391 of the IRR of the LGC provides that the proceeds from the shares of LGUs in the proceeds from the development and utilization of the national wealth shall be appropriated by their respective sanggunian to finance local development and livelihood projects, provided that at least eighty percent (80%) of the proceeds derived 264 from the development and utilization of hydrothermal, geothermal, and other sources of energy shall be applied solely to lower the cost of electricity in the LGU where such source of energy is located. Article 454 (d) of the same IRR reiterates this mandate and provides further that disbursements from such special accounts under the General Fund shall proceed from itemized appropriations in the budgets of LGU instead of by lump sum. Such itemized appropriations shall be for specific development projects/activities embodied in the local development plan and/or public investment program formulated and prioritized by the LDC and approved by the sanggunian concerned. 24. Section 53 of the LGC provides that, “[a] majority of all the members of the sanggunian who have been elected and qualified shall constitute a quorum to transact official business.” a. What comprises a “quorum,” and “majority” in the Sanggunian? Quorum is defined as that number of members of a body which, when legally assembled in their proper places, will enable the body to transact its proper business or that number which makes a lawful body and gives it power to pass upon a law or ordinance or do any valid act. 113 Section 53 of the LGC requires that the majority of all members of the sanggunian who have been elected and qualified shall constitute a quorum to transact official business. Majority, when required to constitute a quorum, means the number greater than half or more than half of any total. 114 b. Is the Presiding Officer included in the determination of the entire membership of the Sanggunian for purposes of computing the quorum? Can the Presiding Officer vote? In the case of Javier and Piccio III vs. Cadiao, et al.,115 the SC ruled, to wit: “The Vice Governor, as the Presiding Officer, shall be considered a part of the SP for purposes of ascertaining if a quorum exists. In determining the number which constitutes as the majority vote, the Vice Governor is excluded. The Vice Governor's right to vote is merely contingent and arises only when there is a tie to break.” c. What constitutes simple majority and qualified majority? Generally, ordinary measures require for its enactment only the approval of a simple majority of the sanggunian members present, there being a quorum. These pertain to the normal transactions of the sanggunian which are approved by the sanggunian through a vote of simple majority of those present. On the 113 Javellana vs. Tayo as cited in Zamora vs. Caballero, G.R. No. 147767, January 14, 2004 Perez vs. Dela Cruz as cited in Zamora vs. Caballero 115 G.R. No. 185369, August 03, 2016 114 265 other hand, there are certain measures where the LGC requires for its approval the vote of majority of all the members who were duly elected and qualified. This is called approval by the qualified majority of the sanggunian. In this case, the approval is to be voted not just by the majority of those present in a session there being a quorum but by the majority of all the members of the sanggunian duly elected and qualified regardless of whether all of them were present or not in a particular session, there being a quorum.116 25. What shall be deemed as essential operating expenses? Can these include all Prior Year’s Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses (MOOE)? If not, who shall determine the same? It is imperative to distinguish MOOE from essential operating expenses. MOOE is defined as an allocation to support the operations of the LGUs including those for supplies and materials, transportation and travel, utilities and other maintenance activities. On the other hand, essential operating expenses refers to specific objects of expenditure under MOOE, which are of utmost importance, indispensable, and extremely necessary for the continued operation of a particular LGU. Determination of essential operating expenses in the executive branch shall be made by the LCE, while for the legislative branch, it shall be done by the Vice-LCE. As a reference, in Atienza vs. Villarosa, the SC ruled that “[t]he Vice-Governor, as the presiding officer of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan, has administrative control of the funds of the said body. Accordingly, it is the Vice-Governor who has the authority to approve disbursement vouchers for expenditures appropriated for the operation of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan.”117 26. What is the voting requirement to pass an Appropriation Ordinance? In Municipality of Corella vs. Philkonstrak, the SC ruled as follows: “An appropriation ordinance requires the affirmative vote of a majority of all the sanggunian members. Article 107(g) of the IRR of the Local Government Code provides the general rule that no ordinance or resolution shall be passed by the sanggunian without prior approval of a majority of all the members present. The exception to the general rule is that for ordinances or resolutions authorizing or directing the payment of money or creating a liability, what is needed is the affirmative vote of a majority of all the sanggunian members, whether present or not. Simply, the quorum in the general rule depends on the number of the sanggunian members present while the quorum in the exception depends on the total number of sanggunian members voted into office. 116 117 La Carlota City vs. Rojo, GR No. 181367, April 24, 2012 G.R. No. 161081, May 10, 2005 266 In the case at bar, Corella asserts that Municipal Ordinance No. 2010-02, the appropriation ordinance in question, directs and authorizes the payment of money; thus, requires a majority vote of all the members of the sangguniang bayan, not only of the members present. Thus, since the sangguniang bayan of Corella is composed of a total of 11 members, the majority vote of six is required in order for municipal ordinance no. 2010-02 to be valid and binding. However, the municipal ordinance only obtained five affirmative votes, based on the quorum on the sanggunian members present at that time, which was eight members. Thus, Tocmo contends that Municipal Ordinance No. 2010-02 is null and void. Consequently, the contract between Corella and Philkonstrak is null and void too.” 27. Section 320 of the LGC provides that “[t]he ordinance enacting the annual budget shall take effect at the beginning of the ensuing calendar year. An ordinance enacting a supplemental budget, however, shall take effect upon its approval or on the date fixed therein.” Does this mean that the requirement of publication under Section 59 of the LGC and Article 113 of its IRR can already by dispensed with? No. Posting and/or publication, as the case may be, of the appropriation ordinance is required under Section 59 of the LGC. The word “shall” connoting mandatory character or command118 was used by the law without any qualification or exemption, as follows: “(a) Unless otherwise stated in the ordinance or resolution approving the local development plan and public investment program, the same shall take effect after ten (10) days from the date a copy thereof is posted in a bulletin board at the entrance of the provincial capitol or city, municipal, or barangay hall, as the case may be, and in at least two (2) other conspicuous places in the local government unit concerned.” (Emphasis supplied) “(d) In the case of highly urbanized and independent component cities, the main features of the ordinance or resolution duly enacted or adopted shall, in addition to being posted, be published once in a local newspaper of general circulation within the city, provided, that in the absence thereof, the ordinance or resolution shall be published in any newspaper of general circulation.” (Emphasis supplied) 28. How may the use of savings and augmentation under Section 336 of the LGC and the use of the savings as funds actually available for supplemental budget under Article 417 of the IRR of the LGC, as amended by Administrative Order No. 47 (implementing Section 321 of the LGC) be distinguished? The following table summarizes the distinctions between the use of savings under Sections 336 and 321 of the LGC as aforementioned: 118 Jurisprudence and statutory construction teach us that the word "shall" connotes mandatory character; it indicates a word of command, and one which has always or which must be given a compulsory meaning, and it is generally imperative or mandatory in nature (Enriquez v. Enriquez, 505 Phil. 193, 199 [2005], as cited in UCPB General Insurance Company, Inc. vs. Hughes Electronics Corporation, G.R. No. 190385. November 16, 2016) 267 SECTION 336 (Use of savings and augmentation) What is the instrument Ordinance required for authority? REQUIREMENT Is there a need for a No need for supplemental budget? supplemental budget SECTION 321 (Use of savings through Supplemental Budget) Appropriation Ordinance covering a supplemental budget a Supplemental budget needed Where should the proposal From the LCE or the From the LCE only emanate? Sanggunian For provinces or highly No urbanized cities, will the ordinance be subject to review by DBM? Yes Nevertheless, as to voting requirement, the affirmative vote of a majority of all the sanggunian members is required to pass an Appropriation Ordinance, whether for annual or supplemental budget, under Article 107 (g) of the IRR of the LGC. Relatedly, the use of savings and augmentation within the same expense class falls under the category of “Use of Appropriated Funds and Savings” under Section 336 of the LGC. Hence, if the Appropriation Ordinance requires qualified majority in its passage, it follows that any modification in said appropriation will have to comply with the same requirement. 29. Can the Sanggunian pass an Appropriation Ordinance covering a supplemental budget for the current fiscal year after December 31? No. The Sanggunian cannot pass an Appropriation Ordinance covering a supplemental budget for the current year after December 31. Supplemental budgets cover changes in the annual budget, thus, they should be authorized within the fiscal year covered by the annual budget. Section 353 of the LGC provides that the official fiscal year of LGUs shall be the period beginning with the first (1st) day of January and ending with the thirty-first (31st) day of December of the same year. Further, the reversion of funds under Section 322 of the LGC is at the end of the fiscal year (except in cases of continuing appropriations when the capital outlay projects are not yet completed). 30. What is the effect if the Appropriation Ordinance is not posted or published? Is posting/publication a requirement for the effectivity of the Appropriation Ordinance? If the Appropriation Ordinance is not posted and/or published, as the case may be, its validity may be questioned. However, laws, ordinances and other issuances enjoy the presumption of regularity and validity until invalidated by the court. 268 31. In the exercise of the veto power, the reenacted figure results in a situation where the expenditure is greater than the estimated income. What figure or procedure should the LGU adopt? By analogy, the rule under Section 323 of the LGC may be applied. The reenacted figure should not exceed the estimated income since the basic rule is that the aggregate amount appropriated shall not exceed the estimates of income (Section 324 [a] of the LGC). 32. One of the functions of the Secretary to the Sanggunian is to keep the seal of the LGU and affix the same with his signature to all ordinances, resolutions, and other official acts of the sanggunian. What is the effect on the ordinance if the Secretary to the Sanggunian does not sign the ordinance? The law provides that the Secretary to the Sanggunian shall affix his signature to all ordinances and present the same to the Presiding Officer for his signature (Section 469 [c] [2] of the LGC and Article 122 [a] [3] [ii] of its IRR). Accordingly, the Secretary to the Sanggunian cannot refuse to sign the Appropriation Ordinance. Otherwise, he/she may be liable under applicable laws. Nevertheless, in case the Secretary to the Sanggunian refuses to sign, such refusal will not affect the validity of the Appropriation Ordinance duly passed by the Sanggunian. Otherwise, that would be tantamount to giving the Secretary to the Sanggunian the “veto power” or the control in deciding whether the Appropriation Ordinance will be valid or not, and if it will be submitted for the consideration of the LCE. 33. One of the functions of the Secretary to the Sanggunian is to keep the seal of the LGU and affix the same with his signature to all ordinances, resolutions, and other official acts of the Sanggunian and present the same to the Presiding Officer for his signature. What if the Presiding Officer does not sign the ordinance? What is the effect on the ordinance? The following provisions of the LGC mandate the Presiding Officer to sign the ordinance: The Secretary to the Sanggunian shall affix his signature to all ordinances and present the same to the Presiding Officer for his signature (Section 469 [c] [2] of the LGC and Article 122 [a] [3] [iii] of the IRR of the same law). The Secretary to the Sanggunian shall forward to the LCE for approval, copies of ordinances enacted by the Sanggunian and duly certified by the Presiding Officer (Section 469 [c] [3] of the LGC and Article 122 [a] [3] [iii] of the IRR of the same law). Further, Section 49 provides that the temporary Presiding Officer “shall certify within ten (10) days from the passage of the ordinance x x x.” 269 However, if the Presiding Officer refuses to sign, such refusal will not affect the validity of the Appropriation Ordinance duly passed by the Sanggunian since the Presiding Officer has no veto power. In such case, the Secretary to the Sanggunian may certify to the fact of the Presiding Officer’s refusal to sign. 34. Can the Sanggunian withdraw the proposed Appropriation Ordinance which was already submitted to the LCE for approval? Currently, there appears to be no relevant legal provision in such a case. However, it may be assumed that the withdrawal of the proposed Appropriation Ordinance may generally not be allowed since the legislative process at such point has already been completed. Hence, the executive consideration of the proposed Appropriation Ordinance should take its course. Ultimately, however, the foregoing premise is without prejudice to the decision of the Sanggunian and/or the LCE based on their sound discretion and the Internal Rules of Procedure. 35. What amount may the LGUs appropriate in their annual/supplemental budgets (ABs/SBs) covering proceeds from loans? May the total amount of the loan as approved (but actually to be released in tranches) be considered as “funds actually available” or only those amounts that are released to and actually received by the LGU? The total amount of the approved loan even if it would be received in tranches may be the subject of appropriations under the AB or SB. Section 316 (b) of the LGC provides that the LFC shall recommend the appropriate tax and other revenue measures or borrowing which may be appropriated to support the budget. Further, SB may be enacted when it is supported by new revenue sources pursuant to Section 321 of the LGC. It may be gleaned from Article 417 of the IRR of the same law as amended by Administrative Order No. 47 dated April 12, 1993, that approved loans may be considered as a new revenue source when it has not been included in the estimate of income which served as basis for the AB or not taken into account during the preparation and enactment of the AB. 36. If the amount to be appropriated will be based on the loan proceeds released to and actually received by the LGU, will the LGU have to conduct a separate procurement for every loan proceeds received, in view of the provisions of RA No. 9184 (The Government Procurement Reform Act)?* Considering the total loan proceeds shall be appropriated (even if released in tranches) in the AB or SB, the procurement shall be for the entire amount of appropriations. Under General Provision No. 32 of the FY 2023 General Appropriations Act, LGUs are allowed to enter into a multi-year contract. A resolution authorizing the LCE to enter into multi-year contracts passed by the sanggunian shall __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 270 be required prior to the commencement of any procurement activity for multi-year projects. Consistent with Section 5 of RA No. 9184, the Approved Budget for the Contract (ABC) for purposes of procurement is the budget for the contract approved by the Sanggunian as embodied in the Appropriation Ordinance authorizing the Annual/Supplement Budget. 37. Whose signatures are required in the Appropriation Ordinance? Will the Appropriation Ordinance need the signature of all the members of the Sanggunian or only those who have voted in favor of its passage? The minimum signatures required in an Appropriation Ordinance are those of the Secretary to the Sanggunian, the Presiding Officer (Section 469 [c] [2] of the LGC), and the LCE (Section 54 of the LGC). The Internal Rules of Procedure of the Sanggunian may, however, provide additional requirements for signatures in the Appropriation Ordinance. 38. Can the Sanggunian validly appropriate amounts for projects under the Office of the Sanggunian? As a general rule, projects should be appropriated in the proper offices under the executive department as it is the LCE who is primarily vested with the responsibility for the execution of local budgets and the accountability therefor. On the other hand, the functions of the Sanggunian is primarily legislative in nature, thus, they are not tasked to execute budgets or implement projects. However, appropriations for projects for the Office of the Sanggunian (e.g., construction of building) may be provided under the said Office. Budget Review 39. May the provision for lumpsum before its legal basis is issued, like salary adjustments, be allowed in budget review? If a legal basis exists during the review of Appropriation Ordinance, the provision for the lumpsum may be allowed. Nevertheless, a condition that subsequent provisions should be made only when there is an existing legal basis at the time of enactment of the Appropriation Ordinance shall be imposed in the review action, otherwise, the lumpsum will be disallowed. 40. Can the reviewing officer include the list of specific documentary requirements (i.e., certificate of savings, trial balance, etc.) in the documents to be submitted if the funding source is from PS savings, loans, etc? In the checklist of Documentary and Signature Requirements for Supplemental Budget, the Certification of Savings is already included. Hence, the Trial Balance may no longer be required. However, it is the responsibility and accountability of the certifying officials in the Certification of Savings to ensure that the declarations therein are true and correct. Otherwise, they may be made liable under applicable laws. 271 41. Can the Sanggunian or LCE withdraw an Appropriation Ordinance already submitted to a reviewing body? Generally, the enactment of the Appropriation Ordinance has already been completed at the LGU level. Hence, the review process must take its course. 42. Under what budget will an LGU operate after the local sanggunian has overridden the veto of the budget or items of appropriation by the LCE? The budget or items of appropriations as overridden shall be implemented. Under Section 55 of the LGC, the vetoed item or items of appropriation shall not take effect unless the Sanggunian overrides the veto; otherwise, the item or items in the Appropriation Ordinance of the previous year corresponding to those vetoed, if any, shall be deemed reenacted. 43. The LCE vetoed some items in the Appropriation Ordinance. The Sanggunian, instead of overriding the veto, passed a new Appropriation Ordinance which already adopted the original Executive Budget. Did the Sanggunian take the proper action on the matter? Which ordinance shall be the basis of budget review? No, the Sanggunian did not take the proper action on the matter. Pursuant to Section 55 of the LGC, the Sanggunian may override the veto of the LCE by two-thirds (2/3) vote of all its members thereby making the ordinance effective. Since the first Appropriation Ordinance, enacted in accordance with the pertinent provisions of the LGC, was already submitted to the reviewing authority, the same shall be the basis of the budget review. 44. May the LGUs appropriate less than 20% for development projects in its annual budget? No. Section 287 of the LGC mandates LGUs to appropriate no less than 20% of its annual NTA for development projects in the annual budget. In which case, insufficient provision of the 20% of the annual NTA for development projects will result to the declaration of the Appropriation Ordinance as inoperative in its entirety. 45. On budget review, can the reviewing officer include the list of specific documentary requirements (i.e., certificate of savings, trial balance, etc.) in the documents to be submitted if the funding source is from PS savings, loans, etc.? In the checklist of Documentary and Signature Requirements for Supplemental Budget, the Certification of Savings is already included. Hence, the Trial Balance may no longer be required. However, it is the responsibility and accountability of the certifying officials in the Certification of Savings to ensure that the declaration therein are true and correct. Otherwise, they may be made liable under applicable laws. 272 46. Should an ordinance authorizing supplemental appropriations (supplemental budget) submitted after the fiscal year be reviewed? Yes, provided the ordinance authorizing the supplemental appropriations was enacted within the fiscal year covered by the annual budget, inasmuch as supplemental budgets cover changes in the annual budget as authorized under Section 321 of the LGC, as implemented by Article 417 of its IRR, as amended by Administrative Order No. 47 dated April 12, 1993. Budget Execution 47. Are adjustments in the release of annual allotments of Offices due to shortfall in the receipt/collection of anticipated revenues considered changes in the Annual Budget, which necessitate the passage of an ordinance or resolution by the Sanggunian? An ordinance or resolution is not required to be passed by the Sanggunian to effect adjustments in the release of quarterly allotments of Offices. Any shortfall in revenue collection should signal the deferment of non-priority expenditures and the non-release of the allotments indicated as reserve, for later release or needing clearance under the Allotment Release Order (ARO). These reserve impositions, earmarking of funds for clearance and withholding of funds for later release to provide safeguards for shortfall in the collection of anticipated revenues are policy-based actions to be reflected in the Appropriation Ordinance for the budget year prior to the issuance or release of the ARO. Accordingly, the deferment of non-priority expenditures and non-release of allotments are activities within the budget execution phase of the local budget process which are authorized by law to be undertaken by the Executive Branch of the LGU. Hence, an ordinance or resolution by the Legislative Branch of the LGU is no longer necessary. However, accountability/accounting reports reflecting the same must be furnished the Sanggunian on a regular basis. Finally, it may be noted that Section 337 of the LGC provides that the “[d]isbursements in accordance with appropriations in the approved annual budget may be made from any local fund in the custody of the treasurer, but the total disbursements from any local fund shall in no case exceed fifty percent (50%) of the uncollected estimated revenue accruing to such local fund in addition to the actual collections: Provided, however, That no cash overdraft in any local fund shall be incurred at the end of the fiscal year. x x x” 48. When is a sanggunian authorization separate from the appropriation ordinance necessary for contracts entered into by the local chief executive for and in behalf of the LGU? If an appropriation ordinance already contains in sufficient detail the project and cost of a capital outlay such that all that the local chief executive needs to do after undergoing the requisite public bidding is to execute the contract, no further 273 sanggunian authorization is required, the appropriation ordinance already being sufficient. On the other hand, if an appropriation ordinance contains lumpsum appropriations for capital outlays or describes the projects in generic terms without details such as “infrastructure projects”, “inter-municipal waterworks, drainage and sewerage, flood control, and irrigation systems projects,” “reclamation projects” or “roads and bridges,” there is an obvious need for a covering contract for every specific project that in turn requires approval by the sanggunian. Specific sanggunian approval may also be required for the purchase of goods and services which are neither specified in the appropriation ordinance nor encompassed within the regular/personal services and maintenance operating expenses. 49. Who between the LCE and the Vice LCE is authorized to approve purchase orders issued in connection with the procurement of supplies, materials, equipment, including fuel, repairs and maintenance of the Sanggunian? The Vice-LCE has the authority. The authority granted to the Vice-LCE to sign all warrants drawn on the local treasury for all expenditures appropriated for the operation of the Sanggunian as well as to approve disbursement vouchers relating thereto necessarily includes the authority to approve purchase orders covering the same. Effectively, since it is the Vice LCE who approves disbursement vouchers and approves the payment for the procurement of the supplies, materials and equipment needed for the operation of the Sanggunian, then he also has the authority to approve the purchase orders to cause the delivery of the said supplies, materials or equipment. 50. Who is the proper authority for the hiring of casual and job order employees in the Office of the Vice-Mayor/Vice-Governor and in the Sanggunian Bayan/Panlungsod/Panlalawigan? The authority to appoint casual and job order employees of the local Sanggunian belongs to the Vice-Mayor/Vice-Governor. The authority of the Vice-Governor/Vicemayor to appoint the officials and employees of the local Sanggunian is anchored on the fact that the salaries of these employees are derived from the appropriation specifically for the said local legislative body. It is the source of their salaries which sets the employees and officials of the local Sanggunian apart from the other employees and officials of the LGU. Accordingly, the appointing power of the Vice-Mayor/Vice-Governor is limited to those employees of the local Sanggunian, as well as those of the Office of the Vice-Mayor/Vice-Governor, whose salaries are paid out of the funds appropriated for the Sangguniang Bayan/ Panlungsod/Panlalawigan. 274 As a corollary, if the salary of an employee or official is charged against the municipal/ city/provincial funds, even if this employee reports to the Vice-Mayor/Vice-Governor or is assigned to his office, the Mayor/Governor retains the authority to appoint the said employee pursuant to Sections 444(b) (v); 455(b)(v); and 465(b) (v) of the LGC. The Vice-Mayor/Vice-Governor, as the presiding officer of the local Sanggunian, has administrative control of the funds of the said body. Accordingly, it is the ViceMayor/Vice-Governor who has the authority to approve disbursement vouchers for expenditures appropriated for the operation of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan. 51. Can the LGU pass an ordinance authorizing use of savings and augmentation under Section 336 of the LGC when operating under a reenacted budget? No. Use of savings and augmentation under Section 336 of the LGC is possible only when there is an “approved annual budget” for the current year. A reenacted budget does not qualify as an approved annual budget for the current year. 52. Is the payment of RATA, Hazard Pay and Subsistence Allowance allowed under a reenacted budget? Yes. RATA, Hazard Pay and Subsistence Allowance, which are authorized in the Appropriation Ordinances of the previous year, are deemed reenacted. To construe “salaries” in a limited sense will deprive an employee with an otherwise authorized allowance or benefit. Only the rates of the subject allowances provided in the prior year’s budget are considered reenacted. Section 323 of the LGC provides that in case of failure to enact the annual appropriations by the sanggunian “only the annual appropriations for salaries and wages of existing positions, statutory and contractual obligations, and essential operating expenses x x x shall be deemed reenacted.” Following the nature of the enumerated items that are deemed reenacted, the phrase “salaries of existing positions” should be construed to cover all authorized personnel services and/or benefits for existing positions in the preceding year. Authorized personnel benefits pertain to those under Section 4 (f) of Congress Joint Resolution No. 4 date June 17, 2009 or the Salary Standardization Law, to wit: Personnel Economic Relief Allowance, Uniform/Clothing Allowance, Year-End and Cash Gift, Hazard Pay, etc. 53. Can the LCE and Vice-LCE hire personnel under a reenacted budget? The LCE may appoint personnel in the executive branch when operating under a reenacted budget as long as the position is existing and funded in the Plantilla of Personnel of the previous year’s budget. 275 Meanwhile, the Vice-LCE can sign appointments for officials and employees in the Sanggunian if their salaries are derived from the appropriation specifically for the said local legislative body (Atienza vs. Villarosa, G.R. No. 161081, May 10, 2005). 54. What is the effect if the reenacted appropriation is higher than the subsequently approved current appropriation? When the reenacted appropriations is higher than the approved appropriations, the LGU concerned should make the necessary adjustments/reductions and corrective actions. The rule under Section 323 of the LGC may be applied, by analogy, which provides that “[i]n case the revised income estimates be less than the aggregate reenacted appropriations, the local treasurer concerned shall accordingly advise the Sanggunian concerned which shall, within ten (10) days from the receipt of such advice, make the necessary adjustments or reductions. The revised appropriations authorized by the Sanggunian concerned shall then be the basis for disbursements.” 55. In case of failure to enact an annual budget, are appropriations authorized in the preceding year’s supplemental budgets deemed reenacted? Yes. Article 415 (a) of the IRR of the LGC provides that “x x x Only the annual appropriations for salaries and wages of existing positions, statutory and contractual obligations, and essential operating expenses authorized in the annual and supplemental budgets for the preceding year shall be deemed reenacted (emphasis supplied). 56. Is the appropriation for development projects of no less than twenty percent (20%) of the NTA included in the reenacted items? No. Only the annual appropriations for salaries and wages of existing positions, statutory and contractual obligations, and essential operating expenses authorized in the annual and supplemental budgets for the preceding year shall be deemed reenacted and disbursement of funds shall be in accordance therewith (Section 323 of the LGC and Article 415 of its IRR). Accordingly, there can be no implementation of new projects under a reenacted budget. In Quisumbing vs, Garcia, G.R. No. 175527, December 8, 2008, the SC reiterated the provision of Section 323 of the LGC which provides that, “in case of a reenacted budget, “only the annual appropriations for salaries and wages of existing positions, statutory and contractual obligations, and essential operating expenses authorized in the annual and supplemental budgets for the preceding year shall be deemed reenacted and disbursement of funds shall be in accordance therewith.” Hence, the appropriation for development projects of no less than twenty percent (20%) of the NTA is not included in the reenacted items. 276 57. Is the honoraria granted to judges by LGUs limited to the maximum rate set under Local Budget Circular No. 62 dated 29 July 1996? The provisions of LBC No. 62 are directory and cannot be used to limit the amount of honoraria to be granted by LGUs to judges stationed in their locality following the rationale of the Supreme Court in the Dadole vs. COA, G.R. No. 125350, December 3, 2002 (Dadole) wherein LBC No. 55 was declared void for going beyond the law it sought to implement. In the case of Dadole, the SC ruled that: “Section 458, par. (a)(1)(xi), of RA 7160, the law that supposedly serves as the legal basis of LBC 55, allows the grant of additional allowances to judges "when the finances of the city government allow." The said provision does not authorize setting a definite maximum limit to the additional allowances granted to judges. Thus, we need not belabor the point that the finances of a city government may allow the grant of additional allowances higher than P1,000 if the revenues of the said city government exceed its annual expenditures.” 58. May the appropriations for security services be used to pay the salaries and wages of contractual employees of the LGU tasked to perform functions of security personnel? No, the appropriation for security services is an MOOE item which may not be used to pay the salaries and wages of contractual employees which is a PS item. Pursuant to Section 336 of the LGC, “funds shall only be available exclusively for the specific purpose for which they have been appropriated.” 59. Can the vetoed item of appropriation which was overridden by the Sanggunian Panlalawigan be implemented and/or executed? Yes. The action of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan overriding the veto by the LCE effectively renders the vetoed items operative, as if not vetoed at all. Pursuant to Section 54 of the LGC, “x x x The sanggunian concerned may override the veto of the local chief executive by two-thirds (2/3) vote of all its members, thereby making the ordinance or resolution effective for all legal intents and purposes.” Allocations to Local Government Units 60. Are barangays created by LGUs after the effectivity of the LGC entitled to NTA shares? No. Pursuant to Section 285 of the LGC, the financial requirements of barangays created by LGUs after the effectivity of the LGC shall be the responsibility of the LGU concerned. 277 61. How are the NTA shares of the cities and municipalities computed considering the NTA portability? Pursuant to RA No. 11683,119 to minimize the effect of conversion, the municipalities converted into cities shall bring their respective allotments derived from the national taxes, known as the NTA, to the allotment of cities. Under Section 2 of the IRR of RA No. 11683, the amount shall be equivalent to the newly-converted cities' most recent NTA shares as municipalities. The resulting allocation shall be distributed based on population, land area, and equal sharing as prescribed in Section 285 of the LGC. The said portability shall be effective for a period of three (3) years from conversion into cityhood. ILLUSTRATION: In 2022, Municipality A was converted into a component city (named as City A) after it was ratified through affirmative votes cast in a plebiscite. Municipality A has a current NTA share of Php 100.0 million. For FY 2023 the total NTA share of LGUs is estimated to be at Php 1.0 Trillion. In the computation of the FY 2023 NTA share of cities and municipalities, the following steps shall be followed. Step 1. Determine the NTA allocation per LGU level based on Section 285 of the LGC. 2023 NTA: Php 1.0 Trillion LGU Level Allocation Total NTA Shares Provinces 23% 230,000,000,000 Cities 23% 230,000,000,000 Municipalities 34% 340,000,000,000 Barangays 20% 200,000,000,000 TOTAL 100% 1,000,000,000,000 Step 2. Subtract the last annual NTA share of the newly-converted city as a municipality from the aggregate share of municipalities and add it to the aggregate share of cities. 2022 NTA of Municipality A: Php 100 million Total Adjusted LGU Level Allocation NTA Shares Provinces 23.00% 230,000,000,000 Cities 23.10% 230,100,000,000 Municipalities 33.90% 339,900,000,000 Barangays 20.00% 200,000,000,000 TOTAL 100% 1,000,000,000,000 119 An Act Amending Section 450 of Republic Act No. 7160, otherwise known as The Local Government Code of 1991, as amended by Republic Act No. 9009, by Providing for the Requisites for the Conversion of a Municipality into a Component City, and for Other Purposes 278 Step 3. Allocate the shares based on the following formula: For provinces, cities, and municipalities: a. Population – Fifty percent (50%); b. Land Area – Twenty-five percent (25%); and c. Equal sharing – Twenty-five percent (25%). Items of Appropriations Included, By Attribution, in the General Fund Annual Budget 62. What are the items of appropriations that shall be included, by attribution, in the General Fund Annual Budget? The following items of appropriations shall be included, by attribution, in the General Fund Annual Budget: a. Gender and Development (GAD) programs, projects and activities (PPAs) (RA No. 7192, RA No. 9710; Philippine Commission on Women [PCW]-DILG-DBMNEDA Joint Memorandum Circular [JMC] No. 2013-01, as amended by PCWDILG-DBM-NEDA JMC No. 2016-01 dated January 12, 2016); b. Programs, projects, activities and services that will address the needs of senior citizens (RA No. 7432, as amended by RA No. 9994 and RA No. 7876) and differently-abled persons (RA No. 7277, as amended by RA Nos. 9442 and 10070, and Batas Pambansa Blg. 344); c. Community-based Human Immunodeficiency Virus/Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (HIV/AIDS) prevention and care services (RA No. 11166); and d. Local Council for the Protection of Children – One percent (1%) of the NTA of barangays, municipalities, and cities shall be allocated for the strengthening and implementation of the programs of the Local Council for the Protection of Children (LCPC) (Section 15 of RA No. 9344). Confidential Expenses 63. What are Confidential Expenses? Pursuant to Commission on Audit-Department of Budget and ManagementDepartment of the Interior and Local Government- Governance Commission for Government-Owned and/or –Controlled Corporations (GCG)-Department of National Defense (DND) Joint Circular (JC) No. 2015-01 dated January 8, 2015, Confidential Expenses refer to those expenses pertaining/related to surveillance activities in civilian government agencies that are intended to support the mandate or operations of the agency. 279 64. What is Confidential Fund? Pursuant to COA-DBM-DILG-GCG-DND JC No. 2015-01 dated January 8, 2015, Confidential Fund (CF) refers to the lumpsum amount provided as such in the appropriation ordinances of LGUs for their Confidential Expenses. 65. What are the legal bases for the allocation and use of funds for confidential expenses? The general welfare clause under Section 16 of the LGC states, among others, that, LGUs shall “…maintain peace and order, and preserve the comfort and convenience of their inhabitants.” COA-DBM-DILG-GCG-DND JC No. 2015-01 dated January 8, 2015 provides the “Guidelines on the Entitlement, Release, Use, Reporting and Audit of Confidential and/or Intelligence Funds.” 66. What are the general guidelines in the allocation and use of public funds for confidential expenses? The guidelines for the allocation and use of public funds for confidential purposes are prescribed under COA-DBM-DILG-GCG-DND JC No. 2015-01. The following provisions thereof may be emphasized: a. The allocation for peace and order concerns may be provided in the annual budgets of LGUs provided that such is a priority concern. It is provided further that the specific amount for Peace and Order Program (POP) is included in their Peace and Order and Public Safety Plan and that there is a specific appropriation for POP in their annual Budget. The computation of allowable CF of an LGU shall be based on the budget of the LGU’s POP only. b. All allocations for CF shall be supported with a Physical and Financial Plan indicating the proposed amount allocated for each program, activity and project, where disbursements pertaining to CE shall be based. c. The release and utilization of the total CF shall be covered by a resolution duly approved by two-thirds (2/3) of the total membership of the Local Peace and Order Council. d. In the event that additional CF in excess of the limitation is extremely necessary, additional appropriation supported with duly authorized supplemental budget shall be approved by the Secretary of the DILG. e. CF shall be used only for the following Confidential Expenses: Purchase of information necessary for the formulation and implementation of program, activities and projects relevant to national security and peace and order; Rental of transport vehicle related to confidential activities; 280 f. Rentals and the incidental expenses related to the maintenance of safehouses; Purchase or rental of supplies, materials and equipment for confidential operations that cannot be done through regular procedures without compromising the information gathering activity concerned; Payment of rewards of informers; Uncover/prevent illegal activities that pose a clear and present danger to agency personnel/property or other facilities and resources under the agency protection, done in coordination with the appropriate law enforcement agencies; and Others that may be authorized by the GAA or other special law/s. In no case shall the CF be used for the following: Salaries, wages, overtime, additional compensation, allowance or other fringe benefits of official and employees who are employed by the government in whatever capacity or elected offices, except when authorized by law; Representation, consultancy fees or entertainment expenses; and Construction or acquisition of buildings and housing structures. g. Conduct of confidential activities shall, as far as practicable, be done with proper collaboration with any of the following law enforcement agencies: (a) the Philippine National Police, (b) the Armed Forces of the Philippines, (c) the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency, or (d) other agencies with lawenforcement functions. Such collaboration, if undertaken, must be specified in the accomplishment report of the concerned agency. h. Disbursement from CF shall be supported with documentary evidence of payment, among others, which shall be submitted to the Intelligence and Confidential Fund Audit Unit in a sealed envelope signed by the Special Disbursing Officer. i. Disbursements from the CF shall be supported by Certification of the Accountable Officer of the CF signed under oath. 67. What are Peace and Order Programs (POP)? Pursuant to COA-DBM-DILG-GCG-DND JC No. 2015-01 dated January 8, 2015 and DILG Memorandum Circular No. 2022-118 dated September 19, 2022,120 Peace and Order Programs refer to any or a combination of the following programs, activities and projects which may be included as part of the Peace and Order and Public Safety Plan of LGUs so that these shall be eligible for funding of the CF: 120 Guidelines on the Development and Formulation of the Peace and Order and Public Safety Plan (POPS-PLAN) 2023-2025 281 a. Crime and disorder – violations of the law and situations that disrupt harmonious living within a community. Illegal drugs – a mandatory sub-area, in compliance to RA No. 9165 or the Comprehensive Dangerous Drugs Act of 2022 Consistent with the above provisions, this sub-area is expected to be formulated and accomplished by the Sub-TWG on LADPA formulation, in close coordination with the POPS TWG, as may be necessary. b. Conflict – Refers to a situation where two or more groups are in disagreement with each other or in disagreement with the State. The source of disagreement may be the control and possession of resources, when one party feels deprived, offended or oppressed by another or by the policies and programs of the State. i. Violent extremism and terrorism; ii. Insurgency/armed conflict; and iii. Prevalence of private armed groups, contributing to the proliferation of gun culture, “rido” or clan wars, unjust use of military and police auxiliaries. c. Threats to the environment and human security (illegal logging, illegal mining, illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing (IUUF), smuggling, illegal activities related to quarrying, etc.) d. Other related-peace and order concerns that may be deemed necessary. 68. What are the procedural guidelines in the release, use and augmentation of Confidential Fund? COA-DBM-DILG-GCG-DND JC No. 2015-01 likewise provides for the following procedural guidelines: a. LGUs with peace and order concerns shall allocate in their respective Annual Appropriations Ordinance funds for POP, as part of the Peace and Order and Public Safety Plan. The total amount of CF shall not exceed thirty (30%) of the total annual amount allocated for the LGU’s POP. b. The release and use of CF shall be covered by a Resolution duly approved by two-thirds (2/3) of the total membership of the Local Peace and Order Council. c. LGUs shall secure Certification from the concerned PNP Chief in their locality relative to the peace and order situation highlighting in concrete details the circumstances which require the urgency in allocating CF. d. Additional CF shall be covered with a supplemental budget authorized by the Sanggunian concerned and/or reviewed by the DBM Secretary or his authorized representative as the case may be, the source of which shall not come from the 20% Development Fund of the LGU. 282 e. Request for additional CF in excess of the ceiling provided in item 5.1.3.1 of the JC shall be filed with the concerned DILG Field Officer justifying the need therefor supported with the following documentary requirements: f. Duly approved Three-Year Peace and Order and Public Safety Plan; Annual and Supplemental Appropriations Ordinance indicating the appropriations for CF; Certification from the Budget Officer as to the availability of appropriations; Certifications from the concerned PNP Chief in their locality relative to the peace and order situation highlighting in concrete details the circumstances which require the urgency in allocating funds for confidential activities; Physical and Financial Plans for both the original allocation for CF and the subject request; and Certification of Full Disclosure Policy compliance. Upon review of the documents and field-verification of the circumstances as to the need to allocate additional CF, the DILG Regional Office shall forward the request within five (5) days to the Director of the Bureau of Local Government Supervision (BLGS) for further evaluation. The Director of the BLGS shall submit his or her recommendation to the Secretary of the DILG, who shall approve or disapprove the request. Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund 69. What is a “State of Calamity”? Pursuant to RA No. 10121121 and its IRR issued on September 27, 2010, it is a condition involving mass casualty and/or major damages to property, disruption of means of livelihood, roads and normal way of life of people in the affected areas as a result of the occurrence of natural or human-induced hazard. 70. What is the Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund (LDRRMF)? Is it over and above the Calamity Fund? Pursuant to RA No. 10121, the present Local Calamity Fund shall henceforth be known as the Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund (LDRRMF) which shall be sourced from not less than five percent (5%) of the estimated revenue from regular sources. Hence, the LDRRMF is not over and above but is now what was previously called the Local Calamity Fund. 121 An Act Strengthening the Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and Management System, Providing for the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Framework and Institutionalizing the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Plan, Appropriating Funds Therefor and for Other Purposes 283 71. Is LDRRMF sourced only from the not less than 5% of the estimated revenue from regular sources? Per Commission on Audit Circular No. 2012-002 dated September 12, 2012,122 the following are all the sources of the LDRRMF: a. Not less than five percent (5%) of the estimated revenues from regular sources of the LGUs; b. The unexpended balance of the LDRRMF in the preceding years within the 5year validity period of the Special Trust Fund; c. Funds transferred from the NDRRMF upon approval of the President; and d. Funds received from other LGUs and other sources. 72. What are the general guidelines on the use and allocation of the LDRRMF? Pursuant to NDRRMC-DBM-DILG Joint Memorandum Circular No. 2013-1 dated March 25, 2013, citing Section 21 of RA No. 10121, the LDRRMF amounting to not less than five percent (5%) of the estimated revenue from regular sources shall be set aside to support disaster risk management activities such as, but not limited to the predisaster preparedness programs including training, purchase of disaster response and rescue equipment, supplies and medicines, for post-disaster activities, and payment of premiums on calamity insurance. Of the amount appropriated for LDRRMF, thirty percent (30%) shall be allocated as a lumpsum Quick Response Fund (QRF) or stand-by fund for relief and recovery programs in order that situation and living conditions of people in communities or areas stricken by disasters, calamities, epidemics or complex emergencies, may be normalized as quickly as possible. 73. Can the purchase of drugs and medicines be included as part of pre-disaster activities for which the LDRRMF may be used? Yes. Purchase of drugs and medicines may be included as part of pre-disaster activities for which the LDRRMF may be used (Section 1, Rule 18, IRR of RA No. 10121). 74. Who may declare and lift a state of calamity? Pursuant to Section 16 of RA No. 10121, the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC) as the National Council shall recommend to the President of the Philippines the declaration of a cluster of barangays, municipalities, cities, provinces and regions under a state of calamity, and the lifting thereof based on the criteria set by the National Council. 122 Accounting and Reporting Guidelines for the Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund (LDRRMF) of Local Government Units (LGUs), National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund (NDRRMF) given to LGUs and Receipts from Other Sources 284 The declaration and lifting of the state of calamity may also be issued by the local sanggunian upon the recommendation of the LDRRMC, based on the results of the damage assessment and needs analysis. Aid to Barangays 75. What is the legal basis for the provision of Aid to Barangays? Section 324 (c) of the LGC provides that, “[i]n the case of provinces, cities, and municipalities, aid to component barangays shall be provided in amounts of not less than One Thousand Pesos (P1,000.00) per barangay;” Gender and Development 76. What is Gender and Development (GAD)? GAD is an approach to development that focuses on how social, economic, political and cultural forces determine how differently women and men participate in, benefit from, and control resources and activities for development. It recognizes the different roles, responsibilities, expectations, interests, needs, and contributions of men and women in society and integrates these gender concerns in the development planning process. GAD recognizes women as agents of development and not merely as passive recipients of development assistance. 77. What are the legal bases for GAD and GAD Planning and Budgeting? RA No. 7192 and Executive Order No. 273 mandate agencies, including LGUs, to institutionalize GAD in government by incorporating the GAD concerns in their planning, programming and budgeting process. The allocation of funds for the implementation of a GAD Plan is a statutory requirement that must be complied with by provinces, cities, municipalities and barangays. The Philippine Plan for Gender-Responsive Development (PPGD), 1995-2025, which was adopted through E.O. No. 273, specifies the services that must be implemented for women in relation to those stipulated in RA No. 7160. DBM-NEDA-NCRFW JC No. 2004-1 (superseding DBM-NEDA-NCRFW JC No. 200101) provides the guidelines for the preparation of annual GAD Plan and Budget and Accomplishment Report to implement the Section on programs/projects related to GAD as provided in the annual GAA. For a more comprehensive discussion on GAD, refer to the Primer on Gender Mainstreaming and Institutionalization in the Budgeting Process, August 2002, issued jointly by the DBM and NCRFW through the support of the Canadian International Development Agency. 285 PCW-DILG-DBM-NEDA JMC No. 2013-1 prescribes the policies and procedures in mainstreaming gender perspective in local planning, programming and budgeting; local legislation; project development, implementation, monitoring and evaluation. PCW-DILG-DBM-NEDA JMC No. 2016-01 dated January 12, 2016 provides the guidelines for the preparation of GAD Plan and Budget; and Accomplishment Reports. 78. What is a GAD Plan? A GAD Plan is a tool for gender mainstreaming. A GAD Plan is a systematically designed set of PPAs carried out by agencies for a given period of time to address gender issues and concerns of their respective sectors and constituents, specifying the targets to be achieved and identifying the performance indicators that will measure their accomplishments. The GAD Plan is viewed as an integral part of the overall LGU plan. The formulation of a GAD Plan shall follow the regular planning and budget calendar/schedule of LGUs and shall be anchored on the existing Comprehensive Land Use Plan, Provincial Development and Physical Framework Plan/Comprehensive Development Plan, Local Development Investment Program and Annual Investment Program (AIP) preparation. 79. What is a GAD Budget? A GAD budget is the total amount provided in the General Fund Budget of the LGU to finance the PPAs in the GAD Plan. The earmarking of at least five percent (5%) of the total annual appropriation for GADrelated activities is an indicative figure that should be attributed to the existing PPAs of LGUs’ budgets. Accordingly, the GAD budget must not be interpreted as an additional and separate fund that will be provided by the national or local government. 80. How is the GAD budget prepared? The GAD Budget is prepared based on the estimated costs of functions and PPAs translated from the demands/commitments identified in the GAD Plan. The GAD Focal Point Chairperson, in close coordination with the LGU’s Budget Officer, shall be responsible for the preparation of the GAD Budget. The review of the GAD budget proposal is done following the regular evaluation process applicable to the regular budget proposal, of which the GAD budget is a component. In the determination of expenditure ceilings in terms of sectoral service and nature of expenditure as basis for budget preparation, the LFC shall ensure that the GAD Plan, approved by the LDC and the Sanggunian, are considered as among the primary source documents used. 286 The costs of functions and PPAs to implement the GAD Plan may include any or all of the following items: • • Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses; and Capital Outlays. The GAD PPAs may be classified into: a. Organization-focused, where efforts are geared to respond to gender issues that affect the welfare and performance of women and men employees of the LGU; and b. Client-focused, where efforts address gender issues that affect the LGU’s clients and/or constituents. 81. Who reviews and approves the GAD Plan and Budget (GPB)? Pursuant to PCW-DILG-DBM-NEDA JMC No. 2016-01 dated January 12, 2016, all provinces, highly urbanized cities, independent component cities, and LGUs within Metro Manila shall submit their GPBs, accompanied by their GAD ARs, to the DILG Regional Office for their review and endorsement. Reviewed and endorsed GPBs shall be returned to the LGUs concerned for incorporation in their annual budgets to be enacted by their Local Sanggunian. Component cities and municipalities shall submit their GPBs to the PPDO to ensure the alignment of the municipality/city GAD PPAs with the priorities of the province and then from the PPDO to the DILG Provincial Office for its review and endorsement. DILG endorsed GPBs shall be returned to the LGUs concerned for incorporation in their annual budgets to be enacted by their Local Sanggunian. Indigenous Cultural Communities (ICC)/Indigenous Peoples (IP) 82. What is the funding source for the salaries of ICCs/IPs? Since the representative from ICCs/IPs is specified in the LGC, and reinforced in RA No. 8371, the funding requirements relative to the IP representative to the Sanggunian shall be charged against the PS budget of the LGU, which shall be waived from the PS limitation only on the initial year of creation. Creation of Positions 83. What is the general rule on the creation of positions in LGUs? Section 76 of the LGC empowers LGUs to design and implement their own organizational structure and staffing pattern that will effectively address their 287 respective developmental plans, programs, objectives and priorities. The creation of positions shall be consistent with the rules and regulations established under Civil Service Commission Memorandum Circular No. 12, series of 2022.123 Further, per existing policy, creation of non-mandatory positions and offices in LGUs may be allowed subject to the following conditions: That they are priority needs as identified by the LCE, the Sanggunian and/or LDCs concerned consistent with Section 17 of the LGC; All mandatory positions stipulated under the LGC and other pertinent laws have been created and provided; The SSL has been fully implemented; The general limitations on PS expenditures are not exceeded; and The classification of the positions is consistent with the standards and implementing rules and regulations of RA No. 6758. 84. Can the LGU create new positions without corresponding appropriations? The LGC provides that the Sanggunian shall determine the positions and the salaries, wages, allowances and other emoluments and benefits of officials and employees paid wholly or mainly from local funds and provide for expenditures necessary for the proper conduct of programs, projects, services and activities of the local government (Section 447 [a][1][viii]; Section 458 [a][1][viii]; and Section 468 [a][1][viii] of the LGC). Accordingly, any position created in the LGU shall be adequately provided with funding requirements for basic salary, including the associated compensation attached to the position such as allowances, RATA if entitled thereto, year-end benefits, etc., for it to be considered a properly created position. Otherwise, a position is not deemed properly created if such had not been fully provided corresponding appropriations for basic salary and other compensation. 85. Are unfunded positions considered vacant and deemed to be abolished? A vacant position is an authorized position in the official plantilla which is unfilled. Although vacant, the same is covered by adequate appropriation for salaries and associated compensation costs. On the other hand, unfunded positions, that is, those not covered by funds for salaries and associated compensation costs, should be deleted in the plantilla since there are no appropriations to back up their legal existence. 123 2022 Guidelines and Standards in the Establishment of Organizational Structures and Staffing Patterns in Local Government Units 288 Annex A. Synchronized Local Planning and Budgeting Calendar YEAR/ MONTH Year 1 – July 1. 2. 1. 1. 1. 2. 3. 1. 2. Year 1 – August to November ACTIVITIES NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES GUIDELINES, MANUALS, TOOLS, SYSTEMS 3. 4. 1. 1. 2. 3. RPS Sourcebook (DILG) CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) DILG Policy Guidelines on Updating of Local Plans PLPEM and other reference documents (NEDA) PLPEM and other reference documents (NEDA) eSRE (BLGF) LGFPMS (BLGF) RPS Sourcebook (DILG) CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) LGPMS (DILG) RaPIDS (DILG) PLPEM and other reference documents (NEDA) RPS Sourcebook (DILG) CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) RaPIDS Guide (DILG) NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES (Election Year) Reconstitution of Local Planning Team (Election Year) Reconstitution of Local Planning Team Setting of planning guidelines for updating planning database Assessment of implementation of current PDPFP Preparation of workplan for updating/preparation of CDP Updating RaPIDS/LDIS Updating of Ecological Profile Formulation of goals, strategies and objectives based on the review and analysis in order to make them more responsive to the current situation and to make them consistent with higher level plans Identification of priority PPAs to achieve the BLGF generates/ updates financial indicators and transmits to Provinces through the DILG RaPIDS / LDIS financial indicators from BLGF made available to cities and municipalities by DILG CITY/ MUNICIPALITY PROVINCE Updating of planning database of Formulation of PDPFP (Analysis of the planning environment; Formulation of goals, strategies and objectives; Identification of priority PPAs) 289 YEAR/ MONTH ACTIVITIES NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES GUIDELINES, MANUALS, TOOLS, SYSTEMS NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES CITY/ MUNICIPALITY PROVINCE goals/objectives for the next six years (structured list of PPAs) Year 1 – September DILG Guidelines on Reconstitution of Local Special Bodies CSO Handbook (Election Year) Reconstitution of Local Special Bodies (Local Development Council, Peace and Order Council, Local Health Board and Local School Board) (Election Year) Reconstitution of Local Special Bodies (Local Development Council, Peace and Order Council, Local Health Board and Local School Board) DILG Policy Guidelines on Updating of Local Plans Convening of PDC to present draft PDPFPs and Structured List of PPAs of Cities and Municipalities for the purpose of harmonization Mayor to present Structured List of PPAs PLPEM (NEDA) Approval of PDPFP Medium-Term Revenue (OwnSource and External) Forecasts for Planning Purposes generated (latest year Yt-2) by Local Treasurers Medium-Term Revenue (OwnSource and External) Forecasts for Planning Purposes generated (latest year Yt-2) by Local Treasurers Medium-Term Forecasts for Current Operating Expenses prepared by Local Finance Committee Medium-Term Forecasts for Current Operating Expenses prepared by Local Finance Committee Sectoral Development Plans completed (Ranked List of PPAs completed) Preparation of First Draft of LDIP: New Development Investment Financing Potential component 1. 2. Year 1 – NovemberDecember RMM (BLGF) BOM (DBM) 1. 2. Year 1 December – Year 2 February BLGF to provide Medium Term Forecasts to Local Treasurers (November) RPS Sourcebook (DILG) CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) PLPEM (NEDA) Formulation PDIP of 290 YEAR/ MONTH Year 2 – January 1. 2. CDP Illustrative Guide (DILG) Year 2 – March CDP Illustrative Guide (DILG) Finalization of LDIP: Finalization of Local Resource Mobilization Program and Medium-Term Financing Plan Drafting of Implementation Instruments: Legislative Requirements, CapDev Agenda and Monitoring and Evaluation Strategy Finalization of Implementation Instruments Conduct review of approved CDP and provide feedback to component LGUs Approval of CDP to include the Implementation Instruments (LDIP, Legislative Requirements, CapDev Program and M&E Strategy) Submission of CDP to the Province for review Approval of PDIP 1. Preparation of AIP by the Local Finance Committee Preparation of AIP by the Local Finance Committee Approval of AIP by the Local Sanggunian Approval of AIP by the Local Sanggunian 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. Year 2 – June 15* CITY/ MUNICIPALITY PROVINCE PLPEM and other reference documents (NEDA) 2. Year 2 – June 7* NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES CDP Illustrative Guide RMM (BLGF) Year 2 – February Year 2 – May* ACTIVITIES NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES GUIDELINES, MANUALS, TOOLS, SYSTEMS RPS Sourcebook (DILG) CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) RMM (BLGF) BOM (DBM) PLPEM (NEDA) CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) BOM (DBM) BOM (DBM) Issuance of Local Budget Memorandum on NTA level for ensuing year by DBM 291 YEAR/ MONTH ACTIVITIES NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES GUIDELINES, MANUALS, TOOLS, SYSTEMS NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES Year 2 – June 16* Year 2 – July 5* BOM (DBM) BOM (DBM) Year 2 – July 15* BOM (DBM) Year 2 – August* BOM (DBM) Year 2 – October* BOM (DBM) Issuance of Budget Call Conduct of Budget Forum Prepare and submit Budget Proposals (Department Heads) Conduct of Budget Hearing (August 15) Preparation of Executive Budget (October 10) Submission of Executive Budget to Local Sanggunian for approval (not later than October 16) Enactment of an Appropriation Ordinance authorizing the Annual Budget Submission of Appropriation Ordinance to DBM for review Submission of Executive Budget to Local Sanggunian for approval (not later than October 16) Enactment of an Appropriation Ordinance authorizing the Annual Budget Submission of Appropriation Ordinance to Province for review Review of Appropriation Ordinance of Component Cities and Municipalities Budget Execution Budget Execution Budget Accountability Budget Accountability Monitoring of implementation of the PDPFP and PDIP Year 2 – October 17 onwards* BOM (DBM) Year 2 – Within three (3) days after approval of the Ordinance authorizing the Annual or Supplemental Appropriations* Year 2 – Within ninety (90) days from the receipt of the submitted Annual or Supplemental Budgets for review of Provinces, Cities and Municipalities* Year 3 – JanuaryDecember* BOM (DBM) Year 3 – JanuaryDecember* BOM (DBM) BOM (DBM) PLPEM (NEDA) Review Appropriation Ordinance Provinces, HUCs/ICCs Municipality Pateros CITY/ MUNICIPALITY PROVINCE of of and of Issuance of Budget Call Conduct of Budget Forum Prepare and submit Budget Proposals (Department Heads) Conduct of Budget Hearing (August 15) Preparation of Executive Budget (October 10) Review Appropriation Ordinance Barangays 292 of of YEAR/ MONTH NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES GUIDELINES, MANUALS, TOOLS, SYSTEMS NG OVERSIGHT AGENCIES 1. 2. Yearn – June 7* 1. 2. PLPEM (NEDA) CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) BOM (DBM) Monitoring implementation the CDP Adjustment of LDIP of of Adjustment of PDIP CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) Yearn – May* CITY/ MUNICIPALITY PROVINCE 1. April* RPS Sourcebook (DILG) 2. CDP Guide and Illustrative Guide (DILG) PLPEM (NEDA) ACTIVITIES Preparation of AIP Preparation of AIP Approval of AIP Approval of AIP * - recurring every year 293 Annex B. Proposed Major Final Output (MFO) and Performance Indicators (PIs) of the Different Mandatory Offices in LGUs OFFICE LOCAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE (LCE) LOCAL SANGGUNIAN (including Vice-LCE) MANDATE/ FUNCTION Exercise general supervision and control over all programs, projects, services and activities of the LGU MFO PIs PROGRAMS MFO 1: EXECUTIVE GOVERNANCE SERVICES Percentage of programs, projects, and activities (PPAs) fully implemented within prescribed schedule EXECUTIVE GOVERNANCE PROGRAM Enforce all laws and ordinances relative to the governance of the LGU and the exercise of the appropriate corporate powers Ensure the delivery of basic services and the provision of adequate facilities Enact ordinances, approve resolutions and appropriate funds for the welfare of the LGU and its inhabitants Approve ordinances and pass resolutions necessary for an efficient and effective local government Approve Annual and Supplemental Budgets of the LGU Percentage of policies and ordinances fully enforced Percentage of services delivered rated at least satisfactory by clients MFO 1: LEGISLATIVE SERVICES Number of ordinances and/or resolutions enacted LEGISLATIVE PROGRAM Percentage of enacted ordinances and/or resolutions rated at least satisfactory by stakeholders Percentage of appropriation ordinances enacted within prescribed deadline Review action completed for all submitted LGU budgets within the prescribed period rated at least satisfactory in the case of Annual Budget LOCAL ACCOUNTANT Take charge of both the accounting and internal audit services of the LGU Review supporting documents before preparation of vouchers to determine completeness of requirements Prepare and submit financial statements to the LCE and the sanggunian concerned MFO 1: ACCOUNTING SERVICES Percentage of expenditures with NO adverse COA audit findings FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING AND REPORTING PROGRAM Percentage of Bank Reconciliation completed within 5 days from receipt of Bank Statements Percentage of cash advances liquidated within the prescribed deadline 294 MANDATE/ FUNCTION OFFICE MFO PIs PROGRAMS Percentage of financial reports submitted within the prescribed deadline Budget Utilization Rate (Obligation and Disbursement) LOCAL ADMINISTRATOR Develop management and administrationrelated plans and strategies upon approval of the LCE MFO 1: MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES Delivery of administrative support services during and after man-made and natural disasters and calamities Number of management and administration-related plans and strategies of PPAs Percentage of management and administration-related plans/strategies or PPAs approved MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION PROGRAM Percentage of management and administration-related plans/strategies and PPAs implemented Percentage of effectiveness and efficiency of response during disaster/calamities LOCAL AGRICULTURIST Delivery of basic agricultural and support services MFO 1: AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION SERVICES Percentage of agricultural services fully implemented within prescribed schedule AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION PROGRAM Percentage of increase in agricultural/aquacultural productivity of farmers, fishermen and local entrepreneurs LOCAL ASSESSOR Ensure all laws and policies governing the appraisal and assessment of real properties for taxation purposes are properly executed Exercise the functions of appraisal and assessment primarily for taxation purposes of all real properties in the LGU concerned Issue, upon request of any interested party, certified copies of MFO 1: APPRAISAL AND ASSESSMENT SERVICE Percentage of updated records on the valuation and assessment of real properties APPRAISAL AND ASSESSMENT OF REAL PROPERTY PROGRAM Percentage of increase in tax revenues due to appraisal and assessment of real properties Percentage of certificates issued within the prescribed period of issuance 295 MANDATE/ FUNCTION assessment records of real property and all other records relative to its assessment OFFICE LOCAL BUDGET OFFICER Exercise technical supervision and visitorial functions (Provincial Assessor) Review and consolidate budget proposals of different departments and offices of the LGU MFO PIs PROGRAMS Percentage of city/municipal assessors supervised MFO 1: BUDGET MANAGEMENT SERVICES On-time submission of consolidated budget proposals to LCE BUDGET MANAGEMENT PROGRAM On-time release (within the standard time) of release documents Assist the LCE in the preparation of the annual and supplemental budgets On-time submission of required reports to oversight agencies Study and evaluate budgetary implications of proposed legislation and submit comments and recommendations thereon Percentage attendance to meetings of LFC Percentage of acceptance of the proposed budget by the LCE Acts as member of the Local Finance Committee On-time processing of action documents No overdrafts appropriation LOCAL ENGINEER Administer, coordinate, supervise, and control the construction, maintenance, improvement, and repair of roads, bridges, and other engineering and public works projects of the LGU concerned Provide engineering services to the LGU concerned, including investigation and survey, engineering designs, feasibility studies, and project management. ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE MANAGEMENT SERVICES in Percentage of infrastructure projects completed according to standards, within project budget and schedule ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE MANAGEMENT PROGRAM Percentage of reports, designs, studies and other required documents completed within the prescribed schedule/deadline Percentage of permits issued within prescribed schedule (building permits, etc.) Regulate and ensure compliance with existing policies in infrastructure development and public works 296 OFFICE LOCAL GENERAL SERVICES OFFICER LOCAL HEALTH OFFICER MANDATE/ FUNCTION Take custody of and be accountable for all properties, real or personal, and supplies owned by the LGU and those granted to it in the form of donation, reparation, assistance and counterpart of joint projects. MFO PIs PROGRAMS MFO 1: FACILITIES AND SUPPLY MANAGEMENT SERVICES Percentage of Property, Plant and Equipment of the LGU accounted for in the year-end inventory report submitted on time to the Commission on Audit GENERAL SERVICES PROGRAM Quantity of supplies purchased, issued and balances properly maintained Maintain and supervise janitorial, security, landscaping and other related services in all local government public buildings and other real property, whether owned or leased by the LGU Formulate and implement policies, plans, programs and projects to promote the health of the people in the LGU concerned Percentage of public buildings and other real property properly maintained MFO 1: HEALTH IMPROVEMENT SERVICES Number of policies formulated and implemented HEALTH SERVICES PROGRAM Strategic local health plan prepared within deadline Information campaign and render health intelligence services Number of confined/out-patient served Number of persons provided with health services Number of barangays provided with health information services LOCAL LEGAL OFFICER LOCAL PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COORDINATOR Render his opinion in writing on any question of law when requested to do so by the LCEs, Sanggunian and other department heads Represent the LGU in all civil actions and special proceedings Formulate integrated economic, social, physical and other development plans and policies for consideration of the local development council. MFO 1: LEGAL ASSISTANCE AND RESEARCH SERVICES Percentage of requests for legal opinion/ recommendations acted upon/responded to within 15 days from receipt of request LEGAL SERVICES PROGRAM Percentage of cases represented or acted upon MFO 1: PLANNING, MONITORING AND EVALUATION SERVICES Percentage of PPAs in the duly updated approved LDIP derived from the duly updated approved PDPFP/CDP PLANNING, MONITORING AND EVALUATION PROGRAM Percentage of PPAs in the duly approved AIP derived from the annual slice of the 297 OFFICE MANDATE/ FUNCTION Monitor and evaluate the implementation of the different programs, activities, and projects in the LGU concerned in accordance with the approved development plan MFO PIs PROGRAMS duly updated approved LDIP Percentage of PPAs in the Appropriation Ordinance derived from the duly approved AIP Percentage of project proposals prepared Percentage of projects implemented and monitored LOCAL SOCIAL WELFARE AND DEVELOPMENT OFFICER LOCAL TREASURER Formulate and implement social welfare measures, plans and strategies Be in the frontline of service delivery, particularly those which have to do with immediate relief during and assistance in the aftermath of man-made and natural and calamities The treasurer shall take charge of the treasury office, perform the duties provided for under Book II of the LGC. Take custody and exercise proper management of the funds of the LGU concerned. Submit to the LCE certified statement of income and expenditures for budget preparation purposes MFO 1: SOCIAL WELFARE AND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES Improved response time to social welfare issues and concerns SOCIAL AND WELFARE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM TREASURY OPERATIONS SERVICES Percentage of actual revenues over estimated revenues for the current year TREASURY OPERATIONS PROGRAM Percentage increase of collections for the current year over last year Percentage of notices issued to delinquent taxpayers within the prescribed period Percentage of civil remedies/actions filed against delinquent taxpayers within the prescribed period Percentage of collections duly receipted and intactly deposited the following banking day Submission of detailed statement of receipts and expenditures within the prescribed period 298 OFFICE LOCAL VETERINARIAN LOCAL DISASTER RISK REDUCTION AND MANGEMENT OFFICER MANDATE/ FUNCTION Regulate the keeping of domestic animals. Regulate and inspect poultry, milk and dairy products for public consumption Enforce all laws and regulations for the prevention of cruelty to animals. Take the necessary measures to eradicate, prevent or cure all forms of animal diseases Set the direction, development, implementation, and coordination of disaster risk management program MFO PIs PROGRAMS MFO 1: VETERINARY REGULATION SERVICES Percentage of required laws, acts and other regulatory guidelines implemented/ enforced VETERINARY REGULATION PROGRAM Percentage of reported animal diseases treated MFO 1: DISASTER RISK REDUCTION AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES Number of predisaster training conducted DRRM formulated updated DRRM PROGRAM Plan and 299 Annex C. The Service Falling Under Each of the Major Sectors Pursuant to the New Government Accounting System of the Commission on Audit General Public Services Sector Executive Services Legislative Services Planning and Development Coordination Services Budgeting Services Treasury Services Accounting Services Administrative Services Civil Registry Services General Services Assessment of Real Property Services Auditing Services l Information Services Legal Services l Prosecution Services Administration of Justice Services Land Registration Services Claim Registration Services Police Services Fire Protection Services Repair and Maintenance of Government Facilities Social Services Sector Education and Manpower Development Public Education Services Medical Subsidiary Services Manpower Development Services Sports Center, Athletic Field, and Playground Maintenance Service cultural Project Services Cultural/Conference/Convention Center Operation Services Health Health Services Field Projects (Immunization, Inoculation, Blood Donor Services) Day Care Clinic Hospital Services Chest Clinic Housing and Community Development Housing Projects Sanitary Services Street Cleaning Garbage Collection Sewerage and Drainage Street Lighting Community Development Services 300 Economic Services Sector Agricultural Services Veterinary Services Natural Resources Services Architectural Services Engineering Services Economic Enterprises and Public Utilities Operation Services Tourism Services Other Services Services that cannot be categorized in any of the sectors identified above shall be under other services. 301 Annex D. Coding Structure by Type of LGU and Office* 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Province 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 02 02 02 02 02 02 02 02 03 Mandatory Offices 001 Office of the Governor 002 Office of the Vice-Governor 003 Office of the Members of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan 004 Office of the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlalawigan 005 Office of the Provincial Treasurer 006 Office of the Provincial Assessor 007 Office of the Provincial Accountant 008 Office of the Provincial Engineer 009 Office of the Provincial Budget Officer 010 Office of the Provincial Planning and Development Coordinator 011 Office of the Provincial Legal Officer 012 Office of the Provincial Administrator 013 Office of the Provincial Health Officer 014 Office of the Provincial Social Welfare and Development Officer 015 Office of the Provincial General Services Officer 016 Office of the Provincial Agriculturist 017 Office of the Provincial Veterinarian 018 Office of the Provincial Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Officer 019 Office of the Provincial Internal Audit Service 020 Office of the Provincial Persons with Disability Affairs Officer 021 Office of the Provincial Public Employment Service Manager 022 Office of the Provincial Youth Development Officer Optional Offices 001 Office of the Provincial Population Officer 002 Office of the Provincial Environment and Natural Resources Officer 003 Office of the Provincial Architect 004 Office of the Provincial Information Officer 005 Office of the Provincial Agricultural and Biosystems Engineer 006 Office of the Provincial Cooperatives Development Officer 007 Office of the Provincial Tourism Officer Others 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 Cities 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 Mandatory Offices 001 Office of the City Mayor 002 Office of the City Vice-Mayor 003 Office of the Sangguniang Panlungsod Members 004 Office of the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod 005 Office of the City Treasurer 006 Office of the City Assessor 007 Office of the City Accountant 008 Office of the City Budget Officer 009 Office of the City Planning and Development Coordinator 010 Office of the City Engineer 011 Office of the City Health Officer 012 Office of the City Civil Registrar 013 Office of the City Administrator 014 Office of the City Legal Officer 015 Office of the City Veterinarian 016 Office of the City Social Welfare and Development Officer 017 Office of the City General Services Officer __________________________________ * Revised as of reprinting for FY 2024 302 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 01 01 01 01 01 01 02 02 02 02 02 02 02 02 02 03 018 Office of the City Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Officer 019 Office of the City Internal Audit Service 020 Office of the City Persons with Disability Affairs Officer 021 Office of the City Public Employment Service Manager 022 Office of the City Youth Development Officer 023 Office of the City Senior Citizen Affairs Head Optional Offices 001 Office of the City Architect 002 Office of the City Information Officer 003 Office of the City Agriculturist 004 Office of the City Population Officer 005 Office of the City Environment and Natural Resources Officer 006 Office of the City Agricultural and Biosystems Engineer 007 Office of the City Cooperatives Development Officer 008 Office of the City Tourism Officer Others 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Municipalities 01 Mandatory Offices 01 001 Office of the Municipal Mayor 01 002 Office of the Municipal Vice-Mayor 01 003 Office of the Sangguniang Bayan Members 01 004 Office of the Secretary to the Sangguniang Bayan 01 005 Office of the Municipal Treasurer 01 006 Office of the Municipal Assessor 01 007 Office of the Municipal Accountant 01 008 Office of the Municipal Budget Officer 01 009 Office of the Municipal Planning and Development Coordinator 01 010 Office of the Municipal Engineer/Building Official 01 011 Office of the Municipal Health Officer 01 012 Office of the Municipal Civil Registrar 01 013 Office of the Municipal Social Welfare and Development 01 014 Office of the Municipal Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Officer 01 015 Office of the Municipal Internal Audit Service 01 016 Office of the Municipal Persons with Disability Affairs Officer 01 017 Office of the Municipal Public Employment Service Manager 01 018 Office of the Municipal Youth Development Officer 01 019 Office of the Municipal Senior Citizen Affairs Head 02 Optional Offices 02 001 Office of the Municipal Administrator 02 002 Office of the Municipal Legal Officer 02 003 Office of the Municipal Agriculturist 02 004 Office of the Municipal Environment and Natural Resources 02 005 Office of the Municipal Architect 02 006 Office of the Municipal Information Officer 02 007 Office of the Municipal Population Officer 02 008 Office of the Municipal Agricultural and Biosystems Engineer 02 009 Office of the Municipal Cooperatives Development Officer 02 010 Office of the Municipal Tourism Officer 03 Others 303 Annex E. Process Guide for Climate Change Expenditure Tagging 304 Annex F. Project Monitoring/Inspection Report PROJECT MONITORING/INSPECTION REPORT As of Month Year (Quarterly) Name of Project (Total Project Cost [TPC]) Location Implementing Agency Date of Major Action Taken/ Project Issues Findings Recommendation Inspection Project 1 (TPC) Submitted by: ______________________ Designation/Office: _________________ Date: _____________________________ Noted by: ____________________ Agency Head Instructions: Name of Project: Indicate the title of the project as found in the approved program of work, loan, or grant agreement. TPC: Indicate the total project cost of the project, in million pesos. Location: Indicate the location, i.e., barangay/municipality/city/province/region where the project is implemented. Implementing Agency: Indicate the name of agency/GOCC/LGU that implemented the project. Date of Project Inspection: Indicate the month, day, and year when the project inspection was conducted. Major Findings: Indicate the major observations during the project inspection, including the latest physical status of the project (Ahead, On, or Behind Schedule) Issues: Indicate the operational constraints/concerns observed during project implementation. Actions Taken/Recommendation: Indicate the remedial measures taken/being recommended to improve work progress or to commend outstanding performance, include updates on agency actions, provide information if issues were elevated, the requested actions, and the corresponding response. Report Deadline – One (1) month after the reporting quarter. Note: At the end of the report, indicate the name, designation, and office of the person who prepared the same, including the date the report was prepared. 305 GLOSSARY OF TERMS Accountability - Holding local government officials answerable to the public where their authority is derived, for use of public resources, to face consequences for their actions inside and outside of the government. Activity – a work process designed to contribute to the accomplishment of specific objectives and the implementation of a program, sub-program, or projects. Annual Budget - Refers to the financial plan embodying the estimates of income and expenditures for one (1) fiscal year (Section 306 [a] of the LGC). Annual Investment Program (AIP) - Refers to the annual slice of the Local Development Investment Program (LDIP) which constitutes the total resource requirements for all PPAs consisting of the annual capital expenditure and regular operating requirements of the LGU. Appropriation– Refers to an authorization made by Ordinance, directing the payment of goods and services from local government funds under the specified conditions or for specific purposes (Section 306 [b] of the LGC). Allotment - An authorization issued to a Department/Office by an LGU to allow the latter to incur obligation for specified amounts contained in an appropriation Ordinance. Appropriation Ordinance - Refers to the law or Ordinance passed by the local sanggunian directing the payment of goods and services from local government funds. Allocation - This is the amount earmarked for a specific program, activity or project to pursue a development objective. Budget Deficit- A financial status to which government expenditures exceed revenues. Bottom-Up-Budgeting - An approach to preparing the budget proposal of agencies, taking into consideration the development needs of provinces, cities and municipalities as identified in their local poverty reduction program. Budget Authorization - The second phase of the local budget process where local receipts and revenue are authorized for expenditure for local development. Budget Preparation - The first phase of the local budget process where generated funds are allocated to prioritized programs/activities/projects of the LGU to pursue its development goal. Budget Accountability - The last phase of the budget process where all funds are accounted for at End of the year to explain what PPAs were implemented, where funds were spent and Utilized and results were attained. Budget Review - This is the third phase of the local budget process where the local budget is subjected to scrutiny and evaluation in pursuance of the LGC. Budget Execution - This the fourth phase of the local budget process where the authorized budget is used to implement approved PPAs. 306 Capital Outlays - refers to appropriations for the purchase of goods and services, the benefits of which extend beyond the fiscal year and which add to the assets of the LGU concerned, including investments in public utilities such as public markets and slaughterhouses (Section 306 [d] of the LGC). Civil Society Organizations- A non-state and non-profit association that works to improve society and the human condition. Comprehensive Development Plan (CDP) - A multi-sectoral plan formulated at the City/municipal level embodying the vision, sectoral goals, objectives, and policies within the term of LGU officials and the medium term. Continuing Appropriation - refers to an appropriation available to support obligations for a specified purpose or projects, such as those for the construction of physical structures or for the acquisition of real property or equipment, even when these obligations are incurred beyond the budget year (Section 306 [e] of the LGC). Current Operating Expenditures – refers to appropriations for the purchase of goods and services for the conduct of normal local government operations within the fiscal year, including goods and services that will be used or consumed during the budget year. CSO Representative - A member CSO who is authorized by the CSO to participate in the local budget process of a particular LGU. Debt Service- The sum loan repayments, interest payments, commitment fees, and other bank charges on foreign or domestic borrowings. Financial Expenditures - A new expense class for management supervision, which includes interest expenses, trusteeship fees, bank charges, and other financial charges. Income - Refers to revenues and receipts collected or received forming the gross accretions of funds of the LGU (Section 306[i] of the LGC). Local Development Council (LDC) - The body mandated by law to assist the corresponding Sanggunian in setting the direction of economic and social development, and coordinating development efforts within the territorial jurisdiction of the LGU. Local Development Investment Program - A basic document linking the plan to the budget. It contains a prioritized list of PPAs which are derived from the CDP in the case of cities and municipalities, and the PDPFP, in the case of provinces. The LDIP should include PPAs to be implemented and financed annually within a three (3) to six (6)-year period. Major Final Outputs (MFOs) - Goods and services that a department/office in the LGU should deliver to constituents through the implementation of programs, activities and projects. These MFOs have corresponding performance indicators according to quality, quantity and timeliness. Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses (MOOE)- An allocation to support the operations of local government units including those for supplies and materials, transportation and travel, utilities and other maintenance activities. Mission Statement – An action-oriented statement that describes the organization’s purpose/s, its core functions, philosophies and goals that leads to the realization of its vision. 307 Non-tax Revenues - Fees, charges and other government collections in exchange for services rendered and penalties imposed. Organizational Outcomes (OOs) – short-to medium-term benefits to clients and communities as a result of MFO delivery. Participatory Budgeting - an approach wherein citizens, through CSOs are allowed to take part in the process of allocating public resources. Performance Indicator (PI) – a characteristic of performance (i.e., quantity, quality, timeliness and cost) that is to be measured. Performance Target (PT) – a predetermined level (numerical target) of quantity, quality, timeliness, and cost of an output. Performance Measurement (PM) – use of methods to measure incremental progress indicators from baselines to targets. Programmed Appropriations - Appropriations in the Ordinance that are supported by existing resources and can be released during the budget year. Program - A homogenous group of activities necessary for the performance of major purpose for which the LGU is established. Project - A special undertaking to be carried out within a definite time frame which is intended to result in some pre-determined measure of goods and services. Receipts - Refer to income realized from operations and activities of the local government or are received by it in the exercise of its corporate functions, consisting of charges for services rendered, conveniences furnished, or the price of a commodity sold, as well as loans, contributions or aids from other entities, except provisional advances for budgetary purposes (Section 306 [l] of the LGC). Resources - Refers to the revenues, gross borrowings free or unencumbered cash balances. Revenues - Refer to the income derived from the regular system of taxation enforced under authority of law or Ordinance and, as such, accrue more or less regularly every year (Section 306 [m] of the LGC). Reversion - refer to the moving of an unexpended balance of an appropriation to the unappropriated surplus of the general fund at the end of the fiscal year and shall not be available for expenditures except by subsequent enactment. Stakeholders - people or organization that may come from either within or outside the LGU. The ones most commonly-referred to as stakeholders in an LGU setting are its constituents or clients. These are the businessmen, private-sector groups, senior citizens, women, farmers, fishermen, differently-able, indigents and disadvantaged-members of society. Supplemental Budget - A budget that is enacted after the Annual Budget. Changes in the annual May be done through supplemental budgets pursuant to Section 321 of the LGC. Savings - refer to portions or balances of programmed appropriations which have not been released or obligated resulting from: i) discontinuance by the head of the agency concerned of the program, activity or project (P/A/P), for justifiable causes or for causes not attributable to the fault or negligence of the agency and which will render it impossible to implement the 308 said P/A/P; ii) Non-commencement or inability of the agency to obligate an allotment for causes not attributable to the fault or negligence of the agency and which will render it impossible to implement the said P/A/P; iii) improved systems and efficiencies in the implementation of P/A/Ps and delivery of services which are consistent with their performance targets; iv) a lower contract cost than that provided in the approved budget for the contract; and v) unused personal services costs pertaining to a) unfilled, vacant or abolished positions; b) non-entitlement to allowance and benefits; c) leaves of absence without pay; and d) death of pensioners, decrease in the number of retirees, or other related causes. Tax Revenues - Compulsory charges or levies imposed by the local government on real property. Goods and services, individuals, and entities like income tax, value-added tax, and special taxes. Transparency - Full disclosure of all local government transactions, which should include programs/activities/ projects which are relevant, timely, and accessible/accurate information on local governance. Unprogrammed Appropriations - Appropriations in the local annual budget that can only be utilized when revenue collections exceed targets, and when new revenue sources arise, or when loans are approved for specific projects. Vision Statement – is an aspirational statement made by an organization that articulates what they would like to achieve. It depicts a vision of what the organization will look like in the future and sets a defined direction for the planning and execution of department-level strategies. 309 PROJECT TEAM FOR THE UPDATING OF THE BUDGET OPERATIONS MANUAL FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS Project Team Leaders : Undersecretary Wilford Will L. Wong (2022 to 2023) Assistant Secretary Rolando U. Toledo (2022 to 2023) Assistant Secretary Achilles Gerard C. Bravo (2022) Project Team Leader – Technical Review Subgroup : Undersecretary Janet B. Abuel Central Office Technical Team Members and Overall Coordinators : Director Ryan S. Lita (2022 to 2023) Director John Aries S. Macaspac (2022) Regional Offices (ROs) Technical Team Members : Ruby P. Muro Joseph Cicero M. Sy Irene B. Gahid Marie Christine D. Andaya Ria V. Bansigan Ryan A. Milanes Francis C. Bautista Ludivina T. Potot Isabel C. Taguinod Rosalie C. Abesamis Nympha R. Manalastas Jacqueline B. Ludovice Ricky L. Sanchez Alexander P. Calma Maria Angelita C. Cells Antonio F. Villanueva Jr. Mae L. Chua Maria Liane L. Gayomali Lenin S. Bernales Maricor U. Baquial Imelda C. Laceras Aleli N. Hernandez Mark Louie C. Martin Alelie B. Ramos Rudylia C. Parrel Nonito H. dela Cruz Gary R. Martel Antonio M. Faunillan, Jr. Akmad J. Usman Libertine C. Cagang Maria Fe D. Jagna Jenneth C. Partosa ADB Consultant : Atty. Julian Ll. Pacificador, Jr. 310 PROJECT TEAM FOR THE UPDATING OF THE BUDGET OPERATIONS MANUAL FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNITS Technical Support Local Government and Regional Coordination Bureau Legal Service Rowena M. Marte Ruby Ann G. Añonuevo Amabelle Colleen T. Francisco Alvin A. Amil Roxanne Cleath A. Gonzaga Director Andrea Celene M. Magtalas Atty. Rosemarie D. Pagala Atty. Philip Jeffrey D. David RO for the MIMAROPA Michael M. Lacsamana Crystine S. Cuartero Christian G. Mendoza RO V February E. Manuel Jennifer B. Barcoma Joanna M. Rasco RO VI Mariel Dave M. Gallego Cecile C. Lacson RO VII Carlo C. Maraat Annie J. Linguis Zarah Leigh A. Ranile RO VIII Juvy A. Lobedica Absal N. Abah Neuman M. Gallardo RO IX Eddie Albert A. Cruz Giovanni O. Tabanao RO X Eden N. Pingol Mary Ann Margaret T. Melad Mark Welnorr M. Callao RO XI Namnama Grace Elarcosa Mary Emlea Ganzon Hubert Von Labor RO XII Arlyn B. Adajar Hamzur M. Nawal Roxanne Mae D. Mapa Joshua C. Tianchon Cherry W. Bravo Nasrudin P. Salik Ma. Ayla I. Nacional Mary Methyl Joy B. Gabiazon RO XIII Elvin D. Chatto Desiree G. Ruben Rhona Mae U. Gabia DBM Regional Offices RO for the National Capital Region RO for the Cordillera Administrative Region RO I Katherine B. Castro Edith W. Velarde Neljie G. Amande Marione Bien A. Bungcayao Atty. Noemi P. Humilde Mayna M. Caymo Deysabel B. Quindasan Julius Jose M. Camara Mike M. Flores Christa N. Mendoza RO II Jose C. Pamittan Juliet T. Bilag Macario C. Gumabay, Jr. Enrique C. Bugar RO III Jenina M. Pineda Ariel P. Dayrit Thelma Abigail N. Macalino Katrina Mae M. Yalung Camille Dianne D. Tulabut Arnelie R. Guiao RO IV-A Ella Loraine D. Obra Rujen A. Polo Rissah Maryelle S. Arenas James Christopher C. Verano Melody F. Tomo 311 Republic of the Philippines DEPARTMENT OF BUDGET AND MANAGEMENT