Rubric for Oral Reporting
Name of student for assessment: _______________________ Course and Year: __________
Task Description: The student is required to choose an industry and discuss the unit operations involved, and most
importantly the industrial waste it produces.
CRITERIA
Weight
Not Satisfactory
Developing
Satisfactory
Excellent
Rating
1
2
3
4
Content
3 points Points presented Points presented Many good points Enough points
not clear;
was somewhat
presented; just
presented;
information does clear; too little
enough
information given
not support ideas information
information
was more than
presented
what was
expected
Organization
1.5
Information was
Information
Information was
Information was
points very disorganized; showed little
organized, with
well organized,
Difficult to
organization;
occasional
clear discussion of
understand
audience take
confusion
ideas
same effort to
between ideas
follow
Delivery
1.5
Presenter
Presenter was
Presenter was
Presenter was
points mumbles; voice
somewhat
sometimes
confident; voice
can hardly be
nervous; voice
confident; voice
was clearly heard;
heard; no eye
somewhat
can be heard; eye with eye contact
contact with the
audible; with
contact most of
most of the time
audience
minimal
the time with the with the audience
frequency of eye
audience
contact with the
audience
Visual Aids
1.5
Visual aids were
Visual aids were
Visual aids were
Presentation was
points poorly prepared;
marginally
well prepared;
appropriately
does not support
prepared;
supports most of
supported with
the topic
somewhat
the topic
varied sources
presented
supports the topic presented
presented
Preparedness 1 point Not prepared;
Somewhat
Just enough
Completely
reads the entire
prepared;
preparation;
prepared;
report; does not
sometimes read
discussed the
discussed the
discuss the topic;
the report;
assigned topics
topic assigned
explained at least most of the time
very well
two sub topics
well;
Audience
1 point Presented
Presented
Held audience
Involved Audience
Interaction
information
information with
attention most of in the discussion;
without audience minimal audience the time;
held audience
contact; unable to contact; able to
Responds to most attention
answer questions answer one
questions clearly
although out
question correctly
References
0.5
The topics cited
Some of the
Majority of the
Majority of the
point
were not properly topics cited were
topics cited were
topics cited were
referenced
properly
properly
properly
referenced
referenced
referenced
PERFECT RATING: 40 POINTS
STUDENT RATING: _______