Analytic Scoring Guide For Rating Creative Products
Discussion
4
Distinguished
3
Proficient
2
Apprentice
1
Novice
Grammar/
Technique
Appearance
Presentation was
lengthier and more
detailed and
handled with ease
of expression
Project uses
advanced
grammar or
technique.
The project is
very neat and
exceptionally
organized
Presentation was
longer with detail
and explanation.
Project uses
competent
grammar or
technique.
The project is
neat and
organized.
Presentation was
limited with little
detail.
Project uses
below standard
grammar or
technique.
The project is
somewhat neat
and organized
Presentation was
extremely limited
with few to no
details.
Grammar or
Technical skills
are not apparent.
The project is
not neat or
organized
Idea-Project
development/
support
The writer shows a
depth and complexity
of ideas supported by
rich, engaging, and
/or pertinent details.
There is evidence of
analysis, reflection,
and insight beyond
the facts of the story.
16=100
15=98
14=97
13=96
12=94
11=91
10=87
9=84
8=80
7=72
6=65
5=58
The writer shows a
4=50
depth of idea and
0=0 No attempt at a
project development
sharing ideas from the project
story.
The writer has
Percentage grade ____
unelaborated
development of the
project.
X 4
The writer has
minimal development
of the project.
Final Grade
_____/400